Who will make the 2013 All Australian team?

By Samuel Gates / Roar Pro

The All Australian side is something that is always hotly debated and never quite the perfect showcase of the league’s true talent.

The standard of young players this season has been incredible, with the likes of Jaeger O’Meara, Chad Wingard, Tom Liberatore, Dustin Martin, Jamie Elliot, and Jeremy Cameron being among the best in their teams, as well as matching it with the league’s top players.

Choosing clear winners between the young talent coming through and the established stars for selection isn’t that simple.

Perhaps the only player guaranteed selection this season will be Gary Ablett Jr. The Gold Coast captain is favourite to win another Brownlow medal and is dominating the new Vero Player Rating system.

The Magpies’ powerhouse duo of Pendlebury and Dane Swan are likely to be in the mix again, while Fremantle probably deserve to have at least one defender make the cut.

Many AFL fans can marvel at how well Ross Lyon has masterminded the Dockers defensive strategy. I hope he’s the All Australian coach.

This year’s selections could also throw up some surprises from teams outside the eight. Don’t be surprised if North Melbourne and the Western Bulldogs get a few on the field. GWS are also hoping for a consolation prize after a tough season with a pick in the forward line.

The 2013 AFL season has once again shown that the modern game belongs to the midfielders. Sydney proved last season that you can win a flag without having a key focal point up front.

This year’s top eight has been marked by sides with balanced midfields; players who are capable of winning hard, contested ball and dishing it out to fast outside runners.

Richmond’s first taste to finals footy in over a decade is testament to their midfield dominance. Trent Cotchin has averaged over 27 disposals a game while Dustin Martin is second in the league for handball receives from a set position with 61.

The young Richmond runners probably still need time to develop to the standard of Sydney’s engine room though, with Daniel Hannebery and Kieran Jack in career best form this season. This due are capably supported by Josh Kennedy, Jarrad McVeigh, Adam Goodes, Ryan O’Keefe and a plethora promising young players.

Fremantle’s midfield is also hitting their prime. Nathan Fyfe is playing better then ever and Michael Barlow is a true star of the game.

A common trend in All Australian selections over the past decade is to include a midfielder on the forward flank. The breadth of talent among modern midfielders cannot simply fit into six on-field positions.

Expect Adelaide’s Patrick Dangerfield to feature in the forward line as a result of the goal-kicking ability he has displayed this season.

In selecting defenders, it is interesting to note that Fremantle and Sydney have conceding less points than any other team by a considerable margin.

For the other sides, Geelong’s Corey Enright and Harry Taylor are definitely two of the best defenders in the league. Carlton’s Andrew Walker could be an exciting selection on the back flank, while North Melbourne’s Scott Thompson has been a big improver.

There are probably about four or five Fremantle players that could feature in this year’s backline.

In the forwards, three tall men is a likely option. Jeremy Cameron and Josh Kennedy should be locked in.

Hawthorn’s Jarryd Roughead has arguably had his best season to date, and I would like to see him start at centre half forward and be used as a second ruck option.

The league has also given the spotlight to many of the great small forward this year too.

No one has improved more than North Melbourne’s Lindsay Thomas, and Chad Wingard, Steven Motlop, Jeff Garlett and Jamie Elliot are also in the mix. Dustin Martin probably won’t break into the midfield this year but might be a chance on the flank with his goal scoring abilities.

Here’s my team starting from the fullbacks. Feel free to give feedback below:

FB: Corey Enright (Geelong) Luke McPharlin (Fremantle) Scott Thompson (North Melbourne)

HB: Andrew Walker (Carlton) Harry Taylor (Geelong) Nick Malceski (Sydney)

M: Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn) (vc) Scott Pendlebury (Collingwood) Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs)

HF: Patrick Dangerfield (Adelaide) Jarryd Roughead (Hawthorn) Chad Wingard (Port Adelaide)

FF: Lindsay Thomas (North Melbourne) Jeremy Cameron (Greater Western Sydney) Josh Kennedy (West Coast)

Foll: Will Minson (Western Bulldogs) Kieran Jack (Sydney) Gary Ablett Jr (Gold Coast) (c)

Int: Dane Swan (Collingwood) Joel Selwood (Geelong) Daniel Hannebery (Sydney) Brendon Goddard (Essendon)

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2013-08-26T11:52:04+00:00

Samuel Gates

Roar Pro


The race for selection is so tight. I can already see a few things that might change after this round. Kennedy and Cameron were kept goalless on the weekend. Cameron only had 2 disposals. Cloke could move into full forward and Michael Walters or Steven Motlop could play as a small forward in the pocket. That would take out the 3 talls option that was unpopular. Harry Taylor was all over Tippett on the weekend too.

2013-08-22T04:33:37+00:00

Nash Mitchell

Roar Rookie


Great team although Boak, Goldstein or Cloke deserve a spot ontop of Goddard!

2013-08-21T10:58:25+00:00

Jsteel

Roar Pro


The amount of midfielders the AA selectors put on the bench/out of position always frustrates me. Should be no more than 2 in my opinion. That said, one of Selwood/Hannebery has to go. I'd give the edge to Selwood given I'd probably start him on the ground and make him skipper. Given that you already have Goddard to play defense on the interchange, I'd give that extra bench spot too one of Stevie J, Stokes or Mayne. As already said Mcpharlin won't get in, move Thompson to FB and play one of Glass/Gibson/Talia there. 50/50 on the debate between Cloke and Kennedy as well, will probably purely come down to the one that ends up with the most goals.

AUTHOR

2013-08-21T10:57:52+00:00

Samuel Gates

Roar Pro


Travis Cloke had a great first half of the season, especially the 7 goals he kicked against Richmond. He's also 2nd in the league for marks behind Nick Riewoldt, and only two goals behind the Coleman leaders. He's kicking for goal at only 56% though. Josh Kennedy on the other hand is at 75%. He's close to selection but his kicking has let him down again.

2013-08-21T10:49:44+00:00

Jsteel

Roar Pro


Mcpharlin a walk up start in round 11, but correct missed too much footy should not and will not get in

AUTHOR

2013-08-21T10:49:32+00:00

Samuel Gates

Roar Pro


I actually have Jeremy Cameron at full forward. Josh Kennedy is in the pocket. His defensive pressure is actually quite good. He has 66 tackles for the season so far which places him 5th best at the Eagles.

2013-08-21T07:48:35+00:00

fadida

Guest


He was probably doped to his eyeballs. I don't know that Essendon will have too many reps :)

2013-08-21T07:47:32+00:00

fadida

Guest


:D

2013-08-21T07:37:45+00:00

langou

Roar Guru


The 5th placed South American team

2013-08-21T05:45:00+00:00

Hawker

Guest


he was great at CHB until they started moving him forward. been leaking goals last 6 weeks

2013-08-21T03:44:41+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


The English cricket team at the Oval.

2013-08-21T03:17:31+00:00

Connor

Guest


The winner of the Grand Final

2013-08-21T03:17:17+00:00

Connor

Guest


The only full forwards or CHF's that should be in the team are those leading the Coleman. Travis Cloke wont be in the 44 and shouldnt be purely based on that shot he had against Sydney. As well as other things

2013-08-21T02:29:41+00:00

fadida

Guest


Who are we playing? ;)

2013-08-21T01:53:28+00:00

Seano

Guest


Carlisle from the bombers has been great in the back half this year and can swing forward, been better than all the back 6 plus the bench this year. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2013-08-21T01:41:36+00:00

Rich_daddy

Roar Guru


Nic Riewolt and Jarrad McVeigh I reckon should get a gig.

2013-08-21T01:30:13+00:00

Andrew

Guest


Travis Cloke is the best power forward in the AFL. He is a must.

2013-08-21T01:21:25+00:00

Jermayn

Guest


Yeh McPharlin has zero chance to get in this year.... Thompson, Mackenzie and Glass all have had better years than him.

2013-08-21T01:20:02+00:00

Steve J

Roar Guru


My main gripe is three power forwards, and if you put Cameron in a pocket then it has to be more than just goal kicking, he has to have that defensive pressure that is a must for forwards nowadays. Which is why I'd go for Mayne or even Ballantyne in that position over Cameron. (note - it is all about the position for me)

2013-08-21T01:13:17+00:00

langou

Roar Guru


McPaharlan is no chance but the following Freo players will; probably in the squad at least Mayne, Johnson, Mundy, Fyfe, and Barlow

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar