Sledging is stupid. And weak

By Matt Cleary / Expert

Australia’s cricketers and apparently England’s cricketers – and when Australia plays India, South Africa, New Zealand, all of them, their cricketers, too – appear cool for their on-field ‘banter’ and sledging and yapping to one another to remain out there on the field.

The old edict of whatever happens there stays there is in play unless, of course, someone wants something heard on the stump microphone which would put ‘pressure’ on one’s opponent in the form of a public grilling by the unpopular press.

It’s sort of like using the media as an avenue to mentally disintegrate one’s opponent, as the outing of Jonny Bairstow’s funny little headbutt thingy in the pub was. It is a thing. It’s understood.

Is it bad? I dunno. I played fourth grade for Woden Valley, bowled first change, batted 11. I got the fielding award for fielding fine-leg and third man.

So there was that.

But sledging? No expert. I didn’t like it that much. I didn’t like the sort of nastiness of it. Because most of it was weak. All the fielders out there, being ‘tough’, ganging up on one batter without the consequence of anything physical really happening in return.

In that way, footy was more honest. If you said something mean to a big fat pig in the front row – even from way out on the wing – you could expect almost immediate retribution in the form of two sets of six-inch studs raking down your back.

I was once rucked by a prop forward in my own team. Wayne Hickey didn’t care who you were, if you were bottom the ruck between him and ball – or even just lying there, looking pretty – you were getting a shoe-ing. And the plump white meat of my inner thigh still quivers at the thought.

But in cricket? Please. Being sledged by some dickhead on the field didn’t affect me at all.

It was all sort of cartoonish, amateur, dumb.

And as I said, it wasn’t like they were actually going to hurt you. It was piss-ant.

(AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

But then it was only fourth grade, and the sledgers, even the grizzled old boys, weren’t that expert at it. Queanbeyan boys were the worst/best for it. They had blokes would call you rabbit this, ferret that while you were waiting padded up.

It was funny, if anything. Dropkicks acting tough, thinking they’re Ian Chappell.

Test cricket isn’t far removed. Mitchell Starc probably can break your freakin’ arm, of course. But, really, being yapped at by someone from third slip… how could it affect how you bat?

Few years ago I asked Mitchell Starc about the ‘aggressive’ nature of Australia’s cricket and talked about him flinging the ball at Ben Stokes and a Kiwi tail-ender whose name you could Google if you were of a mind, and I mused to Mitchell that it must be hard to remain ‘aggressive’ while thinking of the children, and so on.

And Mitchell Starc said: “It’s always something that’s in your mind. At the same time, we’re trying to win games for Australia. That’s first and foremost for us. Obviously we’re always in the limelight and have to be conscious of what people might think.

“But we are just trying to win the game for our country. We’re always going to play aggressive cricket. That’s how we play our best cricket.

“But it’s important we don’t overstep that line. We have in the past and I’m sure we will in the future. And we’ll hear about it.”

(AP Photo/Rick Rycroft)

And then I said: “But where is this ‘line’? What is it? You’d only know when you’ve over-stepped when someone tells you that you have, no?”

And Mitchell Starc said: “Yeah, a lot of the time the officials decide where the line is.

There’s been times in the past when a bit of friendly banter’s been perceived as something different. Other times things have been let go.

“But as the Australian team we have to know how the public view things and how we view things ourselves, too.”

And, as there often is in our summer of cricket, there’s something of a hullabaloo about the whole sledging thing and the captains are yapping away at each other on the field, and it’s a thing, again.

Matt Prior alluded to something offensive or personal or something someone said to an England player or players, and hasn’t said what it was or who said it and did it from the other side of the planet.

But it had the effect of riling up said unpopular press types, a bit like yapping into the stump microphone.

Steve Smith responded by saying of the current malarkey that the Aussies – and it would appear England, New Zealand, and so on – will just do their thing and play their cricket and yap at one another, being ‘tough’, until the match referee deems they’ve over-stepped that ephemeral grey line.

(AP Photo/Eranga Jayawardena)

“I think the umpires and match referees are there to determine that,” said Smith when asked if “hand on heart” he was comfortable with what his players had said to England’s players in Brisbane.

Joe Root, meanwhile, said: “It’s Ashes cricket.”

And there could be no argument.

Added Root: “I don’t think it ever went too far, I think both sides are desperate to win and desperate to do their country proud. And that was just expressed, I think, out on the field.”

A few other things, too. Stupid ones. And weak.

The Crowd Says:

2017-12-09T21:41:38+00:00

Cam

Guest


There was a moment I didnt like in the 2nd test. England was in the final run chase to win the game. Cook was beaten by a good ball. As the ball is thrown around the field back to the bowler, Cook takes a few steps to regain his thoughts for the next ball, while he is doing that an aussie fielder runs in from point and stands at the crease and shows him how to play the shot. Now we are waiting for the fielder to get back to his position and Cook to set himself, I'm sure there were some words said too. That stuff is not required.

2017-12-09T01:13:41+00:00

Rugbyfan in WA

Guest


As long as it is not personal etc banter is fine. As a batsman i knew i was frustrating the other team when they started to sledge and it would steel my resolve to not get out. As long as the two teams shake hands at the end of the day and have a beer together then it's fine.

2017-12-08T22:29:10+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


Change your bed sheets , agaaaaaiin , ? Matt ( the hack ) Cleary . Geez ,,, I hope someone isn't stupid enough to pay this stooge to publicly wet the bed like this . What's next ? Winning is for losers ?

2017-12-08T22:06:56+00:00

I ate pies

Guest


For your sake I hope you don't. I'd dominate, and I'd let you know all about it.

2017-12-08T12:04:46+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


It’s a stretch, but fair play for trying.

2017-12-08T11:04:38+00:00

michael steel

Guest


I played both D grade Australian Rules football and D Grade cricket 30 years ago. Playing football I gave out the sledges and copped them because it's a contact game and you could stand toe to toe and say what you liked. In cricket I never spoke to an opponent in an aggressive way on (or off) the field. I just thought it was cowardly.

2017-12-08T09:34:31+00:00

Internal Fixation

Guest


I have never seen or actually received a notice that England has turned up for this series

2017-12-08T09:26:14+00:00

ozinsa

Guest


You need help with your there’s, their’s and they’res my friend

2017-12-08T08:24:43+00:00

Working Class Rugger

Roar Guru


I attended a non-traditional Rugby school who came to the sport filling in for a traditional Sydney GPS school's 2nd grade. We discovered very quickly that girlfriends tended not to get too much of a rise out of the opposition. Mothers might get an attempted smack in the mouth. It was when we would offer to take their grandmothers out and show them a good time was when we really stirred the nest. Good fun. On the flipside. They were bloody rubbish at it.

2017-12-08T08:16:46+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


It’s the send offs I don’t need. In any sport. Typically the bloke giving it looks the foolish one.

2017-12-08T08:11:08+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


Seems like most on this forum, you have either never seen or received an actual headbutt that fits the description.

2017-12-08T07:28:44+00:00

MattR

Guest


And that's why the Author only ever played 4th grade.....

2017-12-08T06:51:01+00:00

Alan

Guest


Right up there was: Marsh to Botham: How's the wife and my kids? Botham to Marsh: Wife's fine, kids are ret@rded... Lesson? Pick your target well. :)

2017-12-08T06:39:54+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


That’s just a bit of banter that The real sledgers are already mentally fragile and already half beaten in the head .

2017-12-08T06:37:40+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


Mental toughness is batting thru challenge adverse conditions and similar applies to other sports . The sledgers are already weak minded and their half beaten when they resort to verbals . It makes beating those sledgers so much more fun . Weak as pss. Each to their own though mate , let’s hope I play agdinst in you in cricket or footy someday .. lol

2017-12-08T05:38:58+00:00

Linphoma

Guest


And after two terrific Test matches, played with skill and verve by both sides contributing, all we want to do is discuss who said what to whom? Let's talk about the cricket.

2017-12-08T05:37:20+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


Jake lol

2017-12-08T05:36:49+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


Lol

2017-12-08T05:36:04+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


I played cricket for 30 years . While only an average grade player . My best batting was always when I was sledged . It enhanced my concentration. The same on s footy field , but being a big guy on a footy field it just made me tackle them even harder , to the sledgers regret . There are some dumb people on this sight that like to name call , they r mentally weak . That’s why it only the mentally week individuals sledge . Actions speak louder then words . No matter the name calling on this site , I won’t be sledged to stop giving my opinions . Good luck to all the decent cricketers out there .

2017-12-08T05:18:39+00:00

Kavvy

Guest


That's not what irony means, Alanis.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar