What will your team aim to achieve in Super Rugby AU?

By jeznez / Roar Guru

With Super Rugby AU fast approaching, I was drawn to ponder how the various teams will approach the competition.

For the Brumbies it looks straightforward: continue their excellent season to date. They are undoubtedly the front runners, looking settled and having put in several excellent performances this season.

Dan McKellar has had a blow losing Cadeyrn Neville to injury but acted quickly and brought former Brumby and current Sunwolf Ben Hyne in. Blake Enever, Lachlan McCaffrey and Allan Alaalatoa should all be back after their own injury issues.

The Rebels and Reds were equal second on the Aussie Super Rugby ladder before the break and have slightly different challenges to step their game up to the Brumbies.

The Reds have had moments where their play has looked irresistible but they are still very inconsistent. They’ll know they haven’t produced an 80-minute performance of their best rugby. They also have a mini-rebuild to effect with the loss of Izack Rodda, Harry Hockings and Isaac Lucas.

Izack Rodda (Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

Not letting the loss of those three derail their season is going to be a test but there are silver linings. Lukhan Salakaia-Loto looks likely to shift back to lock, where many of us want to see him. Michael Wood and Fraser McReight will have greater opportunity to push for spots at lock and openside. While the loss of those three is big, the Reds can hopefully cover and still build their game.

The Rebels have almost the opposite issue of the Reds, they’ve been more consistent but without the peaks in performance. Having one more win than the Reds points to their ability, and the number of mature and experienced campaigners across their squad should help them compete.

The big question for David Wessels is how he gets the team to improve that final bit to compete with the likes of the Brumbies. Apart from a Round 1 loss to the Sunwolves they accounted for the weaker teams in the comp with relative ease but looked to be a step off the pace of teams like the Sharks and Brumbies when they met.

The Rebels lack a bit in scrummaging strength, don’t quite have the musculature to mix it with the most powerful packs and don’t have the express pace to compete with the quickest back lines. They are going to have to find those final improvements through ensemble play, and getting Jordan Uelese on the pitch wouldn’t hurt them either.

The Force are back! Tim Sampson has made a clear statement that they won’t be recruiting outside their Global Rapid Rugby squad. They won the NRC, defeating a Super Rugby-stacked Vikings side, but the addition of Wallabies into the other squads will make them a much tougher proposition.

Further, the Force have lost some key talent from that NRC campaign, with the likes of Carlo Tizzano and Michael McDonald at the Waratahs, Andrew Deegan and Cameron Orr at the Rebels and Issak Fines at the Brumbies.

The path is still simple and clear: play the best rugby they can and build respect from opposition and fans. They’ll be seeking wins but the results almost don’t matter as much as the heart and performance they display.

Finally, we come to the basket case of Aussie rugby, my Waratahs.

(Ashley Feder/Getty Images)

Andrew Hore and Daryl Gibson have overseen the place falling apart. Paul Doorn and Rob Penney have a mighty task in front of them to rebuild the side. Penney had minimal input into the squad but the players he did attract worry me.

Tetera Faulkner at 31 was brought in to shore up the scrum, despite not being a great scrummager. Sam Talakai is three years younger and got supremely fit during the off-season. Talakai has dominated for the As. He should be filling the role that Faulkner is.

Damien Fitzpatrick at 30 was looking to retire but was asked to stay on for another season. Robbie Abel, also 30, was brought in to share the hooking duties with him. Andrew Tuala is their understudy but at 29 is not the future.

I’m hoping that Tom Robertson has had a car tyre hoisted in his backyard during isolation and thrown thousands of practice lineouts. He looks the obvious player in the squad to transition. This break was a golden opportunity for a player that is struggling to find his spot.

Tom Staniforth has been in professional rugby since 2014 but still cannot dominate contact, a key failing for a lock. Rob Simmons and Ryan McCauley are not enforcers either. Pat Tafa has been the dominant lock for the As. He needs opportunity.

Ned Hanigan will hopefully be back and despite being much maligned should add some starch to the pack. Will Harris and Nick Champion de Crespigny look like two big men with some speed that could transform the way the Tahs can play.

Both Lachlan Swinton and Jack Dempsey look to be more focused on their ruck work this season with Swinton looking the stronger to me. Dempsey really should be under pressure from Hanigan, Harris and Champion de Crespigny as play resumes.

Charlie Gamble looks almost a clone of Pete Samu: similar size, speed and both schooled through Canterbury systems. Gamble and Carlo Tizzano can offer something with Michael Hooper if we seek to speed play up after the big men crash and bash.

Siosifa Lisala is a 26-year-old marquee player added to the squad but is yet to take the pitch. He’s been reasonable for the Waratahs As but so have Cam Clark and Tristan Reilly, so why was he someone Penney pursued?

Kurtley Beale at 31 and Karmichael Hunt at 33 are the old men of the back line but neither have been in form. It’s hard to find a replacement for Hunt but Beale has obvious replacements with the shining lights in the back three being Jack Maddocks, Mark Nawaqanitawase and James Ramm.

Mark Nawaqanitawase in action for the Waratahs. (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Lalakai Foketi and Joey Walton are the midfield I’d like to see. Walton at 20 is young and at 88 kilos lacks size but has pace, something Gibson’s final signing Tepai Moeroa lacks. I’d love to be pleasantly surprised by Moeroa but am not holding my breath.

Regardless, Will Harrison needs better runners around him. Too often he’s the guy taking it to the line or making the desperation tackle because players aren’t presenting around him.

Penney has to use this rebooted comp to change tack. He’s picked too many older players regardless of form and potential. Losses like those against the Brumbies and Chiefs could be forgiven if he had a young team out there learning, but to do it with players that are at the end of their careers is doing nothing to rebuild the Tahs.

Apologies for devoting half the article to my Waratahs. I know for many of you they are your least favourite team but they are the side that need to most drastically change from what the coach has been doing.

Have I hit the mark with what the various sides should be aiming to do?

I really feel this comp is going to see the Reds and Rebels hunting for the Brumbies, while the Waratahs and Force try to build their games.

Are there players or tactics that haven’t been getting a run that you want to see more of in Super Rugby AU?

The Crowd Says:

2020-06-13T06:20:58+00:00

Morsie

Guest


Hehehe, bang on. Comment of the century.

2020-06-10T11:35:58+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


Exactly Jez. Pretty much the same board and chairman that selected and supervised the previous chronically under performing CEO and coach, have selected a new CEO and coach so all we need to do is replace the Chairman. Then a chronically under performing organisation can return to health. Sorry, I do not believe it. If such a thing were possible it would be because there is a strong product or service, exceptional staff and a healthy customer base. It is difficult to judge whether staff are part of the problem or the solution from the outside. I am certain the product is poor and the customer base fragmented and reluctant to buy. Chance of turning around current design ship - zero. Tim Rapp has been in numerous roles around the traps, he is either a competent guy or yet another clever professional rugby operative whose main skill is to shuffle to the next job without being found out. Under the current circumstances at the Waratahs, impossible to judge his performance fairly. Comprehensive restructure is required and somebody who will be accountable for the decisions he makes needs to decide whether or not the chairman, directors, executives or employees have a productive role to play or not.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T09:43:40+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Sure mate but I really don't think I've re-written anything. My opening response to you was: We’ve got a new CEO and new coach, if they could just show Roger ‘Wiggs has the support of all the states’ Davis the door we might get back on the right path Maybe I would have been clearer without my little side sledge of Davis in italics but I've never wavered from my actual statement.

2020-06-10T09:31:08+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


Lets forget about it Jez, I can't keep correcting your re-writing of previous posts.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T09:00:35+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


So the board is appalling but when I suggest the Chairman is part of the problem you disagree. Of course on and off field need to fire for there to be sustained success. Why do you think I nominated CEO, Coach, Chairman and GM as the critical roles? We've changed two of those, I've suggested one of the others should go (he's been in the role since 2012). The GM I'm unsure of, he's been in the role since 2017. Given my dim view of the prior CEO/Coach and current long term Chairman I think he deserves a chance to operate with the new guys before we make a call. (plus admission time, I've always liked Timmy. He played for my club and he's a good bloke)

2020-06-10T08:42:03+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


Both on field and off field need to be firing. The fact that success was fleeting shows how key off-field is. Without it you are relying on once in a generation players etc, which then puts the Brumbies successes in the same category. Although they have been undoubtedly been the nest administrative set up as well which puts a floor under less good years. Back to NSW, I do not think replacing the CEO and coach is that big a deal. The board put up with appalling incompetence for years, selected Penney by over-ruling Hore, who then resigned. I have not seen any tangible evidence of a dramatic transformation of the new coach and CEO put in place by the current chairman and board. I am hoping for the best but have no belief there is any plan for the worst. We all bag Izzy but perpetually in Australian Rugby we only believe in miracles and saviours. Success is hard work x time, in an environment which favours ingenious set piece moves and quick easy points.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T07:08:42+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


My comment specifically said that now they have replaced the CEO and Coach that if they replaced the Chairman as well they might get on the right path. The demise of the Reds happened after McKenzie left. For the Tahs after the loss of Cheika. Doesn’t that lend support to my argument that the team leadership is key?

2020-06-10T06:58:12+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


Agree on turfing the lot, subject to saving any babies concealed by bath water. You were very specific that showing Davis the door was all that was required. The Davis controversy was blown up by the media, and convenient for the RA Board as well. The RA structure is not right, the obvious one being that there should not be fully autonomous SR franchises to start with. Own fitness standards, playing philosophies and financial strategy with the RA always there to bail them out. Cooperating with the Wallabies and coaching staff is still only optional. My original comment covered the '14 win and my view was that '11 was built around a group of players who just outperformed, QC unbelievable. Of course in both years squeaked past the Crusaders who especially suffered following the earthquake. Remember how Queensland administration was lauded for their brilliance but then imploded wjen the Reds stopped winning?

2020-06-10T06:47:42+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


Short, I like the look of him.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T04:25:03+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


You've lost me mate. If you don't know about Davis then what was your "Disagree on Davis" comment about? We aren't talking about one bloke. I was talking about CEO, Chairman and Coach of the organisation. The other bloke who should potentially be in the discussion is GM Tim Rapp. If I'm following your argument you seem to be saying the Tahs are doomed because of RA structures - my question then is why doesn't that seem to be dooming the Brumbies this year? Why were the Tahs able to achieve success in '14? Reds in '11? Surely the management of the team rather than just RA structures has something to do with it?

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T04:19:02+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Back up halves are Short and McDonald, they both go alright. Tafa looks the impact guy for the middle row, he just needs to be given a go.

2020-06-10T04:08:35+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


I don't know about Davis personally, but it is irrelevant. Replacing Davis with someone who is going to solve all of our problems is the same as parachuting one man behind enemy lines. Only three outcomes; they join the enemy, are captured or killed. It is the structure, and who stays or who goes, is a judgement call as to who is part of the problem and who could be part of the solution. As for all of the stuff reported in the press; pfft. Miller was also part of the Wiggs push so QRU was in, and that is 6/16 votes. They might all have been on board when the wind was blowing from Mosman, and just as quickly desserted ship when it became a southerly buster. Happens all of the time and is part of the problem with the RA Constitution; the "members" are financially dependent on RA at all times. More particularly right now when they are the only source of funding.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T02:18:15+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


I know it was a typo, just couldn't resist giving you a bit of stick over something inconsequential. If I was picking the Wallabies there would be something like 10 Brumbies, 7 Rebels, 4 Reds, 1 Tah and 1 Exeter player in the 23. If you want to argue over who should be favourites between the Tahs and Force you won't get an argument from me (although I'm not confident my team will beat yours, I agree they should be favourites) But to suggest they are the #1 team on paper with their personnel vs the Brumbies, Rebels and Reds personnel is just a silly comment. Then again your comment "The Brumbies are the favourites" means you know that and you've just been winding me up.

2020-06-10T01:54:20+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


22 was a typo... not that the additional player make a difference to the point I make. Many players in the Tahs that do not even make your bench will run-on in another franchises e.g. Carlos, MacDonald, etc. The Brumbies are the favourites, however the Tahs should do very well with the resources and talent they have. You may think they are weak this year just because you are used to picking a team stacked with current Wallabies year after year.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T01:02:15+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


You think Davis needs longer? He's been Chairman since 2012 so while he can probably take a bit of credit for '13/'14 he also has to wear the slide since. Plus that ludicrous statement that lasted less than 24 hours before the other state chairs publicly called him out for a liar is utterly damning in my book.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T00:47:42+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


I think he could best support the development of the young backs by running the water.

2020-06-10T00:47:40+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


Are you sure they only got off two shots? Disagree on Davis. Waratahs have consistently under performed since 1995. Something is not right and my long experience with failure is that for individuals it becomes "functional" rather than "personal". Designed for under performance and set up to fail.

2020-06-10T00:44:41+00:00

Boomeranga

Roar Rookie


Yes. I know what he provides and like I said, I wouldn't want him out of the picture, but lock is our biggest and longest term problem. There are several others who have received contracts for years for whom the time has come to either step up or their contract be given to someone else. It is so frustrating that, not only are there better NSW locks at other sides (both current and potentially), but the Brumbies can bring back a bloke like Neville who makes an excellent impact immediately. Meanwhile, we keep faffing around changing the blokes next to Simmons who don't cut it. Perhaps they are too comfortable.

2020-06-10T00:42:29+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


I really think Beale places too much pressure on himself to make the difference. Consequently his performance has suffered at NSW and also the Wallabies, compounded partly by the consequent lack of confidence. As far as his defence he needs to be told to tackle low and forget going high to "prevent" an offload. Being a small non dominant high tackler with poor technique, he will never be more than a speed bump. Which is still one step up from the QC spinning arm revolving door method which only makes an occasional impact, usually at a YC height. I think we would be better using him at 12 in a way that supports the development of Foketi and Harrison and investing in the growth of the back three.

AUTHOR

2020-06-10T00:39:08+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


We've got a new CEO and new coach, if they could just show Roger 'Wiggs has the support of all the states' Davis the door we might get back on the right path. I take the glass half full view that '13/'14 show that the Waratahs can succeed under the current structure. They just shot themselves in the foot (probably both feet to be fair) under the leadership of Hore and Gibson in the following seasons.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar