Marsh and Khawaja are the answer to Australia's batting woes

By Alex Hudson / Roar Guru

As mentioned by every Australian news source within the last 24 hours, the Australian Test team needs to address its batting line-up.

Although Marnus Labuschagne and Steve Smith impressed, with Cam Green and Will Pucovski looking very promising, the top seven overall lacks stability and confidence. The answer to Australia’s batting woes has been staring us in the face all along in Usman Khawaja and Shaun Marsh.

Usman Khawaja
This season so far, he has not been included in any Australia or Australia A set-ups. Instead, he’s been dominating the Sheffield Shield, averaging 56.50 in his three matches for Queensland. Out of the three games, he looked particularly in-form and Test match-ready against South Australia in Round 4, scoring 131 and 46*.

Khawaja is an aggressive batsman (for Test standards), having hit 312 Test fours in his 44 matches. He goes at a strike rate of 50.55. Another positive is that Khawaja has experience batting all around the order, from 1 to 6 for both Queensland and Australia. When batting, his traditionally perfect technique mixed with his elegance and innovation is something that has been missed in the current Australian line-up.

The former Test player’s use of the reverse-sweep is second-to-none, having played 31 of them in 2018 for the Test team alone. Khawaja’s class is something that has not been replaced in the team since he got dropped in 2019.

Shaun Marsh
In his four Sheffield Shield matches for the season, he is averaging 97 and has scored 485 runs (second-most in the competition, behind Will Pucovski). His best performance so far occurred in Round 3, when he scored 115 and 88. Like Khawaja, Marsh hasn’t been selected for any Australia set-ups this season, despite his performances with the red ball at the domestic level.

Shaun Marsh with his brother Mitch (Photo by Lee Warren/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

Again, similar to Khawaja, Marsh has experience batting for Australia from opening all the way to 7. Marsh is a mix of old-school and modern-day batting. His traditional and extremely solid batting style means that, although he very rarely pulls out the reverse sweep or any shots of that kind, he still manages to go at a strike rate of 43.85 in his 38 Tests and has hit 264 fours and eight sixes in the process.

It’s time to address the obvious: the age barrier.

Whenever one of these two batsmen is in the discussion to make a Test comeback, the media and the Australian public always disagree due to their age, with Marsh being 37 and Khawaja 34. People pick and choose when mentioning age – for example, Marsh is only a year older than Tim Paine, but how many outlets think that Paine should retire purely based on his age?

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

With Khawaja, he is the same age as current ODI and T20 captain, Aaron Finch, and is only a year older than Matthew Wade. If everything came down to age, then why are David Warner (34), Paine (36), Wade (33) and Moises Henriques (33) all still in the Test squad? If the age factor is to be applied, then consistency is a must.

Usman Khawaja and Shaun Marsh are experienced internationals in great form in domestic cricket, and both deserve a spot in the Test squad against South Africa.

The Crowd Says:

2021-01-22T04:45:57+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Anybody suggesting Shaun Marsh should get his 10th shot at cementing his spot in the test team, clearly hasn't been watching Shaun Marsh playing tests for AUS. 1 game out of 10 he gets a score and is a waste of space for the other 9. Too old to be useful in the field either.

2021-01-21T02:45:36+00:00

cruyff turn

Roar Rookie


I'm not having a go at you. Yes, Carey would make the batting order stronger if he were there and not Tim Paine. No disagreement there. Whether he's a better keeper is debatable. But if Paine were to be dumped, then who becomes captain? And both of us have identified that Carey would not just be able to come in and captain in his 1st Test.

2021-01-21T02:29:04+00:00

Jason

Roar Rookie


I am talking about making the batting stronger all round. Carey provides that and is a better keeper. Anyway, have a good day.

2021-01-21T01:58:06+00:00

cruyff turn

Roar Rookie


Yes, but like you say, we couldn't make him captain on his debut! Unless you mean we bring him in as a batsman, and then make him captain and wicketkeeper once Paine is no longer there? I'm not sure how we got on to Carey in the first place, because I didn't mention him when talking about our top 6!

2021-01-21T01:27:48+00:00

Jason

Roar Rookie


I think Carey will ultimately be Captain but we can't bring him in and immediately make him Captain, can we ? He is VC of the Aus T20 team. He would be perfect.

2021-01-21T00:45:28+00:00

cruyff turn

Roar Rookie


Well, the captaincy is whole different topic. If not Paine, then my pick would be Pat Cummins. This whole thinking that a fast bowler can't be the captain is overblown. Imran Khan and Kapil Dev captained their countries with distinction, and didn't appear to suffer. I agree that Smith should not be considered. Not for what happened, but I would just like to see him bat.

2021-01-21T00:03:42+00:00

Jason

Roar Rookie


Like McDermott. Carey to come in at 7 ? Question is, who is Captain. Smith not an option imo.

2021-01-20T22:36:56+00:00

cruyff turn

Roar Rookie


No they're not! The Marsh/Khawaja ship has sailed! Besides, if you were to look at Australia's batting, at full fitness, then you would have a top five of Pucovski, Warner, Labuschagne, Smith and Green. Yes, Green to move up to #5. So essentially, we're only looking for one batsman who can be #6. Look for a younger guy, like Ben McDermott.

2021-01-20T22:17:30+00:00

badmanners

Roar Rookie


Khawaja got that score against South Aus who in there 4 shield games have taken only 26 wickets out of the 80 possible. Not even a pop gun attack. And his 3 other innings were 4, 4 and 41.

2021-01-20T19:49:31+00:00

Max power

Guest


I think the roar has republished an article here from 2015. Must be a glitch

Read more at The Roar