Australia don't deserve top Test ranking yet

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

Australia must beat Pakistan away this October and then win the Ashes in England next year to deserve their new No. 1 Test ranking.

The Aussies were yesterday gifted the ranking they had coveted since losing it in August 2009.

Their leapfrogging of South Africa, who slid to second spot, was the result of their recent resounding triumphs over the Proteas and England.

By vaporising England 5-0 at home Australia signalled they were a rising force, before delivering on the hype with a gutsy 2-1 defeat of the Proteas in South Africa.

Both series victories were extremely impressive and the Aussies were deservedly lavished with praise. But the defeat of South Africa was the first time they had beaten a formidable opponent away from home since 2009, when they again upset the Proteas.

Meanwhile, South Africa have not lost an away Test series in eight years. During that extraordinary run they have toppled heavyweights India, England and Australia in their own backyards.

The Proteas remain worthy of the No. 1 Test ranking. They have been a dominant side year after year, regardless of the conditions. Such grand success is not erased by one defeat in a three-Test series.

Australia may be the team to beat right now, but prior to their Ashes demolition job they had gone nine Tests without a win. To be the rightful owners of the No. 1 Test ranking the men in baggy greens have to show they can prosper on turning decks, as well as in England.

South Africa have achieved both of those things in recent years, and the Aussies will have the opportunity to replicate their feats over the next 15 months.

Can they conquer Pakistan and their spin wizard Saeed Ajmal on dusty decks in the UAE in October?

Can they back that up by besting India at home in next summer’s four-Test series?

Can they knock off the West Indies in the Caribbean early next year?

Most importantly, can they back all that up by lifting the Ashes in England for the first time in 14 years?

If the Aussies tick each of these boxes then they will feel like the true No. 1 Test side.

Skipper Michael Clarke suggested as much yesterday after learning of his side’s ascension to the head of the rankings.

“The true test of a great side is sustained success and now our goal is to maintain these rankings and continue to play great cricket as we lead into challenging Test series against Pakistan and India, and the ICC Cricket World Cup at home,” he said.

“We had a fantastic home summer against England and a great series win away against South Africa earlier this year, but the challenge now is to continue that form.

“We have a huge amount of respect for the South Africa side, and the length it held the number-one Test ranking is testament to the great side it is. South Africa will no doubt continue to be a formidable opponent in Test match cricket.”

So how exactly did Australia suddenly climb to number one yesterday despite not having played a Test since March?

The Test rankings are recalibrated annually. This recent update either completely removed or downgraded the weighting of several of Australia’s most disastrous series, including their Ashes pounding in 2010-11 and the 4-0 loss in India early last year.

But their No. 1 ranking will not be safe for long. South Africa have easy series coming up against Sri Lanka and Zimbabwe, both of which will be completed before Australia travel to the UAE for their tough contest against the unpredictable Pakistan.

Australia may well find themselves back below South Africa again in a matter of months.

That would be a fair result. The Aussies are surging but they still have a lot to prove.

The Crowd Says:

2014-05-15T22:55:50+00:00

Steele

Guest


There are no champion teams around at the moment, and the ranking reflects that. As good as Sth Africa have been, they really didn't have much opposition. IMO they were a dominant team in a weak era. Now they have lost Kallis and Smith they are on a bit of a slide. They still posses a few great batsmen but their reliance on Steyn is a problem.

2014-05-12T09:00:25+00:00

SAFFA28

Guest


I have to agree that AUS is the best side at the moment. However ,SA had to play excellent cricket and Win Series over a couple of seasons to reach that number 1 spot. How is it possible that AUS snaps it up in 2 Series? Makes no sense ! If AUS kept on playing like they did for the last 2 seasons I would have no doubt in my mind that they are and deserve that No1 spot! But come on , 3(SA,ENG,IND) series losses and then 3(SL,ENG,SA) wins and you go to number 1 vs SA 5(ENG,AUS,IND,PAK,NZ) wins,1(PAK) draw and 1(AUS) loss for the same period and you go down to no 2!!! Does this make any sense to anyone?

2014-05-11T09:53:56+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


Nope, says more about the points/ranking system.

2014-05-07T09:19:43+00:00

Nudge

Guest


It helps though Ronan. Just have a look how James Anderson has performed in australian conditions when the ball hasn't swung. Southee will get murdered here, but I think Boult will do ok

2014-05-06T10:41:15+00:00

Vistro

Guest


it seems absurd to me that South Africa have been knocked down to second considering their seriously good away record: it has been almost eight years since they last surrendered a series on enemy turf, in Sri Lanka in 2006. I feel now that their part of a questionable “big three” ICC commercial powers lopsidedly pulling the world’s strings – have been well nigh fast-tracked because it may suit some public relations or marketing agenda.

2014-05-06T06:19:36+00:00

Wiljoy

Roar Rookie


With all this blabber going on about the quality of the Aussie team in comparison with the other cricketing nations the fact clearly remains,...THIS IS THE WORST AUSTRALIAN TEAM FOR 40 YEARS.

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:27:45+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Absolutely Barry, Aussie fans would be livid were the situation reversed.

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:25:07+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Fair point Lachlan.

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:23:25+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


It is going to be fascinating to see how SA rebuild without Smith and Kallis. They are fortunate to have a soft run of Tests the next year to sort that out

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:21:41+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


They need to win in England and NZ first to prove that though jameswm

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:20:57+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Yep Australia were the dominant team in that last Test also and completely deserved the win.

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:19:31+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Yeah I think the Aussie team circa 2001 is the greatest in history, with the 80s Windies a close second.

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:18:26+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


How long has it been since cricket was a "gentlemanly" sport?

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:17:23+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I should say though that in Boult and Southee's cases they don't need to be consistently over 140kmh as their skill level allows them to be extremely effective bowlers regardless.

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:15:48+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


That's a fair point Dalgety, SA were never as frightening a side as they could have been because of a tendency to go defensive too often.

AUTHOR

2014-05-06T04:14:20+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Beating Pakistan in the UAE is no easy task either though.

2014-05-06T02:50:17+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


We'd be filthy if the situation was reversed, we'd dominated for years and lost the No 1 ranking on the back of one series. Australia has had a golden 6 months...SA a golden 6 years. Before the Ashes series we'd lost 3-0 to England and 4-0 to India. There's no way off the back of two series wins we deserve No1 ranking.

2014-05-04T00:20:17+00:00

Lachlan

Guest


"South Africa have an easy series coming up against Sri Lanka" Not quite right, if you check South Africa's recent record in Sri Lanka you might think otherwise. Yes SL might not be as strong as they had been in previous years, but to call it an easy series and liken them to Zimbabwe is unfair and simply wrong. It won't be a cakewalk for the Proteas by any means.

2014-05-03T21:31:50+00:00

schtumpy

Guest


It's sad that Pakistan's political chaos has robbed them of their formidable home advantage. Beating India in India is now the toughest job but Pakistan in Pakistan used to be on a par.

2014-05-03T14:07:48+00:00

Shouts Chen

Guest


The chances of Australia gaining 1ST place is likely.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar