Time to put the Sharks out of their misery

By Chris Love / Roar Guru

Wow just wow! What a difference less than 24 hours makes in rugby league.

As if things weren’t bad enough for the Cronulla Sharks. A quarter of a season without scoring a point ended on Friday night with 25 or so minutes of the best football Cronulla has produced all year.

A rare season highlight drowned out in the time it took for a digital shutter to close on Todd Carney’s career. The fact that Carney was the playmaking catalyst behind the upset win over the Broncos made it even worse.

Let’s see. A massive fine over the supplements scandal that the club can’t afford to pay. A coach suspended until next season. ASADA’s incompetent investigation looming large over the entire club. No major sponsor. Now no marquee playmaker and even less of a prospect of signing a new one.

Where does this really leave the Sharks? With ASADA’s investigation due to rock the club even harder in coming weeks, depending on how much evidence they can provide. Surely the NRL’s patience much be wearing thin in the Shire?

Is the writing now not already on the wall for Cronulla? Short of them producing a junior with amazing talent, 2015 looks a write off for finding a gun five-eighth.

What major sponsor is going to touch the Sharks now? As if the financial implications for the Sharks weren’t bad enough, how can the Cronulla club afford to fight any possible sanction from ASADA in the courts? Not doing so would surely mean the inability to field a side at all in 2015.

Is it not time for the NRL to cut their losses with the Sharks? I’m sure the fans of clubs with huge junior bases and no drug scandals hanging over their heads would be livid with any further financial or otherwise support for Cronulla.

They rolled the dice with Carney. They rolled the dice with Steve Dank. In both cases they rolled the dice with sponsors. They crapped out.

It’s time the NRL turned this torrid, sorry story into a positive of the future and let the Sharks die the self induced death of a self-medicating drug addict. Pun completely intended.

What a perfect opportunity to finally give an under represented area in this nation their chance to field a team as soon as possibly 2015. No major expansion or change to the current system is necessary. Surely, the neglected fans of Central Queensland, Central Coast NSW, Adelaide or Perth deserve a chance.

This isn’t on parallel with the Souths de-registration. Souths were a foundation club with a hugely rich history of success with a massive junior base. The Sharks have never won a title and it took the Super League war’s dilution of the competition for them even to make a grand final.

The teething problems of getting a fledgling club in one of these areas off the ground, in such a short period of time, would be dwarfed by the publicity, cost and sheer blight on the game a long drawn out battle in the courts that Cronulla will provide. If of course the worst fears out of the ASADA investigation come to life.

If it comes to that. I honestly think it’s in the best interests of the game for the NRL to cut its losses with Cronulla. Get rid of them and put this whole sorry affair in the past by using that licence in an area that deserves a chance to roll the dice.

It ticks all the boxes. A new area is represented. The NRL can set a precedent on the roll of clubs on the integrity of the game. They wipe the floor with the blight that the Cronulla club has brought to the game. New sponsors will flock to a fledgling club that won’t touch Cronulla. The critics of the Sydney centric nature of the NRL get satisfied with expansion coming at the expense of a Sydney club.

The NRL will never get a better chance to pull the trigger than this.

The Crowd Says:

2014-07-01T23:51:44+00:00

Slide

Guest


Learn to #GetYourFactsRight #Cadet

2014-07-01T23:39:28+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


St George and Cronulla hated each other because Cronulla was part of the St George footy catchment area and was lost. Cronulla had no time for St George because the Dragons tried to stop Cronulla from being promoted to the Sydney RL first division.

2014-07-01T12:15:38+00:00

Parrafan

Guest


Funny enough Gallen was a Parramatta junior. One we were not sad to have let go. It's interesting to see how so many good nrl players were developed in the parra junior system. Very big positive. Now if only we could continue to fix up our talent spotting and player retention.

2014-07-01T10:58:41+00:00

Remmy

Guest


I follow the Broncos.. So that answers your question in regards to my team's performance. Ok, I did get the facts wrong in regards to the NRL having to prop up Cronulla.. However the NRL atm gives grants of the same amount to all NRL clubs.. But because clubs like Brisbane already make a profit, people in the NRL said it is unfair to give the same amount of money to each club when it should be given on a needs-basis. So next year the annual grant for the NRL will be less for the richer clubs, which is good. But the NRL next year is bringing in a benchmark system which requires clubs to meet targets in regards to revenue, sponsorship and attendances (and other criteria). The clubs that do achieve their goals will receive money. Now remember, the Sharks only last year were bailed out by securing a consortium of companies to take on their debt so they could do a huge infrastructure development around Shark Park on the Bay.. Let alone a Pizza Shop guy paying $3mil to get rid of more debt.. Now this is good that this has been sorted.. However Cronulla's brand is damaged.. Has been for years. They can't even get a major sponsor let alone the sponsorship needed for such professional clubs.. They have two big name players now after Carney's sacking and only Ennis to add to that roster. The fact is that Cronulla is at long odds to achieve the KPI goals that the NRL will benchmark for the clubs, and due to this they won't receive extra cash and the situation looks like it will only become worse.. If Cronulla does not turn their position around then they will not have their license renewed because they aren't making themselves sustainable. This is just the fact of the matter.. I would love to see the Sharks very healthy, but they aren't. The only good thing about Cronulla is that they own their own stadium.. But I do not think that will save them.

2014-07-01T10:33:05+00:00

Chris Love

Guest


#LearnToRead

2014-07-01T10:29:29+00:00

Chris Love

Guest


Gallen was a Parramatta junior.

2014-07-01T06:54:09+00:00

Fred

Guest


This article belongs in the urinal with TC.

2014-07-01T06:53:20+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


My apologies. I thought you were suggesting a promotion/relegation system, which would be a dismal failure. Your idea has merit, however if a current NRL side was dropped to a 2nd division, I think their fans would, for the most part, see it as being dumped. For instance North Sydney run around every weekend as Souths feeder side, yet most people I speak to say "Bears? Do they even still exist?"

2014-07-01T06:41:44+00:00

Richard

Guest


If this article sets the standard for this spots website then it is destined to fail itself. As many people have already pointed out the Sharks have had plenty of good and bad times as per any team in the NSWRL/ARL/NRL competitions over the years. Yes they are going through a bad patch at the moment and I am confident they will pull through once again. If we look at other clubs for a moment how can we go past Melbourne and Bulldogs for salary cap issues, they survived. Newcastle and Penrith have huge financial issues, are we talking about moving them? Shall we forget about the Bulldogs and Coffs Harbour not all that long ago. All clubs have had their trials and tribulations, some have had player issues whilst others have had endemic issues with what amounts to cheating by rorting the salary cap. The Sharks own their ground, have a huge development underway for a more secure financial future and have a great junior pool of players. If any other club had these attributes we would be saying the club would have a great future. Yes I am a Sharks supporter and have been for 37 years, so if there are no Sharks then there is no NRL for me ... that simple really.

2014-07-01T06:26:10+00:00

V.O.R.

Guest


That's all they've got left Chris. An extreme case of DENIAL going on with Sharkies fans.

2014-07-01T06:14:53+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


Mars/Masterfoods is one example, not to mention the large number of companies based in Northern Sydney. not that it matters anyway. There's no rule or precedent that a company must be based in the area a team represents in order to sponsor them. The only thing the NRL cares about is eyes on screens, bums on seats and the disposable income.

2014-07-01T05:55:20+00:00

Football United

Guest


No Pro/Rel, just a national division to sit below the NRL to cater for Potential Expansion teams or regions that aren't quite ready for their own team yet. If a team does well in it over the years and brings in supporters then they go up with approval from the NRL. Much better than bringing in teams blind. We cannot call the NSW & QLD a second division, it's a miss match of reserve teams and local clubs and the gap between them and the NRL is too big atm. Sunshine Coast Ipswich Jets Cairns Pride Central Coast Bears Perth Reds Port Moresby Hunters South Logan Magpies Illawarra Steelers

2014-07-01T05:37:44+00:00

AGO74

Guest


Yep. Central Coast is a dud. The fans up there already have their own teams that they support (tigers are big up there as a lot of westiea moved north) and there is no real commercial value to nrl in introducing a team up there. What major businesses are up there? Economically speaking its a poor area with a reliance on Sydney for a lot of its workforce.

2014-07-01T05:05:28+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


Are you talking about a promotion and relegation system? Or just a second division in general? Because we already have second division in the form of NSW & QLD Cups

2014-07-01T04:51:04+00:00

slide

Guest


Yeah Perth Pirates, they've got 4,000 odd supporters on their website. That should do it. If they ALL turn up every week they'll have enviable crowds of 4,000. Great stuff.

2014-07-01T04:44:52+00:00

Rod Gallagher

Guest


As far as I am aware no money has gone to Cronulla. This in unlike clubs that have been owned in wholein part by newscorp

2014-07-01T04:41:25+00:00

slide

Guest


Nice editing job Chris! #NoCredibility

2014-07-01T04:37:48+00:00

slide

Guest


Thanks Chris, Nice link, but that's hardly convincing. The fine will be reduced by $400k if the Sharks meet certain conditions, leaving only $600k to be payed off. Furthermore, the article says that they "may" be given 5 years to pay the fine. This means that they will still be required to pay the fine, but they "may" just be given a little longer to pay it. That's hardly a "bail out" particularly in comparison to the Dragons $2MIL. But good googling mate, you almost made an argument. You are improving ever so slightly. Keep on banging that typewriter scoop! One day you might even write for Women’s Weekly!!

2014-07-01T04:33:47+00:00

tigerdave05

Guest


I firmly believe to comment on anything you need to have all the facts and to say Cronulla had not been in a grandfinal except for the super league one against Brisbane shows that you are intact clueless and should do your research before showing you are a buffoon. History shows that Cronulla played in the 1973 grandfinal and again in two grandfinals in 1978. They did win a midweek competition during the 70's or early 80's.

AUTHOR

2014-07-01T04:29:44+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru


Read it again. PLAY-MAKER. What are you going to run G-Train out in a 6 jersey next year champ?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar