Round 1 of the A-League was so cliché

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

It is far too soon to jump to conclusions about the ten A-League clubs after only one week. Or is it?

All sporting teams have patterns and cultures and after the first weekend of matches, some clubs appeared to be confirming theirs, with others bucking the trend and threatening to morph into a better version of themselves.

A cliché might be the best way to define each club’s first foray into the season.

Brisbane Roar – ‘With all due respect, don’t take this the wrong way’
Friday night was a disappointing result for the Roar after Melbourne City proved far too clinical, with Bruce Kamau snaring a brace. Unfortunately for Brisbane, many pre-season forecasts appear to now have weight after a lacklustre performance, albeit with an undermanned squad.

Many had the writing on the wall, claiming John Aloisi’s ‘Dad’s army’ would lack speed and skill, and find it difficult to replace the goal-scoring prowess of Jamie Maclaren.

On the basis of what we saw, those predictions appear accurate. Massimo Maccarone will need far better service than that with which he was provided on Friday.

The return of Brett Holman, a fitter Maccarone and the impending arrival of Eric Bautheac will be positives, however there was something a little ominous about the performance.

Melbourne City – ‘Money can’t buy happiness’
Or can it? With all their internationals on deck, City will look a powerhouse. The only problem is that we have said the same thing for the last three years.

Even without Fernando Brandan, Tim Cahill and Bruno Fornaroli, City were far too good for a struggling Brisbane and ironically, it was Kamau, the local, who did the damage.

Ross McCormack and Bart Schenkeveld were impressive in their debuts. At their best, this squad looks likely.

If Brisbane’s unimpressive performance was as poor as some felt, City might still have a lot to prove. Alternatively, they may have finally assembled a squad capable of producing the returns expected of considerable expenditure.

[latest_videos_strip category=”football” name=”Football”]

Central Coast Mariners – ‘Two steps forward, one step back’
In what many will see as the match of the round, the Mariners were eventually belted by the Jets, yet not disgraced. It was a positive start and after taking an early lead, a penalty and a stunning Roy O’Donovan hat-trick made things look far worse than what they actually were.

Asdrubal scored, they dominated the corners won and, with some more poise in front of goal, the match could have taken on a different aspect. Wout Brama will add some much-needed composure when he is fit and firing.

Newcastle Jets – ‘I’ve changed, I promise’
Wow, what else was there to say after the Jets thumped five unanswered goals past the Mariners after falling behind early. Many felt O’Donovan would be a good signing, however no one could have predicted such opening-day efforts.

Ronny Vargas lived up to his billing as a potential A-League star and the Hunter will come alive if their team is able to continue to produce the attacking, Ernie Merrick football they seemed committed to play on Saturday.

Sydney FC – ‘Form is temporary, class is permanent’
Nothing much appeared to have changed from a Sydney FC perspective. If anything, they might be more dangerous this season. There were, however, some serious defensive lapses with Paulo Retre struggling on the left.

While still sweating on the pending return of the first stringers, Michael Zullo and Rhyan Grant, the distinct lack of clear chances created by the Victory will be seen as a positive by the manager.

The class through the middle of the park was evident again, and Milos Ninkovic looks again set to choreograph much of Sydney’s attack.

Melbourne Victory – ‘We was robbed’
The Victory will be a top-four side again this season, that much is clear, yet Kevin Muscat has them convinced that they always deserve more.

The intensity and aggression of the manager will again entertain all and sundry, as he launches barrage after barrage on officials, opposition coaches and players.

Their weapons are intact, young players like Jason Geria and Thomas Deng have another year under their belt and Leroy George looked particularly impressive.

But for an overplayed ball to Besart Berisha, the grand final draw may have been emulated in this, the 44th edition of the Big Blue.

Irrespective of the score, there will always be a case for the injustice of the result. Muscat is an expert at finding it and using it to motivate his talented squad.

Wellington Phoenix – ‘Don’t shut me out’
In their ongoing quest for success, respect and numbers that validate their continued participation in the A-League, the Phoenix began in impressive style against the Reds. An attendance well in excess of last season’s average was a good place to start.

Despite the fact that both teams seemed content with a sharing of the points, there was enough positivity in Wellington’s play to suggest they will surprise many this season.

With three players absent on international duty, their full starting XI looks solid. Relying heavily on Roy Krishna for goals is an issue, however a firing Andrija Kaludjerovic could be a buffer for Wellington and provide another attacking option.

Adelaide United – ‘Just give me some time’
There was so much to like about the Reds’ opening performance. After the horror season that ended last April, Marco Kurz has assembled a solid squad, with impressive imports, and worked hard on developing combinations.

Unfortunately, those combinations were far from polished and Adelaide will be a different team after eight or so weeks of A-League action.

Once Isaias, Baba Diawara, Karim Matmour and Johan Absalonsen start to link and find continuity in attack, the team will appear more like the top-six candidate they look likely to become.

Western Sydney Wanderers – ‘A change is as good as a holiday’
The ‘everybody out, everybody in’ recruitment style of Tony Popovic over the last few seasons looks to have finally returned the Wanderers to something near their former selves.

Ironically, the man behind the moves is gone and Hayden Foxe is overseeing the still-developing squad.

If the combinations between Oriol Riera, Alvaro Cejudo, Roly Bonevacia and Jumpei Kusukami continue to develop, the entire league will do well to stop them.

They look to be the squad that, more than any other, will buck the trend of their recent performances and return to the lofty heights of the ladder.

Perth Glory – ‘Defence wins championships’
If this cliché is indeed the case. Perth Glory won’t be winning one this season.

The dual strikes of Riera and Kusukami just before the break were wonderful goals, yet the defensive lapses were obvious and a continuation of the failings of the back line last season.

While Kenny Lowe flapped his way up and down the sideline and his quality attacking imports such as Andy Keogh and Diego Castro created some chances, the harsh reality of the defensive issues at the Glory remain.

Positive additions such as Xavi Torres and Andreu Guerao, as well as the ever-improving Adam Taggart, will mean little unless the Glory address their defensive insufficiencies.

It’s great to have you back A-League, and nice to see you on commercial free-to-air television as well.

Shame everything was so cliché.

The Crowd Says:

2017-10-10T07:43:00+00:00

The Phantom Commissioner

Roar Rookie


Yes things where eerily similar to last season at my house, when WSW scored their second goal against us l was scolded by my wife for my language which was a regular occurrence during the 16/17 season. Glory games look like they are going to be very entertaining for the neutrals once again this season with the you score 2 and we'll try and score 3 approach, very stressful for fans of the club like myself though unfortunately.

2017-10-10T06:29:46+00:00

Yowzers

Roar Rookie


Cheers mate hope you're right! I know we've only played one game but it seems like; We have a coach playing blokes in their best positions, and trying to win games instead of stamping his 'philosophy' on he club. We have players who are no only of a decent level but have played with some mongrel and belief. This is all new to me. Can't possibly last too long.

2017-10-10T05:31:09+00:00

Realfootball

Guest


The resurgence of the Jets is, for me, the most exciting thing about this new season. Merrick is a class act as a coach, and the similarity between the way the Jets played against CCM and his great Victory team was spine tingling. Jets V Sydney in Newcastle is going to be one cracker of a game.

2017-10-10T05:12:40+00:00

punter

Guest


Likewise Fad, I thought the new players made it a lot more interesting.

2017-10-10T04:57:56+00:00

Richo

Guest


Well done to the Wanderers, couldn't have been easy adapting to life under a new gaffer so close to the opening game of the season. As for my Glory boys, another wasted pre season it would seem. Sixty minutes in and we looked absolutely spent. Hopefully it doesn't take us until round 6 for us to start kicking into gear.

2017-10-10T04:49:08+00:00

Fadida

Guest


Too many to choose from Stuart. The WSW Spanish trio look excellent, ditto the CCM Dutch duo. Vargas, the Poles, George, AU's recruits. The returning Australians, Herd, Da Silva

2017-10-10T04:24:02+00:00

Waz

Guest


That's pretty much my take. The defence looked very solid just suspect on corners (as jb has pointed out that's been there for three seasons now). And then a lack of general cohesion with individual players fading in and out of the game. Some of Skapetis's work in the wing in the second half was magical but he was awol in the first half which was typical of a few players. FBK looked unfit but stayed on his feet ✔️ so no need for over reactions yet.

2017-10-10T04:19:14+00:00

Waz

Guest


Well said Post Hoc. Stuart's article is very welcome even if I have disagreed with it. Hopefully he writes something similar after R9 say where one of us gets the unnecessary but totally enjoyable bragging rights otherwise known as "I told you so" ... (please let it be me, please, please ...)

2017-10-10T04:19:06+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


Pretty sure Petratos asked Sydney to release him since he wanted to move overseas. But, he ended up in the Malaysian 1st Division.

2017-10-10T04:14:45+00:00

Waz

Guest


All clubs are subject to the salary cap jb but not all clubs develop such good players. How many players arrive at Roar and leave as better players? Quite a few I'd say ... and as they get better they attract the attention of other clubs and their agents salary expectations go up. Petratos is the best example: a reject from Sydney he arrived on the low salary band, was resigned to the mid salary band, and signed for Hets on the high salary band. Now if there were no cap 1 or 2 more would have been retained but Roars reality is most would probably leave any way unless more money is found?

2017-10-10T04:14:43+00:00

Waz

Guest


All clubs are subject to the salary cap jb but not all clubs develop such good players. How many players arrive at Roar and leave as better players? Quite a few I'd say ... and as they get better they attract the attention of other clubs and their agents salary expectations go up. Petratos is the best example: a reject from Sydney he arrived on the low salary band, was resigned to the mid salary band, and signed for Hets on the high salary band. Now if there were no cap 1 or 2 more would have been retained but Roars reality is most would probably leave any way unless more money is found?

2017-10-10T04:04:58+00:00

Waz

Guest


Agree on D'Aggers; the issue with Roar was a total lack of cohesion in the first half where the defence was the only unit that looked like it knew what it was going (apart from corners sadly). Second half was better but still not quite there. I'm optimistic for Friday but Adelaide will be after a win as well so it'll be a ding-dong battle I recon

2017-10-10T03:40:04+00:00

Square Nostrils

Guest


Crowds this season will be determined by the closeness of the season, which will be determined by the strength of the imports. That is the only difference between this year and last when Sydney FC ran away with it. Worth noting that the record A-League attendance season was 3, when Newcastle were Champions and The Mariners were Premiers. Matches between them drew well and also between, both Mariners, Newcastle and Sydney/ Melbourne, although Newcastle drew 15000 against Phoenix. Newcastle is one of the few traditional football areas in Australia, if the Jets are firing at the same time as the big city clubs, the whole league benefits. Over to you double haggis.

AUTHOR

2017-10-10T03:14:08+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


The Wellington Crowd was very pleasing.

2017-10-10T03:03:48+00:00

Lionheart

Guest


I haven't seen the game on TV, just live at AAMI, and then in the away seats so a long way from the action much of the time. I didn't see any bad players as such - just rusty players unfamiliar with each other. I wouldn't write them off just yet. They just kept passing the ball to the wrong place.

2017-10-10T03:00:24+00:00

Realfootball

Guest


That is good news, jb, given there was no launch even close to worthy of the name.

2017-10-10T02:59:29+00:00

Realfootball

Guest


What I certainly didn't see with the Roar, LH, was 11 players who look even close to competing for anything this season. Canon fodder for the ACL. Worst team we've had since the Bleiberg days. This Frenchman had better be Broich MKII or our season is cooked.

2017-10-10T02:59:12+00:00

Lionheart

Guest


yes, it's such a pity JB, that Roar put so much effort into Dimi and get little for it. I loved watching him and Borrello develop over the years, gradually improving one season to the next. Those early years and he just didn't know what to do when he made a break toward goal. Brattan was in the team then too, and developing with them. Sad to see them running around in other A League teams but really do wish them well.

2017-10-10T02:49:49+00:00

Post_hoc

Guest


Rick I suspect it you don't understand the discussion and think it is petty and childish. I suspect it your problem and not those on here. We have 1 article on the A league, 1 on the W League a few on The socceroos and a few others on "other football" I don't see an issue with that, as has been said time and time and time again, we have lots of football going on all the time, not just 1 that AFL types are used. Rick, the issue appears to be with you and not those on here

2017-10-10T02:43:33+00:00

j,binnie

Guest


Stuart - While not a true comparison it is interesting to note that these 5 opening games of the season drew 66,814 fans ,while the same fixtures last year only drew 64,480. Four of the 5 home teams all increased their "gates" from the previous years. Good sign? Cheers jb.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar