HENRY: Smith's appointment means it's time for the tyros

By Geoff Lawson / Expert

The Nathan Lyon inspired victory in Adelaide will not be repeated in Brisbane – that’s the 12 wickets bit, not necessarily the victory bit.

The grass will be greener, the footmarks will not be as deep and the finger spinners will not be reaping the rewards of close-in fieldsmen suffocating prodding batsmen and deafening umpires with appeals.

The ‘Gabba Test will produce a different style of match, but hopefully maintain a number of quality batting and bowling performances, as well as a good dose of tension on day five.

Virat Kholi may well fancy a true ‘Gabba surface even more than the batting paradise at North Adelaide.

Peter Siddle should warm the pine as Josh Hazlewood would be a handful with his height, bounce and pace.

It is time for the tyros.

The Marsh brothers together, a new batting order and a new captain – an Australian victory has rarely produced so many changes in the XI.

I have to admit to being a little surprised at the elevation of Steven ‘Smudger’ Smith to the most important office in the country, but pleasantly surprised as well.

Brad Haddin as the wise old head of the operation seemed to be the obvious candidate to lead the national team in Brisbane, especially as the Michael Clarke career obituary looked a tad premature.

Plan A was to have Haddin as the short to medium term skipper with Smith as the intern gaining experience along the Test and ODI path with a view to taking the throne if Michael Clarke’s body failed to heal.

That plan contained a lot of rational thinking and would give Smith time to grow into the leadership role and for Haddin to phase out of the team on a high note while serving as a leader in all senses of the word.

Brad Haddin is one of the most selfless players in the land, he has no desire to “leave a legacy” or be remembered for his captaincy record, he is man who wants to play hard and fair and win every game he plays.

Brad was an outstanding captain of New South Wales until his position was usurped in a part of the deal that brought Simon Katich to Sydney after his disaffection with Western Australia cricket. Haddin graciously stood aside then for the benefit of Bluebag cricket and there is no doubt that had he been given the Australian big ‘C’ he would not have followed the example of more recent office holders who clung on by their fingernails.

If that was the concern of the national selectors and CA Board (and possibly a reason for bypassing the wicketkeeper) then their fears were ill founded. Having said that, Steve Smith is an excellent captaincy election.

I saw his captaincy up close during last season’s Sheffield Shield final where he combined some classy batting with cool, calm decision making. He lead that team quietly and effectively.

He is not one to get into arm waving, finger pointing and insistent vocal tones. I can’t foresee any remonstrations with opposing players that characterised Steve Waugh, Ricky Ponting or Michael Clarke’s reigns.

A little less noise on the field won’t hurt the game. That is not to say that he isn’t a tough competitor for he has proven that he can personally do the business under pressure and he has been an integral part of winning teams – the Shield final being a case in point.

Fortunately his form has been outstanding and I think his run scoring and consistency over the past 12 months would have weighed heavily in the discussion. His infectious fussiness and fidgeting will be satirised but will also be his own idiosyncratic watermark, it gives him a shadow of comic relief which reflects his demeanour – his smile is genuine and a scowl rare, brief and quizzical.

The game could do with some lightening up at the moment and Steve Smith’s creative and unaffected style of getting on with the game could be just what the doctor ordered.

I hope he bowls himself more often than not, too.

The Crowd Says:

2014-12-16T17:19:01+00:00

Armchair Expert

Guest


Dizzy or Henry?

2014-12-16T10:29:56+00:00

Viren

Guest


Great call picking him. Have always rated him for the positive effect he has on his teammates right from 2010. Is it just me, or does he seem like Boon's spiritual successor?

2014-12-16T10:06:13+00:00

Gav

Guest


Johnson and Hazlewood id recon

2014-12-16T09:49:59+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


Don't like the look of the attack without Harris. But then I never do like to see him missing. Be interesting to see who takes the new ball.

2014-12-16T09:26:14+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


This could be the start of the next generation Aussie team, new skipper, new alrounder, new quick etc... Smith appears to have all the qualities required to be a top leader even if he was thrusted into the role a year or two earlier than many expected. Happy to see Starc back, the guy is so talented. It will be interesting to see how Hazlewood goes. I assume Harris is being given a rest or is he injured ? I wonder if Smith wins the toss will he bowl first !

2014-12-16T07:38:12+00:00

Vish

Guest


Clarke could still come back n play in the team purely as a batsman. He could relax and play the role Ricky Ponting played for a couple of years under Clarke. Tat would offer Smith a helping hand and would ease his burden.

2014-12-16T04:59:38+00:00

Eric

Guest


Youv'e been hit in the head to many times Dizzy to say that brad only wants to play hard and fair when he is forever appealing for LBW and catches at the wicket when they are plainly not out yet he has the best veiw on the field. The selectors could of and should of made the hard decisions before the start of this series to replace a number of the national team, and blooded more youth into the side.

2014-12-16T04:28:48+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Great to see Starc get another crack. Most of his recent Tests have been played on very unresponsive decks in India, UAE and England (largely, I think, because he's seen as a guy who can be threatening on lifeless decks with his pace and reverse swing). Can't wait to see what he can do on a lightning quick Gabba pitch that suits him perfectly. He's been bowling very sharply in the Shield and nudged 150kmh in the UAE. I think the Indian batsmen would wish that Siddle was still playing instead.

2014-12-16T03:37:32+00:00

Ross Fleming

Roar Rookie


My prediction is that Stephen Smith will prove a great captain. He has grown into an accomplished cricketer who exudes confidence. It will be unsurprising if he doesn't resemble Michael Clarke in his willingness to try unorthodox tactics. With some players you just get that gut feeling that they will take up captaincy without breaking stride. Would also love to see now some younger batsman coming in with the likes of Khawjaa, Burns and Carters given a good run. Khwaaja in particular is one like Hughes who just needs a extended run to show his class. Watch out for the Indians bouncing back in the coming game. Great to see Starc back in the X1 again.

2014-12-16T03:23:51+00:00

Gooner

Guest


Correct. In England if your a sportsman with the last name smith. Your nickname=smudger

2014-12-16T03:22:00+00:00

Red Kev

Roar Guru


Looks like Dizzy got his wish - Starc, Hazelwood and Johnson to all play.

2014-12-16T03:17:11+00:00

jameswm

Guest


Hmmm Nudge. Chasing a declaration isn't the only time I've seen Haddin give his wicket away going for quick runs.

2014-12-16T02:19:55+00:00

Nudge

Guest


"Brad Haddin is one of the most selfless players in the land". Totally agree with this comment from Dizzy. How many times has he thrown his wicket away playing for the team? I can count 3 just in last years ashes. He averages 35 with the bat in test cricket but if he played a tad conservatively with the team was going hard in search of a declaration, like most do, I reckon his average would be around 40.

2014-12-16T01:30:14+00:00

soapit

Guest


apparently mike hussey gave him the nickname after playing with another smith in england who had that nickname. he said on the cricket the other day he thought all smiths were nicknamed smudge (difficult to tell how much he was joking about that)

2014-12-16T01:22:35+00:00

Craig Watson

Guest


Smithy has proven he thrives on pressure as purely a batsman. So I see no reason why he would not carry that same steadfast attitude into his captaincy. Couple of things that puzzle me about Smithy. Those constant equipment adjustments and annoying patting of the helmet before he fronts up to a bowler. The other is where did he get that quirky nickname of Smudge? Is he a fan of the Aussie rock band that bears that name. The dictionary definition of smudge is a 'smokey fire' to ward off mosquitos or safeguard fruit trees from frost. Would love the get the answers to both some questions.

2014-12-16T00:57:01+00:00

Shortfineleg

Guest


It was a brave decision by selectors - and I applaud them for it! I just wish they would extend that bravery when selecting batsmen - Burns is ready.

2014-12-15T23:53:09+00:00

Mike

Guest


I think he will be a beauty and if he is being endorsed by Mr Pointing and Mr Chappell then I am an sure they know a hell of lot more than me so looking forward to watching the test tomorrow on my Birthday, yeah nice way to spend the day. Good Luck Steve Smith Australia is with you. Mike

2014-12-15T22:30:35+00:00

TriangleFlatDog

Guest


While I applaud Smith's selection as captain, I just hope his form doesn't suffer with the responsibility of the captaincy on his young shoulders

2014-12-15T22:29:55+00:00

Dan

Guest


Agreed 100% -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2014-12-15T22:25:08+00:00

Chris Kettlewell

Roar Guru


I actually think Smith will be the sort of player, like Clarke, who revels in having that responsibility and just keeps getting better, rather than the sort who would struggle under the pressure. He seems to thrive on a challenge and has a great deal of determination under those baby-faced looks.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar