Aussie pride takes a battering but Lyon proving a spin king

By Patrick Effeney / Editor

After Australia’s loss to Zimbabwe, coach Darren Lehmann said he didn’t have enough expletives to describe how he was feeling about his side’s performance.

When the Aussies’ colloquial, parochial mentor doesn’t have enough swear words floating around in his noodle to lambast his charges, I doubt all but Shakespeare himself would have the power to describe the inner churnings of Lehmann’s mind.

Michael Clarke was rightfully filthy too, but that will do little from here on. He’s likely enjoying a snack on his stopover right now, with not enough Wifi signal to Skype the lads and get up them. Text away Clarkey.

Aussie fans have the right to be disappointed and angry too, and it’s likely we would be even more outraged if the weird and wonderful worlds of the AFL and NRL weren’t so consuming right now.

But the worry for me isn’t for this loss, or Australia’s prospects in the Tri-series. I still think they’ll make the final, and they’re a good shot at winning that game against South Africa. You certainly can’t accuse South Africa of having a strong spin attack, so there’s that playing field levelled at least.

I’m not even worried about the World Cup starting in February next year. A loss on a slow, turning Harare pitch has so little relevance to a tournament held in Australia and New Zealand next year it’s not worth expending brain cells trying to think about it.

Losing the number one ODI ranking sucks, but it’s still not the worst thing to come from this.

The bigger concern has to be the Test series against Pakistan in the United Arab Emirates in October. Because losing six wickets to a reasonable spin attack on a turning wicket says to me that Australia’s problems dealing with quality spin are still very much in the present.

Prosper Utseya is a fine bowler. I can’t say I’ve seen too much of either Sean Williams or Donald Tiripano’s offerings, but they looked very serviceable on Sunday.

None of them are Saeed Ajmal, the offie who will be Australia’s primary adversary in the UAE. The pitches there aren’t rank turners like Mumbai, but they’re not exactly the WACA either.

The two grounds on which Australia will play in October have at least one telling statistic in common; the top Test wicket-taker. Ajmal tops the counts for both stadia with 37 and 18 respectively.

Watching Phil Hughes, George Bailey and James Faulkner all fall to spin reminded me of the battles in India almost 18 months ago. Wince-inducing batting collapses saw Australia cop a 4-0 hiding there. Michael Clarke and Steve Smith were anointed Australia’s only successes with the bat after the rout. Shane Watson and Chris Rogers are also likely to soak up batting spots against Pakistan, but it’s hard to pick a sixth specialist bat who plays with confidence against the turning ball.

There are only two Tests in the Pakistan series, and unfortunately there’s little to suggest that whoever’s entrusted with the job of supporting Australia’s two best players of spin is up to it.

The only thing in their favour is that UAE decks spin less than those of the subcontinent. That’s little comfort when you look at Australia’s performances in turning conditions. If it hasn’t happened already, there might be wicket-related telegrams on the way to Abu Dhabi and Dubai right now.

On the positive side, Australia has a spinner who can combat Ajmal for top wicket-taker in that series. Nathan Lyon continues to show that his around-the-wicket method is worth persisting with. Hell, it’s about the only thing that went right in Harare. Four wickets gave Australia a sniff against Zimbabwe, as the hosts struggled to the paltry target of a bit over 200.

The trajectory from around the wicket suits Lyon. It allows him to come over the top of the ball with his spinning finger, giving his deliveries more fizz when they bounce. The downside is he is denied access to many of the footmarks created by Mitchells Starc and Johnson. His showings so far suggest it’s well worth the sacrifice.

His swat for six from the penultimate ball of Australia’s innings wasn’t half bad either.

I’m sure that of those expletives swirling inside Lehmann, not many would have been directed at Lyon, who continues to produce for Australia. Whatever little section of the choir that was left singing the wrong tune on the former groundsman will soon be converted.

So while Lyon continues to show he is the solution to the spinning question, doubts remain about the other main discipline of cricket, and I’m not talking about fielding. You can be assured they’re getting quality practice in the nets if Lyon’s there.

The loss to Zimbabwe doesn’t mean much, either in the context of this series or in the make-up of the team for the World Cup. But set against the broader context of last year’s failures in India and the Australian culture playing spin bowling, it is a body blow to the team’s pride.

Brutally exposed against Ajmal’s lessers, improvement, and lots of it, from our batsmen is the minimum required by the time October 22 rolls around.

The Crowd Says:

2014-09-03T02:35:48+00:00

Clavers

Guest


Have they? Good move!

2014-09-03T02:32:06+00:00

Clavers

Guest


From his 85 in 92 balls against SA with three spinners operating, it is clear that Hughes can in fact handle spin.

2014-09-03T02:30:42+00:00

Clavers

Guest


Those who bagged Hughes for his batting against spin after the Zimbabwe match should reappraise their comments in the light of his innings against South Africa. He scored 85 of 92 on a turning wicket with three spinners operating; Duminy, Tahir and Phangiso bowled 24 overs between them. After Duminy was brought on to open the bowling in an attempt to replicate the Zimbabwe experience, but Hughes scored 9 off the first 6 balls he faced from Duminy and he was taken off after just two overs. Hughes has shown once again not only his talent, but more importantly his capacity to learn and improve.

2014-09-02T22:02:47+00:00

AlanKC

Guest


Pretty difficult for a slinger to chuck, they're generally the "most" legal.

2014-09-02T22:01:25+00:00

AlanKC

Guest


The 15 degree came in largely because analysing video showed that most bowlers bent and then straightened their arm during delivery. 15 degrees was decided on because that's where it became clear to the naked eye - or at least, that's my understanding of it.

2014-09-02T06:45:18+00:00

Silver Sovereign Likes Cactai

Guest


What has doolan done that was so much better than bailey in the ashes? One fifty in 3 tests is not much better than bailey's ashes highlights of 54, 46, one unbeaten thirty odd and a 34. Their first class records are very similar. I would stick with bailey at 6 where he is a natural aggressor who can attack well with the tail and put Watson back to 3 where he has been most effective My pakistan tour team would be Rogers, Warner, Watson, Clarke, smith, bailey, haddin, Johnson, starc, bird/Patto, Lyon

2014-09-02T05:37:01+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


Well very likely we will be waiting forever for that one!

2014-09-02T03:48:34+00:00

Brisbane boys

Guest


Spoken like a batsman Cover the pitches Spring the bats, careful you don't touch the ball the wrong way batsmen are too pretty for there own good ps not a bowler just sick of watching this fine game of a battle between bat and ball degenerate into baseball.

2014-09-02T03:02:50+00:00

Chris Kettlewell

Roar Guru


Johnson bowls with a dead straight arm, the furthest away from a chucker you can find. If you want to have a go at Aussies, you've picked a pretty poor target! Of course, you have a problem trying to find a good target, because Australian's don't tolerate chuckers at any level of the game, meaning someone with a suspect action will rarely get anywhere near first class level, let alone international level.

2014-09-02T02:47:21+00:00

Nudge

Guest


If Johnson chucks it I'm prepared to go and live in England for 3 years,and you wouldn't wish that on your worst enemy.

2014-09-02T01:45:56+00:00

Sideline Comm.

Guest


I'd like to say we hate chuckers because we are a fair and even society who believe in the sanctity of the law above all else, but honestly it's probably got more to do with a bloke with who has a suspect action (Murali) taking the crown of most wickets from Warne. But nevertheless, (and I know you're poking us a bit for a laugh) Johnson has a straight arm when he bowls, so he is not a chucker. He slings from the side (though nowhere near as much as Malinga) but that is not illegal. Baseball pitchers get their momentum from the whip like action in the elbow, which is what some bowlers are being accused of doing.

2014-09-02T01:45:37+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Australia's always been pretty tough on chuckers. Every now and then a shield bowler pops up for official scrutiny. Johnners absolutely does not throw. I think the Aussie camp have been disrespectful toward the Zimbabs. Got done fair and square.

2014-09-02T00:52:42+00:00

Sideline Comm.

Guest


I was glad to see that the academy in Brisbane is importing a subcontinent practice pitch though. It might help us stop the rot, at least with the new guys if they get enough time on it.

2014-09-02T00:50:37+00:00

Sideline Comm.

Guest


Here we go, another bitter pom. Enlighten us: How is Johnson's bowling suspect?

2014-09-02T00:49:16+00:00

Sideline Comm.

Guest


Missed the point mate. It's not about the danger, it's the (unfair) extra rotations that spinners can put on the ball by bending and straightening the arm that makes it illegal and 'just not cricket'.

2014-09-02T00:24:31+00:00

Shaun

Guest


It's an absolutely stupid rule, they only bowl at +- 100km/h so batsman should just suck it up. How can the way Mitchell Johnson or Lasith Malinga slinging the ball at +-150km/h be any more legal...it's more dangerous. If they want to be serious about spinners chucking then they should be serious about pace bowlers slinging

2014-09-01T23:50:20+00:00

Ash

Guest


Yeah agreed mate on Ajmal but once Murali was let through then it opened the door for others as well

2014-09-01T23:49:29+00:00

Ash

Guest


Agreed on the top 6, Hughes shouldn't anywhere near it until he can handle spin and aside from Doolan alsolook at White as he got shield runs last year.

2014-09-01T23:36:24+00:00

Dan

Guest


Ajmal deadset chucks it He was recently reported did anything come of that? The 15degrees rule is ridiculous, it's basically saying you can't stand there and completely throw it, but you can a little bit. In my opinion if your arm bends then straightens it's a throw. Anyone who thinks murali, ajmal and even harbijan have/had legal actions needs there eyes checked. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

AUTHOR

2014-09-01T23:25:49+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


Pretty well agree here SC. Rogers and Warner will battle hard, and find themselves in trouble at times. We'll just have to deal with that. Doolan is untested against spin, and the others are known quantities. The culture of failure against quality spin is the thing that worries me, and will continue to until Ajmal starts bowling!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar