Analysing the state of rugby in Australia

By jack rathborne / Roar Rookie

Australia is known for its stunning beaches, cricket, it’s deadly animals, multiculturalism and rugby, but unfortunately we aren’t performing in one of these key things that have our great country recognised around the world.

Rugby has been a crucial part of our country’s history for over 150 years. If something isn’t done about it soon, we will lose one of the most important things that makes us Australians.

I remember when I was ten years old sitting down on the floor in front of the TV ready to watch my beloved Wallabies start their journey to reclaim the Rugby World Cup in 2011.

As the opening ceremony started my mother told me a story about the first world cup I attended in 2003, although I couldn’t remember it because I was two at the time. She told me how all the Wallabies had to do was win the world cup final against England, which I was present for, and how if we did it would’ve been Australia’s third time winning the world cup, making us the first country to do so.

Unfortunately the game narrowly escaping Australia’s grasp in overtime, and with the loss came an era of darkness and defeat in world cup rugby for the Wallabies. They didn’t make a final again until 2015, an excruciating 12 years after the last chance of becoming embedded in history.

(Steve Christo – Corbis/Corbis via Getty Images)

In 1864 if you wanted to play rugby in Australia, you could do so only by attending the University of Sydney, as it wasn’t yet played anywhere else. The first official game of rugby ever played in Australia was Sydney University versus Newington College in 1869.

From the late 1800s to 1987 rugby grew in popularity around the world, culminating in the creation of the first Rugby World Cup in 1987. Throughout the 1990s the Wallabies had some of their best seasons, climaxing in two rugby world cup victories that put Australia firmly at the top of international rugby at the end of the decade.

But as the millennium ended it brought with it a change in the tide of competition for better or worse.

In 2015 I was fortunate enough to travel to England on a rugby tour with Newington College. We travelled around the British countryside while following the Wallabies as they played their pool games. Like the Wallabies in their pool matches, we went undefeated, although it was unfortunate that they couldn’t keep that streak going until the end of the tournament.

It was fate that would see the Wallabies encounter their arch rivals, the All Blacks, in the world cup final. The New Zealand side was the best team in world rugby, and the outcome of the game, a 34-17 All Blacks victory, didn’t reflect the intensity of the game.

(AFP)

Out of the eight rugby world cups that have taken place, Australia has never not made it through to the quarter-finals. Only four countries have ever won the world cup: New Zealand has won three times, Australia twice, South Africa twice and England once.

During the 1990s Australia competed in three world cups, winning two, making us the only country to have won the world cup twice at the time. That was the case until 2007, when South Africa won their second world cup.

Australia won their two World Cups in 1991 and 1999, but professional rugby wasn’t introduced until 1995. Players were playing simply for the recognition and pride of playing for their country, and the team barely changed between those victorious years.

Today we are seeing more players coming out of school and going straight into rugby league rather than going through the different levels of club rugby to be selected in the professional teams because they are paid at an earlier stage. This is mainly because players can be scouted while still at school to play for a development squad of one of the professional clubs in the NRL.

There are ten New South Wales NRL teams, including nine in Sydney, that you can be paid to play for compared to rugby union’s one professional NSW side, but rugby union requires a player to play at so many different levels before you can be selected for a professional team.

Rugby union is therefore missing out on the players who are choosing to play league for quick money. Although the average pay for an NRL player in 2018 is $313,000 and will increase to $330,000 over the next five years, the average pay for a Super Rugby player is only $225,000 almost $100,000 less.

(Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

In 2016 World Rugby obtained information from each country as to how many people play the game. Australia had 767 clubs and 86,952 registered players, of which 26,664 were boys under the age of 13, 19,239 were male teens, 39,380 were senior males and 1,669 were senior females.

Only 86,952 people in a population of 24 million were playing rugby union. Eight years earlier, in 2008, there were 466,182 people playing rugby league in Australia, which is five times the number. At the same time in 2016 New Zealand, with a population of 4.7 million people, had 600 clubs with 156,893 union players and only 24,000 playing league.

I’m not saying that rugby should be taken back to the amateur days, that New Zealand will never be beaten, that rugby players should get more money or even that rugby league is to blame for all the current problems in union; I’m simply trying to ascertain the reason for the issues plaguing my beloved Wallabies and the sport of rugby union in Australia.

I’ve tried to understand why Australian rugby is having these issues. Now it’s up to the sport to determine what changes can be made so that the Wallabies and Australia can get back on top.

The Crowd Says:

2019-11-23T12:48:47+00:00

Rolando

Guest


Thanks for this synopsis Jack. "’ve tried to understand why Australian rugby is having these issues" The reason is money. It's nothing to do with Rugby Union and everything to do with human nature.

2019-11-01T09:53:31+00:00

Tom

Guest


Rugby in Australia was, and still is, culturally the "posh boys" game, played in a small clutch of private schools. You won't change that through marketing or advertising. It's simply ingrained. Just as you won't turn New Zealand or England to Rugby League. Australia just needs to accept that for a long time it punched above its weight in rugby, but those days are gone. We're just one of the mediocre nations.

2019-10-03T01:58:40+00:00

peter

Guest


Rugby will never compete with basketball or AFL...too many rules..You indicatedd you went to a Privat e school. therein is the problem. Upper class elitist game played by white kids wih lots polynesians playing for money. Rugby is great for the larger body type . I dont know any one who plays rugby here in Victoria, most kids play soccer afl or basketball/netball. Rugby needs to be inclusive for it thrive i Vic, Get away from private schools..too elite..

2018-04-06T23:03:07+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


Clubs played to their own laws. Dublin Unversity Football Club was founded in 1854.

2018-04-06T22:57:17+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


They pocketed more than they paid the players.

2018-04-06T22:50:27+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


The RA don't do due diligence they look after their mates than get stabbed in the back.

2018-04-05T13:14:03+00:00

Bludger

Guest


That’s called the NRL. Union is nearing end of days in Oz. It is just too small now to ever come back.

2018-04-05T13:10:08+00:00

Bludger

Guest


How could they play rugby as we know it when the laws of union were not written until the 1870s. Aussie rules and soccer are older.

2018-04-05T07:23:08+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


TWAS, don't you think they would have closed the case and drop it if there was nothing to be found? I think they will find that the ARU was incompetent that will come as no surprise to us in the West.

2018-04-05T04:56:03+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


It has a lot to do with what you said.

2018-04-05T04:51:40+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


So where are the savings to go to grassroots?

2018-04-05T01:07:04+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


I don't know what that has to do with any of what I've said.

2018-04-05T01:05:03+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Salary cap increases were always going to occur. Wages do not remain stable. Cap increases basically accommodate the revised squad size remember.

2018-04-04T14:23:36+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


Do you think the European unions will get much in their 30% in a weaker currency that they have to wait eight years for?

2018-04-04T14:21:47+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


'Despite your apparent aggression I actually think our positions are much closer than you believe.' Disagree. Unions like the RA and SARU deserve squat from European unions. 'Oh and by the way, the idea of revenue sharing isn’t mine, it comes from the NZ Union.' and they were told quiet rightly to take a hike. How do you explain to the clubs down in remote parts of Cornwall who are trying to arrange buses for their underage teams to travel to away fixtures and fund pads for their seniors that the RFU can't distribute funds towards them this season as they had to cost cut? Mainly due to distribution 30% of the gate earned from the near annual fixture at Twickenham against the Wallabies to the RA who p..s their money against the wall on pointless rebranding, relocation, junkets, consultancy fees, worldwide searches for executives that begin and end in Sydney that they can no longer fund their own. Sorry doesn't wash. Will Carling's remark about the 100 old farts is completely relevant to modern day Australian Rugby administration.

2018-04-04T07:50:12+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


It's only the Tahs that get an increase? Surprised Wallabies like Coleman, Genia, Haylett-Petty etc didn't all go rushing to NSW to cash in. I'm in full agreement that cutting the Force was the wrong thing for Aussie rugby. Also think it is ridiculous that the cutting immediately preceded increased squad sizes and salary cap increases to the remaining Super teams. Not sure there is a NSW bias in either of those things happening though and if there was intended to be it certainly wasn't succesfully implemented.

2018-04-04T05:23:23+00:00

shooshiner

Guest


" And instituting a draft for an amateur competition? Nothing better to help further drop participation by telling amateur players, who have to pay to play, where they have to play " We all know Sydney University are no amatuers Train Without A Terminus. Same goes with University of Queensland.

2018-04-04T05:01:35+00:00

Captain Sensible

Guest


Dean, They were thrashed in the RWC 2015 final.Let`s be frank and clear about that.It was a false dawn.-.Back in those days you mentioned they did invariably much much better post RWC years without that spud Chieka at the helm. After 1987, The 1989-1994 Wallabies were great and after 1995, 1998 -2003 were great .Cheika has taken this team to rock bottom in 2016-2017. Also pre RWC 2015, 2014 was also a bad year for Cheika.He has such an atrocious record, I cannot fathom how he keeps his job? .Time for Cheika to fall on his sword.

2018-04-04T04:30:54+00:00

concerned supporter

Guest


Powerbrokers, a good description Jeznez, Some people much prefer power to money.

2018-04-04T04:13:51+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Suspect you may be largely right, although it is possible that 1 and 2 are the other way around. Of course they think that getting those two right will ensure a strong Wallabies and that will magically make everything ok. I love my Shute Shield team and I love my Super rugby side but for me the key to Australian rugby's future is going to be the NRC. Rather scary if that truly sits at the bottom of the priority list for the largest powerbrokers in Australian rugby.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar