The Roar
The Roar

Alex Hudson

Roar Guru

Joined October 2019

23.2k

Views

39

Published

33

Comments

Published

Comments

Hi Renato, thanks for the links. I’m well aware of Victor Trumper’s class and dominance with the bat. I just feel that it’s more of a debate surrounding whether or not Bradman is the best cricketer of all time opposed to whether or not he’s even the best Australian batsman of all time.

Sources including the BBC (https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/2V6BjFgdJ5KcfVHhR3bwBLz/the-greatest-cricketer-of-all-time-your-votes-revealed), Yahoo Sports (https://cricket.yahoo.net/news/the-10-greatest-cricketers-of-all-time-110104660) and many more have listed Bradman as the greatest cricketer of all-time. Between getting voted as the Greatest Male Athlete of the Past 200 years by the Australian Confederation of Sport in 1988, named Male Athlete of the Century in 1999 by the Sport Australia Hall of Fame and, in 2000, he was voted the greatest cricketer of the 20th century by Wisden Cricket Almanack.

I think it’s fair to say Bradman is Australia’s best ever batsman. In saying that, your reasoning for Victor Trumper is very sound and I’m not trying to undersell his legacy at all. Trumper’s class, consistency, and the way he went about representing Australia DEFINITELY shaped the way for the likes of Bradman, Archie Jackson and just about every Australian batsman of that generation and beyond. Thanks for your feedback.

Bradman: The man, the myth... the keeper?

Interesting point, the sites where I got my information on the O’Reilly – Bradman relationship were: https://www.smh.com.au/sport/a-notorious-feud-an-ugly-sectarian-conflict-20080927-gdswmk.html and http://cricmash.com/conflicts-controversies/2015/1/24/don-bradmans-rifts-with-his-teammates-especialy-bill-oreilly-and-jack-fingleton

Bradman: The man, the myth... the keeper?

This includes his Test and First-class centuries (29 and 117).

Bradman: The man, the myth... the keeper?

I think that the Vitality Blast in the UK is of very similar to level to the Big Bash. As for the Pakistan Super League, despite it not being quite as strong, it brings in more and more quality internationals every year. This year, the tournament featured Rashid Khan, Colin Munro, Ravi Bopara, Imran Tahir and Mohammad Nabi (to name a few).

Australian hopefuls have gone global

Since time of writing, Ivan Toney won the EFL Player of the Year Award at this year’s London Football Awards.

The intrigue surrounding Ivan Toney and Brentford

I’ve never understood how Mankads could be against the spirit of the game. If the rule wasn’t put in place, you would get incidences like Bravo in almost every game. I see nothing wrong with it, particularly so if a warning has been given already as well.

Dwayne Bravo's IPL tactics spark debate over the morality of the 'Mankad'

For anyone that missed it, yesterday on day 2 of WA’s Sheffield Shield game against Victoria, Joel Paris scored his maiden Sheffield Shield century. He got 102* off 155, hitting 11 4’s and a 6 in the process. On top of that, in the same day, Paris got the early wicket of opener Marcus Harris on 2.

The return of Joel Paris

The match will be played at Lilac Hill against Wanneroo and will feature big names such as Brad Hope, Nick Hobson, Cameron Steel, Jim Allenby, Kelvin Smith and Travis Birt

The return of Joel Paris

It’s been announced that Paris is in the 14-man squad for WA’s upcoming Sheffield Shield fixture against Victoria. However, if he’s 13th or 14th man, I imagine that the WACA would allow him to still play in the 1st Grade Final for Claremont-Nedlands.

The return of Joel Paris

In an article on nba.com from the 20th January this year, Ben Simmons was considered the 2nd best defender in the league for this season so far, ahead of Anthony Davis, Rudy Gobert and Giannis Antetokounmpo. The article stated: “Just to give a sample of his defensive work: RJ Barrett, Tyler Herro, Caris LeVert, Russell Westbrook, Markelle Fultz and Pascal Siakam have shot a combined 14-of-56 from the field (25 percent) when Philadelphia’s 6-foot-10 floor general has been the closest defender, per Second Spectrum tracking data.”

Ben Simmons should still be an All Star

Great to hear from a Brentford fan. If Ollie Watkins keeps up his form, having already scored 6 goals in his 12 appearances for Aston Villa, I think a potential England call-up in the upcoming seasons would be on the cards. It would be great to see Brentford in the PL next year, with talent like Ivan Toney, I hope to see them succeed in years to come.

Brentford FC could be playing in Europe

My top 7 would be: Marcus Harris, Tim Paine, Marnus Labuschagne, Steve Smith, Travis Head, Matt Wade and Cam Green

Tim Paine should open for Australia

Justin Langer just announced that Marnus Labuschagne will not open the batting. At the moment, it’s looking like the selectors are picking between Joe Burns, Matthew Wade and Tim Paine to open the batting, probably alongside Marcus Harris. Also, (if fit), Cam Green has also been promised a spot for the first test, presumably in the middle order.

Tim Paine should open for Australia

I agree. Also, when Green is fully fit in red-ball cricket, WA lacks any international fast bowlers in their lineup. Players like Lance Morris, Matt Kelly and Cam Gannon are still good bowlers but, Green’s fitness could mean that he would be one of WA’s main pace-bowlers for years to come.

Why Australia chose Henriques over Green

Yes he is. The ball that broke Shaun Marsh’s bat was at 140kph.

The Wild Thing: Lance Morris adds to Western Australia's bulging pace stocks

As well as Mitchell at Pick 13, Bam Adebayo was at Pick 14. To think that that draft class has already produced 3 all-stars who were selected at 3, 13 and 14 is extraordinary.

What should the 76ers do in the draft?

Hi Micko, the first half of the first episode focuses on the South Africa saga and then the rest of the series follows on from there. So to answer your question, yes it does show what happened in South Africa. Hope that helps.

Why 'The Test' is a must-watch

Hi Mick, the amount of players playing fo each team at a time can vary due to factors such as the level of indoor cricket that is being played and where the match is being played. Indoor cricket matches can use either 6 or 8 players per team depending on the factors mentioned earlier.

The 2020 cricket World Cup you probably haven't heard of

Hi Paul,
India, West Indies and UAE also have very strong sides. Coming into the tournament, India won their 2 warm-up matches, which included a win against Afghanistan by 211 runs and Zimbabwe by 23 runs. Also, keeping in mind that India are the defending champs in this competition due to their successful 2018 campaign in New Zealand. West Indies also won their 2 warm-up games and defeated the likes of Canada by 3 wickets and Scotland by 126 runs. Surprisingly, the United Arab Emirates team is one to look out for, coming off victories against a strong New Zealand side by 1 wicket and Japan by 253 runs.

When it comes to names to watch out for from lesser known cricketing countries, UAE opener and wicket-keeper Vriitya Aravind is in great batting form, with recent scores of 98 and 53. He is also in good form with the gloves, getting 3 stumpings in his most recent match against Japan. Also, the Scotland wicket-keeper Tomas Mackintosh is in good knick with the bat, scoring 103 against Japan earlier this week.

The emblem that is by my name is 2 cricket bats going across each other and then a red cricket ball in the middle.
Thanks for your comment Paul, hopefully this clarifies a couple of things.

A guide to the 2020 under-19s World Cup

In the Stars’ recent match against the Melbourne Renegades, all 5 Western Australians in the Stars’ squad were chosen for the starting XI. This increases the chance for all of them to play against the Scorchers next Wednesday significantly. This is helped by the fact that the Melbourne Stars have now lost Adam Zampa and Peter Handscomb due to international duty.

The unlikely WA Big Bash clash

Hi Paul,
Neser is yet to play a first class game at the MCG in 2019. In 2018, he played 2 first class matches against Victoria at the MCG, picking up figures of 1/39, 3/39 and 3/49 at an average of 18.14. These included key wickets such as Marcus Harris, Aaron Finch, Travis Dean, Glenn Maxwell and Peter Handscomb. Unfortunately, I’m not aware of his all time average at the MCG but these are good statistics to begin with.

Australia needs Neser to cover hurt Hazlewood

This case of the bails not falling off has occurred extremely often in the last couple of years, particularly in international cricket. I’m not sure whether the bail makers are doing anything different or not but regardless, this is starting to became a big issue. Also, Karunaratne ended up with 59 out in the end which is needless to say, a good score.

Remarkably stubborn bails rob Pakistan quick of a wicket

The Australian T20 team has been doing great although I would’ve liked to see the inclusion of a few more T20 specialists in the side. For example, D’Arcy Short, Chris Lynn and Jake Weatherald (to name a few). This would’ve been a good chance for them to put their names forward for the World Cup and get the game time they deserve. D’Arcy Short got player of the tournament in the 2018/19 Big Bash as well as the 2019 Vitality Blast and definitely deserves to play for Australia.

Langer has Australia purring in T20Is

Don’t get me wrong, I’m a big supporter in Michael Neser making his test debut, but I don’t believe it should be this summer. That’s because with a bowling attack of Pattinson, Starc, Cummins, Hazlewood and Richardson, I don’t really think that Australia needs another pace-bowler thrown into the mix. Although he has been performing quite well with the bat and despite Mitch Marsh being injured, Australia’s still got many top quality all-rounders to choose from such as Travis Head, Glenn Maxwell and Ashton Agar. However, as Neser is 29 years old, he still has a bit of time to make his test debut.

Why Michael Neser must play in the first Test

The article is about why and why not Usman Khawaja and Matt Renshaw should open for Australia in the upcoming test series against Pakistan

Should Khawaja and Renshaw open against Pakistan?

close