Match preview: Sydney Swans vs Carlton Blues

By Justin Mitchell / Roar Guru

The Carlton Blues return to the SCG on Friday night, taking on one of the AFL favourites, the Sydney Swans.

Marn Grook is an important round for the Swans, with Indigenous stars Adam Goodes, Michael O’Loughlin and Lewis Jetta celebrated over the past decade.

Hawthorn edged the Swans by six points in a thriller at the SCG in the corresponding round last year, with superstar Indigenous players Shaun Burgoyne and Lance Franklin jointly awarded best on ground honours.

A repeat for the Swans would be heartbreaking, given their harrowing Round 6 loss to Carlton last year, amid their worst start to a season since 1994.

Sydney made them pay for their win in Round 23 last year, Franklin booting ten goals to seal his fourth Coleman medal in the Swans’ 81-point romp.

While Carlton would give themselves an outside chance, few else would, given their form and position on the ladder.

The Blues held Geelong to just 73 points at home last week, and recorded more scoring shots, but it’s hard to look at the result as anything other than Geelong cruising in second gear after the five-minute mark of the first quarter.

[latest_videos_strip category=”afl” name=”AFL”]

Sydney dominate the head-to-head between the teams since 2012, winning eight of their last nine clashes, with Carlton’s win at the MCG last season breaking the streak of eight wins.

There have been several close matches, most notably the final at Stadium Australia in 2011 and Josh Kennedy’s herculean effort in Round 18, 2016 to drag the Swans over the line by six points.

But when the Swans win big, it’s always off the back of a strong second half, with ten or more goals kicked after halftime in their last four 60-points-plus wins.

Liam Jones will be eager to test himself against the premier forward in the league, but his recent form – especially against Tom McDonald – has been condemned by Fox Footy presenter Danny Frawley.

Carlton have struggled with possession of the ball all season, ranked 18th and 15th for average disposals and average contested disposals – the Swans are ranked seventh (381.5) and sixth (150.9) respectively.

Also, expect to see the ball spending a lot of time inside the Swans’ forward half, with Sydney leading Carlton in disposal efficiency (72% to 69%), rebound 50s (plus-five) and inside 50s (plus 4.6), as well as score differential (Swans plus-119, Carlton minus-380).

Carlton have a lot to prove, with gun on-ballers Ed Curnow and Patrick Cripps leading the way, while the Swans recall out-of-favour winger Nic Newman and forward Gary Rohan.

Key matchups

George Hewett versus Patrick Cripps
Patrick Cripps is in fantastic form, backing up from two terrific seasons before, and is the top-ranked Carlton player in the AFL’s player ratings, at 20.

George Hewett, on the other hand, struggled to hit his straps early, but has performed admirable shut-down jobs over the last month on Nat Fyfe, Dayne Zorko and Tom Mitchell.

Ed Curnow versus Harry Cunningham
Ed Curnow is a barometer for the Blues – when he’s ticking, they’re threatening. He’s found joy against the Swans in recent weeks, so it falls to the Swans back-up stopper Harry Cunningham to curb his influence.

Cunningham can get the job done, most recently neutralising Isaac Smith in the Swans’ fantastic nine-point win against the Hawks in Round 8.

Lance Franklin versus the entire Carlton defence
Liam Jones will be having nightmares lining up against Lance Franklin this week – his recent form led to a hilarious condemnation by Frawley after Round 9. He’s a terrific intercept player, but even the best defenders are hapless without help, or when the ball is camped inside the opponents forward arc.

Lance Franklin may well play the decoy role this week, with Sam Rowe, Lachie Plowman and Jacob Weitering capable of doing a job.

Dane Rampe versus Charlie Curnow
Charlie Curnow is an exciting young player and capable of hitting the scoreboard hard and fast. He’s a quick, athletic, can take great marks and kick a bomb.

But this week, he’s up against the best fullback in the league. Rampe is in terrific form and will prove to be a worthy adversary.

Dane Rampe (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

It’s a big week for Gary Rohan
The Swans forward was recalled after being dropped and publicly berated for not working hard enough by head of football Tom Harley. He didn’t play in the NEAFL last week and needs to prove that he’s worth his spot in the side.

Prediction
Sydney Swans by 68 points.

The Crowd Says:

2018-06-03T22:48:18+00:00

Macca

Guest


Yeah me and my big mouth!! Cripps still managed 6 clearances but his 17 disposals was his lowest for the year.

2018-06-01T12:37:23+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


I would say he’s got the better of Cripps tonight. Don’t know the numbers (I know how much you love stats) but his impact tonight was no where near his last month.

2018-06-01T03:21:06+00:00

Macca

Guest


I have my doubts about Hewett going with Cripps - Hewett stands 188cm and weighs 83kg and Cripps stand 195cm and 93kg, Cripps averages 8.3 clearances compared to Hewetts 3.3, Cripps averages 6.3 tackles compared to Hewetts 3.5 and Cripps averages 19.6 contested possessions to Hewetts 10.3 - if the Swans go with that match up I think it will be a win for the blues.

2018-06-01T03:14:08+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


For me Sydney aren't one of those sides that you generally see blow opposition off the park, especially one that plays a game style like the Blues and especially on the smaller SCG. But Justin has nailed the match up's, other than I think you will find Grundy spend a fair bit of time on C Curnow.

2018-06-01T03:12:34+00:00

Macca

Guest


You aren't alone there - his clearance and tackling numbers in the VFL have been super impressive, I expect he will spend a fair amount of time forward but if he can replicate that form when he does go into the middle it will be big for us - another 190cm mid always comes in handy - especially against the swans. I would love for Bolts to send him to the first bounce with Cripps, Kreuzer and Curnow.

2018-06-01T03:09:46+00:00

Macca

Guest


And yet where are they AD? The amount of people on here who just like to whinge about the blues is amazing.

2018-06-01T03:08:54+00:00

Macca

Guest


Great write up Justin - one thing though I will find it interesting if the Swans do try to "neutralise" Ed Curnow given Ed usually neutralises the oppositions most dangerous mid while getting a heap of it himself (particularly this year). How he goes will have a massive impact though - Cripps, E Curnow & Kreuzer really need to crack in around the contests and try at least to break even with the quality big bodies the Swans have around the ball.

2018-06-01T02:42:25+00:00

Rippa86

Guest


I'm just looking forward to how Jack Silvagni plays in the midfield.

AUTHOR

2018-06-01T02:23:51+00:00

Justin Mitchell

Roar Guru


Thanks AdelaideDocker :) There were supposed to be 6 key points as well, but they're missing... possibly duplicate content of the preamble 1: Swans average winning margin since 2012 is 43 points 2: Last time they met 3: Info about the players in the player ratings 4: Swans kick 10 second-half goals in their 60+ wins 5: Carlton struggle with possession 6: Swans should dominate forward half possession

2018-06-01T02:12:08+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


Perhaps this would appease those aggrieved by the earlier match forecast. Good write up, Justin. Similar margin to what I’m tipping.

Read more at The Roar