The top 5 best sporting rivalries since 1970

By johnnoo / Roar Pro

Rivalries. Professional sports lives off it, markets itself off of it. Rivalries play a major role in capturing a wider audience’s attention to the specific sport and there are many in professional sports that could indeed go on forever.

I have selected my top five best rivalries since 1970.

No 1. Muhammad Ali vs Joe Frazier

Ali and Frazier’s first fight was dubbed the “Fight of the Century”. As most fights back then it was scheduled for 15-rounds — eat your heart out Sonny Bill Williams, you only did 10 versus Francois Botha!

Joe Frazier won on points after 15 gruelling rounds. Before the match there was a lot of build up and tension and indeed the fight lived up to it. Brutal and compelling, all 15 rounds.

The next two fights were highly controversial too. Ali won the second fight on points, but debate rages on whether it was the right decision. And in “The thriller in Manila” the fight was called off in the 14th round, despite Joe Frazier’s protest, wanting the fight to continue.

Ali said after the fight it was the “Closest thing to dying that I know of.”

Gives you an idea how brutal and competitive their rivalry was.

No 2. Magic Johnson vs Larry Bird

These two also featured plenty of tension between each other as they were bitter rivals on and off the court. Whilst later they became friends in the early 80’s they were mortal enemies, both with a determination to win.

There were many great matches, stretching from the NCAA final in 1979, all the way to the last times they met in the NBA finals in 1987. It was both compelling and moving to see them became close friends during their career. That lives on today.

No 3. Alain Prost vs Ayrton Senna

What can one say about these two men, who went hard in F1 cars, always taking it to the edge? Their rivalry was dangerous, but also highly skilful.

A great rivalry that was as tense as it came, both men fuelled by controversy and with a fierce will to win.

Prost won four world titles, Senna won three. But Senna got his titles in seven years while Prost took nine.

No 4: Monica Seles vs Steffi Graf

There was something very compelling about these two ladies. Both attracted attention wherever they went, were highly talented, had a fierce will to win and both were in their prime of their careers when they locked horns. Seles was the first win a Grand Slam final when she was as 16 years old at the French Open, beating Graf 7-6, 6-4.

They then went on to have three more Grand Slam final duels over the next three years (1990-93). Perhaps most notably Graf beat Seles at Wimbledon in 1992 in a rain-affected match. A slam Seles craved. Seles never won Wimbledon, and sadly was never the same player after being stabbed in April 30th 1993.

But their rivalry in sports was as good as it gets.

No 5. New Zealand All Blacks vs France

The French don’t fear the All Blacks, a rare thing in rugby.

Four World cup matches past the group stage, head to head resulted in a 2-2 record.

All four matches were controversial, but compelling. None more so than the All Blacks’ one point win over the French at the Rugby World Cup in 2011 in New Zealand.

So there is my top 5 roarers. Tough choices all. Do you agree, disagree? I’d love to know. Over to you!

The Crowd Says:

2013-02-27T02:55:53+00:00

Wal

Roar Guru


Since some have gone local, Canterbury v Auckland - NPC or Ranfurly Shield. Some quotes from the NZ herald of 2 of the epics I can remember 1985: Canterbury 23 Auckland 28 One of the classic shield matches. Canterbury stood to equal Auckland's record run of 25 defences, which had endured since 1963. Auckland jumped out to a 24-0 lead at halftime before the home side came storming back to get within a whisker of saving the shield. The crowd (52,000) remains the largest in Ranfurly Shield history. This win started Auckland's record-breaking 61-match run. 1990: Auckland 33 Canterbury 30 The infamous no-scrums game. After John Buchan had been sent off in the first five minutes, Canterbury sent on Phil Cropper, a former hooker who had played on the side of the scrum for the previous two or three years. It was decided that free kicks would replace scrums. Canterbury scored two tries to one, but Fox (29 points) kept Auckland in front. The 1998 Super Rugby Final where James Kerr, a discarded Aucklander scored for the Crusaders in the final minutes. and the 2003 Final where the Blues were out scored 2 tries to 3 and in a thrilling final 10 minutes. Daniel Carter, Leon MacDonald and Chris Jack were either stopped on the line or were just centimetres short before winger Caleb Ralph finally found a way through in the 76th minute to reduce the lead to 21-17. http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=10349226

2013-02-25T11:40:33+00:00

Evan Askew

Guest


If anyone in the England cricket team couldmatch Lillee it was probably Tony Greig. Amiss had a very good test record but Lillee and Thommo made him their bitch. There was rivalry between Fletcher and Lillee too but again a vast dfference in their actual abilities.

2013-02-25T03:57:54+00:00

marayong tiger

Guest


Balmain V Souths since 1912 I think when souths turned up on GF day and kicked off claiming a GF win. Stands today in there GF tally. Prior to the game both clubs agreed to protest to the league by not attending the game as it being rated below the possible/probable kangaroo rep game.

2013-02-25T03:05:51+00:00

dadiggle

Guest


It is basketball for woman. Mostly being watched for woman with short skirts who likes to show their underwear more than foot faults. Kiwi's have found a new way to take a peek by lifting each other up.

2013-02-25T01:10:48+00:00

NicolasPA

Guest


Netball? What is Netball?

2013-02-24T23:24:10+00:00

langou

Roar Guru


Steve Weibe vs Billy Mitchell http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dYuJYX6orM

2013-02-24T22:55:26+00:00

Brian

Guest


A recall reading a newspaper article on this once: Included was India v Pak Cricket Yankees v Red Sox El Classico Brazil v Argentina

AUTHOR

2013-02-23T05:26:06+00:00

johnnoo

Roar Pro


nickoldschool Thanks mate for your thoughts, , When factoring , in my top 5 , I took in an important component, appealing to a wider audience beyond local borders,. All 5 on my list did. Some great local derbies there, but reality is even today many sports fans wouldn't even know about local derbies like Boca VS River Plate, or say a Benfica VS Porto. Prost VS Senna was a special rivalry, completely dangerous at times, and so compelling watching 2 F1 drivers of such high class, go head to head, in such fast cars, it's as good as it gets. I agree I liked F1 in the 80's and 90's, the drivers really thrived on the rivalries big time and it was very personal good and bad moments,as all good rivalries are, or become. And F1 is still dangerous today, but back in the 80's it was more dangerous for multiple reasons, it heightens the rivalry even more. And the AB'S VS France , I stand by to, the last 25 years for me the best clashes or some of the best clashes have involved AB'S VS France. I researched various websites, to find out All Blacks and French feelings about playing each other, and the feeling i share about the rivalry is mutual. The AB'S describe the French as a classic rivalry and love playing them. Grahame Henry said the boys love playing the French, and always get fired up playing them, and Dan Carter was the same. So many reasons why AB'S VS France is a special rivalry, on so many levels, you being French would understand the rivalry. But for the big 1 is the, ability, as Grahame Henry said , the French have the ability to make the AB'S bring out the best and worst in them, and that's what makes it compelling, it unnerves the AB'S playing the French which is a rare thing , for the AB'S the most successful sports side ever in any national team. And the French play with unpredictably, amazing and awful ,and flair ,and passion and love of rugby, all rolled into one. And like South Africa, both gave proud domestic competitions with rich histories. But the French are a thorn in the AB'S side , and will continue to do so. Jonah Lomu made his test debut vs the French in the 2-0 series loss in 1994 in NZ, and said he still rates Émile N'Tamack, the best winger he played against. Some good ones, you added thanks nickoldschool.

2013-02-23T03:19:03+00:00

nickoldschool

Roar Guru


Like your list Johnnoo and the fact you looked at international rivalries rather than local ones or derbies: nsw v qld, real v Barca, boca v river plate, there are just too many in every country. So good on you for resisting the pressure to stay within our borders. Funnily enough, the Prost v Senna one was probably the most 'deadly' of the ones you mention in your list. Even if they are the only two sportsmen who were unable to be physically in contact with the other one, they could with one move kill the other pilot. Best Formula one years of my life with these two.

2013-02-22T23:10:32+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Of course, the great Jocky Wilson story is the time Dexy's Midnight Runners appeard on Top of the Pops singing their hit "Jackie Wilson Said" which was referring to the great Motown singer. Unfortunately, one of the producers on TotP got a bit mixed up and....well, you can see who they put a picture of on the big screen behind the band. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpPF7RzbYb4

2013-02-22T22:33:02+00:00

Mango Jack

Guest


Ha ha ha. Certainly, in terms of playing ability, there was no contest. I reckon Lillee was probably a better batsman than poor old Mike. But in terms of a contest of wills, and all the colonial symbolism it represented, it was a great contest.

2013-02-22T10:59:02+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Lillee v Brearley - that wasn't a rivalry. A rivalry is supposed to denote some kind of evenness in the contest.

2013-02-22T05:36:36+00:00

RAF

Guest


My brother and me had a pretty serious rivalry in the backyard cricket and rugby league test matches between 1971-1977. Fiercely fought, blood spilled, cheating was in abundance and the victor had first dibs in the shower.

2013-02-22T04:56:07+00:00

Mango Jack

Guest


Dennis Lillee vs Mike Brierley. The uncouth colonial against the pompous aristocrat, it was great theatre.

2013-02-22T04:52:56+00:00

Mango Jack

Guest


Phil Gould vs reality?

2013-02-22T03:39:00+00:00

matt h

Guest


Last 30 years?

AUTHOR

2013-02-22T03:17:04+00:00

johnnoo

Roar Pro


Allanthus some great ones. AFL is not global enough, so doesn't have wider audience, a bit like GAA sports in Irleand , but some great rivalries there. Collingwood VS everyone else is a good start. Crows VS Power is biitter, tracing back to formation of SANFL as Power under Port Adelaide group came in later. Damien Martyn VS Hayden didn't know that one. Good one. Cricket is littered with rivalries. ASHES, India-Pakistan, Aust VS West Indies in there prime. Viv Richards VS Lillee, Richard Hadllee VS NZ, Imran Khan VS India, Kapil Dev VS India . Tendulkar VS Pakistan -For mine the 2 best civil war rivalries were Mark VS Steve Waugh. While both were moving up the ranks competing for aussy spots, fancy getting dropped in the test team in 1990 , by none else than your twin brother, take that Steve. Hayden VS Slater was also a compelling rivalry, which Slats one hands down in all fairness in the 90's. -Flintoff VS Ponting had brief moments. Some great ones Allanthus. -Broncos VS Canberra in the 90's 91-94 had some great memories and tension, 2 amazing rosters test standard sides, had some great battles. Would loved them to of been a grand final, never happened but had some good finals battles. Bulldogs VS Eeels is as bitter as they come in NRL, as is Eeels VS Storm,Manly VS Storm.

AUTHOR

2013-02-22T03:09:08+00:00

johnnoo

Roar Pro


Lancey5times, I thought about and did some research but there were some actual better ones in golf, Arnold Palmer was biit older than Nicklaus,. Where as Jack Nicklaus and Lee Trevino , Trevino was only 1 moth older, they had a better rivalry , one of all time best. My best golf 3 Jack Nicklaus - Lee Trevino Four times, Nicklaus finished second in major championships to Trevino, who was pushed to the greatest performances of his career by his burning desire to beat the Golden Bear. Jack Nicklaus - Tom Watson Like Trevino, Watson thwarted Nicklaus in four different majors, including the famed "Duel in the Sun" at the 1977 British Open, the greatest head-to-head battle in golf history. Think about that for a second. If not for Trevino and Watson, Nicklaus would have 26 major titles. Nick Faldo - Greg Norman This rivalry bridged the gap between the Nicklaus and Woods eras in golf. Faldo frequently got the better of Norman, drubbing him in a head-to-head pairing at the 1990 British Open at St. Andrews and taking advantage of Norman's epic collapse at the 1996 Masters. Nicklaus-Trevino for min was the best as both players were the same age basically, Watson was 9 years younger than Nicklaus, but they went for it too. Faldo-Norman were great. BUt Nicklaus-Trevino great, but still my top 5 is my top 5. Still stubbornly holding on to it for now lol. But great 1 you said, Lancey5times.

2013-02-22T02:38:55+00:00

Allanthus

Guest


Johnno Probably shouldn't ignore AFL, Collingwood v everyone else is a good place to start. Crows v Power has a lot of feeling to it as well. Actually that throws up an interesting concept, rivalry within the same team, ie Andrew McLeod v Tyson Edwards. Which I guess throws up Wayne Carey v Anthony Stevens... Richie Blackmore v Tawera Nikau... just shows what happens when women get involved in sport :) Damien Martyn v Matthew Hayden. Don Bradman v Bill O'Reilly. Ian Botham v Ian Chappell. Some deep seated rivalries there. What about Nancy Kerrigan and Tonya Harding? Now that was one serious rivalry, on and off the pitch.

2013-02-22T02:22:12+00:00

clipper

Guest


The England Germany rivalry in Football is very lopsided via English eyes - the Germans would consider Holland or Italy greater rivals, but the English press have a field day whenever it occurs.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar