Bulls closer to Shield final as discarded pair send selectors another reminder

By Scott Pryde / Expert

With just two rounds remaining in the 2017-18 Sheffield Shield, the Queensland Bulls appear to be in the driver’s seat for a spot in the final after a commanding win over South Australia. These are all my key points from Round 8.

Queensland Bulls are looking good, but do they have what it takes to win the competition?
The Bulls have rocketed to the top of the table. They currently lead the competition by eight points and just one win from the final two games will more or less secure their spot in the big dance.

Of course, the pressure will remain on to an extent because of the Shield’s bonus points system, but the Bulls are in an incredibly good position given how close the rest of the competition is.

Their win over the struggling Redbacks by 115 runs indicates their form is at the top and with no real losses to the Australian tour of South Africa – bar Usman Khawaja – they are almost at full strength.

The question of whether they have what it takes to win remains though. An in-form Matt Renshaw is a key at the top of the order, especially if they were to get home ground advantage and only need a draw to take hom the Shield.

Talent is littered right throughout their order though. Marnus Labuschange has produced plenty at first drop including a solid 62 in the game just completed, while Sam Heazlett and Jimmy Pierson among others add depth to their order.

The bowling attack, led recently by Brendan Doggett and Luke Feldman have done their job, with the spin of Australian hopefull Mitchell Swepson adding plenty.

There is a youthful exubrance about this Bulls team. Whether they have enough experience to win the Shield is anyone’s guess, but they didn’t put a foot wrong against the Redbacks.

Victoria move away from the ‘G and find a way to win
As I discussed after Round 7, playing home games at the Melbourne Cricket Ground has crueled Victoria this season. A lifeless deck means not a single result has been forced on the famous ground, but the Bushrangers have done enough on the road and after a huge 255 run win over Western Australia – including a stack of bonus points – they are back to second.

To go from last to second in one round illustrates how close the competition is, but the Bushrangers, with games ahead at the Junction Oval and in Hobart will be confident of two results.

The make-up of the final is likely to come down to bonus points, but the Vics seem like a team who are likely to win their remaining two games against an understrength Blues outfit and Tasmania.

With Glenn Maxwell, Aaron Finch, Cameron White, Daniel Christian and Peter Siddle leading the way, they are experienced and know how to win under pressure. Don’t be surprised to see them finish in the top two.

Matthew Wade and Matt Renshaw fire… again
In Round 7, former Australian wicketkeeper Matthew Wade and opening batsman Matt Renshaw both blasted centuries, making their return to some sort of form.

It was reminiscent of the form which saw them rise to the national team in the first place, and what had been missing from both of their games for the majority of the summer.

Renshaw was on an upward trend anyway with a couple of half-centuries, but he continues to put the pressure on Cameron Bancroft to perform in South Africa, scoring another against the Redbacks. This time, it was an impressive 112 in Queensland’s first innings which virtually set the match up for the visitors.

He made almost a third of their first innings runs, with the Redbacks then proving exactly what the pitch was doing by capitulating for just 162.

From there, the result of the match was a mere formality and with Renshaw making back-to-back centuries, he will look to continue that form for two, maybe three more matches and then take it to county cricket in England with an eye of breaking back into the national set up.

Wade meanwhile all but admitted his Test career was over shortly after being dropped for this summer, replaced by fellow Tigers’ keeper Tim Paine.

While Paine’s form was superb over the summer and there is no chance of him losing his spot anytime soon, Wade is putting the pressure back on with two straight centuries. This one has to be taken with a grain of salt given the road which was presented at the Sydney Cricket Ground, but there can be no doubting Wade is looking good at the crease – something like his former self.

Tasmanian youngsters continue rise
Tasmania might have been involved in one of the more boring draws you are every likely to see with New South Wales at the Sydney Cricket Ground, but that didn’t stop 23-year-old quick Tom Rogers and 21-year-old batsman Jake Doran from making their mark.

With final match scores reading 8 for 449 and 4 for 489, Rogers was the absolute pick of the bowlers as he took 4 for 88 in 20.5 overs. It continues an impressive run of form for the young quick, after he took combined match figures of 7 for 55 last round in Tasmania’s innings rout of Western Australia.

After an impressive Big Bash and good performances on either side, Rogers is a name to monitor over the next couple of years.

Doran, on the other hand, moved from New South Wales and until a this season has never looked himself in the apple isle.

He cracked his maiden century in November and hasn’t looked back, making runs in all but one of his last five Shield innings, including a solid 97 against New South Wales. Like Wade’s score, it has to be taken with some reluctance because of the nature of the wicket, but Doran is on the rise.

With age on his side and a keeping ability to go with it – although that’s not getting much of a run in Tasmania – he is still someone who should be firmly in the future of Australian cricket.

What to make of New South Wales?
It’s difficult to know how to judge the Blues at the moment. The pitch and weather ruined their game against Tasmania, but it means they have had two draws and three losses in their last five matches with the side not looking like winning since their Test players moved away from the side.

With players like Peter Nevill, Nic Maddinson, Moises Henriques, Daniel Hughes and Steve O’Keefe, there is no excuse for them not to be matching it with other States in the Shield.

All five of those players have Test aspirations – to play for Australia – and if they can’t dominate, or at least be winning half of their matches against those other states, then questions have to be asked.

Their performances under pressure have been anything but fantastic, and the Blues at this stage are looking a long way from a finals berth. Even though it’s only two points on the ladder and could swing in a round, they must find a way to beat Victoria and limit the advantage they gain in the next round if they are to make the final.

At the moment though, that looks like a pipe dream for New South Wales. The team don’t know how to win and without their Australian players, it doesn’t look likely to change.

Here is a reminder of where the competition stands with two rounds to go.

Round 8 full results
New South Wales drew Tasmania at SCG
Victoria defeat Western Australia by 255 runs at WACA
Queensland defeat South Australia by 118 runs at Adelaide Oval

As it stands, this is the Sheffield Shield ladder.

    1. Queensland – 40.34
    2. Victoria – 32.11
    3. Tasmania – 31.44
    4. New South Wales – 30.79
    5. Western Australia – 27.43
    6. South Australia – 27.16

These are the remaining fixtures for the season.
Round 9
March 3 – March 6: Victoria vs New South Wales at Junction Oval, St Kilda
March 5 – March 8: Tasmania vs South Australia at Blundstone Oval, Hobart
March 6 – March 9: Queensland vs Western Australia at The Gabba, Brisbane

Round 10
March 14 – Match 17: Tasmania vs Victoria at Blundstone Oval, Hobart
March 14 – Match 17: New South Wales vs Queensland at North Dalton Park, Wollongong
March 14 – Match 17: South Australia vs Western Australia at Gliderol Stadium, Glenelg

Roarers, what did you make of Round 8 in the Sheffield Shield? Drop a comment below and let us know.

The Crowd Says:

2018-03-02T13:34:56+00:00

Brissie Boy

Guest


Adding to that, I think the change to the Dukes ball post Christmas has really worked in our favour as well. The four quicks have functioned well as a unit and the extra movement provided by the different ball seems to have played a major part in that. Case in point, Neser's spell in the 30-40 over period in the South Australian first innings, where he managed to extract a prodigious amount of movement with the old ball and knocked over Lehmann and Carey (two lefties) with balls that started well outside leg before moving back to take the top of off stump. Those were two dismissals which you would have been much less likely to see with a Kookaburra. Still feel our batting needs to improve overall if we are to challenge for the title, especially considering Renshaw's likely impending call-up to the Test team although hopefully the return of Burns (and maybe some runs for Bancroft) can alleviate this. With a declining FC average of 25, Hemphrey still doesn't look like anything more than a stopgap choice in the middle order and hopefully will not be part of the XI long term. Would honestly prefer to have Forrest back in Hemphrey's place for a last hurrah in the Shield final if push came to shove given his outstanding form as leading run-scorer in both Premier Cricket and the Futures League, but the coming out of University is that he has been blacklisted by QLD Cricket General Manager Brett Jones (ex West Coast AFL defender) and won't be picked again regardless of performance.

2018-03-01T21:15:54+00:00

Rob

Guest


You could also say Renshaw was on significantly more testing wickets at the start of the season. How many people were blaming Warner and Smith poor form in the ODI series on mental fatigue? Renshaw was 20yld when picked for Australia and had actual played less than 12months of FC cricket when he made his debut. He was on a tour to India within 3months of making his debut. Would opening the bat against a rampaging, confident South Africa followed by Pakistan and then facing India and Bangladesh away series cause mental fatigue? People started questioning his technque? His technique had worked against South African quicks in a pink ball Test and also given Australia an oportunity of beating India in the first to games of a 4 match series on raging turners? I really laugh at the people complaining he was costing Warner because he scored to slowly. Menwhile Warner hits a 100 before lunch and Renshaw makes 167 NO. on the first day of the same Test. His SR is no different than S. Marsh or S. Waaugh who bat at 6. Renshaw is a Test standard batsmen but needed a rest. Bancroft is totally out of his depth and needs to be replaced.

2018-03-01T08:08:10+00:00

Adam Vics all day

Guest


3rd to be exact.

2018-03-01T07:21:16+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


David Moody and Cameron Green.

2018-03-01T07:20:54+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


I suspect time will heal. Tim Paine came back too soon.

2018-03-01T06:56:26+00:00

Fergus

Roar Rookie


the MCG has been appalling this season. the groundsmen are either love roads or are completly inept. After all the draws you think they might leave a little more grass on it or prepare it earlier so it deteriorates and spins. Apparently such thinking is beyond them

2018-03-01T06:51:43+00:00

David

Guest


It feels like I left someone out? Maybe it's just that Agar was in NZ for those silly T20's (and Tye but he's not in our best shield team).

2018-03-01T06:50:20+00:00

JohnB

Guest


Qld cricket site has been saying he is looking to play the Futures League game next week. If he got through that he'd be available to play NSW and the final.

2018-03-01T06:32:11+00:00

BurgyGreen

Guest


Do you have any insight on whether Whiteman definitely plans to return to keeping? I certainly hope he doesn't give up the gloves.

2018-03-01T06:15:46+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Paris is actually the very best of them all. Definitely first 11. The authorities are allowing him to bowl 10 overs in this weekend's one day grade final. He has been playing as a batsman recently. Whiteman is scoring steadilt now but not keeping. After last weekend's effort, we could see Whiteman selected to open as a batsman only in the Shield.

2018-03-01T06:02:06+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


There you go, starting to get too the of one reasons wrong with our Shield setup.

AUTHOR

2018-03-01T06:00:06+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


They are close enough given because as Rellum says, the pair never looked like playing. Burns though - yeah, that was an oversight.

AUTHOR

2018-03-01T05:59:21+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Unsure about Burns injury situation. I didn't think he was going to be. Imagine if it was Renshaw and Burns at home in a Shield final though? They could just stonewall for two days to get the draw

AUTHOR

2018-03-01T05:57:45+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Yeah James - they are going to struggle over the last two rounds. Can see the Blues taking the spoon

2018-03-01T05:37:16+00:00

David

Guest


Not making excuses for WA but (off the top of my head) they are missing Coulter Nile, Behrendorf, Paris, Whiteman whilst Bancroft, S&M Marsh and Richardson are in SA. Paris maybe the only one above not in WA's best 11. So take 7 of your best players out and your team looks ordinary. As much as Langer wants to win the shield, I think his focus is on developing the kids into international cricketers and I don't think there is any argument he does a good job of that.

2018-03-01T05:25:45+00:00

Fergus

Roar Rookie


Batting results have improved for those players because of form reversal and easier batting wickets. Apart from the MCG the first 3 shield rounds had assistive or in some cases very assistive wickets for the bowlers.

2018-03-01T05:20:53+00:00

Fergus

Roar Rookie


No bird is Tasmanian, he just moved interstate during his youth at some point. Get your facts right.

2018-03-01T05:18:01+00:00

Fergus

Roar Rookie


It's actually really concerning how easily tassie is able to run through opposition sides at home. It indicates that some teams are playing on roads far too much for there on good and explains to some extent the ineptness of Aus bats in english like conditions. Now that the batting has come together for Tas, visiting teams are really struggling to win.

2018-03-01T05:13:45+00:00

Fergus

Roar Rookie


Wades keeping has improved out of sight and is now decent if not very good something many don't seem to want to admit. The reason he was dropped from the Australian side was his under performance with the bat not his gloves which is saying a lot.

2018-03-01T03:08:21+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


That was only his second Shield century over his whole career. I wouldn't be blowing his trumpet too much.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar