It's time for Melbourne City to make their mark on the A-League

By Mike Tuckerman / Expert

Melbourne City could be the club we all love to hate, but their brief history has largely been marked by indifference. Is tonight the night that all changes?

There’s a lot to like about Melbourne City from a neutral standpoint.

They’ve given us Bruno Fornaroli and brought back Luke Brattan. They’ve revitalised the likes of Dario Vidosic and Oliver Bozanic and Stefan Mauk.

They’ve introduced seasoned European pros like Bart Schenkeveld and Michael Jakobsen, and their stadium resembles the sort of football cathedrals we see in Europe.

They even had Tim Cahill for a while.

Why, then, do they engender so much indifference?

It’s partly because Melbourne Victory are the most parochially backed side in the league.

Say what you will about Bleak City, but there’s no denying the fact that Victory fans are a ravenous bunch at the best of times.

It’s this sort of partisanship that ‘Team 11′ is trying to tap into with an expansion bid representing south-east Melbourne.

However, hampered by sharing their stadium with Victory, a rebadged City haven’t quite managed to attract the same level of support.

It didn’t help that the old Melbourne Heart was a bit of a non-entity.

The missing point of difference with Victory was one of the most discussed elements of the Heart era.

But now that the City Football Group are busy polishing another English Premier League trophy – and no doubt having a quiet word to Ange Postecoglou up in Yokohama as well – their focus should by rights return to the A-League.

So we should all care, especially if City go on and win the championship.

It shouldn’t be forgotten that they did everything they could to try and keep Ross McCormack. The Scottish striker finished as the league’s third-best goal scorer this season, despite playing just 17 games.

(AAP Image/Joe Castro)

And the burly McCormack – who hasn’t featured in a single Aston Villa squad since returning to England – turned out to be one of the more inspired signings of the season.

So why should we begrudge a club which year after year brings down entertainers like Fornaroli and McCormack and the sadly missed Fernando Brandan?

And when is the A-League going to do something useful with the salary cap?

How is it actually helping if clubs that show some initiative lose players like McCormack – or worse still, Melbourne Victory star Leroy George – while others like the Central Coast Mariners don’t even spend the full amount available?

Isn’t a cap designed to act as an equalising measure simply holding back the bigger clubs, and robbing the A-League of the sort of players who might actually bring some fans through the gate?

If they weren’t so busy trying to stall for time to ward off FIFA’s advances, the first thing on Football Federation Australia’s agenda should be to revamp the salary cap.

Or get rid of it altogether.

And they should take a look at some more realistic ticket prices while they’re at it.

“We listened to the feedback from last year’s finals and dropped ticket prices across the board to allow families to attend,” was the headline quote from Greg O’Rourke in the build-up to the finals.

Yeah, yeah Greg… we’ve heard it all before. And there’s that magic word again: “families”.

[latest_videos_strip category=”football” name=”Football”]

You sometimes wonder whether you’re supposed to be attending a football game or a Wiggles concert.

But putting aside the fact that many of the young fans who actually create the atmosphere inside A-League grounds are kids themselves, ticket prices for the finals series are still too high.

That’s not a problem for O’Rourke – he doesn’t pay for his tickets – but it is for fans expected to shell out an eye-watering $69 plus booking fee for a City Gold ticket tonight.

No wonder the seats on halfway are always empty.

That shouldn’t take away from what will be a blockbuster clash at AAMI Park.

Hated and proud? Melbourne City just need to do something memorable first.

The Crowd Says:

2018-04-22T11:51:22+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


Real Madrid have been sponsored by the Spanish government , not Catalonia

2018-04-22T05:41:37+00:00

Leonard

Guest


You left out the Q - prepare for a social media storm of outrage, and perhaps a call from the HRC Peoples Commissar!

2018-04-22T05:39:04+00:00

Leonard

Guest


About "not [posting links to [Hinds'] articles" - who do you think you are, to be in effect demanding this? Students at one of our more closed-minded and ideologically dumbed-down universities doing a 'no-platforming' rant?

2018-04-22T05:27:11+00:00

Leonard

Guest


Why would Real Madrid get grants from the Catalan government? (And given the latest rift between Madrid and Barcelona, they won't ever.)

2018-04-22T05:23:31+00:00

Leonard

Guest


"A capped league reduces the quality of players and therefore onfield quality" - mmmm, looks like one of the claimed consequences of opening a closed or heavily sheltered market in economics. Despite (understandable but unrealised) fears at the time, the removal of many tariffs in the Hawke-Keating era did not cause mass starvation, widespread poverty and permanent 25% unemployment. In general terms, our quality of life and quantum of wealth has increased. So, maybe, could the same apply to Association Football here?

2018-04-20T17:59:10+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


Nothing wrong with that. That sounds about the full extent of their supporter base. Can't ask for more.

2018-04-20T14:27:09+00:00

Redondo

Guest


Less than 8,000 turned up for tonight’s City vs Roar elimination final. A worry.

2018-04-20T07:59:53+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


What is this link about? Takes me to an icon for channel one Is this on the free view tv app ?

2018-04-20T07:51:29+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


Fair enough

2018-04-20T07:49:52+00:00

Kangajets

Guest


The mighty grey schilllachee trained by the freedmans I think Baggio ran in a cox plate in 1993 A great era for Australian thoroughbreds with Italian names Newcastle trainer Paul Perry won some races with pele and Van nistelrooy got around for Rossy Stitt of Taree . Berisha races in Melbourne Pretty sure Winx is named after Harry Winx

2018-04-20T07:43:46+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


That joke will never get old, Mike. :)

AUTHOR

2018-04-20T07:38:44+00:00

Mike Tuckerman

Expert


I actually suspect Melbourne City think they've done the right thing appointing Warren Joyce. He was renowned for his work with Manchester United's reserve team. I think the feeling was that he'd help bring young players through (that the City Football Group could potentially sell off to EPL clubs for a profit).

AUTHOR

2018-04-20T07:21:10+00:00

Mike Tuckerman

Expert


I'll have to ask her. But in the meantime I'd just rather we didn't link to his articles.

2018-04-20T07:05:36+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


"This is a variation which could add real interest to the game." Until they stuff it up with VAR.

2018-04-20T06:57:28+00:00

realfootball

Guest


Yeah, Kanga, I'm in the go for it camp. Because it sure ain't working now.

2018-04-20T06:55:45+00:00

realfootball

Guest


Why? I'm sorry, Mike, but you need do to explain. Because you're right - you do raise these issues and good on you. So what's the problem. Did he sleep with your girlfriend?

2018-04-20T06:38:31+00:00

Grobbelaar

Roar Guru


This is a variation which could add real interest to the game.

2018-04-20T06:37:00+00:00

Grobbelaar

Roar Guru


Apologies, Mike.

2018-04-20T06:27:17+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


It isn't a typo, it's actually a new format that FFA are trialing. Three teams means higher ratings - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W64ySTJg1j0

2018-04-20T06:25:54+00:00

LuckyEddie

Guest


Maybe Hinds at their ABC could actually do something like cover and help promote football. Their ABC is so consumed with the LGBTWYZXZZXFBJH crowd that they really are a sad PC joke.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar