A scintillating Bledisloe icebreaker and what becomes of the injured Boks?

By The masked soup-bone / Roar Rookie

What a feast of scintillating rugby the first southern hemisphere Test match this year dished up for all our armchair connoisseurs. Davie Rennie certainly announced his arrival as the Aussie game changer on our international stage.

Rennie’s new broom swept the petulant Cheika era firmly into the history books. His focused, no nonsense and bloody-minded approach inspired his young team to give the rugby world 89 minutes’ notice that he’s scripting a new chapter in the rich Wallaby history.

His green young guns all came up trumps asking difficult questions of a strangely disconnected All Blacks team under new coach Bob Foster, with both Harry Wilson and Filipo Daugunu very impressive and probably set for long international careers.

This game confirmed my opinion that Foster was a huge All Black mistake. I doubt a Scotty Robinson-coached All Blacks would have given us the spectacle we witnessed.

Which brings me to the once prodigal son that’s matured and was the glue that fused the Wallaby game plan together – James O’Connor.

A prodigious young talent that conquered some personal demons while plying his trade up north, he’s now come of age with a compelling and total performance.

I expect he will be a vital cog in Rennie’s inevitable march up the world rankings.

The underdone Bok’s have a stiff challenge ahead to front our southern hemisphere brothers in a month’s time – if we make it across the pond

Then, there’s the Boks’ supposed conundrum at 10. Pollard’s long-term injury has attracted quite a few barrels of ink, especially on this forum.

The speculation and multiple questions being asked about what we need at 10 to maintain the Boks’ impressive head of steam built up under Rassie Erasmus’s guidance has quite frankly reached comic proportions.

(Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Polly is world-class, but one swallow doesn’t make a summer. A look at history normally points the way and despite me being dubbed a “living fossil” by my 25-year-old son, please bear with me while I dive into SA’s rich rugby ancestry to motivate my assertion that it’s a non-issue.

One of my earliest rugby memories was pre-TV with my ears glued to shortwave radio. I was listening to the brainstrust of Dawie de Villiers and Piet Visagie tying the Wallabies, All Blacks, France and England into knots behind a hard driving monster pack.

They had a rock solid defence while playing the territory game with pin-point kicking and de Villiers sniping breaks while Visagie was the deadly goal kicker and seamless link to legendary outside backs like John Gainsford, Mannetjies Roux and Tom van Vollenhoven.

This came from a long-gone era when the Boks dominated the world game like a colossus; much like the past decade and a half’s All Blacks vintage of Henry-Hansen domination.

The cool winds of isolation started stunting our rugby and our ivory tower was demolished by Willie-John McBride’s Lions in 1974; much like they did to the All Blacks four years prior.

The take-out from that is that we didn’t have a top flyhalf. The selectors picked four different fly halves in four Tests while the most gifted player of his era, Peter Kirsten, was deemed too small and young.

Disgusted, he left the game and became one of the best international cricket batsman of his era.

That however does not mean that a flyhalf is the be-all and end-all for a successful Bok rugby team; it means that every successful Bok team has had a compelling and complementing mix in the 9/10 axis.

So we simply solve our supposed playmaker conundrum by looking at the available playmaker combinations.

At nine we have Faf de Klerk; Cobus Reinach and the young guns Herschelle Jantjies and Sanele Nohamba, while at ten we have Elton Jantjies, Curwin Bosch, Robert du Preez – and my choice and personal favourite Frans Steyn.

I’ve left Damian Willemse out. He’s become a startled deer in the spotlight of an upcoming trainwreck, just like a young James O’Connor was five to eight years ago and I never rated Jantjies at Test level.

Here are my picks.

15. Willie le Roux (Aphelele Fassi)
14. Cheslin Kolbe (Rosco Speckman)
13. Lukhanyo Am (Jesse Kriel)
12. Damian de Allende (Jan Serfontein)
11. Makazole Mapimpi (Sbu Nkosi)
10. Frans Steyn (Curwin Bosch)
9. Cobus Reinach (Faf de Klerk/Sanele Nohamba)
8. Duane Vermeulen (Sikhumbuzo Notshe)
7. Pieter-Steph du Toit (Arno Botha)
6. Siya Kolisi (Marcel Coetsee)
5. Eben Etzebeth (Jean-Luc du Plessis)
4. Franco Mostert (JD Schickerling)
3. Frans Malherbe (Trevor Nyakane)
2. Malcolm Marx (Bongi Mbonambi)
1. Steven Kitshoff (Ox Notshe)

Not quite worth betting the house on but definitely a little something on the side I think.

I expect howls of indignation, but a new combination of Reinach and Steyn in the 9/10 axis will be a nightmare to defend against while Faf entering the fray after 45-60 mins will inevitably spark chaos in the opposition’s established attack/defence rhythm.

This is a win-win I think. Reinach is an excellent technician, but is also deadly around the fringes which will create a split-second defensive hesitation which will set up Steyn to dictate the game.

Curwin Bosch is a prodigious talent. He’s the real deal but is weak defensively so it’s time overdue to get him under Jacques Nienaber and Mzwandile Stick’s tutelage.

(Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

It’s a skill set than can be acquired with correct coaching. He can also cover 10 to 15 from the bench if needed and can become vital next year against the Lions.

The Boks currently have an embarrassment of talent and a wise head at the helm to harness it, so no panic stations required.

They have lots of “workarounds” available to fill any perceived weaknesses or gaps. The necessary extended squad of up to 48/50 players will also give some young nuggets exposure to become polished up for the future while becoming imbued with the Bok spirit and work ethic.

A unique “on-the-job” Springbok finishing school opportunity bar none.

Move over and pass the biltong and popcorn please.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2020-10-15T14:59:05+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


Very sad news just hit the presses; :shocked: :sick: :angry: Springboks withdraw from the Rugby Championship...

2020-10-15T09:36:17+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Montpelier is also notorious for keeping their players out of internationals with “injuries.”

2020-10-15T09:35:05+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


He lost 6 kg in one match!

2020-10-15T09:34:41+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Great points on Serf and Bongi. I defer!

AUTHOR

2020-10-15T07:17:59+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


I couldn't agree more about Polly; in the Bok set-up he's a perfect fit and a once in a generation player.

AUTHOR

2020-10-15T07:09:26+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


Serfontein learned his rugby up north while de Allende came through the Western Province ranks so I suspect it's simply a matter of exposure to the current brainstrust; Serfontein has never been involved in any Springbok camps or activities since the 2018 reboot; initially he was injured but has been in sparkling form since.

AUTHOR

2020-10-15T06:59:04+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


An interesting snippet revealed during an interview on the "Use it or lose it" channel hosted by Jean de Villiers and Schalk Burger on Youtube; apparently he's quite famous for dabbling in the kitchen..! We can all most definitely see that at the beginning of every new season..

2020-10-15T06:29:29+00:00

Jonty Shonty

Roar Pro


Serfontein really is the forgotten man hey. So we know why Rassie isn’t a fan? De Allende fit the mould better?? Attitude not right?? Maybe a bit of both??

2020-10-15T05:17:51+00:00

Jonty Shonty

Roar Pro


Malherbe looks like he needs another straining stint in Japan too!

2020-10-15T05:16:30+00:00

Jonty Shonty

Roar Pro


Loving Nohambe. Seems he can read the game beautifully. And I think the last time we had a scrummy like that his name was Fourie and that turned out ok!

2020-10-15T04:13:48+00:00

Tooly

Roar Rookie


Mornay Steyn at 10 not Frans. We need Lolisio with JOC at 12.

2020-10-15T02:20:27+00:00

blue

Guest


The coach has already said his first choice 10 is Jantjes. Frans Steyn was only a backup ten at Montpellier. His foray as Bok ten was really awful and got cut short at the time. His kicking style lends itself to charge downs. He is not a 10 and never has been. 12 is his best position. That extra space and running hard on to the ball suits him to a tee. A lot has been invested in H Jantjes but he is still the understudy to Faf. To suggest that Reinach will leapfrog Herchelle ignores the last two years under Erasmus. It will not, and should not happen. I love Reinach, but he is third cab off the rank, and possible fourth now behind Nohombe. Handre Pollard needs to be looked after like gold. When he is healthy, we are a whole different animal to contend with. There is daylight between him and any other option. The one player that I have wished every year to see in a Bok jersey again is Serfontein. What a player.

AUTHOR

2020-10-15T01:28:28+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the compliment Jonty; much appreciated. The press back home scorns my more philosophical bent towards all things rugby but I've hopefully found a more appreciative audience for the musings I have on this game we all love. That said; credit must go to The Roars editors. Under Alistair Coetzee the Boks scrumhalf cupboard seemed bare; even Faf being summarily discarded but with the proper; knowledgeable coaching now in place; it's very difficult to decide who to leave out and who to pick! Reinach and de Klerk are indubitably our current top technicians and I believe Cobus is overdue an extended run to entertain the crowds and polish him up some more while it will also keep Faf on his toes; we're going to need him breathing fire to stop Gatland's B&I Lions assault next year! That said; the young and rather lightweight Nohambe has really impressed me; he's bursting at the seams with that mystical quality we call "nous"; something that cannot be coached and he might just be the next big star for the Boks at nine. What I find very encouraging is that; for the first time in my memory; under Rassies/Sticks tutelage; the Springboks are starting to implement "the long game" with our young talent and I look forward to seeing our young talent properly nurtured light up stadiums across the world; particularly with our outside backs set to completely redefine the old; established Springbok paradigm.

AUTHOR

2020-10-15T00:46:27+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


Thanks Harry; always nice to to hear from my favorite guru. Fassi is definitely a keeper; he's an intuitive player that reads the game well and pop up in the right places at the right time with dazzling acceleration that's difficult to defend against while Speckman has similar intuition and is nearly as good a "stepper" as Kolbe; skills he honed on the sevens circuit. Serfontein joined the pantheon of luminaries like Richie McCaw and Schalk Burger as junior world players of the year next to Polly in our 2011 Junior WC triumph and retreaded as an outside centre by Henecke Meyer; has never let a Bok team down; winning "top defender" accolades in most tests he played in. Personally; I rate him higher than de Allende in the "nous" department as well. Bongi is very underdone at the moment; just like P-S du Toit; both recovering from serious injuries but unlike PSdT is a momentum player that needs to build up a head of steam over multiple matches while Marx; two years ago rated as the best hooker in world rugby; is a very influential player; he was instrumental in both WC final tries; giving the final pass before the Mapimpi/Am magic show and he put in the monster tackle for the loose ball that unleashed Kolbe's stepping magic that oh; so humiliated my pet hate; Owen Farrell. JD is an old Rassie favorite and the long term injuries to RG Snyman and Lood de Jager is now opening the door for this "new Bakkies Botha" belated entry to the top table. Bosh's turnstile defence is a concern but his extraordinary talent makes a serious coaching investment a worthwhile exercise; the first being bulking up his slender build; he has the frame for it and his weakness is impact at the point of contact when attempting a tackle.

2020-10-14T21:53:21+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Good article, soup bone. I like Fassi's big boot and fast feet. Specman seems a bit of a project, still? Optimising French- and UK-based players makes sense; they have more rugged rugby recently than NZ/OZ. Would LOVE to see Serfontein, for example. I trust Frans in big matches. Who wouldn't? On what basis can you distrust him? But Bosch must learn to tackle; Willemse as the 23 for me. I won't bench any RWC-starter, so Bongi to start. Yes, yes, yes on JD Schickerling.

2020-10-14T21:33:42+00:00

Jonty Shonty

Roar Pro


Lovely writing soup bone. Thoroughly enjoyed the trip down memory lane. Sport seemed much more wholesome back then didn’t it..? Anyway agree with your thoughts. Personally I’d swap Faf to start and Reinach coming on in the second for his snipes against a tired defence. I too like Bosch. He brings a triple threat on attack but I just don’t think you can teach someone to tackle. You either have the minerals or you don’t. Hadn’t considered Steyn for 10 but that makes a lot of sense. Please do write more! Enjoyed it.

Read more at The Roar