The NRL's top five coaches of 2018 (so far)

By Jay Ross / Roar Guru

They say the success of a leader is best judged by the actions of those he guides. So who are the top five coaches after five rounds of the 2018 NRL competition?

The usual suspects of late have been 2017 premiership winner Craig Bellamy, the unflappable Wayne Bennett and Paul Green from the successful Cowboys.

But this year, they have been overshadowed by a new crop of mentors.

1. Ivan Cleary
He has recruited well but still doesn’t have a champion team at his disposal. Regardless, Cleary has the Tigers playing as a motivated group who are inspiring each other on the field with passionate and unwavering defence and a far more controlled attack.

He has instilled confidence in halfback Luke Brooks, who is having one of his most consistent years in first grade. In addition, Cleary has transformed Benji Marshall into a clever ball-player who is able to lead with his game management rather than quick footwork.

Cleary’s gameplan is simple but effective – tackle hard, get through the six in attack, and play the game in the opposition’s half. He has devised a strategy that works well given the strengths of his current crop. Players like Elijah Taylor and Ben Matulino are a reflection of his personality – honest, no-nonsense workers.

The Tigers are doing a lot of things right in 2018 and the team spirit is something Cleary can be very proud of. They may even end up in the top eight, which was unimaginable when the season started.

[latest_videos_strip category=”rugby-league” name=”League”]

2. Stephen Kearney
Stephen Kearney has assembled a team that exudes self-confidence and control. Kearney obviously has a determination to win in 2018 and he has sold his dream to many great players, attracting new recruits Kevin Proctor, Tohu Harris and Blake Green.

Kearney has instilled a poise not seen by previous, flamboyant Warriors teams. Their spirit is shown through the breathing ritual they go through after scoring a try. They form a tight circle, arm in arm, and simultaneously breathe together as a unified force, while taking in the calm words of captain Roger Tuivasa-Sheck.

This year, Kearney is blessed with a skillful and powerful side, and they could just go all the way.

3. Paul McGregor
The Dragons traditionally start every season well, but after about eight or so rounds, they fade into the darkness. This season looks different.

The Red V are undefeated after five rounds, and their wins have been convincing every week.

McGregor has filled in the missing pieces of his puzzle with skillful halfback Ben Hunt and the ferocious leader of the pack, James Graham.

Gareth Widdop has been waiting for a halves partner to take the pressure off him, and the team is reaping the rewards. The forwards now have a mentor in Graham, building on the strength of Josh Frizell, Jack De Belin and Paul Vaughan.

In attack, they are an excitement machine, with ‘Mary’ giving speedsters Euan Aitkin and Matt Duffy freedom to roam.

The team spirit is strong, evidenced in the fact that the Sydney-based players have organised a 12-seater bus to ride to training in Wollongong together. Jason Nightingale, the instigator, was quoted as saying, “We’ve invested in a bus so we can include our whole Sydney family.”

The Dragons are clearly on the road to brighter days.

(AAP Image/Michael Chambers)

4. Nathan Brown
The Newcastle Knights are no longer the easybeats. Nathan Brown has sold his dream to a host of new talent – including a future star of the game, Kalyn Ponga, who plays with far more maturity than his 20 years.

Other followers of the Brown brigade include Mitchell Pearce, Aiden Guerra and the exciting Connor Watson – a young half the Roosters did not want to lose.

This year, coach Brown has already concocted impressive wins against the Sea Eagles and, recently, the more-fancied Brisbane Broncos.

The 45-year-old has now spent 15 years in the top job at various homes. In 2003, as a 29-year-old, he was given his first coaching job, at his beloved Dragons, who finished second on the ladder in 2005, but by 2008 he was booted out.

Brown then took an opportunity to hone his skills in England, leading Huddersfield to the 2009 Challenge Cup final. He then moved to St Helens and guided them to victory in the 2014 grand final.

In 2015 he returned home and took up a position with Craig Bellamy as ‘coaching consultant’ at the Melbourne Storm.

Now he finds himself in Newcastle with a far wiser head on his shoulders. In fact, it feels like the Knights are moving away from the wooden spoon zone and headed in the direction of the top eight in 2018.

Knights coach Nathan Brown. (AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

5. Anthony Griffin
Could any coach have had a more tumultuous start to the year? He lost captain Matt Moylan to the Cronulla Sharks before the season started, the had to field questions about key players wanting out.

This was followed by numerous rumours about Griffin being a puppet to Phil Gould, who was apparently meant to be the one running the training sessions. More recently, he’s had to revise his gameplan to accommodate the nine-week injury to key playmaker Nathan Cleary.

Throughout all this, he has been composed and can hold his head up high, letting the team’s attitude and results speak for themselves. He has managed James Maloney’s healthy ego and created a team spirit based on ferocious defending and strong runs through the middle.

The Panthers have won two in a row, including a convincing 33-14 victory over the Cowboys. They may well be headed for a hat-trick of victories with a home game against the Titans this week.

Griffin has moulded the Panthers into a dangerous side who, at this stage, may just maintain their momentum despite a growing injury list.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2018-04-15T09:47:12+00:00

Jay Ross

Roar Guru


Too true

2018-04-12T20:04:21+00:00

shirtpants

Roar Guru


Or was it frizelled?

2018-04-12T10:49:26+00:00

DP Schaefer

Guest


Cleary definitely, Mary and Kearney have been saved by some new faces after poor performances in the past. They aren't suddenly good coaches. Brown learning, but seriously should have done better last year. Might develop into a top line coach in a year or two. Griffin - well his 'revival' came after Gus took a closer role in the coaching. Barrett doing better than a couple of those given the difficulties he started with.

2018-04-12T08:07:21+00:00

Ben Wilson

Guest


Kevin Proctor plays for the titans not the warriors

2018-04-12T08:06:53+00:00

John

Guest


Will be interesting to revisit this list at the end of 24 rounds to see how these coaches a faring. Without looking at any stats I do wonder if teams that get out of the gates early in the season runs out of puff towards the end, and if there is a correlation, how many of those sides were coached by relatively inexperienced coaches or coaches that were under immense pressure. You would have to think coaches that are new or are under pressure would want early runs on the board for job security so they may sacrifice a season so they can build for the next season.

2018-04-12T07:33:35+00:00

Forty Twenty

Guest


The voices of reason struggle to gain traction when the dreaded declaration is widely broadcast ' he can't coach' . I've asked some fans how sure are they and what method have they used to be so sure of themselves. Whether they understand it or in denial all they are doing early in a coaches career is looking at the scoreboard and if it makes them unstable then the coach must be to blame. All the other factors apparently don't count and the scoreboard is a sure measure of a coach in their black and white world.

2018-04-12T07:13:25+00:00

Brian S

Guest


I know i'm in China working & it's hard to get NRL news, but i didn't know Kevin Proctor had left the Titans for the Warriors ? ;)

AUTHOR

2018-04-12T06:56:58+00:00

Jay Ross

Roar Guru


Thanks for your comments Ron. You're right - the Titans won't be happy with me. Wouldn't it be great if Proctor became a doctor!! Dr Procter.

AUTHOR

2018-04-12T06:54:06+00:00

Jay Ross

Roar Guru


Appreciate your kind words 'The Barry'.

AUTHOR

2018-04-12T06:51:36+00:00

Jay Ross

Roar Guru


Too true. Good correction - my head must have be frizzled :)

2018-04-12T05:43:46+00:00

Celtic334

Guest


He's obviously naming kiwi super rugby players; Matt Duffy - ex Storm and Kiwis winger now playing for the Blues Tyson also actually has a brother that plays for the Highlanders (Shannon not Josh but we will let him off with that) :P

2018-04-12T05:36:53+00:00

664 neighbour of the beast

Guest


WHY ARE WE SCREAMING!!!! IM ANGRY!!!

2018-04-12T05:36:34+00:00

664 neighbour of the beast

Guest


2018-04-12T05:15:22+00:00

Muzz

Guest


And Matt Duffy's mate Matt Dufty!

2018-04-12T04:38:17+00:00

KenW

Guest


Actually Don this one sticks at me too. It's been quite a recurrent motif recently but it doesn't really hold up. I don't think the Bennett years count (hmm maybe 2011) - if you finish 1st it's not a strong start, it's a strong season. Last year it definitely works, they were 6 from the first 7 (they lost rd2) but before that they hadn't won a round 1 game in donkey's. In 2016 they won 2 of the first 6. In 2015 they lost the first 2 games before stringing a few together. Long term Saints supporters just wouldn't see their team as strong starters - their more common technique over the years is a big rearguard action to sneak into the bottom half of the finals in the last couple of weeks of a season.

2018-04-12T04:08:02+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


Jay, Kevin Proctor-ologist is definitely not at the Warriors, thank god. They signed the good one in Tofu.

2018-04-12T01:15:08+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


Brown is justifiably going well - sure if you consider he's had the wooden spoon the last 2 years and his only premiership is with st Helens in super league which really is like winning Intrust cup. Like The Barry said Arthur has really achieved nothing except he's a really nice bloke and also Barrett who has all these wraps on him. Of all the coaches on the way up Paul green seems to be next top liner. Only Bennett and bellamy are the only coaches who have multiple successes and once they are gone the others will need to step up.

2018-04-12T00:35:20+00:00

Wayne Turner

Guest


What about BA and Ricky ha,ha,ha...

2018-04-12T00:33:57+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


As someone said above I reckon it’s really difficult to judge coaches from outside the club. No insight into their man management, how they work with assistants, training, etc. we all look at a team winning and say “the coach must be good”. A couple of examples. Brad Arthur - since coming into first grade there have been massive wraps on Arthur despite having achieved not a lot. I don’t understand the wraps on him. He seems to talk sense but most coaches do. I’m not suggesting he’s a bad coach but it always seems to me to be a bit of group think giving him massive wraps so early on. Paul McGregor is the other example. For much of his tenure the Dragons attack has been dire. Last year the Dragons started sensationally but lost their way from mid season. There appeared to be absolutely no plan B, no changes to structure, playing style or personnel. It was deer in the headlights stuff as they got rolled week after week by far worse performing teams and rolled out the same team and attacking style. This is an objective example of where a coaches influence and performance can be judged...from memory their decline wasn’t caused by an injury crisis or anything. So they’ve started well again and McGregor deserves credit but it doesn’t suddenly make him a top five coach. I think he needs to be judged when the Dragons hit a flat spot or have a few injuries or have a run of tough games... Cleary seems to get a strong season out of a club early in his tenure but historically finds it difficult to maintain the rage. BTW Jay - I’m really enjoying your articles. Some interesting well considered takes on things. Cheers.

2018-04-12T00:31:41+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


I think you may have to include Garth Brennan in your top five. This is his first year as an NRL club and so far he has done a good job except for 1 flogging. Compare him with Nathan Brown who has had 2 close wins a surprise against Broncos and 2 hefty losses. Brennan has beaten manly and Broncos comfortably. Not all of these coaches may end up making eight but you have to give credit where it's due.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar