Sorry Brisbane and Sydney fans, but a Storm vs Cowboys grand final should have everyone salivating

By Ryan O'Connell / Expert

After a somewhat lacklustre regular season, the NRL finals have been scintillating, with plenty of drama and, more importantly, some exceptional football.

Though you would expect the quality of play to rise once you say goodbye to the bad teams, that’s not always the case, as some finals games can be boring, lopsided or uninspired.

Not in 2017. The rugby league on display over the last couple of weekends has been of a great standard, and we’re now right down to the business end of the season, with just four teams remaining.

The Melbourne Storm will face the Brisbane Broncos at AAMI Park in Melbourne on Friday night before the Sydney Roosters take on the North Queensland Cowboys at Allianz Stadium on Saturday, with the winners meeting in Homebush for the grand final.

With all due respect to Brisbane and Sydney, if you’re not yearning for a Storm versus Cowboys final, you’re either a Broncos or Roosters fan, or you really hate Melbourne or North Queensland.

The Broncos and Roosters have never been popular teams outside of their own supporter base.

For many years in the ARL and then the NRL, Brisbane simply represented ‘Queensland’ in the eyes of many New South Welshmen, which immediately put the Broncos offside with the majority of fans south of the border. State of Origin breeds a lot of hatred and pettiness, and for many, that doesn’t end with the third game in the interstate series each year – it carries on.

With the Broncos always having a fair share of Maroons players, plus the enigmatic Wayne Bennett as coach, it adds up to them struggling to have many people call them their second-favourite team.

Proving that pettiness isn’t just based on parochial state borders, the Roosters have never been the darlings of rugby league either, despised both in and outside of Sydney.

(AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

The general perception is that the Chooks buy players (rather than develop them), cheat the salary cap, and that their chairman, Nick Politis, wields his considerable power to the unfair benefit of his club.

Fans never let the truth get in the way of a good story, and those reasons to hate the Roosters realistcially don’t actually hold any weight. Yet passion has never been close friends with rational thought.

Though the Daily Telegraph consistently attempts to promote the notion that Sydneysiders always get behind whatever Sydney team is left in the competition, I don’t think that’s true at all. I certainly feel no favouritism towards Sydney clubs once the Bulldogs are done.

As such, few people will be hoping for a Broncos-Roosters grand final.

That’s not to say Melbourne are everyone’s cup of tea. Far from it. You could argue that the Storm may be even more unpopular than the Broncos and Roosters combined.

Whether it’s their location way outside of rugby league heartland, their guilt in cheating the salary cap, the narrative they brought wrestling into the game, the presence of Maroon royalty – Cameron Smith, Billy Slater and Cooper Cronk – in their playing ranks (that rubs Blues supporters the wrong way), or simply their sustained brilliance and success over many years, Melbourne is an extremely loathed franchise.

(AAP Image/Julian Smith)

Like the aforementioned Broncos and Roosters, whether that hatred is fair or not is completely beside the point. Rugby league fandom is built on emotion and tribalism, and a large part of that is not just supporting your team, but hating every other team. This ensures that fans only need a smidgen of proof that the opposition is worthy of being disliked, and their confirmation bias kicks in.

However, what the Storm do have on their side is that they are very, very good at football. They’ve been the best team in the competition this season, and have been NRL’s for over a decade. They play an attractive style of football and have a number of players who will be remembered as all-time greats, as well as a brilliant coach.

So if you truly love rugby league, you want to see Melbourne in the final, because you want to see the very best.

The Storm will need a partner for the big dance though, and what better person than Cinderella for that lovely role?

The North Queensland Cowboys tick a lot of boxes when it comes to the fairytale underdog. They only barely made the top eight, needing the Dragons to capitulate in order to book their spot in the finals. They’re also playing without their injured skipper – and world’s best player – in Johnathan Thurston, not to mention losing the services of the game’s best prop, Matt Scott.

Yet they find themselves just one win from the grand final after knocking out last year’s premiers, the Cronulla Sharks, in week one, and then beating Parramatta on Saturday night.

The only thing that counts against them is the fact they won the competition a few years ago. If you could add ‘premiership drought’ to their narrative, they would surely be the most sentimental favourite in NRL history.

A Cowboys win would be a fantastic story, and as such, many people will be hoping they can add the Roosters to their list of scalps.

The Cowboys’ chances aren’t confined to just ‘hope’, though; they’re in with a real shot of another upset on Saturday night. They have momentum on their side on the field, and plenty of momentum off the field as well, with most fans jumping on board the bandwagon.

(AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

Yet it’s not these intangible factors that should give the Cowboys optimism they can beat the Chooks, but rather some concrete, rugby league-related reasons they should feel good about their chances.

They are playing excellent football at the right time of the year and will have built up a lot of confidence from their two thrilling finals wins thus far.

Meanwhile, coach Paul Green has emerged as a sensational young tactician who brings a level head and calmness to his squad, which ensures the team plays – for the most part – under control and composed. Important qualities that their two vanquished foes did not exhibit.

Lastly, you can’t win without talent, and though it’s unfair to single out two players from a whole team that has been playing well, Michael Morgan and Jason Taumalolo have been at the top of their games. They are both now legitimate superstars. When you have a forward making 200 metres a game for fun and a half who controls the game beautifully, but with flourishes of brilliance, you’re in a very healthy position.

The Cowboys aren’t an average team on a fun roll; they’re a very good team. Combine that with their alluring underdog narrative, and Melbourne’s sheer footballing excellence, and we should all be salivating over a potential Storm versus Cowboys final.

The Crowd Says:

2017-09-20T08:08:35+00:00

Uncle Nick's Chauffer

Guest


which ones? - seem to have more ex Roosters players in the Cows teams these past few year- I think 5 of their GF team were ex Rooster players - 7 in the 25 player squad overall in 2015- Plus Coach Green Asiata/Hannant/Kostjasyn/Lowe/Moga/Tamou/Winterstein

2017-09-20T07:51:43+00:00

Uncle Nick's Chauffer

Guest


Not sure what Penrith were trying to achieve inside the Bronco's 20 - went sideways way too often which was easily read by the defence - the try and the almost try(Cambell-Gillard) was achieved by turning the ball back inside to go through the middle- needed to do that more - plus the grubber behind the defence was rarely used since Brisbane have their fullbacks defending in the line as well.

2017-09-20T07:41:36+00:00

Uncle Nick's Chauffer

Guest


Hard to say what form the Cows are in when evaluating both Cronulla and Parra's game- neither of them played well over the course of the game- both conceded way too many penalties and both had very poor set completion rates and high error rates- to be in a winning position - teams need high completion and low error rates and penalties conceded. It looked like Parra spent too much energy(physical and mental) in the previous game vs Storm as their second half vs Cows was poor-Teams after big games the previous week can often be flat the next week. It was the first final series for most of the Parra players and the Sharks have been struggling all year for consistency and were no way near their 2016 form for most of 2017. Looked a tired side in fact.

2017-09-20T07:25:31+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I love how you always only come back to the spelling and grammar.

2017-09-20T06:46:29+00:00

Uncle Nick's Chauffer

Guest


One would have to say that the Roosters will be a sterner test for the Cows than both Cronulla and Parra were

2017-09-20T06:43:51+00:00

Uncle Nick's Chauffer

Guest


I seem to recall Pearce steered the Roosters to a premiership in 2013 though - X factors what are they - Keary/Mitchell Perhaps

2017-09-19T23:20:12+00:00

nopuritan

Guest


nah, that wasn't brutal, the rest of the quote is brutal... "I can assure you it has not recurred...Women, er, women sense my power, and they seek the life essence. I do not avoid women...but I do deny them my essence."

2017-09-19T12:31:29+00:00

Rob

Guest


The Roosters crow a lot.

2017-09-19T12:27:13+00:00

Rob

Guest


The Cowboys have started to form some combinations in recent weeks. I find it funny how people forget how important it is to play consistently together to form partnerships and cohesion in both attack and defence. The Cowboys have struggled all year keeping the same 17. Taumalolo 2 week suspended, Coote, Granville, Martin, Cooper, Winterstien, Hess and O"niel have all been missing during the season. The constant turn over of players has had as much, if not more of an impact as losing JT and Scott. Morgan, Martin, Coote and the outside backs looked more fluent against the Eels. The defensive line is looking solid and the players are getting to understand the right spacing and line speed of their inside and outside teammates. In 2015 the Cowboys played almost the entire season with the same 17 players. The biggest thing in the Cowboys favour is team work and confidence in each other. At the moment they appear to be more settled and confident than they were at any point this season.

2017-09-19T12:21:11+00:00

Peter

Guest


Ryan, thank you. I will cease being a pain in the butt (at least temporarily). :-)

2017-09-19T11:36:54+00:00

Rob

Guest


Is Grant Aitken the Ref? In all honesty without Aitken the Rooster are ordinary.

2017-09-19T11:04:26+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Heaven forbid there be more than one person who could not give a crap about spelling and grammar

2017-09-19T11:00:50+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


There is no C in my name you dullard

2017-09-19T10:57:24+00:00

Walrusty

Guest


The longer everyone keeps the Storm as the favorites, the longer they will be expected to win. Which will put them under more pressure to deliver. Broncos have the upper hand in this scenario as they are expected to lose.I see an upset probable along with a Roosters brain fade. A very likely 2015 rematch.

2017-09-19T10:55:57+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Um play nice??? Were you not the one having a go at me for supporting five teams??? So much for your nice play???

2017-09-19T10:53:24+00:00

BigJ

Roar Guru


Thanks mate, same to you

2017-09-19T10:03:44+00:00

Bee bee

Guest


There was some sincerity there behind the joke. It doesn't bother me how many teams you support. Myself, I just haven't got the time/energy so I stick to one. All the best to you and your teams.

AUTHOR

2017-09-19T09:01:18+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


Peter, I think it's extremely sensitive, and a little silly, to take exception with one small part of a story that is otherwise overwhelmingly positive about the Cowboys. Even more so when that small part is a fact: the Cowboys were lucky to make the eight, and could have easily missed out. That doesn't mean they didn't deserve to be in the 8. I never said that. Quite simply, because I think they did/do deserve to be there. To say I give them little credit is to ignore the rest of the piece. As for not focussing on the Dragons, the reason is simple: the piece is about the top 4, and the Dragons aren't in it. No need to talk about them. They didn't deserve to be there, because - as you said - they showed no spine in a must-win game. If the Dragons had won that game, the Cowboys would have been unlucky, because I think they were the better team during the season. As it stands, the Dragons capitulated, and the Cowboys luckily got in. That doesn't denigrate that what they did during the season, or what they have done in the post-season. That's not to say they're a bad the

2017-09-19T08:47:51+00:00

Peter

Guest


Dear Ryan, sorry, I'll try again. My first comment was the implication from you and others that the Cowboys didn't deserve to be there, they only got to 8 because they were so lucky that the Dragons lost their last game. The Cowboys got to 8 in accordance with the rules, without Thurston or Scott, but with a group of players who grew enormously in stature - Ethan Lowe, for instance. Why so little credit to them? Why so little criticism of a truly pathetic last game from the Dragons? Is that any clearer? If not, sorry, it will have to do. The second point was separate, and I did not intend to convey that you should have highlighted both. The Cowboys won one more game, and gained two more competition points, than the Dragons. You could assign that to any one of the 12games the Dragons lost. Why seize on the last one, except that it provides an easy "lucky Cowboys" write-up. Thank you for taking the trouble to reply to my first post. I'd be interested in your response, if you wish to make one, to the separate comments .I posted.

AUTHOR

2017-09-19T08:42:33+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


Alright boys, that will do. Put the toys back in the cot, and everyone play nice.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar