The age-old debate of which European club produces the best talent normally centres around two teams: Ajax and Barcelona.
The Youth Academy in Amsterdam and La Masia in Catalonia have seen countless players, including several young Australians, pass through their doors – however, surprisingly they are only ranked in second and third place when it comes to overall success.
A recent study by the International Centre for Sports awarded Portuguese side Benfica the highest score for an academy set-up in Europe.
The study took into account the number of players trained, their ages and the level they reached in their career. Benfica ranked above the more fancied Ajax and Barcelona.
Benfica Campus is the training ground and youth academy of the Portuguese giant. It is a 19-hectare site in Quinta de Trindade, approximately a 30-minute drive from Lisbon.
In recent seasons their graduates read like a roll call of Europe’s elite footballers:
Ruben Dias, Bernardo Silva, Joao Cancelo, Joao Felix, Ederson, Victor Lindelof, Nelson Semedo, Goncalo Guedes and Andre Gomes, to name just a few.
(Photo by Matt McNulty – Manchester City/Manchester City FC via Getty Images)
Benfica have made an eye-watering £1 billion in just over ten years from player sales, and eight academy graduates were part of the national team squad for Euro 2020.
The club have an open-door policy with coaches who come from all over the world to learn new techniques and gain insight into how a country with just over ten million people produces such high-quality talent.
Luis Araujo is the longest-serving academy coach on Benfica’s books, and one of the most underrated when it comes to youth development.
He joined the new academy when it opened 15 years and has coached every age group from the under-14s upwards – having a hand in nurturing the several superstars I mentioned earlier.
Portugal is a country with not as many football resources, compared to larger European nations. Their players are naturally gifted, but it is elite youth-level coaching that Benfica provides which gives the players a high chance of success.
The money from players sales has been used to make the Benfica Campus one of the very best in the world.
It has nine world-class pitches, two elite gyms, 28 dressing rooms and can accommodate 68 players living there.
Benfica has overhauled its scouting and coaching networks and now predominantly focuses on players’ dribbling abilities more than any other technical skill.
Centre-backs are expected to dribble out with the ball to start an attack and defensive midfielders after intercepting an opposition pass will need to be able to dribble forward and progress an attack.
Technical skills are honed with the use of a simulator, which has robots that move along the walls of a cage – monitoring every single player movement
Young players are tested on their speed of reaction, vision and finishing, as they are tasked with aiming for moving targets after taking the ball down.
This system gives the club coaches the ability to see which player has the likelihood of making it at the very top level – due to their technical skills constantly being worked on with the aid of this revolutionary tech.
Benfica’s scouting system consists of hundreds of scouts who watch youth fixtures every week and, like the other big Portuguese sides, they have scouts worldwide, monitoring countries like Australia.
In recent years, there has been a large Australian contingent plying their trade at all levels in Portugal – Anthony Carter, Dylan Collard, Ryan Teague, Tristan Hammond, Max Mikkola, Sam Silvera, Brooklyn Barataud, Jack Mitsoulas, Evan Ball, Dimitri Kostopoulos, Adrian Cabra, Bailey Rule, and Jeremy Siarakas.
While many of the names mentioned above have since left Portugal, Teague, Collard and the silky Danny Choi are still toiling away in the country’s lower divisions.
Benfica is a club that anyone associated with youth development should be looking closely at.
The focus on players’ dribbling ability and coaching methods are two things that are lacking in Australia’s own system.
At work
Roar Rookie
It’s one of the biggest bugbears of mine (of Australian players), that we either don’t have the ability and/or confidence to beat a player 1 on 1. Imagine our wingers or high full backs running and at a man and taking him 1 on 1 and whipping a low hard cross to players in the box, such a dangerous move for the defence, but it’s so rare to see in the A League. Or a forward putting on a move to create a clean shot on goal for themselves, instead they’ll more commonly cease the move and pass it sideways or back to restart some slow play around the box that never eventuates to anything threatening.
Islandsinthestream
Guest
I would say you can’t teach people great football technique, you either got it or you haven’t, simple test throw football at someone, if they instantly get it under control they’ve got it, if the ball squirms/bounces away and they have no control, no amount of athleticism or training will compensate for this. You need to identify those that can combine football technique, with the other football attributes, spatial awareness, decision making etc, which is where the academies come in but it’s getting the right player at the start is where the Australian academies need to work on.
Pro Rel NSD
Guest
Besides City I don't see any clear style of play in any other teams. And City press hard so usually they work better in colder conditions. Most other styles change dependent on the coach but when they are let go than a new style and new players come in on the revolving door.
chris
Guest
Many players still go through Coerver coaching or similar here so I can't agree its totally gone from our curriculum. It was never part of the official curriculum. But neither was proper technique in how to strike a ball, or how to cross etc etc. It's all about team shape and structure.
Will
Guest
With the AIS gone, its now up to the clubs to find best practice in developing the next generation of players. This might sound like a broken record with the a-league particularly but each club should have their own identity in not only how they play but what kind of players that want to develop whilst comparing it to world's best practice.
Simmo
Roar Rookie
Good article Andy. What do you think of Tom Byer's "football starts at home" philosophy? His view is that parents are the key as they're the ones who can teach fundamental ball control skills when kids are in their greatest learning window: before 5 years old. Football skills, like languages, can be picked up super easily at young ages. And for football, the best individual skills to master as early as possible are ball control, rather than passing, scoring, and others https://www.fourfourtwo.com/performance/training/can-you-coach-a-child-two-years-old
Redcap
Roar Guru
Whomever helped Bernardo Silva hone his talent certainly deserves a medal. Wonderful player.
TheSecretScout
Roar Guru
exclude the massive financial difference between both countries. the main thing to take away from this that i tried to highlight, is the emphasis on dribbling (this has unfortunately been coached out of australian youth for years) that is everything to do with the coaching system here
Pro Rel NSD
Guest
We should copy as much of it as possible in Australia
Statler and Waldorf
Roar Guru
At what age do Portuguese players play 11 V 11?