Where have all the good rucks gone?

By McRath / Roar Rookie

Since the days of the spirited Jim Stynes and the loose larrikin that is Spider Everitt, the AFL has been lacking in quality, charismatic ruckmen that have the spirit to match their talent.

Sadly, the former has passed away while the latter spends his days ‘entertaining’ the aged population of the Gold Coast with his day job that is afternoon radio.

With West Coast champion Dean Cox and Freo giant Aaron Sandilands two of the last of their generation remaining, who are tomorrow’s hopes for a taller future?

Despite the club being based around youth and enthusiasm, new boys GWS have recruited neither in their ruck division, with ex-Port reject Jonathan Giles hardly sprightly at 24.

Meanwhile Dean Brogan (another ex-Port player) would be a lot more useful if he was fit enough to get out of bed in the morning.

Speaking of Port Adelaide, they acquired the services of several big names over the off-season, however they may have overrated ruck recruit Brent Renouf’s intended impact.

Renouf’s injury-affected preseason has contributed to the up and down form he’s produced since coming to Port’s aid.

At this early stage, Port may as well have gone for Billy Longer and been done with it.

I mean c’mon, the guy wasn’t even in the best 22 at his old club. But don’t you know that you can’t put a price on experience (if 48 games can be classed as experienced).

Needless to say, Renouf was happy to cross the border to the Southern State. I just hope he knows he’s not likely to win another flag with his new club.

Another to jump ship and join a new team recently is Adelaide’s Sam Jacobs, the secret doppelganger for Mad Magazine’s Alfred E. Neuman.

But while the Crows are flying in 2012, Big Red has been well down in form on last year. After his 2011 breakout season, he’s struggled lately.

He’s finding less ball than Nick Maxwell during matches. Hell, if it weren’t for his 30-odd hitouts a game, he’d be seen about as much as a Gold Coast goal umpire.

Back to Melbourne, and after the retirement of their triple-premiership-winning big man, Geelong have struggled to fill the massive hole in the shape of Ottens’ head.

They’ve placed their future in the hands of Nathan Vardy, a kid who’s whiter than Hughesy and played about as many senior games in 2012 as Brendan Fevola.

The Cats have also picked up a guy who’s nearly old enough to be Jaeger O’Meara’s dad in Orren “don’t ask me why my parents called me that, maybe because I was born in the fifties” Stephenson.

At least things are simpler than at Carlton, where they’ve got a former number-one draft pick and a coach who can’t work out whether he’s a ruck or a forward.

That’s not to mention a rejuvenated Shaun Hampson – aka Mr. Megan Gale – who gets less screen time than his girlfriend (seriously, Channel Seven – sort it out).

Add to the mix an emerging young talent who’s garnered more interest than a beer garden on Boxing Day and the Blues selection panel has a job that’d give that of Mark Neeld a run for its money.

Over to the West and the Eagles are putting in place their succession plan for the Big Cox with Nic Natinui.

It’s only a matter of time before he jumps Cox both in his team’s pecking order and in literal sense; seriously the kids thinks he’s Michael Jordan going for a dunk every time he goes for a mark.

This list wouldn’t be complete without a mention of the massive 211 – Sandilands himself, who’s taller than Hayden Ballantyne and Matthew Pavlich put together.

For all his height, though, Sandilands couldn’t win a beauty contest if he were up against the likes of Shrek and Susan Boyle.

Come to think about it, he bares a striking resemblance to the enormous Mr. Larson from Happy Gilmore.

The AFL’s best chance for the future lies in Richmond’s golden-mullet-wielding, ass-kicking Ivan Maric.

He’s got the aggression, fighting spirit, a fast-growing cult following and most importantly – a bright future.

He’s taken his game to a new level in 2012 since joining the Tigers and the yellow and black faithful (as well as the wider AFL community) can rest easy knowing that when the likes of Coxy and Sandi retire, the spirit of the big man will live on.

The Crowd Says:

2012-06-10T04:05:52+00:00

lazar vidovic

Guest


yes guys we hope maric ivan can reserect the endangerd species (ruckman)demitriou wants to stop the centre bounce clash with a basketball tip off, in the NAB cup next year ........that will be the end off us as we know it ........yes the arthritus is killin me now but the big run up from the edge off the sqaure was a specticle to watch as us warhorses clashed like big gladiators ...GO IVAN

2012-06-01T12:47:12+00:00

BigAl

Guest


Not sure what the point of this article is. . .but I get the feeling that the influence of the big tap ruckman is rapidly declining ! I mean,how many times do you see at a centre bounce Sandilands getting a perfect palm out to a team mate - with commentators swooning ? Not many ! - far better value at centre bounces etc. are a fleet of pacy quick witted scavengers.

2012-06-01T06:46:36+00:00

Johnno

Guest


I don't know a lot about AFL but Paul Salmon was a full forwad not a ruckman.

2012-06-01T06:45:32+00:00

MyLeftFoot

Roar Guru


best of all time Richmonds number 1 draft pick back in '88, Richard Lounder.

2012-06-01T06:38:29+00:00

Ian Whitchurch

Guest


Cameron, Nahhh. Brogan got decisively out-played by Giles, and Sauce and Folau havent been terrible either when pinch-hitting.

2012-06-01T01:41:42+00:00

Brewski

Roar Rookie


Graham Wright certainly doesn't love Ironmonger !, AFAIK Ironmonger played footy for many years in the USA after moving to California. Have not heard his name in years. Marich is the man ATM, gotta love a mullet.

2012-06-01T01:23:43+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


How could you not love John Ironmonger? Not only the greatest name in the history of football, playing for the greatest club, but the best ruckman who didn't jump. Just pretty much stood there and waited for the ball to come to him. So many great ruckmen in the 80s and 90s. Barry Round, Alex Ischenko, Matt Rendell, Paul Salmon, Lazar Vidovic. Just great big slabs of humanity who lumbered around while their teammates buzzed around them like TV satellites orbiting the earth.

2012-06-01T00:51:47+00:00

Nathan of Perth

Guest


Not a bad article, all up.

2012-06-01T00:30:56+00:00

Cameron

Guest


"Meanwhile Dean Brogan (another ex-Port player) would be a lot more useful if he was fit enough to get out of bed in the morning." One of the more unfair comments I've seen while visiting the roar. Brogan is currently injured with a cracked wrist while before that his experience really shone through for GWS as a go to man.

2012-05-31T23:57:15+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Don Scott versus Crackers Keenan. I just wanted to say that. Mumford is pretty handy.

2012-05-31T23:45:11+00:00

DanMan

Guest


Dean Ccx's goal early in the 2005 GF was pretty special - running backwards with the flight, taking it over his head, running with a bounce and then slotting it form outside 50 on 45 degree angle. Wasn't old enough to appreciate Madden's goal a he time so I can't compare.

2012-05-31T23:45:10+00:00

Aware

Guest


You've never watched the game if you think Jim Stynes was a true ruckman. Jim was never a ruckman in the classical sense. Like Peter Moore, he was a run-on tall man but beither man had much idea about centre bounce tap-outs. That set the scene for more mobile tall men to take on the game. Jacobs, Cox and Sandilands are more like old-time ruckmen.

2012-05-31T23:16:18+00:00

CraigB

Roar Guru


If you think S Jacobs is having a poor season then you instantly lose all credibility. Easily the most influential player on the Crows list and impossible for them to replace if injured. Speaking of the Crows have you seen J Jenkins, 2 bounces (1 left handed 1 right handed) then goals from 50.

2012-05-31T22:59:46+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


I'm not totally sure what point the article is trying to make about personalities, but it seems like personalities have gone out of AFL in general. 18 year old draftees are now getting extensive media training. Although Fasolo still gives good interview. McEvoy, Leuenberger, Mumford and West throw their weight around a bit.

2012-05-31T20:19:50+00:00

The_Wookie

Roar Guru


Justim Madden streaking through the centre square and kicking a glorious goal from outisde 50 v Adelaide in the 93 Semi Final is one of my favourite football moments of all time.

2012-05-31T18:05:57+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Big Shaun Rehn Adelaiade Crows. Sam Newman gellong and nines footy show. Slamming Sammy Nemwan boys. And Ironmunger great and mighty Fitzroy.

Read more at The Roar