Kyrie Irving is the rotten fruit

By Troy Hanning / Roar Guru

The Garden of Eden was beautiful but short lived in the heart of Brooklyn.

But the contamination of the former paradise started and ended with the arrival of Kyrie Irving.

In their first two games together as Nets, James Harden and Kevin Durant scored or assisted on 84 per cent of the team’s total points, leading to wins against the Orlando Magic and the Milwaukee Bucks.

The duo were clicking on a level that I have never seen Harden click with any star teammate before, both racking up the stat sheet almost seamlessly. In fact with all the high fives, flashy passes and smiles – and admittedly defensive lapses – the Nets looked like an All Star team.

But in the next game, the Nets let the 29th worst offence in the league – the Cleveland Cavaliers – score 147 points in a tight loss.

So what happened? Well, Irving happened.

(Photo by Mike Stobe/Getty Images)

He was returning from his unexcused absence, after leaving his new head coach blind. His coach was expecting him to play that night.

His new teammates were only experiencing their first ‘wait, what did Irving do?’ teammate moment. Durant was forced to play in back to backs because of the shortened season and the Nets’ .500 record.

After finally coming back, the paradise was flipped on its head.

Any fan that watched the first two games could sense the dark, cloudy feeling from his arrival, especially in Harden, who at halftime of the Cavaliers game had only taken a few shots and was looking like a lost rookie on offence.

This is supposed to be the team’s best passer and ball handler, maybe even the best in the league. Yet it was Irving who took twice as many shots as the beard.

Even Bruce Brown, the team’s best guard defender – who should have been guarding Collin Sexton – played just over seven minutes.

My theory is that Steve Nash knew if he benched Irving for a more tactical specialist, especially down the stretch, Irving would be, well, Irving.

This isn’t speculation that Irving was the cause for not all but most of this demise, because there is evidence of him doing this in nearly every season of his stardom.

Irving has never maximised a team’s chances of winning since requesting a trade to branch off from LeBron James all the way back in 2017.

(Photo by Sarah Stier/Getty Images)

Boston’s first year was a great example as the team overachieved without Irving in the conference finals, taking it to seven games. Irving’s second go around was filled with him trashing the coach and young teammates to the media, ruining the team’s chemistry and visibly giving up on his team in that final Bucks series.

Even after joining a new Nets team, while not even playing more than 20 games because of injuries, Irving beefed with the media all year, calling the industry pawns. But that absence from playing must have really riled Irving’s need to defy as he has already put on one hell of a spectacle just a few weeks into the season.

I’m just waiting for someone to show me the track record of talented All NBA level players who did nothing but inexplicably degenerate or stagnate team after team for years – then like a flip of a switch, become a dependable selfless player, with a team-first attitude.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Imagine if this was a talented yet injury-riddled player, constantly returning for snippets of the season just to find himself back on the sidelines with a new cast, bandage or crutch. It would not matter if he was the best locker-room guy in the league – if you have not contributed to a team’s success admirably while taking a fat chunk of the salary, fans would relish the day that player was sent packing his bags.

Irving should be looked at the same way. He is an undeniably talented player who for personality or attitude reasons is just not going to be the uplifting point guard who is a breeze to play with and coach.

Instead he will be the rotten fruit, dragging a long season even longer with snide remarks, making headlines that championship-driven teams just don’t make, and slowly but surely inhibiting the team to reach its maximum potential.

The Crowd Says:

2021-02-17T04:54:20+00:00

astro

Roar Rookie


Its funny as I dont completely disagree with you on this...Kyrie is such a hard player to assess as I'm not sure he actually makes his teams that much better, despite his incredible talent. Maybe this year with the Nets will help clarify his 'legacy' one way or another...

AUTHOR

2021-02-17T04:36:42+00:00

Troy Hanning

Roar Guru


We agree Boston was a failure. Id also argue that the mess he cause last season with the media was funny because he was barely playing but still making head lines. Ill agree I may have come across to strong in this one.

AUTHOR

2021-02-17T04:35:06+00:00

Troy Hanning

Roar Guru


AHHAHA I think you have a career in television producing.

AUTHOR

2021-02-17T04:34:23+00:00

Troy Hanning

Roar Guru


No one can dispute that Kyrie is a baller tho!

AUTHOR

2021-02-17T04:33:48+00:00

Troy Hanning

Roar Guru


Hey, Kyrie clearly has been the one to sacrifice the most this season. Now, I do believe Kyrie will be 'normal' for the rest of the season and not cause any more mess - But, next season, remember I said this, he will fizzle out into his old narcissistic dramatic ways!

2021-02-08T01:05:46+00:00

astro

Roar Rookie


You cant really think benching Irving for Bruce Brown in a tight game is a good idea? Look, I'm not a massive Kyrie fan, but whatever you or I or the media think of him, its clear lots of players like the guy. Do you think Durant and Harden would want to play with him if he was that bad? And to say, he "inexplicably degenerate or stagnate team after team for years"...well, his time at Boston didn't work out, but he was great for the Cavs and he did bring Durant to the Nets, so that's one team where things haven't worked out for him or the team. Hardly years and years of degenerating teams...

2021-02-06T21:25:51+00:00

Lara

Guest


Don’t know the guy will enough . However, with 3 superstar players, who are all great players, with huge pay packets n only one who hasn’t got a ring to his name, it’s going to be fun to watch. The Brooklyn management n coaches may have bitten more than it can chew, but the risk n reward to the franchise may be worth it. Ego, money n a ring.....sounds like a TV show.....n there is a boy downunder in the mix, who is in the head office .

2021-02-06T03:30:19+00:00

Elliott Yancey-Brangman

Guest


Irving is a stealer, not a leader. He's very good but no that good if he riles his teammates, coaches, and beef with the media. Game over son.

2021-02-06T00:33:23+00:00

Graeme Docker

Roar Rookie


Interesting take Troy. Kyrie makes himself an easy target. But Harden is not much different, in the past he has refused to play defence, hogged the ball and made his teammates miserable. However Kyrie has made the winning shot in game 7 of an NBA finals and therefore has a ring, Harden does not. As for ball handling, Kyrie is considered by many experts as in the top 5 all time. But it seems as though they both acknowledge that they each need to play better on defence to make it work. I think in couple of months time those doubting Kyrie will have to change their tune.

Read more at The Roar