The two steps Cricket Australia must take to repair their reputation

By Akkara / Roar Rookie

As Australians, we have just been taken through the most humiliating experience due to the astonishing behaviour of our cricketers.

The bullying, sledging and disrespectful behaviour that we have displayed over 50-plus years, under the guise of ‘playing hard on the field’, has turned around and given us the kick in the proverbial.

Despite ongoing international and local condemnation of our behaviour, it seems that Cricket Australia (CA) was oblivious or chose to ignore the issue.

The power of the people
The great power of social media is the platform for the public to expose situations for what they truly are, and to organize action and force change.

I congratulate the South African public and media for their actions. Their attack was focused, multi-faceted and appropriate on offenders of sledging and cheating.

The stump microphones switched on to expose bullying and sledging, the use of the big screens and stairwell video footage to expose unacceptable behaviour, the focused sledging toward reputed offenders – all were well coordinated.

It was no accident that David Warner, instead of Pat Cummings or Josh Hazelwood, was escorted up the stairs to the change room.

It is also clear that while South Africa took some action, not one other person internationally felt any empathy towards the Australian team, particularly the cricketers.

The view is ‘it’s about time, serves them right’. I hope the board of CA has got the message – the public demands cultural change.

A fish rots from the head
The culture of an organisation is determined by the board and CEO, implemented through other lead roles such as coach and captain.

Public demand for change, while not vocal or clear, has been prevalent for many years. Therefore, it is unlikely that the incumbents can implement change they do not subscribe to.

While James Sutherland may have successes that I am unaware of, his handling of recent publicized issues has been highly questionable.

(Photo by Michael Dodge/Getty Images)

The mishandling of the Memorandum of Understanding caused unnecessary levels of mistrust between CA and the Players’ Association.

We were the laughing stock of the world when he made a formal complaint to the South African Cricket authorities in regards to crowd behaviour.

Seemingly unaware of the international view of Australian spectator behaviour and David Warner’s reputation as a repeat offender of sledging – it appeared as a case of typical colonial entitlement!

When the whole world was expecting decisive action relating a confessed cheat, the best he could do was appoint a bureaucratic investigative panel with no reporting date.

His expectation was to have the Australian team be led out to the field by self-confessed cheats. We must thank Malcolm Turnbull and the Australian Sports Commission for forcing appropriate prompt action, sparing the team and nation further embarrassment.

With such inability to read the gravity of a situation, it is highly questionable that Sutherland could implement cultural change within CA.

The man for the job… or is it a woman?
The greatest area of growth at the moment is women’s cricket. Watching it, I’d say ‘Cricket is a ladies game.’

In other words, Australian women know what it means to behave as a gentleman! If a female CEO is appointed, sledging will be eliminated in no time.

The kan for the job… at the time
Darren Lehmann was the perfect coach to mend a disintegrated team due to selection mayhem. He has been extraordinarily successful in giving players a sense of belonging and fairness in selections.

His tenure has passed the expiry date, however, and a need for gentlemanly behaviour and fair play is the new call. It is unlikely that any former Australian cricketer would genuinely believe in – nor understand – the gentlemanly spirit of the game. We should look for that overseas.

No one man for the job
Test cricket is the most mentally gruelling form of sport in the world. The series is played over a period of a month. In addition, media and public scrutiny are second to none.

It requires extraordinary mental fortitude, warranting a specialist captain with maturity and mental ability beyond that of which is required for the shorter forms of the game.

[latest_videos_strip category=”cricket” name=”Cricket”]

Kim Hughes and now Steve Smith are examples of when CA ruined the careers of our best of breed cricketers, appointing them Test captain while still in cricketing adolescence (under 26).

The Test captain should be around 30 years of age and captained a state or international team, ensuring they have the maturity and expertise for the job.

He should have a clean reputation and some brain power (at least have passed HSC), to confirm that sound judgment will prevail.

Usman Khawaja is the man. The captain of the Sheffield shield winners (Queensland), a graduate of University of New South Wales, and a commercial pilot, his subcontinental background and excellent reputation makes him the perfect person to institute cultural change within the team.

A diverse Cricket Australia?
In conclusion, the solution is a female CEO, a foreign coach and a Test team captain of subcontinental origin! While this may seem humorous, it is a snapshot of where CA should be in ten years.

The U15 nationals were won by the most progressive team, Victoria Metro, with five subcontinental players.

In contrast, the CA U15 team selected from the very same Nationals had four Queenslanders that did not even make the semis.

On this squad, there were only three NSW players that had two teams qualify in the semis and three from the winning Victorian team.

This gives insight into where the failures of integrity and trust lie.

Simply put, Cricket Australia needs holistic change, and now is the time to do it.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2018-03-29T01:24:37+00:00

Akkara

Roar Rookie


Thanks for your well thought out response, and I apologies for the delay in responding. You are absolutely right in saying the SA public behavior was unacceptable. However, it may turn out to be the reason for a cultural change in our team, for which I am thankful. I think their behavior was a response and targeted very specifically at reputed offenders. We are the root cause for it. The point I was making was that in the test arena (unlike shorter formats), captaincy should be a specialized skill, such as batting and bowling. So similar to a batting allrounder, or bowling allrounder, the captain should be a captain bat, or captain bowler, instead of vise versa. I am not suggesting a dead weight captain like Brearley. As you say, there is no clear successor. I haven’t gone in to the facets of captaincy skills, but facts suggest Khawaja has them, having been selected to captain the Sheffield shield winners, Australia A and I believe the Australia U19s. He is now the ICC no 1 ranked Australian batsman available to us (pretty average bunch). In my view Paine is light weight for test captaining. A search on Nationals Cricket will take you to the Cricket Australia page for this. U15 Nationals is the 2nd news item, where you find the pool of 14, and under player statistics you can find the batting and bowling performances. You will find that a person ranked 37 on bowling and 42 on the batting, and another 29 and 31 made it in. Out of the top 12 bowlers, only one (ranked 6 who was also the no 1 bat), was selected. Also the 3rd ranked bat did not get in. How would kids have confidence in the integrity of CA! The politics still prevail, despite all the objective information now being readily available to the public. By the way, I am not Victorian and not affected by this decision.

2018-03-28T06:31:06+00:00

Leonard

Guest


Two things? Or three? One of them should be 'CA Out!'

2018-03-28T01:38:22+00:00

David White

Guest


I presume the piece by Ankara is meant to be humorous or tounge in cheek. Whilst the ball tampering is a serious breach of rules the responses have in many instances, as in the Ankara piece an overreaction. An overseas coach - why? It is the Australian team and should have an Australian coach. Kawabata as captain? He is lucky to be in the side with inconsistent form. A woman CEO? Why? The CEO should be the best person available for the job - be it man or woman. I agree Sutherland should go - been there to long and tine for a change. Over the years has been a very ineffective leader. Smith and Warner need a suitable penalty imposed after charges have been laid and they have faced a properly conducted hearing -everybody is entitled to dealt with through a proper process. The days of hanging from the nearest tree without a hearing are in the past. As for the actual ball tampering a foolish young man thrown under a bus who, after a suitable but not too harsh a penalty deserves a second chance. The same cannot be said for Smith and Warner

2018-03-27T12:57:10+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


There are so many bad points mixed in with some good points in this article, it's hard to know where to begin. You congratulated the South African people and media for displaying the same boorish manners which you heavily criticised in the Australian players? Neither party are angels as the display of bad manner by Rabada shows and the penalties handed out to de Kock. You;re right about Sutherland, his past year has been a real disaster and he should fall on his sword. To suggest though that bringing on board a female CEO will get rid of sledging. Yeah right? The difficulty with the captaincy issue is simply because we have no natural successor in place. The bulk of the guys in the side are either establishing their places or are under scrutiny because they're under performing and Kahwaja is definitely underperforming. The criteria to be a successful captain in Australia includes a good cricket brain, skills enough to be a long term member of the team, leadership skills and the ability to work with both press and public. It does not include those traits you seem to think are important, though one leadership skill is the ability to integrate players regardless of age, background, etc. Australia will no doubt find an interim leader and will hope one or two candidates shine through in the next 2 years, but don't be surprised if these are some leadership changes in the meanwhile. This also should not be seen as a bad thing. in hindsight we've been very lucky to have had a string of excellent on field leaders stretching back to at least Allan Border so, taking our time and trying a few candidates to get right one should not be seen as a negative. Finally, your indignation about which players were chosen for an under 15s national side has clouded your judgement. You have accused those involved of lacking integrity and trust, simply because the side that won the competition only had 3 players selected. You have no justification for making these accusations unless you can point to players being deliberately left out even though they had superior records in the carnival. Do you have these figures or is this a beat up because players from a particular background were excluded? I have no knowledge of this carnival so would find your response most enlightening.

AUTHOR

2018-03-27T11:21:49+00:00

Akkara

Roar Rookie


Khawaja is currently ranked 3rd best Australian Test bat by ICC. He should be in the team based on that alone. However the points I was making is that for test cricket a specialised captain with the smarts was required and that at this point we need someone who would subscribe to cultural change. Khawaja is by far the smartest on the field and would deal with temptations to cheat appropriately; He has a great experience and success in captaining, including the Sheffield shield winning team this year and Australia A teams. I see him as a Greame Smith type captain. His cultural background, I feel would enable him to subscribe to culture change more readily. The article is somewhat humorous optimism to open the mind of the reader. I am sorry I have failed.

2018-03-27T09:49:43+00:00

RogerTA

Roar Rookie


You haven't read too many articles then Marsh ?

2018-03-27T09:48:45+00:00

RogerTA

Roar Rookie


Kim was probably promoted ahead of his time, which is what the author is suggesting, and then not fully supported by the ACB resulting in his destruction by the bully boys on the team.

2018-03-27T08:25:39+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


Kawaga May be third best now ,ahead of the marsh brothers and Bancroft, so that’s not saying much at all If he doesn’t score runs in the 4 th trust , he will be dropped for good .

AUTHOR

2018-03-27T07:29:22+00:00

Akkara

Roar Rookie


Thanks for your comments. Khawaja is the 3rd highest ranked Australian test batsmen in the ICC rankings (16), next to Smith and Warner. This may come as a surprise to you. He has the mental fortitude for test cricket, and has captained Australia at pretty much every level, U19, Australia A and Sheffield shield winners. Bye the way I do not believe he should necessarily captain the shorter forms of the game. We need a person with great brain power, maturity and a clean reputation to lead the team through the next phase.

2018-03-27T07:26:07+00:00

Marshall

Guest


There it is, the worst article I have ever read on the Roar. I was already questionable but when you put Khawaja up based on his subcontinental background that's sealed it for me. Nuffy of the week.

2018-03-27T06:44:48+00:00

Marlin

Guest


I fully agree with you regarding their boorish behaviour, Akkaraots out of the test team and restore some pride. Ball tampering isn't exactly a hanging offence but the way they conduct themselves should be...

2018-03-27T06:43:48+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


I think you need to do some research on who white anted Kim Hughes out of the captain job Usmsn Kawaga would have to justify his place in the team with a bag full of runs , before he can be considered for captain job

Read more at The Roar