The NRC report card at the halfway point

By Brett McKay / Expert

So then, one month down, five weeks to go. With three more weeks of regular season and two weeks of National Rugby Championship finals to come, we’ve hit the halfway point of the season.

NRC seasons have never been marathons by any stretch, but the 2018 season really feels like the sprint it clearly is.

After sixteen games and a brilliant round of rugby last weekend, we’ve now got a pretty clear idea of where each of the eight teams ‘are at’.

Obviously, the table is a good measure of this, so let’s drag it up a bit higher this week. Tables often aren’t seen as being reflective of competitions, though, and often that’s because it’s easy to come up with whatever qualifier you need. Team X hasn’t played Team Y yet; Team Z has played three-quarters of their games on the road.

But right now, as it stands, the NRC table after four rounds perfectly reflects how I see the eight teams.

NRC table
Fiji 14, Queensland Country 14, Canberra 13, Western Force 13; Brisbane City 9, Melbourne 7, NSW Country 5, Sydney Rays 1.

First to fourth being separated by just one point is the clincher here, and it absolutely marries up with my broad views of the teams before the campaign began this year. Pre-season predictions are always dangerous for short competitions, but you naturally have ‘top half’ and ‘bottom half’ thoughts.

The table currently reflects my ‘top half’ and ‘bottom half’ thoughts. All the current top four are where I thought they’d be. I always thought Queensland Country would be up there, just as I did of the Western Force. Canberra and Fiji were definitely good enough to stick with them.

James Tuttle of Queensland Country. (Photo by Jason O’Brien/Getty Images)

It’s not just the one-point gap that shows their closeness, though; the four teams’ for-and-against differentials all fall within 21 points of each other. That’s three converted tries in a competition currently averaging 10.4 tries per game.

Fiji, Queensland Country, and the Western Force are within four points for and two tries of each other in attack. Country and the Force have just one point in defence between them, while Fiji and Canberra are separated by seven; just four conceded tries separate the four teams. Canberra is slightly behind in attack, but this is somewhat cancelled out by having the best defence in the comp.

They’re clearly the four best teams in the comp, and I think they all go on from here and reach the semis.

Behind them, Brisbane City and Melbourne are certainly next best, and that’s reflected in the two teams sitting four and six points, respectively, outside the top four. Melbourne at halftime last Saturday looked like they’d comfortably beat Brisbane, yet City scrummed their way back into the contest and deserved the win.

Funnily enough, though, I still think the Rising are the team most likely to challenge a current top four side, but the big proviso is that they have to reach the top four first.

Brisbane have Queensland Country, NSW Country (away), and Canberra to come; Melbourne have Canberra (away), Western Force, and Sydney.

Quade Cooper for Brisbane City. (Sportography)

Both runs home are pretty tough, and I’m not sure either City or the Rising are consistent enough to win enough games to challenge for a top four berth.

Below them, while I hoped NSW Country and Sydney would be better than their current rankings, I kind of feared this was where they’d be.

The Eagles were unlucky to lose to Canberra on Sunday though, and they have showed some really good signs in their last two games. They have two top four teams to come in their run home, and though I can’t see them winning all three remaining games, I have a sneaking suspicion they might jag two wins to finish their season.

I can’t say that about the Rays, however. They’ve got three road trips to come, and I’ve still got Johnny Football’s ‘they’ll go winless’ ringing in my ears.

It’s certainly great to see Jack Dempsey playing again, and I stand by my suggestion on the weekend of the need for a completely separate Shambeckler Vui category with the NRC Try of the Year voting. I even like a fair bit of what young Will Harrison has shown at flyhalf.

But gee, it’s really hard to see how and against who they break their duck.

The NRC has always thrown up a curve-ball on the run home, however, and now the fun becomes trying to identify when and where that curve-ball pops up.

NRC Round 5
SATURDAY
Fiji Drua vs NSW Country Eagles – Ratu Cakobau Park, Nausori, Fiji; 3.00pm FST/1.00pm AEST, streamed LIVE on www.foxsports.com.au
Canberra Vikings vs Melbourne Rising – Viking Park, Canberra; 7.00pm, LIVE on FOX SPORTS

SUNDAY
Brisbane City vs Queensland Country – Wests Rugby Club, Brisbane; 3.00pm, LIVE on FOX SPORTS
Western Force vs Sydney – UWA Sports Park, Perth; 3.00pm, streamed LIVE on www.foxsports.com.au

TIPS
All four away teams won last weekend, but I’m not sure that will be the case this weekend.

I think the Drua and Vikings get up at home on Saturday, but with varying widths of margin.

On Sunday, the Queensland derby will be a ripper. Brisbane City have the edge over the history of this game, but Country are a really good outfit again this year and with existing combinations serving them well, and I think that’ll be the case again.

Over in the west, the Force shouldn’t have too much trouble with Sydney – but, it was the Rays that ended Perth’s two-year unbeaten run at McGillivray.

Beware the curve ball…

The Crowd Says:

2018-09-30T11:18:32+00:00

andrewM

Guest


Not to mention a WSR contract or two as well..

2018-09-30T10:32:17+00:00

Sheikh

Roar Rookie


You were right, Brett - upsets happen. I didn't expect it for Brisbane vs Qld, but Brisbane played well

2018-09-30T09:40:10+00:00

robel

Roar Pro


Force v Rays today 30/9/2018. 63-15, dominant performance by the Force on this beautiful sunny afternoon down at UWA sports grounds.

2018-09-30T07:55:10+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Thanks Brett. Looks like City already threw one curve ball on Country. QC beat QC Rays, not looking good so far. As expected.

2018-09-28T05:35:51+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Yes, I am sure they are!! As you say, a pretty good season so far but I would personally like it to be longer. It really needs to be a 8 team home and away season and no finals in my view. But then I am a purist and still think that if you are good enough to finish top of the ladder then you are the winner. However that philosophy can only really work if you have home & away games to remove ground advantage.

2018-09-28T01:44:04+00:00

Kunming Tiger

Roar Rookie


any possiblityof the NRC being expanded into Samoa and Tonga in the next decade?

2018-09-27T14:05:48+00:00

Tom English

Roar Guru


Interesting. Two of Melbourne's losses have been very close, whereas City lost by 18 and 51 - although the scoreline was a little harsh on them in the Drua game. From looking at the draw, Rising's remaining games don't flatter them, Canberra at Vikings, Force at home before Rays at home. I'm resigned to the fact that a Rays game is a Rays' loss, but that's really only one win... City got Qld C, Eagles and Vikings...I dunno. As I said, top 4 looks pretty sewn up to me.

AUTHOR

2018-09-27T13:18:51+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Funnily enough, Tom, I think it's Melbourne that's the smokey. The problem is that having won only 1 from 4, even if they win all three remaining games, I'm not sure it will be enough to sneak into the top four..

2018-09-27T12:36:40+00:00

James Pettifer

Roar Rookie


2014 - all games at AAMI park 2015 - 1 game at Quins, 1 Frankston, 1 Geelong, 1 Morwell 2016 - 3 games at Quins, 1 Frankston 2017 - 3 games at Quins, 1 Frankston 2018 - 1 game in Adelaide, 1 Geelong, 1 Ballarat Having a team called Melbourne Rising not playing a single game in Melbourne, is a bit ridiculous.

2018-09-27T12:35:34+00:00

Tom English

Roar Guru


Brett, I think it's up to Brisbane City to shake up this seemingly set-in-stone top 4, which as you say, most of us predicted pre season as being finalists. Fiji, Qld C, Canberra and the Force have been a level above really, but we ARE only halfway through. Underneath them, I don't think anyone has a real chance, certainly neither NSW team and Melbourne's 2 point difference feels like more than it is. Who knows, they may just be a dark horse, but yeah, only 5 teams in it this year. On another note, good rugby so far, only got out to one game this year unfortunately - as opposed to five last year. At this stage I'm thinking Drua will win any home final, but lose any away game. Even though the finals series storyline seems to be told, here's the bit where some other sub plots pop up.

2018-09-27T12:26:29+00:00

Tom English

Roar Guru


+1

2018-09-27T10:43:58+00:00

AndyS

Guest


Yet astonishingly, while there would be very few who would disagree with either Scott or Brett about what is a comparison of entry level SR players in each country, there are so many that can't or won't take the next logical step...!

AUTHOR

2018-09-27T09:33:10+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


If both comps were on level footing, in terms of being fully professional and relatively equal in terms of not pulling players one way or the other, then this could be an interesting prospect. Until then though, Len, I just don't see the point...

AUTHOR

2018-09-27T09:29:19+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Scott, NSW Country will be hoping that some consolation carries through this week! They'll still be scratching their heads as to how they lost to Canberra on Sunday!

AUTHOR

2018-09-27T09:24:19+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Sheikh, the run home is going to be fascinating, I reckon. The thing that gets me is that even though it looks reasonably self-explanatory as you've laid out here, you just know there's going to be an upset, or a draw, or something to throw everything out of whack. It's just a matter of knowing where and when it happens. Perth were long odds to make the top four last year, and somehow they did. Stranger things can and do happen...

AUTHOR

2018-09-27T09:20:50+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


It's not difficult when following this comp Terrence, but nice of you to say anyway, cheers..

AUTHOR

2018-09-27T09:20:00+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Possibly, Deepers, but the Rising have been playing around different locations for at least the last two seasons, and it may in fact be all bar season one...

AUTHOR

2018-09-27T09:18:32+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


The Vikings pack, of course, wasn't without its issues last week either, which makes Saturday night's contest really intriguing. Vikings will start Vunipola Fifita alongside young TH Tom Ross, who were both great for last hour v NSW Country, but they've lost Josh Mann-Rea this week, which is a blow to their second half stability up front..

2018-09-27T09:04:29+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


Maybe the Mitre 10 and Currie Cup winner than we do not have to be last

2018-09-27T09:01:32+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


Who is surprised that it is hard to find a rugby crowd in such a big AFL city? But do not worry about support, Cameron is on your side and that is all that matters.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar