My predicted South African XV for the Rugby Championship

By Unders / Roar Pro

The anticipation for this year’s Rugby Championship is still in the air.

World Cup winners South Africa will still have much of their squad intact from Yokohama under new coach Jacques Nienaber.

The All Blacks will have a few personnel changes but their strength in depth remains scarily good.

Much is to be said about the potential resurgence of the Wallabies and Pumas, with both entering transition periods after lacklustre and underwhelming cycles for the 2015 semi-finalists and finalists respectively.

Here I give my predicted Springboks XV to kick off the tournament.

1. Steven Kitshoff
The ginger ninja is a very good all-round player and scrummager. He started in South Africa’s awesome campaign. With 47 caps and as a proven World Cup winner, Kitshoff will surely feature under Nienaber.

2. Malcolm Marx
Bongi Mbonambi may have started the final, but Marx brings brilliant defence and energy in contact and to rucks. He really is South Africa’s additional fetcher. He has steadily improved his set-piece game after some concerns with his lineout game.

(Jono Searle/Getty Images)

3. Frans Malherbe
This meaty prop played a huge role in demolishing the England scrum in Japan. He rivals Tadhg Furlong and Kyle Sinckler as the best tighthead prop in the world. A proper wrecking ball in open play and sensational in the scrum.

4. Eben Etzebeth
South Africa’s enforcer and quite possibly one of the scariest and most intimidating players in world rugby, Etzebeth is a proven Test veteran who relishes contact. With 85 caps to his name, Etzebeth is a true Test animal.

5. Lood de Jager
De Jager is an underrated player who has seen a lot of action for South Africa. He marshals the set-piece and maul well alongside Etzebeth.

6. Siya Kolisi (captain)
There’s not much to say about the man who led one of the sport’s greatest and most inspirational campaigns both on a personal and team level. His playing skills have also improved since becoming captain – he’s a quality flanker who dominates in contact and at the breakdown and ranks highly with the likes of Michael Hooper, Sam Underhill, Tom Curry, Julian Savea and Pieter-Steph du Toit.

(Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

7. Pieter-Steph du Toit
He was Men’s World Rugby Player of the Year in 2019 and deservedly so. He’s a massive engine in defence and wears his pride on his sleeve. He’s one of the best players in the world.

8. Duane Vermeulen
At 34 years old his shelf life is small, but he’s the best No. 8 in the world. A beast in contact and one of South Africa’s best in the rucks, Vermeulen is probably the best all-round No. 8 along with his delicate hands.

9. Faf de Klerk
The Fafster’s place is no doubt in this side. It’s hard to imagine that after the 2016 Rugby Championship he was booted from the squad by Allister Coetzee. Since his recall, he’s been one of rugby’s best No. 9s, with fantastic and accurate kicking and marshalling of the scrum and backline. He and Handre Pollard go hand in hand.

10. Handre Pollard
Probably the best goal kicker in the game right now, Pollard is one hell of a player and easily in the top five No. 10s in the game. What’s more, his accurate kicking game is complemented by his abnormal physicality – Pollard is a viable crash ball option with his frame and one of the most comfortable No. 10s in defence.

(Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

11. Makazole Mapimpi
Mapimpi will go down as the first South African to score a try in a final. He brings sheer pace and phenomenal ball carrying, plus he is more capable in defence and aerially. Like Kolisi, he has had a truly inspirational career.

12. Damian De Allende
The glue of the Springbok midfield, DDA has a sound kicking game and is more than competent in defence.

13. Lukhanyo Am
The best defending outside back in the world, I was disappointed to see that in the recent game Rugby Challenge 4 Jesse Kriel was the Boks No. 13 instead of Am. Am is very underrated for a player so comfortable in defence and has the athleticism and precision for attacking moves.

14. Cheslin Kolbe
That try. That step. He’s a very, very athletic player with a phenomenal step. He can cover No. 15 too. Expect plenty more tries from the small fella.

15. Willie le Roux
Maybe it’s time for Damian Willemse, but I think there’s a divide between where the Boks and Stormers want to play him. Le Roux for now has just slid in due to his experience and role as a second playmaker, which Willemse will offer. Only 31, Le Roux has been one of the best for a while and has a slick kicking game to bolster the Pollard-De Klerk axis.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Finishers
There are two options for the Boks to take. One is the preferred 6-2 split, which will be used to grind opponents down. Rudolph Gerhardus Snyman and Francois Louw’s absences mean there are some spots up for grabs.

The reserve props will likely be Du Toit and Vincent Koch, with Mbonambi as hooker and Franco Mostert covering flank and lock.

The second lock spot could be taken by Marvin Orie, who has long been impressive for the Lions – though Jean-Luc du Preez may have some thoughts on that.

I’m unsure about Kwagga Smith’s position with sevens or pursuing the Lions tour – if the 6-2 split is used, I think Marcell Coetzee, the Du Preez brothers, Rynhardt Elstadt and Marco van Staden all have shots for grabs as reserve flank.

I have a feeling the 6-2 split could be used against the All Blacks. In a 6-2 squad the backs will be Herschel Jantjies as reserve scrummie, though No. 23 will be a dilemma.

I am sure that Frans Steyn wants to bow out against the Lions, so either he or Jesse Kriel can cover centre, wing and No. 15, leaving the versatile options to remain alongside Damian Willemse, who could have the tournament ahead of Steyn to receive some game time. Injury permitting, I think Steyn will be featuring in either or both the tournament and Lions series.

In a 5-3 split the Boks could get away with the same forwards apart from a back row sub and have Mostert covering both as since Du Toit can also cover both No. 7 and lock.

A 5-3 split may suggest a more athletic game of rugby, though in a 6-2 split with Kwagga Smith the Boks still have the dynamism of a brilliants sevens player in the back row.

The 5-3 split is more important for the backs though. Jantijes will have the back-up No. 9 role and one of Steyn and Willemse will be there too.

No. 23 therefore could be Jesse Kriel, who unluckily doesn’t make the starting XV. Kriel is shredded has proven experience and good performances on the international stage.

The Crowd Says:

2020-09-12T23:49:24+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Exactly. Great player but time for a younger guy like Kwagga Smith to step in.

2020-09-07T00:07:46+00:00


His inconsistent form makes him unreliable, he got through the RWC, but lets face it, selecting players on reputation keeps young stars back, I would at least like to see new players exposed to the 15 jersey so when Willie continues to underperform there are players ready to step up.

2020-09-06T23:58:41+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Yes, Pollard can cover 12 Willemse can cover a whole host of positions. 12, 10, even as a back-three

2020-09-06T23:57:34+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Le rOUX IS the best South African playmaking fullback-you cant deny that

2020-09-06T23:57:00+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


Perhaps last year Rassie created a structure to maximise both him and le roux He has been great for Montpellier overall, and no le roux there

2020-09-06T23:55:57+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


The truth of the matter is that Pro14 have less exposure to better players in ENgland and fRANCE, where ex-bok and EX-ALL blacks play out their swansongs. Also, Pro14 attracts less top players and the standard there is good but less than English or French Rugby

2020-09-06T23:53:25+00:00

Pundit

Roar Guru


the recent game Rugby Challenge 4 Jesse Kriel was the Boks No. 13 instead of Am. To quote you, Unders, Am has been left out in a video game XV Video games tend to pick hype players, and Kriel is certainly a decent player but with far tooo much hype

2020-09-01T14:50:23+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


I have always liked Akker.. Has that most important quality needed for a hooker... A bit of the devil in him.. Think Dalton, Schmidt, Bismarck, Brits..

2020-09-01T11:35:04+00:00

Ulrich

Roar Rookie


Would like to see Akker given another shot. He should be in the running now that Brits is gone, but they may go with a local guy.

2020-09-01T07:06:35+00:00

Ulrich

Roar Rookie


Actually, there are articles floating around - detailing an excerpt from a book about the Boks during RWC 2019 and how they managed the referees. Duane was deliberately told to do all the queries so the ref wouldn't build up a negative perception toward Kolisi. They would also tie their shoelaces and so on when the ref spoke to them. All part of the psychology and the study the Boks did on referees.

2020-09-01T02:48:06+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Harry I just cannot feel excited about watching our teams playing Connaught, Glasgow, Zebras, Cardiff etc week after week.. Give me The Chiefs, Blues, Reds, Brumbies, Jaguars any time..

2020-09-01T02:38:01+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


At last… Some balance on Le Roux Pinetree.. Your opinion and analysis on him is supported by none other than Bok coach Nienaber.. Recently spoke pretty highly of Le Roux particularly his off the ball contributions to the team.. I’m certain he will still be first choice comes The Lions tour and hope he is.

2020-09-01T02:31:04+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Yes Marx got that reputation for poor lineout throws whilst playing for the Lions.. But the stats never supported it.. Again perceptions..

2020-09-01T02:28:39+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Marvin Orie??? There are at least 5 better lock forwards in South Africa... Sadly looks like RG Snyman is out for 6 months tho..

2020-08-31T16:18:58+00:00


Yeah, mostly perceptions mate. Siya made the second most tackles for the Boks during the RWC. He made the third most runs of the Forwards. He made the most clean breaks of all the forwards. As a leader he encourages his senior players to assist him and he is quite open about it. He admits when he needs help he will ask for it. As a leader he not only inspires his teammates but also the public.

2020-08-31T16:00:00+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


I think the Pro 14 teams will find it quite challenging to defeat the Stormers, Sharks, and Bulls in SA, and I think all three have NH-adaptable packs and styles to take a few wins away. I think a SA team wins the Pro 14, actually.

2020-08-31T15:58:20+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Yes, I know you know that transformation targets are a real thing, so you have to cut Willie and you have to find a few more forwards that fit that reality. I think a lot of it is like-for-like. Damian and Gelant are ballplayers like Willie. You might also think of Ox Nche and Notshe at 8, to balance the scales.

2020-08-31T12:45:04+00:00

TheViking

Roar Rookie


Very good team but... I didn’t see during the World Cup that Siya Kolisi lead the Springboks. It looked like that Duane Vermeulen and Handre Pollard did all the calls and took charge of the leadership. And I also think he usually disappears and he is not dominant in the defence when the Springboks plays against the All Blacks. It’s super important to have a openside flanker that slow downs the All Blacks. Cheers from Sweden

2020-08-31T12:04:21+00:00


Exactly

2020-08-31T11:23:06+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Am, Kolisi, Mapimpi ... all EP lads.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar