Adelaide Oval the saviour of Port, South Aussie footy?

By Adrian Musolino / Expert

“Wanna go to the footy at Adelaide Oval this Sunday?” read the text message from a friend last week. “I don’t give a shit about the two teams, but it’ll be good to see footy at the Oval,” it continued. “Then we can stay in the city for some pints” – the final drawcard.

That friend eventually bailed (Father’s Day commitments), but there was no shortage of interest in going to see Port Adelaide host the Melbourne Demons, 17th versus 13th, at the first ever AFL match at Adelaide Oval on Sunday.

So what would otherwise have been an insignificant final round dead rubber between two of the worst performing teams of 2011, played at a faraway stadium that would have been lucky to get near Port’s home crowd average of 20,912, suddenly become a historical encounter; providing a glimpse into the future.

In the end, 29,340 spent their Father’s Day afternoon in the spring sun at the Oval, where Port and the Adelaide Crows are due to play their home games from 2014, at the revamped 50,000-capacity stadium.

30,000 was suggested as the pass mark in the build up to the game, and although the crowd fell just 660 short, it was still 8428 up on Port’s average and significantly more than what would have been had the game stayed at AAMI Stadium.

And remember to factor Father’s Day into the equation. For every family that’s keen to incorporate an afternoon at the footy into their festivities, there’s a family with unchangeable rituals elsewhere, or that stubborn uncle who won’t budge from the couch. Then factor in the Royal Adelaide Show, into its first weekend. And don’t forget; it was a dead rubber between two also rans.

Just short of 30,000, yes, but still a pass.

Adelaide Oval does have the potential to be the saviour of the stagnating South Australian footy scene, and particularly the wayward Port Adelaide.

Like in Melbourne and so many examples around the world, the city move is a necessity to help draw regular crowds. Adelaide Oval, within walking distance from the CBD, is the perfect spot.

While some traditionalists fought against the redevelopment – particularly the cricket fraternity, bemoaning Aussie Rules’ muscling in on their ground – the fact remains that the location and ground is too good to be used for just state league cricket and footy, one Test match, and the odd one-day and Twenty20 international per year. It’s wasted at present – and has been for far too long.

City stadiums are winners because transportation infrastructure is already geared towards getting large masses of people into and out of the city with ease, catering to most surrounding areas.

Then there’s the extra temptation of combing it with other activities – pints at pubs, cafes, movies, nightclubs, or whatever takes your fancy. In Adelaide Oval’s case, there’s both the CBD and North Adelaide for pre- and post-match options.

It’s quite a contrast to the current home of South Australian football; over 30 minutes from the city centre and further away for those in the east. AAMI Stadium is the antithesis of what modern sporting stadiums should provide – parking is limited, traffic in and especially out of the area is painful, there’s little else to see or do around it, it’s too isolated and far away for most in Adelaide, and small crowds in such a large stadium make for a barren, soulless experience.

As football attendance habits changed and fans became more discerning, crowds inevitably fell for the already vulnerable Port, from their tenuous supporter base.

Why commit to the painful experience of getting to AAMI when matches are often live and in HD at home? Why rule out a whole afternoon in traffic when you can instead watch at the local pub?

My generation and younger don’t have the commitment of previous generations, to rule out an hour and more before and after the game to get to the ground. We want the ability to go to the footy but also keep the option of going to a movie, pub or cafe before and after. It’s our impatience. City grounds cater for that.

Ground maximisation in Melbourne led to the record crowds the AFL currently boasts. There’s no reason why it can’t have a similarly positive effect in Adelaide.

For Port it opens the door to expand its fan base, growing beyond its Port Adelaide roots. Port’s problems are numerous and inherent, and while they will benefit financially from the city move, growing their supporter base is much more important to their sustainability.

While some claim the Crows will only hammer home their advantage in the city, as the club for all South Australians – much like Collingwood and co have done at the expense of Melbourne and North Melbourne (see here) – it’s the first step of Port’s push for hearts and minds; as the alternative club for South Aussies. It’ll be difficult, but it’s a start.

Then there is the neutral factor. The easier it is to get to the ground, the more likely footy fans will take up the option of getting their live action fix on a weekly basis.

With the stadium in the city, why couldn’t non-Port fans pop down to the Oval for some footy after work on a Friday evening, combing it with their usual post-work festivities? It’s a realistic option, certainly much more so than the dull drive to AAMI.

Even if they aren’t Port fans or members, they will contribute to the club’s coffers; a chance for South Aussies, so antagonistic toward the other club, to actually help support both clubs.

Yes, the novelty will eventually wear off once Adelaide Oval is hosting weekly AFL action. But new attendance habits could develop, and new fans potentially won over. It’s a move the AFL and Port needed to make.

On Sunday Port claimed a rousing eight-point victory to avoid the wooden spoon and open their account at the Oval. It was a fitting result.

The AFL desperately needs the Adelaide Oval move to work; it needs two clubs in South Australia. The move to the Oval needs to be the catalyst for the growth of Port’s supporter base.

After its first test, the signs are positive.

Follow Adrian on twitter @AdrianMusolino

The Crowd Says:

2011-09-08T00:41:35+00:00

Kasey

Guest


Its a lot like waverly, both Arctic Park and Footy Park were created out of the same issues, the cricket body and the footy body's failure to communicate and play nice with each other. In my experience, except for the brief period of StKilda and Hawthorn calling it home, Footy Park was more 'loved' by the SA footy public than Waverley both stadia were neglected a bit and failed to modernise from their original remit. Throwing money at Footy Park was more like polishing the turd than anything else I can think of. Thing is, inner city stadiums are the bare minimum these days, the added attractions of city ammenities and easy of access via PT are needed to get people off their couches and out to stadiums. Even the mighty NFL in the USA aren't building humungous stadia out in the burbs anymore. The European football teams are finding it more effective to upgrade their original stadia, which typically have inner city locales and thus bigger costs associated in reconstruction than to move to the burbs on a greenfields site.

2011-09-07T22:52:35+00:00

The Mad Chatter

Roar Rookie


I think it is awesome to see Aussie Rules being played back at the Adelaide Oval. Bring back the glory days when the Oval was packed full of true football fans. The move to Football Park nearly fatally wounded football in SA. It is good to finally see the SACA and SANFL back in bed together for the good of the game.

2011-09-07T12:21:02+00:00

Commo

Guest


Unless the SANFL sells the licenses, I would think never.

2011-09-07T06:20:15+00:00

Patrick Angel

Roar Guru


I'll hit up the footy there then methinks. SCG for the Ashes I think, there are more poms to yell "Saffa!" at :) Would love to see the two Adelaide teams but between the members I doubt I'll get tickets.

2011-09-07T06:00:48+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


Ready for the 2014 season, so both Power and Crows at Footy Park for next two years.

2011-09-07T05:58:10+00:00

JamesP

Guest


Sounds just like Waverley...

2011-09-07T05:57:40+00:00

JamesP

Guest


Construction is scheduled to commence after this years cricket season (Adelaide Crows were recently in the press asking for a NAB Cup pre-season game there). SACA expects it to be ready in time for Adelaides match of the 2013/2014 Ashes series. So definitely by 2014 AFL season (i.e. 2 more sesons at AAMI)

2011-09-07T03:05:46+00:00

PaddyBoy

Guest


I thought that was the issue with the Rams, because I was young, I only remember watching some of their performances, and they were very average (SL I think = no cap). Lead me to believe that there were severe backroom quality issues. I ussumed (incorrectly) that they were more akin to the Bears than the Lions. Would Adelaide be almost entirely FC supporters though, and I would have thought that there would be other areas that would be head and shoulders above Adelaide 2 in terms of where to put a team (Geelong, Sydney 2, a number of large regional areas). When will the Adelaide oval be done? Would love to go see some footy there, cricket as well. If it's in a few years they should be hitting premiership windows after the Port bailouts means they can get some more facilities.

2011-09-07T01:46:07+00:00

Redb

Roar Guru


AAMI is too open (little under cover), has poor 1970's facilities, and does not cater for the modern sports fan.

2011-09-07T01:43:18+00:00

Kasey

Guest


I am not a League authority, but I reckon a RL team could probably survive in Adelaide IF the stadium was the previosly mentioned Opposite AO location. League is a very minor sport in Adelaide, and I would reckon you'd struggle to find many born and bred SAlians who could even tell you the difference between the 15 man game and the 13 man game, assuming of course they even knew that Rugby has 2 varieties. I don't see Adelaide being a viable place for a 2nd HAL team. Adelaide United's attendances will likely be about the same as last year, but with no AO games, I cant really see it increasing from where it is by asignificant amount. United were one of the only teams that recorded a mid-week crowd at or above their final crowd average, so less idweek games wont 'help' United's numbers as much as it will the other 9 teams IMO. Ahead of a 2nd ADL team for FFA expansion on the priorities list has got to be W. Syd, Illawarra, Canberra, Tasmania and perhaps even a 2nd NZ team IMO.

2011-09-07T01:36:15+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


Paddy I don't know for certain, but the Rams' attendances weren't really all that bad, considering that League is such a minor sport in Adelaide. Can Adelaide support 2 A-league teams? One day in the future, I reckon it will. AU attendances are very healthy, in fact, second only behind the Victory I believe, and through most of the history of the NSL, Adelaide had two teams, with a bit of success too.

2011-09-07T01:35:05+00:00

NF

Guest


The Rams weren't exactly a joke they did draw well in there first year albiet being there honeymoon period but it did show the potential they had sure it all went to nothing second year, but I recall Lions/Swans drawing terrible crowds yet the AFL stuck by them if NRL only did the same with Perth/Adelaide. The dividends will eventually come as we saw with the Lions/Swans.

2011-09-07T01:30:14+00:00

PaddyBoy

Guest


Could Adelaide support these (I have no idea). The Rams were a joke and Adelaide doesn't have a big RL following I thought. Not sure about the state of rugby in Adelaide. And does Adelaide have the pop to support 2 A-League teams? I haven't been to the Oval in ages, but love the stadium.

2011-09-06T22:05:57+00:00

The_Wookie

Roar Guru


this is why i dont advocate the expansion of Adelaide oval. Leave it as it is, let Port play there, with showdowns and blockbusters at Aami if needed. Leave Adelaide at west Lakes - they dont want to move anyway. Put Port under new management. It is surely cheaper to play out of Adelaide Oval than Aami stadium - and it stops the SANFL double dipping with rent AND dividends.

2011-09-06T11:25:55+00:00

Football Tragic

Roar Rookie


Will there ever be a time when Port Adelaide and/or Adelaide is taken out of the hands of the SANFL and placed under the banner of the AFL?

2011-09-06T10:15:01+00:00

MyLeftFoot

Roar Guru


Looked fabulous. Loved the scoreboard too.

2011-09-06T03:40:42+00:00

Redb

Roar Guru


Big factor is the sympathy vote kicking for Port finally. South Aust footy fans will relish more games especialyl Friday night no matter who is playing.

2011-09-06T03:39:55+00:00

Marsh

Guest


It's good stadium just in a really bad location.

2011-09-06T03:38:33+00:00

Marsh

Guest


Neutral factor is key for Port cause fan base isn't big enough.

2011-09-06T03:38:29+00:00

Redb

Roar Guru


Great crowd but not unexpected. AAMI Stadium is a dump.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar