Memo IRB: show a little respect, to the French that is

By Ben Pobjie / Expert

France advance on the All Blacks’ haka (EPA/Kim Ludbrook)

You know, sports administrators get the rough end of the pineapple sometimes. There’s always a lot of criticism about how they made the wrong decision, pulled the wrong rein, got in bed with the wrong gaming conglomerate, rushed to the defence of the wrong pack rapist, etc.

They cop it from all sides.

So it’s important for us to acknowledge those times when sports administrators get it right, when they act in the best interests of the game and help advance the true spirit of sport through their common-sense decisions.

This is why I burst into spontaneous applause when I found out the International Rugby Board had decided to fine the French rugby team for advancing too far towards the haka before the World Cup final.

Finally, I thought, stuffed shirts earning their wage through decisive and righteous action.

Because if we allow opposition teams to creep up close to the All Blacks while they perform their pre-game ritual, where does it end?

Will opposition teams be allowed to make rude gestures during the New Zealand national anthem? Will sheep be released onto the field while Dan Carter lines up penalty kicks?

Will Richie McCaw suddenly be expected to adhere to the rules of the game? It’s a slippery slope indeed.

International rugby union is a fragile thing.

The slightest disturbance could knock it off its balance and see it descend into the realm of novelty sports, alongside lingerie football and horse racing. It needs to be shielded from nefarious influences, like advancing team lines.

The results could be catastrophic if the All Blacks were in any way inconvenienced while dancing. It would rend the very fabric of the international game.

For New Zealand, with all its proud rugby history, is the heartbeat of the game, and if its hardest, toughest, most powerful exponents are not allowed to do their little dances in peace, the whole edifice could come crashing down.

What if, during the French team’s heinous display of contempt, one of the All Black players had caught a glimpse of them, and lost his place in the shouting?

What if one of them had been so distracted he’d forgotten whether to slap his thigh or perform a gesture indicating he planned to murder his opponent?

he whole tournament would have become pointless. As Cyril Towers used to say: “The most important thing in rugby is not whether you win or lose, but whether your opponents are allowed to do a dance before the game without fear of annoyance”.

Would you walk up and eyeball Paul Mercurio while he was dancing? No you would not. So why would you do it to Keven Mealamu? You might make the poor little mite cry.

But look, I’m a reasonable man.

I understand it can be difficult to find a way to occupy your time while the haka is going on. That’s why the Wallabies usually take the opportunity to eat a hearty meal and get good and drunk before playing.

So I’m not just using my platform here to berate those who would harass good, decent, New Zealand dancers. I’m here to offer constructive suggestions as to better ways to spend the haka period.

Like for example:

* Bible study. To know Jesus is to know yourself – any international rugby squad could only benefit from sitting down in the in-goal and having a good natter about Paul’s letter to the Corinthians and what it says to us in the modern world.

* A singalong. As far as I know, there is no prohibition in IRB rules against on-field guitars, so why not make one member of your team designated accompanist, and boost team morale with a good old singalong? Recommended songs for playing the All Blacks include “Amazing Grace”, “For Those In Peril On The Sea”, and “Loser”.

* Hold your own dance. The Abs are dancing, why not do your own dance? Because you’ll look like a tool? Well, yes, good point.

* Arts and crafts. Don’t let your hands lie idle. Use this precious downtime to paint a picture, make some macaroni art, or construct a diorama out of toilet paper rolls and pipe-cleaners!

* Take a nice relaxing bath. A relaxed team is a happy team – while the kiwis do their thing, why not duck into the dressing rooms, light some candles, and luxuriate in some scented bubbles?

* Leave and go home. There’s probably something good on TV.

You see? This time while your opponents dance and yell doesn’t have to be wasted.

Find constructive ways to spend the lull between anthems and kick-off, and everyone can enjoy the next All Black clash, without the need for unpleasant displays of team solidarity or distressing distractions from the main event.

After all, rugby without the haka is just … well, rugby. And I hardly think that’s what the crowds at rugby games come to see.

The Crowd Says:

2011-10-28T19:43:49+00:00

Damo

Guest


Ah ptah, Aussie humour is back! Well humour in lieu of cup ..( and a decent pre-game dance). Great article Ben. Cannot believe that some folks (from certain great rugby nation) have taken offence. There's just no pleasing some people. And another thing - Aussies are not sore losers. We just happen to be very AID - articulate in disappointment. That's different.

2011-10-27T11:47:49+00:00

p.Tah

Guest


I think I meant Haka'ed... I've obviously been changing too many nappies.

2011-10-27T11:45:52+00:00

p.Tah

Guest


Apparently the French didn't over step the mark. The groundsman painted the half way line 1m too short. Technically they were in their half. The IRB have reversed the French fine and instead fined the groundsman... not because he made an error, but because he was ugly.

2011-10-27T11:43:02+00:00

Guy Smiley

Roar Pro


Jerry for the love of God just once (only once!) prove you have a sense of humour!

2011-10-27T11:40:27+00:00

p.Tah

Guest


Have to admit I'm all Kaka'ed out too. School kids, flash mobs, dancing ginger bread men. It's exhausting. More is less. Stop the over exposure. But I'll probably be ready for it again by time the next Bledisloe is on.

2011-10-27T11:32:12+00:00

p.Tah

Guest


Too funny

2011-10-27T09:37:44+00:00

Cattledog

Roar Guru


Seems we agree on one thing then, WQ, that the IRB rules governing the Haka are pathetic.

2011-10-27T07:45:00+00:00

WQ

Guest


Cattledog any request to "kick the Haka into touch" is not a valid point! Why do you think that all host nations grant permission for the Haka to be performed prior to kick off? Because they know that the overwhelming majority of their paying public not only like it it, but look forward to it. Of course there are a minority, whom all seem to live on the Roar, that don't. For them the IRB have made some pathetic rules that apply to everybody. Moaman put up a post the other day that hits the nail on the head. His thoughts were that all the whingers and detractors of the Haka should get off their a**e and send a petition asking the ARU to tell the All Blacks that they can't perform the Haka before the next Test Match on Australian soil. So stop wasting your time moaning about the Haka on the Roar and do something about it!

2011-10-27T05:22:31+00:00

Cattledog

Roar Guru


You got it in one, Kuruki! Surprising...

2011-10-27T05:10:36+00:00

Kuruki

Roar Guru


So Cattledog.. What exactly are these ridiculous rules governing the Haka that you speak of?. As far as i know there is only one rule, and that is the opposing team must remain on there side of the line. This rule is also in place for the All Blacks. What they choose to do on there own side of the line is up to them, nobody is forcing them to stand and face the Haka, if they wish to run around and warm up or move into position to start the game, then they are allowed to do so. Who has the right to tell New Zealand that they may not perform a Haka before a match?. Does that give New Zealand the right to ban other nations anthems when they tour New Zealand?. Just because one of your own withdrew your rendition of Waltzing Matilda does not mean we all feel the same way about our traditions.

2011-10-27T03:59:16+00:00

Oakie

Guest


Chuckle chuckle Ben.

2011-10-27T03:56:02+00:00

Justin

Guest


Mike - quite simply the NZers could advance on the French during their anthem. Only one has a haka so the point is moot.

2011-10-27T03:30:03+00:00

jameswm

Guest


Yes WQ, Pocock was completely penalised out the the SA game, and wasn't a factor.

2011-10-27T03:26:14+00:00

daws

Guest


I thought it was a great response by France! It says to the Kiwis that "We won't be intimidated by you and we are willing to do anything to win this game" Including breaking the rules. Does this compare with England swapping balls earlier on in the tournament? Absolutely not. Watch the ABs faces when they're doing the haka. They couldn't believe it! When it finished, instead of staring menacingly like usual they turn around and walk off.

2011-10-27T03:23:14+00:00

Cattledog

Roar Guru


Mate, I made a valid point regarding the Haka in reply to another post. I am not an All Black hater at all and was in fact one of the first to congratulate them and admire them for their consistency, on this site. That aside, the same can't be said for some of their supporters, such as yourself, who takes all opportunities to continually beguile and belittle any suggestion that may go against the grain of everything and anything All Black. I don't need to look in any mirror. Perhaps if the raucous minority of Kiwi posters on this site such as yourself learnt some form of analysis before committing their misguided thoughts to script, we wouldn't be forced to read the tripe you keep inflicting us with.

2011-10-27T03:19:31+00:00

Adams

Guest


As long as he doesn't put it on anyones head or body that's fine.

2011-10-27T03:08:33+00:00

Cattledog

Roar Guru


You're absolutely right. Must certainly come before any investigation into the Haka, referees, scrum laws...which are of minor significance when compared...

2011-10-27T03:07:29+00:00

Seiran

Roar Guru


You put your left foot in, you put your left foot out....;-)

AUTHOR

2011-10-27T02:36:31+00:00

Ben Pobjie

Expert


I mainly didn't substitute Pocock for McCaw because Pocock doesn't play for New Zealand as far as I know. Happy to consider evidence to the contrary.

2011-10-27T02:33:45+00:00

mace 22

Guest


How about stair way to heaven as ralph has made it his own. Now about the article had a few chuckles no gut busting laugh,just a few chuckles. Very good.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar