I’m not worried about how Origin will be refereed

By Clancy / Roar Rookie

I’m no rugby league expert with 20-plus years of experience playing, coaching, commentating and everything in between for the greatest game of all.

I’m just a humble uni student who is a passionate Broncos and Queensland supporter and I can’t get enough of rugba leeg.

So, I suppose I don’t hold much weight when I say I’m not worried about State of Origin like all those journos, experts, former players and keyboard warriors concerned the game has gone soft because you can no longer do what has been forbidden by the rules since 1908: make contact with the head or neck of the ball carrier in a tackle.

Now, I know lots of people will say, “But most contact with the head is accidental”, or, “Oh, come on, he barely clipped him – just play on” and odds are, these people play and follow rugby league.

I understand we play a physical contact sport with the big collisions, crunching tackles and ferocious hit-ups that make it what it is, but no other contact sport in the world is so relaxed about high contact as we are.

Hearing commentators and fans excuse a player getting whacked on the nose or coat-hangered because ‘the tackler got wrong-footed’ or ‘his arm came up off the ball’ can be, frankly, quite frustrating. Contact to the head is contact to the head – it shouldn’t happen and there’s a sense of carelessness from the tackler if their tackle ends up clocking a person in the face and knocking them out.

But I think I’ve made my point about all of this: I agree with the crackdown and don’t think the game will become ‘soft’ or no longer rugby league. Just as the game didn’t become soft when there was a crackdown on thuggery during the 1970s, documented by the popular documentary The Rivalry: Fibros and Silvertails.

The banning of the shoulder charge and even the ever famous ‘biff’ has happened over time. Now, I wouldn’t say the game has become less physical and aggressive because of it; rather, I’d say it’s become less of a thug’s game.

SBW loved a shoulder charge (Photo by George Wood/Getty Images)

Don’t get me wrong – not for a second am I claiming any of those famous players of the past are thugs and bemoan them for ruining the appeal of the sport.

They grew up in a time where that was the norm, but unfortunately for many of the game’s dinosaurs, the game has changed into the modern age where which bloke threw the hardest punch in a game of footy is the toughest bloke on the field is no longer the necessary metric for physicality and toughness.

Moving onto State of Origin: many are bemoaning this series will be ruined and not be the same because of it.

I imagine they cried foul when the game rubbed out shoulder charges, punching and more with the same old argument: “We play a contact sport with lots of passion – it’s bound to happen”.

Again, the game has not been ruined by those changes and it won’t be ruined by these changes. State of Origin is still the showpiece event of rugby league with so much hype and build-up to the series that can begin even at the beginning of the NRL season.

Often, discussions take place around who’s going to put their hand up to play Origin, who’s going to be the bolter, who’s going to return to the Origin frame yet again because Origin is beloved by all for its passion, skill and toughness.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Yet again, I say none of that has been lost in the changes over the years. Yes, maybe some grizzled old fans of ‘the good ol’ days’ have stopped watching but the game has gained much support.

So yes, I will once again remain the optimist and say this year will be another epic chapter in the classic battle of state versus state and mate versus mate.

I’m confident in saying that the mighty Maroons will retain the shield because, well, I’m a Queenslander, and it would be wrong to say otherwise.

The Crowd Says:

2021-06-05T03:58:15+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


Great piece, Clancy. But I am sick to DEATH of people not whinging about refs! :silly:

AUTHOR

2021-06-05T03:56:27+00:00

Clancy

Roar Rookie


Definitely Paul, I think it's a debate because for so long head contact has been excused by experts and fans as accidental or slipping off the ball. However, the reality is that it's just plain careless if anything and I understand it's hard for me to say as an average fan and I definitely think players should've been given more time to adjust but the current situation is still better I think rather than continue on with how it used to be for the rest of the season.

AUTHOR

2021-06-05T03:53:13+00:00

Clancy

Roar Rookie


Exactly Crow, I understand we can't stamp concussions out of the game entirely but we can prevent unnecessary instances of it occurring which I was I'm in agreeance with the crackdown, and yes I definitely think State of Origin will still be the showpiece Rugby League event.

2021-06-04T23:28:11+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


For a humble uni student, you've made your point very well, Clancy, far better than most of the so-called experts you referred to. What's amusing is that this is a topic of conversation at all by the pundits. Surely the more relevant issue is that there's good, consistent decision making applied to both teams? Players know what the refs are going to be looking for and the only thing they want is that the rules are applied to both teams fairly.

2021-06-04T23:13:10+00:00

Walter Black

Guest


"The banning of the shoulder charge and even the ever famous ‘biff’ has happened over time. Now, I wouldn’t say the game has become less physical and aggressive because of it; rather, I’d say it’s become less of a thug’s game" That caused me to think of some recent retirees from the game and think how lucky they were that these rules weren't brought in a decade earlier. Their little legs stomping out of the tunnel like a white rhino going on a rampage would have been cut short along with their careers. I watched a bit of last weeks Union game on FTA last week and there were a lot of nice touches but there were still players that reminded me of that Rhino and of what our game used to be. Today its the more agile player rather than the brick s......... player that is in the ascendancy. Am I sorry that side of the game has gone ? Well yes just a little but I also know that it is the change we had to have and I would sooner watch the athleticism of today's players than the thugs who thought the Biff was a strategic weapon.

2021-06-04T22:29:21+00:00

Crow

Roar Pro


I like your thinking Clancy. Sure the new rules need a change of thinking for many, and yes it is a contact sport however the data is in and it’s conclusive. Head and neck contact is not the way forward. Too many players are suffering from the devastating effects and they are a long time retired as opposed to a short playing career. Brett Horsnell, Ian Roberts, Jake Friend. The list goes on. Origin will be just fine with the speed of the game, ball skills, athleticism and physicality. I too am not worried about how SOO will be governed.

Read more at The Roar