NAB Challenge needs to take an all-regional approach

By SportsFanGC / Roar Guru

The AFL launched a restructured pre-season format for 2014 on the back of the fans, players and clubs unanimously rejecting the previous NAB Cup format.

The earlier incarnation was an unnecessarily long and drawn out competition and some teams (I’m looking at you Swans) paid scant regard to it.

Some clubs preferred to lose the opening round and thus exiting the tournament to continue their preparations.

When consulting with the AFL during the 2013 season, the clubs advised that they saw two-three practice matches in the pre-season as an ideal number to prepare for the season proper.

The NAB Challenge is what we football fans now have in February. It is a nice taste test for the season ahead and gives everyone a chance to see how their team has progressed over the arduous summer months of pre-season training.

You may even see your previous favourite player now donning the colours of a hated rival.

The one thing that has stood out to me above all else so far is the great crowds that we have seen at the ‘regional’ venues which don’t see AFL Premiership season action during the year.

There have been fantastic attendances at Richmond Oval (Adelaide), Joondalup Arena (Perth), Eureka Stadium (Ballarat), Norm Minns Oval (Wangaratta) and Tony Ireland Stadium (Townsville). The locals have made the most of the opportunity to see their teams and heroes in the flesh, gracing the turf of their local club and putting on a good show at the same time.

We still have Blacktown International Sports Park (Sydney), TIO Traeger Park (Alice Springs) and Wagga Wagga to come as the week wraps up.

This is where I think the AFL and the clubs can and should go one step further and play all NAB Challenge matches at regional venues.

This year there are five matches played at Etihad Stadium, two in Geelong and one each in Canberra, the Gold Coast and Launceston.

These are all venues that will host multiple games for AFL Premiership points this year. They, and particularly Etihad Stadium, don’t need the NAB Challenge games there as well.

I have come up with 10 alternate venues for 2015 which will cover the dual aims of taking the game to their heartland areas and also taking the game to areas where the game is still growing.

Below is my list. These venues will be used in addition to the regional venues used this year that are mentioned above:

Shepparton, Victoria (Population 59,972)
Shepparton in central Victoria is only a two-hour drive from Melbourne.

The AFL could use Deakin Reserve which has a capacity of 15,000 and is currently the home ground of both the Shepparton United Football Club (the Demons) and the Shepparton Football Club (the Bears), who play in the Goulburn Valley Football League.

Bendigo, Victoria(Population 105,560)
Bendigo is also essentially just up the highway from Melbourne, taking around 90 minutes to drive there.

Bendigo currently has the Bendigo Gold playing in the VFL and their 18,000-capacity home ground at Queen Elizabeth Oval would no doubt be filled. It is a region rich in Australian Football history and puts another game in the gold fields of Victoria.

Albury/Wodonga, New South Wales/Victoria (Population 106,052)
The border towns are a three-hour drive straight up the Hume Highway from Melbourne and have a great love of Australian rules football.

The AFL would use Lavington Sports Ground in Albury (15,000 capacity), current home of the Lavington Panthers Football Club and host of the grand final for the Ovens and Murray Football League.

Previously the AFL had stated that the lighting was an issue at the ground, but after a $500,000 upgrade in 2010 this is no longer a problem.

Sunshine Coast, Queensland (Population 264,896)
Taking a game to the Sunshine Coast – a 90-minute drive up the Bruce Highway from Brisbane – will be a very easy sell, particularly when you play the game in Noosa.

Using the Noosa Sports Ground, home of the Noosa Tigers from the AFL Queensland State League, should see a bumper crowd fill the venue.

The GWS Giants spent a week in Noosa on a training camp at the end of 2013 and utilised the Noosa Tigers facilities with rave reviews.

Mount Gambier, South Australia (Population 25,881)
Mount Gambier provides four teams to the Western Border Football League and is approximately four-and-a-half hours from Adelaide and a five-hour drive from Melbourne.

The home of North Gambier Football Club, Vansittart Park would be the venue and recently has been approved for funding to improve and update facilities.

In July 2012 the South Australian Government approved $200,000 funding for the precinct and Barry Stafford from the North Gambier Football Club confirmed at the time that it was part of a $3.5 million upgrade.

Warrnambool, Victoria (Population 33,922)
Warrnambool is a three-hour drive from Melbourne and a proud football area. Their best ground, Reid Oval, is set for a $600,000 upgrade in a bid to bring AFL practice matches to the town.

The upgrade will include an electronic scoreboard, a multi-purpose pavilion and updated electricity, gas and water connections. A further stage of upgrading includes the playing surface and lighting.

Reid Oval is home to both Warrnambool Football Netball Club and East Warrnambool Football Netball Club in the Hampden Football Netball League and could be set for NAB Challenge games early next year.

Echuca/Moama, Victoria, New South Wales (Population 19,087)
The border towns are approximately three hours from Melbourne and both towns have teams competing in the Murray Football League – the Echuca United Eagles and the Moama Magpies.

The area is a long time favourite for Melburnians to holiday, camp, fish and use the Murray River for water sports, so a NAB Challenge game would be a great addition to the summer calendar.

I would recommend the game be played in Moama at their home ground at Jack Eddy Oval. For anyone who has had the privilege to play on that ground, it is a great surface.

Geraldton, Western Australia (Population 39,311)
Situated nearly five hours’ drive north of Perth, Gerdalton is home to the Great Northern Football League, which currently has seven teams competing in it.

A strong Australian football town would love to see the stars of the WA clubs playing in their town. The AFL could use Wonthella Park Oval, home to Towns Football Club and former club of young Gold Coast star Jack Martin.

Newcastle, New South Wales (Population 418,958)
I understand the city is firmly in league and football territory, however that is no reason that the AFL shouldn’t try and schedule a regular NAB Challenge game there.

They could use Pat Jordan Oval, the home of Newcastle City Football Club who play in the Black Diamond Australian Football League. It is a big population centre, only just smaller than the Gold Coast, and should have an AFL presence at least once a year.

And one from left field…

Finley, New South Wales (Population 2,509)
My old home town and a quirky choice I will grant you, but the area has a number of towns who would flock to this game at the Finley Recreation Reserve, including Tocumwal, Deniliquin, Berrigan, Cobram/Barooga and Jerilderie.

Finley and the surrounding towns have supplied numerous players to the VFL/AFL in the past, the most famous being Jack Hawkins, Billy Brownless and currently Tom Hawkins the Geelong superstar.

The playing surface is fantastic and the dimensions are the same as the MCG and the town loves its football. The fixture can be a night game as the ground has fantastic lighting and regularly hosts an Easter fixture under lights – usually the Finley Cats against the Deniliquin Rams.

The AFL does a fantastic job of spreading the game around throughout the year. In addition to the five mainland capitals and Geelong and the Gold Coast, this year will see games played in Darwin, Alice Springs, Launceston, Hobart, Canberra, Cairns and Wellington.

Our major population centres are well serviced for AFL action during the year, so why not extend the goodwill and the obvious economic benefits that flow on from hosting AFL teams to the regional areas every year during the NAB Challenge?

The Crowd Says:

2014-03-07T11:42:11+00:00

Tom

Guest


We did get an upgrade here I'm Albury but unfortunately it doesn't meet Foxtels standards, thus we cannot have night matches.

2014-03-01T07:27:25+00:00

Floyd Calhoun

Guest


True enough about Newc. It's Rugby League through & through, but the stalwarts of the Black Diamond League deserve some recognition for their efforts over many years. No. 1 Sports Ground is a worthy venue. It may not create a revolution, but it can't hurt either.

2014-02-28T12:21:49+00:00

alicesprings

Guest


Great to see all the players signing autographs late into the night. Rockstar reception! The players were blown away by the reception they received..even the support staff were taking picture of the crowd!

2014-02-28T12:17:37+00:00

alicesprings

Guest


Awesome game tonight!..no idea what the crowd was but id say around 6k. Well done Alice!

2014-02-28T01:28:49+00:00

Givemefooty

Guest


Great to see you include Newcastle NSW - couldn't agree more. The healthy, loyal and ever growing AFL fraternity in the region is starved of AFL due to Sydney (two hours drive south) being the focus of the AFL. No 1 Sportsground is the premier AFL venue there (the Newcastle City Blues actual home ground) and has had good crowds when games played there in the past.

2014-02-26T12:53:52+00:00

Jack Russell

Roar Guru


Club sides vs AFL sides would be a slaughter. Composite sides though might be competitive.

2014-02-26T12:34:14+00:00

Gyfox

Guest


Well what can we expect from a site that is dominated by soccer, rugby league & Sydney!

2014-02-26T11:22:55+00:00

Adam Julian

Roar Guru


I would like to see a Nines like experiment in the pre-season and all games played in the country. Why have games in these huge stadiums which are empty. For an AFL Nines equivalent something like this could work 20 teams, the 18 AFL clubs and two best of the rest combos made up of the best talent not with an AFL club 12 aside, 20 minute games. Retain Super goal for kicks outside 50 Promote as a party type event like Rugby Sevens and award prize money and a nice trophy and your away

AUTHOR

2014-02-26T05:33:36+00:00

SportsFanGC

Roar Guru


John - Alice Springs and Wagga are already hosting NAB Challenge games and I left them in the calendar in addition to he venues I selected above. Alice is hosting Melbourne and Geelong Friday night and Wagga is hosting GWS and St Kilda on Saturday afternoon.

2014-02-26T03:51:42+00:00

Dave

Guest


What about Gippsland? It's been around five years since the region hosted a pre-season AFL match. Latrobe City (Morwell, Traralgon, Moe) has 72,000+ people. In recent years, the grounds in Morwell and Moe have received major upgrades with AFL matches in mind (if the smoke ever clears, of course). Further east, Sale and Bairnsdale also have suitable facilities.

2014-02-26T03:02:42+00:00

Australian Rules

Guest


There'd be a bit of feeling in some of those games..! The top 4 SANFL, WAFL, VFL, and then the Top 2 VAFA and NEAFL...competing against the AFL clubs...almost FA Cup style! Won't happen, but fun idea.

2014-02-26T02:13:45+00:00

alicesprings

Guest


Might sound stupid but after WA3 and TAS are given teams i think Newcastle (Along with Nth QLD) will be seriously looked at by the AFL. A team to represent the entire central coast. This would have to be over 30yrs away but i have no doubt that the AFL will have it on the radar. We all thought GWS was a pipe dream!

2014-02-26T02:10:45+00:00

alicesprings

Guest


Excellent. Absolutely agree! Have been impressed how games have been spread around this year. People generally don't understand the amazing impact these games have on their respective communities. It does wonders for the game at the grass roots level. For example up here the towns buzzing and they'll be coming in by the bus loads form the outlying communities! In regards to NSW/ACT. Southern NSW/Riverina - It would be great to see an extra game here. Finley…well narranderra has hosted games in the past so i guess its possible. Albury is the logical choice and they're crying out for a game! Wollongong and Coffs Harbour would also be good. Newcastle the largest city in Australia without a team should be getting some attention. However there are only so many Swans/Giants games to go around!

2014-02-26T01:39:26+00:00

Lroy

Guest


The Great Northern League is a very strong comp... they used to play the WA equivalent of the VFA , the "Sunday League" and never lost a game back in the old days. Would like to see games in Busselton or Albany, would be great for the country peope, all the farmers would come along, be a nice way to spend an afternoon.

2014-02-26T01:16:49+00:00

Franko

Guest


Would love to see AFL clubs v League state sides (WAFL, TFL etc) but can't see it happening as AFL house tends to view those leagues almost as competitors. WAFL, SANFL or VFL would give GWS a touch up I rekon.

2014-02-26T00:59:27+00:00

langou

Roar Guru


It doesn't have to be country towns, having games in the suburbs could work as well.

2014-02-26T00:38:12+00:00

John Hamilton

Guest


Dubbo/Bathurst, Broken Hill, Coffs Harbour, Alice Springs, Mt Isa, Kalgoorlie, Port Lincoln, Wagga Wagga. I don't know the logistics of those places but thought I'd throw thme out there.

2014-02-26T00:19:37+00:00

Sean

Guest


That's fine, but don't think Canberra is exactly oversaturated with footy either.

AUTHOR

2014-02-26T00:06:37+00:00

SportsFanGC

Roar Guru


Thanks Mid and good to get some ideas from a NSW resident

2014-02-25T23:48:19+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


Newcastle has hosted trial games before, at the No 1 Sports Ground - great location at the edge of the CBD, a few blocks from Civic Station. Playing area is a bit small, but the surface is excellent. They'd need to get temporary lights put in, but that would be do-able. Another option would be North Dalton Oval in Wollongong.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar