The lock forward has earned a place in the spine

By ScottWoodward.me / Roar Guru

The modern day rugby league lock forward has grown in value and results indicate they should be a member of the all-important spine positions – fullback, five-eighth, halfback and hooker.

Ratings of every player (out of 10) in every position of a club’s starting 17 revealed that the players with number 13 are all very good, and in most cases top class.

The average rating of the lock forward was the highest of any position, and in a shock, halfback, the position that most people likely would have selected on top, actually came in 15-16.

No doubt we have some outstanding halfbacks with Johnathan Thurston leading the way with a 9.5, but the average suffers with four clubs having a halfback rating six or under.

Of the 16 lock forwards, an amazing five rated 8/10 and another nine rated an impressive 7.5/10. Only the Warriors’ promising Seb Ikahihifo and Wests Tigers’ veteran Dene Halatau rate under 7.5.

Have a look at this list and you can see why each club needs a quality lock forward: Corey Parker (Broncos), Greg Eastwood (Bulldogs), Shaun Fensom (Raiders), Paul Gallen (Sharks), Paul Carter (Titans), James Buhrer (Manly), Dale Finucane (Storm), Ikahihifo (Warriors), Jeremy Smith (Knights), Jason Taumalolo (Cowboys), Anthony Watmough (Eels), Elijah Taylor (Panthers), Trent Merrin (Dragons), Glenn Stewart (Souths) and Dene Halatau (Wests Tigers).

Many coaches prefer to use their lock as another prop forward just hitting the ball up the middle and playing big minutes, while others are very much there to hold up the middle and prevent anyone getting past. They are tireless workers and brilliant defenders like the Panthers’ Elijah Taylor and the Raiders’ Shaun Fensom.

Probably the most complete lock is the Broncos’ Corey Parker who records big numbers in all aspects of the game including hit ups, tackles and off loads, he is a coach’s dream.

Champion coach Craig Bellamy has won premierships with lightweight locks Dallas Johnson (93 kg) and Ryan Hinchcliffe (89 kg), and in a sign of the times, his gun recruitment manager Paul Bunn has just signed the Bulldog’s 188-centimetre Dale Finucane at 106 kilograms. Although he is regarded as a big man, he will be packing down behind two props and two back rowers significantly larger than him.

The NRL has just lost their two best locks in Sonny Bill Williams and Sam Burgess, but as you can see there is no shortage of talent.

The Bulldogs were able to say goodbye to Finucane because there is no dearth of top class forwards who all can play lock including Greg Eastwood, Josh Jackson, Tony Williams, Frank Pritchard and even the multi-talented James Graham.

The Raiders are blessed to have such a great worker like Shaun Fensom, who would not be out of place in a NSW Blues shirt, but they also have the highly promising Luke Bateman who has a big future with the Maroons, and new recruit Frank-Paul Nuuausala is also a middle man.

While I prefer Paul Gallen playing a middle role as prop, he will carry the 13 shirt for the Sharks on the left edge. Like the Bulldogs, they also have multiple locks including Luke Lewis, Wade Graham, Chris Heighington and Tinirau Arona.

The Titans have sacked their starting lock Paul Carter which may force Nat Myles to drop back or Greg Bird to move from left back row to lock. Ryan James can start up front for Myles and Matt Robinson could easily replace Bird.

James Buhrer was great for Manly this year and he really solved a problem for them when Watmough went down, and the Storm will be hoping that Finucane can do the same for them with the reliable Hinchcliffe likely shifting to the bench, although I expect him to share the hooking role with Slade Griffin until Cam Smith’s ankle is heeled.

I would start Ben Matulino as my lock at the Warriors, but Ikahihifo is likely to get the nod.

Knights coach Rick Stone has a decision to make where to play his big recruit Tariq Sims, but it is doubtful if he will be preferred over Jeremy Smith, who ticks off every box required for the modern-day lock.

Jason Taumalolo is perhaps the most talented of all the locks with ball in hand at the Cowboys but he is still learning how to play big minutes and improve his defence.

Big off-season Parramatta recruit Anthony Watmough joins an already very talented forward pack but he is set to play lock for 80 minutes every week.

The Panthers have a problem what to do with the talented Adam Docker as he is a lock but has no chance of ousting Taylor.

The Dragons have the amazing Trent Merrin who is clearly their best forward and gives them an edge as one of the game’s best number 13s. They have problems if he goes to the Broncos in 2016.

How do you replace the great Sam Burgess? The answer is you don’t, but Glenn Stewart, if he can find his best form again, is world class and will be valuable for Souths as he is one of the game’s best thinkers. I hope they don’t play John Sutton in the middle as he is more effective on the left edge.

The Roosters’ Trent Robinson will likely decide who plays at lock based on the off-season training and he has many options but I expect either Aidan Guerra or Isaac Liu to take control of the middle.

With so many young forwards at Wests Tigers the calm head of Dene Halatau will be important to them, although Jason Taylor will surely have a long-term lock in mind, maybe it will be the impressive Andy Fiagatusa who joins the top squad this season after a year with the NSW Cup side in 2014.

The Crowd Says:

2014-12-22T02:07:17+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


All three of the Storms tries came off the back of basic Bulldog errors bringing the ball out of their own half. It was pretty disappointing.

2014-12-22T02:03:46+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Then there's guys like Scott Hill who played Origin and (I think) test football at 13 not that long ago. Ball players like Langmack, workhorses like Price and Clyde. 3rd props like Frank-Paul.

2014-12-22T01:33:33+00:00

Jackson Henry

Roar Guru


Yeah, I don't know of how many other NRL players actually slow down the play the ball...in attack...

2014-12-21T00:06:19+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


The Maroons have had plenty of go forward; until 2013 the starting props were either Price or Scott and Civoniceva and their second row hasn't been weak either. The Storm always had good forwards too, not necessarily huge forwards, but generally had quality in the forwards.

AUTHOR

2014-12-20T09:39:21+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


millsy If you look at all of the Maroons games over the last 8 yrs that is in doubt. They won because of their spine. Also the Bellamy Storms wins where not on the back of go forward.

2014-12-20T02:51:59+00:00

The eye

Guest


Yeah,Coach Green experimented with Tamou at lock end of last season,too..suggesting Taumalolo might find himself in the backrow next year,deservedly..and J.Maguire really ripped in the 4n's at lock so Bennys lucked out with a great rotational option there..Storm were vulnerable outside last year and looks like the same personnel out there next year as well..wouldn't want to back them when you throw in their big 3 starting to pile up their injuries

2014-12-20T02:15:52+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


Bellamy seemed to like McLean at Lock last year with Norrie at prop, given Finucane basically operated as a prop for the Bulldogs I think we're more likely to see a one for one swap. Storm forward pack should be very strong next year (as it was this year, at full strength), and Finucane is a quality signing, especially if he can tighten up a bit defence and discipline wise.

2014-12-20T01:50:49+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


Hoffman is perhaps living on past success somewhat, at his best though, it's hard to think of a better player in his position. Couple of points re: 2012. The Bulldogs pack wasn't especially big, Kasiano is a massive man for sure but the rest were all under 115 and the size of both teams was pretty even. The Storm executed Plan A much better than the Bulldogs (who lost the plot after the Perrett try and scuffle). From memory the 3 Storm tries in the GF came from some fairly set plays that Widdop and Cronk use often, sometimes the key isn't having an unpredictable or creative play, but one that's just incredibly hard to stop (or to put it another way, the short pass from Cronk to Proctor continues to be one of Melbournes best attacking plays).

2014-12-20T01:20:12+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


I haven't seen a lot of the Storm this year, I remember his offloads in 2012 damn well though, some of them were works of art.

2014-12-20T00:46:58+00:00

millsy of perth

Guest


For all the hoopla about spines and so forth you can't play football without you winning the forward battle first modern day or yesterday imo

2014-12-20T00:38:18+00:00

Jackson Henry

Roar Guru


Yeah. This.

AUTHOR

2014-12-20T00:21:43+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Peeeko Explains why Thaiday keeps getting a run.

AUTHOR

2014-12-20T00:20:27+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Alex You need to watch some more of Hoffman, he does NOT offload which is a key reason why the Storm had fewer tries on the left this year.

AUTHOR

2014-12-19T22:10:16+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Alex, The problem with too many big forwards is that if it does not work then you do not have a Plan B. The Storm did , and a Plan C. FYI, I think Hoffman is over rated as he dies with the ball all the time when often there is an over lap on. Wait till you see young Nelson Asofa-Solomona this year at the Storm.

AUTHOR

2014-12-19T22:06:45+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Triple I agree with you about Sean (he is 103kgs), but he has just turned 32 which is a shame. Who is the next SOL? I like Chris Hill (27) or Joe Westerman (25) if he could build up.

AUTHOR

2014-12-19T21:56:55+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Muzz Yes, Finucane is a real "Bellamy" type player. I expect him to play lock but the media having him playing front row. When Cam Smith is back I expect the forwards to look like this: 8. Jesse Bromwich 9. Slade Griffin, Cam Smith (Expected back between Round 2 -4) 10. Jordan McLean 11. Tim Glasby 12. Kevin Proctor 13. Dale Finucane 14. Tohu Harris 15. Tom Learoyd-Lars 16. Ryan Hinchcliffe, Ken Bromwich, Felise Kaufusi, Dwayne Weston 17. Nelson Asofa-Solomona

2014-12-19T18:45:00+00:00

peeeko

Roar Guru


i agree about Harrison, QLD didn't want to change a winning team. its the way they are

2014-12-19T14:32:53+00:00

Tripehound

Guest


Scott, cracking article/debating point old son. It is a subject I've been discussing with a few of my mates for the last couple of seasons. With the large number of Aussie coaches plying their trade in the UK over the years, I've always felt that many English sides were playing a kind of mock NRL style football, typified by the changing nature of the loose forward role, from the traditionally more agile ball distributor morphing into a third hit it up prop. 2015 will be an interesting season as the majority of clubs now have home grown coaches, so we'll see if this impacts on the style of footy that each side adopts. Personally I think a bloke that is a terrific player and is out of the mould that all loose/lock forwards should come from is the current England captain Sean O'Loughlin. He is extremely mobile, his defence is steel, he hits the ball up with plenty of verve and has the ability to pick out a pass to put his support clear on a devestatingly regular basis. Combined with his natural leadership qualities I think he is the personification of the ideal modern loose forward and indeed the archetypal loose forward for any era (his dancing weight is around 16 stone whatever that equates to in kilometers!) Should an NRL side ever attempt to pick him up he would have a massive impact on the competition, I would go as far as to say he would be as valuable to his club as a James Graham or Sam Burgess, he is that good.

2014-12-19T12:38:41+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


I'm interested to see different styles of play at work (every team playing the same way isn't good for the game imo), I'm not at all convinced the Bulldogs lost the GF in 2012 on their play style but rather on running into a highly motivated team with several of the top players of their generation in the key positions -- Smith, Slater, Cronk, and Hoffman make a "best XIII" of their age group in my view, and I think we'll be able to say the same about Proctor and Bromwich when they're 30 something too.

2014-12-19T11:19:46+00:00

Muzz

Guest


Interesting stuff, mate. Managing the cap is definitely an art form/skill, and, one of those thankless jobs as we(fans)don't see exactly what goes into it. Finucane is a great pick up by the Storm.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar