Aussies exploit sub fielder loophole with resting ploy, Head's up play turns Test, Waugh not happy with cordon

By The Roar / Editor

Australia’s tactics have been questioned after they rotated their fast bowlers on and off the field in the energy-sapping heat at the Gabba on Saturday.

Josh Hazlewood, Pat Cummins and Mitchell Starc took breaks after their spells to sit in front of big electric fans in the dressing room, munching on crushed ice to cool their body temperature and draping cool towels around their necks.

If a player is off longer than 15 minutes it means they face restrictions on when they can bowl again but the Aussies exploited that loophole by subbing them back on just in time.

“In the rules you’re allowed 15 minutes but I think that’s too long,” said former Test opener Phil Jaques on ABC Radio.

“I have no problems with a welfare issue, a trip to the toilet or to change your shirt.

“But as far as giving them a rest goes, I’m not sure that’s right. To sit in front of a fan doesn’t feel like it’s in the interests of the game.”

The temperature was in the mid 30s for most of the day but with extreme humidity, players from both sides were sweating big time and struggling to cope with the conditions.

Heads-up play turns Test

Travis Head’s brilliance at short leg has helped Australia claw their way back into the Second Test with his run-out of Kavem Hodge turning the match midway through day three.

Hodge clipped a Nathan Lyon delivery off his pads but Head intercepted it and flicked it onto the stumps as the Windies batter tried to dive back to make his ground.

The replay showed Hodge’s bat was in the air as he scrambled hom when Head’s sharp fielding hit the stumps.

Head already has drawn comparisons to the legendary David Boon with a similar stocky build, droopy moustache and match-winning batting and now we can add exemplary bat-pad work to the list of similarities.

He reeled off a stunning catch in the same position to dismiss Windies skipper Kraigg Brathwaite in the first Test at Adelaide.

Head’s run-out of Hodge for 29 ended his steady 74-ball vigil which frustrated the Aussies in the energy-sapping heat at the Gabba.

Joshua da Silva, who like Hodge was a thorn in Australia’s side in the first innings, departed a short time later when he was caught on the second grab by Cameron Green in the gully for seven off Mitchell Starc.

His dismissal left the Windies six down with 157 on the board, an overall lead of 179 and needing the tail to wag again to put a formidable victory target in front of Australia.

The tail didn’t wag and they ended up all out for 193 in the final session on Saturday to set Australia 216 to win.

Fifteen losses and five winless Test tours of Australia have come since a Brian Lara century and Curtly Ambrose’s seven wickets led to a 10-wicket victory in Perth’s fifth Test in February 1997.

Mark Taylor’s men won that series 3-2 against a side also featuring Shivnarine Chanderpaul, Courtney Walsh, Carl Hooper, Ian Bishop and Jimmy Adams.

This side is without a host of their more seasoned campaigners and features two second-gamers, a debutant and Chanderpaul’s son.

“That is the head reason why we are so tuned in, because we haven’t won in such a long time,” veteran quick Kemar Roach said after day two. 

“To win a Test match in Australia as a young side with a lot of debutants and guys who have played less than 10 Test matches, I think that would set a great mark for us. 

“It is a young group and the guys are energetic. They want to play Test cricket and do well against the No.1 team in the world.”

Kemar Roach celebrates dismissing Cameron Green in Brisbane. (Photo by Albert Perez – CA/Cricket Australia via Getty Images)

In the Gabba’s first pink-ball Test in 2016 Pakistan made 450 in their pursuit of a record 490.

“I don’t think you can put a figure on it,” keeper Alex Carey said of what Australia could chase down.

“There are going to be opportunities for batters to get in and I don’t see signs of that wicket breaking up too much. 

“We know the threat of the first 20 overs and the new ball threat. 

“Get through that and there is potential to score a big target. 

“There should be an opportunity for our batters to dig in. Hopefully, it is not a big target but if it is it will be great to see our batters go about it.”

Smith shells second catch before making amends

It’s rare that Steve Smith drops one catch let alone two in a row.

After grassing a straightforward chance on Friday night at second slip, Smith put down a sharp chance off Alick Athanaza when the Windies batter was on 28 on day three.

Smith dived in front of Usman Khawaja who was at first slip but his spectacular one-handed grab didn’t come off even though his teammate probably would have snaffled it.

“Khawaja had that covered behind him as well but you can’t fault Smith for going for it,” said former Australia captain Ricky Ponting on Seven commentary. “It’s one of those ones in the slips, if you see it and it’s to your dominant hand, you’ve got to go.”

Another legendary slips fielder, Mark Waugh, on Fox Cricket thought Smith and the cordon were too close together and that caused confusion.

“That’s first slip’s catch,” he said. “They’re too tight. He should be another metre to his left, Steve Smith, and there woulnd’t have been any doubt. He would have known that was Khawaja’s catch.”

Athanaze only added seven more runs before he was dismissed by Nathan Lyon, with the easy catch taken this time around by Smith.

The 34-year-old Aussie vice-captain snared an athletic catch over his head at second slip to dismiss Alzarri Joseph for a duck in the final session to bring his success rate up to 50% for the innings.

Warner solution not an open-and-shut case for Australia

Steve Smith and Cameron Green fell cheaply for the second time in two Tests since the experiment to replace the retired long-time opener David Warner began.

How to approach life after David Warner remains a question unanswered for Australia’s Test team, but they’re confident Steve Smith “will find a way” after the opening experiment failed again at the Gabba.

Smith was out lbw for six in the first over of Australia’s reply to West Indies’ 311 on Friday’s second day of the Brisbane Test.

Promoted to open after David Warner’s retirement in Sydney, Smith managed 12 in his first effort in Adelaide and was unbeaten on 11 in the second dig as Australia posted a 10-wicket win.

Steve Smith looks on after being dismissed by Shamar Joseph. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Adding to the issue was another failure for Cameron Green (eight), who was slotted back into the side at No.4 as part of the Smith reshuffle. 

The former Test captain’s averaged less than 32 this summer and boasts a highest score of just 50 in five Tests against Pakistan and West Indies, his lowest total in any given summer of a career spanning 14 years.

Smith was exposed, moving dramatically across his crease, Brian Lara picking apart his technique on Fox Sports and an aware Kemar Roach able to exploit it when he nipped the ball back to catch Smith’s pad in line with the stumps.

“His body’s going towards point, his bat is going towards mid-wicket and the ball is crashing into middle stump,” Lara said.

“He’s giving himself little or no chance to make good contact with the ball.”

Alex Carey (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

But Australian teammate Carey said the team and Smith himself had “no concerns at all”.

“He has been dismissed twice as an opener now and he is going to be dismissed a lot more as an opener,” Carey said.

“He is one of the best batters in the world and he will find a way to score big hundreds. 

“He has done it in really difficult situations before … a big innings is coming up and hopefully it is in the second innings.”

Green was out meekly chipping a catch to mid-off, Australia falling to 5-54 before rallying to declare just 22 shy of the visitor’s score.

Kevin Sinclair celebrates taking the wicket of Usman Khawaja. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

That followed a score of 11 in his only innings in Adelaide, with Green now averaging less than 20 since a maiden Test century in India last March in a run that saw him replaced in the side by fellow allrounder Mitchell Marsh during last year’s Ashes.

Selectors resisted a recall for any of specialist openers Matt Renshaw, Cameron Bancroft or Marcus Harris, despite all presenting strong cases for another chance at the top of the order.

Batting will get no easier for Australia, who have two Tests in New Zealand to follow the home summer, before India visit later this year.

with AAP

The Crowd Says:

2024-01-29T01:21:12+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


The story I heard was only that Cummins said the time the batsmen are taking should be taken into account with over rates. He didn't otherwise care. Batsmen have to go off and retire hurt, bowlers can go off for a bit and bring a sub fielder on, then resume. It's always been that way in cricket.

2024-01-28T21:53:59+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


fair enough.

2024-01-28T21:53:30+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


Batsmen can retire hurt if heat distressed, just as bowlers can. The difference at present is batsmen can't have a spell in the sheds for 15 minutes like anyone in the fielding side can. Yes they can retire hurt but so can bowlers. The difference is bringing in a new batsmen which often advantages the fielding team. It seems we have a couple of different standards. During the Windies innings, Cummins complained to the umpires about the number & duration of drinks breaks the batsmen were taking. I don't think the umpires did anything about it, but he himself then disappeared under that rule for more a good 10 minutes or more.

2024-01-28T21:19:30+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Temp in the low 40s, game on the line, kept bowling, needed sugar and fluids, splitting headache at the end, felt weak and dizzy, very dehydrated. And that was only subbies cricket. Batsmen should be able to retire hurt if heat distressed.

2024-01-28T20:29:51+00:00

Tempo

Roar Rookie


He wasn’t whinging, he was drawing to the umpires attention to make sure it didn’t affect their over rate calculation.

2024-01-28T07:13:03+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


If you say so. I’m sure you know best… :thumbup:

2024-01-28T07:12:34+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


Yes it does. That is literally the point. And perhaps you’re not aware, but players are allowed to retire hurt. Neither Jones or Maxwell did.

2024-01-28T07:02:00+00:00

Ace

Roar Rookie


I shall let you wallow in your ignorance and desire to be argumentative

2024-01-28T06:53:54+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Just because you finished your innings does not mean there is no problem.

2024-01-28T06:10:12+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


Both players you’ve mentioned completed their innings. And in fact both those players now say those respective innings were the ones they’re most proud of. Maybe do some research next time? And again for the slow learners…players should be able to retire hurt if they feel they can’t continue. Nobody is being forced to stay out there against their will. Which negates the ‘but it’s life-threatening’ argument.

2024-01-28T05:53:54+00:00

Ace

Roar Rookie


Dean Jones did. Glen Maxwell another hospitalised Don't you understand what humidity can do to sportspeople?

2024-01-28T05:50:32+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


That was a lot of words to admit that in over 2,000 Test matches not a single batsman has collapsed on field due to heat/humidity.

2024-01-28T05:42:23+00:00

Ace

Roar Rookie


Just told you. Can't grasp what I said? Let me explain ...Dean Jones was hospitalised in India after batting in hot humid conditions. Was medically very unwell not that Border was convince at the time he was batting and made some typical comment There has been others.. McDermott

2024-01-28T05:38:12+00:00

Blink

Roar Rookie


It was a particularly bad day in Brisbane where the heat felt more like 48C. It was worse than a Perth heatwave but only for a day. Of course the humidity magnifies it. I think its ok to use the rules in such circumstances.

2024-01-28T05:12:36+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


“There have been some.” You’ll be able to give me details then. A batsman collapsing on field during a Test match due to heat/humidity. Waiting…

2024-01-28T05:06:26+00:00

Ace

Roar Rookie


There have been some. And Alan Border was one who was totally ignorant of these factors particularly in the case of Dean Jones. Saying that it's not always 90% humidity in every playing arena but it is today at in Queensland. So mate we are not inventing stuff ..just read up on it You obviously haven't otherwise you wouldn't post your comments

2024-01-28T04:22:50+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


There was a sidelight to this which hasn't been discussed. During one session, Cummins was caught on a microphone having a whinge to the umpires about the number of breaks the West Indies batsmen were taking. Seems a tad hypocritical to complain about the bowlers from Australia have left the field all together.

2024-01-28T03:56:27+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


"There is absolutely no way the answer is nil." I know this comment is directed elsewhere but I completely agree, the answer most certainly is not to revert to the "good old days". Safe to say then, there has to be a time between zero and 15 minutes where players can sort out short-term issues, without being penalized while not gaining some sort of unfair advantage over a batsman, real or perceived.

2024-01-28T03:49:06+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


fair enough

2024-01-28T03:47:55+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


It freshens players up. Throw in a chance to take on plenty of fluids, have something to eat, even have a quick massage and there's certainly opportunities for the bowlers to be in way better shape late in the day compared to a bloke who's batted under a helmet for 3 or 4 hours

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar