What Australia can learn from Indonesian football

By Adam Owsinski / Roar Rookie

Australians visit Bali for many different reasons. Some go to get healthy, some go for spiritual reasons, some go to relax or live it up and others go simply because it’s a cheap holiday.

One reason Australians tend not to visit Bali is for football – but my cousin and I recently visited Bali United as a part of our holiday to Indonesia. Even our tour guides admitted this was the first time foreigners requested to see the club as a part of a tour. Perhaps I’ve started a new trend and football tourism in Asia might become a thing.

Why would a couple of Aussie football purists be interested in the Indonesian Liga 1? Is it attractive? Does the Indonesian league possess a higher quality of football then the A-League? While the latter might be debatable according to who you ask, I went because of the facility and the uniqueness of the stadium. If you’re ever in Ubud and looking for something to do, I highly recommend going to a game at Kapten I Wayan Dipta Stadium, Bali United’s home stadium, especially if you’re a football fan and it’s the regular season. Since it was Ramadan, unfortunately we couldn’t catch a game, but we still did a stadium tour.

Straight away we were blown away by the size of the place and its casual, low-key design with corporate appeal. It’s a perfect mix of Balinese and Hindu culture as well as modern football.

(AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

Unlike football in the A-League, everything has been scripted to reflect the people of Bali and its culture. From the red, white and black colours representing the Hindu trinity – Tridatu of Brahma (red), Shiva (white) and Vishnu (black) – to the design of the logo, everything just works.

And then there’s ticket prices. If you want to sit with Semeton Dewata, the Bali United ultras, a ticket will cost a mere 50,000 rupiahs (around A$5.20). It’s a highly recommended experience. Regular seating away from the ultras will only set you back the same $5, with VIP corporate seating coming in at just $25.

Even the stadium tour is great value. Your basic $10 entry consists of a guided tour, a visit to the dressing rooms, a visit to the press box, a visit to the royal box, a walk onto the pitch and a visit to the club shop. It concludes with lunch at the Bali United Cafe. It all takes between 30 minutes and an hour and the feed is worth the price of admission alone.

My advice would be to get there early and try to do the tour on a game day and upgrade to a tour with a ticket and souvenir photo. It’ll be worth the price.

The only thing I”m not sold on is the Bali United is the kit. I don’t know if it’s an Indonesian business culture thing, but their kit in general looks like an advertising billboard rather than a fashionable strip people would want to wear in the street. This was the only reason I didn’t buy a shirt, but I did get a lot of birthday and Christmas shopping done at the Bali United Store, which is so big it included merchandise like sarongs and portable cooling devices for the muggy Balinese weather. It rivalled the shops of some EPL clubs in terms of size.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

I couldn’t even figure out why the likes of Melbourne Victory or Sydney FC don’t have one of these. During the A-League expansion phase pundits and punters alike got in touch to say they couldn’t understand why I’m a fan of the Western United Melbourne bid. It’s simple, really, and the Bali United stadium bought the memories flooding back: Western Melbourne’s proposal for a purpose-built won me over.

This simple stadium really bought it home to me. If the people of this tiny island can have such impressive infrastructure designed only for football, why can’t we have it in the A-League? I would even settle for Bali United’s megastore for any A-League club, but even that seems like an impossible dream.

Many non-football people will argue about supply and demand, the labour costs, population and every other excuse under the sun instead of facing the reality of the situation, which is that we need to change. Australia needs an attitude readjustment when it comes to sport if we want to be taken seriously on the football world stage.

It’s a matter of focus, intent and direction, and football in Australia is clearly not on the Australian government’s list of high priorities. Major sports like rugby union, rugby league and Aussie Rules all command sizable government grants, but despite football’s substantial participation rate, it inevitably ends up with scraps.

(Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

So how do these codes repay any of this money back? As rugby union becomes a ghost code in Australia and rugby league has peaked, one must ask where commercial growth and revenue is going to be generated from Australian sport in the future.

As long as the Australian government only sees the feasibility studies of multipurpose stadiums, Australian football will always be behind the rest of the world without specific infrastructure.

This is where the rest of Asia has it so right and Australia has it so wrong. Asian football understands the need for football-specific pitches, as football grounds require higher maintenance standards then rugby fields. Asia’s success globally in Football reflects this investment. You can’t expect to win the rights to a host a World Cup with a cricket pitch in the middle of a football field.

You can play a game of rugby league, rugby union or even Aussie Rules on a field with divots and bumps in the pitch or on dry grounds with no grass. But you can’t play football on them. Dirt patches create havoc on the ball’s bounce, and bumps and divots in the soil cause the ball to bounce unpredictably, making passing more difficult and the ball harder to stop for players.

Badminton, squash, basketball and indoor volleyball use the same style court, so why don’t they share facilities for their major competitions? I don’t understand the compulsion Australians have to play every grass-field sport as soon as a new professional grass pitch pops up. Why aren’t hockey players made to play on a rugby league pitch?

The standard of competition increases with specialised infrastructure, a fact the FFA aren’t willing to promote or fight for. That’s why Bali United impressed me – they have everything they need at their purpose-built stadium.

Bali United’s infrastructure was beyond impressive – in fact the visit to Bali United acted as a cold shower or wake-up call to me as an Australian football fan. If we want to be the No. 1 code in Australia and beat our rugby and AFL rivals, let alone be competitive globally, we need to learn from examples like Bali United.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2019-09-09T10:38:12+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


While that may be tragic, Fans have died in Scotland, Poland, England and a lot of European countries. It doesn't mean we stop looking to them for inspiration.

2019-09-07T08:48:49+00:00

Pedro

Roar Rookie


Sadly 47 fans have died in Indonesia

AUTHOR

2019-09-06T00:10:05+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


My thoughts exactly mate. I also don't understand the internal divisions, we are our own worst enemies in a lot of cases.

AUTHOR

2019-09-06T00:09:17+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


Ah sorry mate, miss understood you. Yeah, I'm also interested in Thai Football. I believe its the new rising start of Asian Football.

AUTHOR

2019-09-06T00:08:21+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


Hi Pacman Again thank you for the contribution, however, as a fan of the game, I disagree with your 'Soccer' analysis. I'm in my late 30's and have also been a fan my whole life. I remember the 'Wog, Sheelia and Poofter Years' of football in this country and to me using the term 'Soccer' is a dog whistle and subliminal memory recall of those years. (i'm also a firm advocate of changing the names of the Socceroo's, because of this). Having a family that was heavily involved in the running of Polonia North Side, I am glad those days are behind us, despite what we may have achieved back then. I also disagree with your comment in having the right people, in the right job. I am purely talking about the A-League era and in my opinion since the A-leagues conception we have never had a 'football person' in charge of our own game, we have again relied on inept corporates from Rugby Union and Rugby League to understand the unique culture of our code. While some things they got right, like the Wanderers and FFA Cup, they have gotten more things wrong. They also only got those things right due to extreme pressure from inside lobbying. Melbourne Victory has the right idea and their success as a club is demonstrated by the success in thier business model. I do agree with you though our Junior Development pathways need a lot of work and we need a new approach. This is why it's imperative in the A league modern era to have football people in charge of football and get all the clubs on the same page. PS I understand your business case for calling it 'Soccer' to make it stand out and be unique, however, I think this is a step back to the old NPL days.

AUTHOR

2019-09-05T23:55:04+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


Until you have been their and witnesses the actual facility itself, you will never understand just how impressive it is. We don't have 'specific' football grounds like this one. A couple of Rugby League teams may have urban grounds like this. The closest thing I could think of in this country would be Club Marconi in NSW. Again you're missing the point, don't make this us vs them issue, but, how we can develop into the number 1 code issue. Using this an example of what every A-league club should have!

2019-09-05T14:56:41+00:00

Tyke

Roar Rookie


I don’t understand why football doesn’t lobby government support, it’s an easy case to plead, “hey we could be one of the best nations in a sport the rest of the world actually plays, that means prestige, and big returns on investment”. Australia becomes one of the best at any sport we support

2019-09-04T10:22:19+00:00

pacman

Roar Rookie


Thanks for your response Adam. Ah, getting "the right person". That is very interesting. Over the years, I would suggest we have had "the right person" on several occasions. The problem is, on every occasion, "the right person" has been overwhelmingly outnumbered by those more interested in the most popular football codes. Not sure how old you are Adam, but I have indicated above that I am in my late 70's, and all the while have been an ardent fan of "soccer". I am old enough to realise the futility of labelling our game as "football" when there are two local codes far more deserving of this description. I hate comparing us with any footballing nation, as demographics vary considerably, but the USA use the term "soccer", and commonsense would suggest we do likewise. "Soccer" will not become a major football code in this country in my lifetime, and I very much doubt it will during the lifetime of any readers currently on this site. Unless, as I stated in my earlier post, Australia experiences unprecedented success in international football, namely, the World Cup. And we all, realistically, are aware of the chances of that happening. Past time to adopt a different approach. We need to develop our junior players with an approach more down to earth than the FFA Curriculum, a document that gives little if any advice to its paper credentialed experts on how to actually have their charges develop good ball control and a respectable first touch. I could go on. But I won't! Cheers.

2019-09-04T06:43:57+00:00

Richo

Guest


we have literally hundreds of suburban grounds like this one

2019-09-04T06:25:33+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


No, I'd love to go the Indonesia-Jakarta. I'm not going. The Thai matches I've been to are probably the most fun I've had watching sport. No aggro at all (unlike the Indos).

2019-09-04T06:16:26+00:00

Onside

Guest


Regarding ' if we want to be the number one code in Australia ', we are, and have been for over one hundred years. Football is the number 1 code at football, AFL is number 1 at Aussie rules, likewise Union and League are each number 1 in those codes. Every sport in Australia , including several Olympic sports are all number 1 in their own specialty . The defining point of difference is the game , not the number of people who follow a particular game. Field hockey, who have won many Olympic medals , and enjoy healthy support , are número uno at hockey and can't be compared to say rugby league ,lawn bowls, tennis or cricket. I understand what you are getting at, but using the number of supporters as the main justification of being number 1 , is a barren exercise . Football is number 1 at football, and always will be .

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T06:04:21+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


AFL and Cricket I agree but RL? maybe in NSW and Qlzd but not nationally.

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T05:57:25+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


I wholeheartedly agree with you mate. The main reason why football never gets anything like this is because of attitude and direction and our willingness to accept the status quo.

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T05:54:08+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


I would stop making this about us vs them, but, more about how we can learn from them. I assume you have at least visited the venue before commenting?

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T05:43:33+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


Let us know what it's like, the atmosphere should be killer.

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T05:43:05+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


Pacman that is the point of my article i clearly acknowledge were not a footballing nation, not yet atleast. However when it comes to world cup, ACL, Derby Time and finals time a lot pretend we are. Also expecting to win a World Cup bid because we hosted the Olympics was enough everdience of that arrogance. However, with the right people in the right jobs, we could be a football nation. If we had the right person leading the charge the government woulnd’t have ingored your email.

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T05:41:23+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


How about you visit it, before making judgments on ‘google earth’? Trust me it’s alot more impressive then anything we have done.

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T05:40:51+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


It’s not a matter of where the profits go, it’s a matter of having the vision, Gaul and will to do it. Eventually, over time all the profits would go to an A-league club or you could arrange a 50/50 deal with the FFA. However, I’m sure the Indonesian governing body gets a cut of Bali Uniteds profits also. My point is Governing Structures , haven’t prevetned clubs in lower leagues from doing it, Our execuse is a lack of will…. PERIOD.

AUTHOR

2019-09-04T05:39:00+00:00

Adam Owsinski

Roar Rookie


They don’t need to be, they can be though. They went for this option. I must say Bali United layout is much more impressive then anything we have. Bali United got government assistance! Again i believe its having the right people in the right job pushing the government and making them see the errors in their ways. If we sit back and accept the reality where the ‘4th best’ code in the country nothing will ever change.

2019-09-04T02:47:20+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


I've seen the Thai national side play numerous times at Rajamangala Stadium in Bangkok and it's always a lot of fun. I'd love to see the Indonesia-Malaysia match in Jakarta tomorrow night.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar