Fifteen bold predictions for the AFL in 2015

By Cameron Palmer / Roar Guru

With the calendar moving from 2014 to 2015, attention moves towards the next AFL season and the anticipation of the return of Australian rules football grows.

To go with that change of year and to build on that anticipation, here are 15 bold predictions for the season ahead.

1. A team from outside the top four makes the grand final
Last year the seven-year monkey on the back of the top four teams making the preliminary finals was broken. With one monkey gone, a gorilla on the back is made to be broken with a team from outside the top four making it to the AFL decider in October 2015.

2. One of last year’s preliminary finalists misses the eight
North Melbourne and Port Adelaide are both facing a tougher schedule in 2015 and bear the weight of expectation. Hawthorn and Sydney both face the battle of complacency after many years being benchmark AFL teams. Seems unlikely right now, but one of these four is going to embark on a brutal 2015 season that sees a contender fall short.

3. AFL home-and-away attendances will fall below 6.4 million for 2015
The AFL was bailed out in 2014 by the rebirth of Adelaide Oval saving the AFL the indignity of reduced attendances. Next year, despite claims of making it the year of the fan, attendances are set to fall.

A number of high drawing clubs headed by Collingwood could be set for tough seasons, Perth will continue to see attendances fall ahead of a new stadium move and the at-home experience only improves and pushes crowds to their lounge rooms. There is no bailout for the AFL this year, attendances will fall.

4. Mick Malthouse signs a multi-year extension with Carlton
It will be one of the most intriguing sub-plots of the season as whether Carlton commit to Malthouse long term for their next premiership push. I eventually expect Carlton to recognise the reasons why they got Malthouse in the first place and sign him on to lead a true premiership charge in coming seasons.

5. The Coleman Medal winner has no link to Hawthorn or Richmond
Nick Riewoldt, Lance Franklin, Jarryd Roughead, Jack Gunston and Jay Schulz – all the favourites for the Coleman Medal seem to be linked in one way or another to Richmond or Hawthorn. Some years the Coleman Medal springs a real surprise, and with the likes of Josh Kennedy, Jeremy Cameron, Taylor Walker and Tom Hawkins looming the Coleman will have no ties to Richmond or Hawthorn.

6. Every team wins six games, every team loses six games
Recent AFL seasons have been plagued at the foot of the table with expansion teams focused on youth and once proud clubs in the midst of lengthy rebuilds. However, 2014 saw a turn as all clubs won at least four games and lost at least five games. It would be a big statement for equalisation if the AFL saw all teams win and lose a minimum of six games.

7. Western Bulldogs claim the wooden spoon
Western Bulldogs currently find themselves on the third line of betting behind St Kilda and Melbourne, however a tough off-season and with changes afoot going into 2015 it could be the Bulldogs who claim the unwanted team wooden-ware of 2015.

8. Greater Western Sydney finishes ahead of Gold Coast
Podcast co-host Mike has been big on this one, and slowly Cam has come around. Gold Coast still have more talent, but GWS have the better AFL experience and a team with enough depth to make a challenge towards finals. While Gold Coast are still reliant on few, GWS are set to display an array of ways to win games.

9. The Rising Star winner has already played an AFL game
In the past two seasons a true rookie has claimed the AFL’s number one award for young players. Expect a trend back towards experience winning out over youth in 2015. There are too many good contenders on the field in a weak draft class for the winner not to already have an AFL game under their belt.

10. The 2015-16 free agency period will be underwhelming without a marquee player move
Since the inception of free agency the AFL has been fortunate enough to have either an elite or marquee name that has made a change of clubs. As clubs start to understand free agency better and sign players up before contract seasons, the list of free agents for next year is already underwhelming and will likely be moreso by October.

11. No key position player is picked in the top five of the 2015 national draft
As was the case back in 2012, there are few standout key position prospects going into next season and for that reason the next draft looks like being a year for midfielders and defenders. Run and carry is in vogue and next year’s draft will be headlined at the top by that.

12. Harley Bennell plays less than seven games
It is the buzz around Perth over the 2014-15 off-season. It could be injury, it could be form, it could be a certain AFL code of conduct being breached. Either way Bennell is in for a rough 2015 season.

13. Scoring increases to more than 92 points per team per game
Scoring fell by six points from 92 to 86 points per team per game last year. As the best teams showed though, attacking football is the way of the future. Expect teams to revert back to attacking game plans and scoring is going to see a much needed revival.

14. Robbie Gray finishes top three at the Brownlow
The classic candidate for the ‘year after syndrome’, which sees the umpires rewarding players a year later than their breakout year. Gray was a deserving winner of the Port Adelaide MVP but a notable absentee at the top of the Brownlow count. That changes this year as even with a good season, Gray is set for a top three place. Replicate 2014 and Gray is your 2015 Brownlow Medal winner.

15. Hawthorn three-peat
Last year no-one saw the obvious until it was too late. Hawthorn were dominant across the season yet were still underdogs in the grand final. Not this year. Until proved otherwise they are favourites and will complete the most unlikely and amazing of three-peats.

The Crowd Says:

2015-09-01T11:17:34+00:00

David

Guest


Cameron, you arent tracking too badly: Correct: 2, 5 and 8. And A few are yet to be seen. I hope you are right about 15!

2015-09-01T11:15:23+00:00

David

Guest


I so hope you are wrong.

2015-09-01T11:14:33+00:00

David

Guest


Trent Cotchin win the brownlow? Will never happen unless the Umpires conspire!

2015-04-29T16:17:15+00:00

Mark

Guest


Hawks won't complete the three-peat, they got very lucky in their last 2 prelims, their luck has to run out.

2015-02-13T02:54:22+00:00

Philip

Guest


I agree with some of the predictions here. I think Hawthorn are clearly the best side in the comp. They have the most depth which is crucial. Port and Sydney had few injuries last year compared to Hawthorn and Hawthorn still won the flag. Port Power fall short on depth and need their best 22 for most of the year if they are to challenge.

2015-01-13T05:09:54+00:00

matt bowyer

Roar Rookie


Coleman - Lance Franklin Brownlow - Trent Cotchin Premiers - Sydney Swans Wooden spooners - St Kilda

2015-01-10T19:14:20+00:00

Gyfox

Guest


To back up my prediction, AFL club memberships are currently 10% above this time last year. Port Adelaide has passed 46,000 - which suggests they will certainly beat last year's record membership.

2015-01-08T00:58:34+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Most of your comments aren't bold or interesting either. Just saying.

2015-01-08T00:56:16+00:00

lyn

Guest


My prediction is that Mick Malthouse will not be re-signed as coach at the end of the year, he will be told to go peacefully or be given the role as "Director of Football" sounds familiar!! then he will spit the dummy and tell everyone he wants to coach again will he courted by Melbourne where he will still be coaching when he is in a Zimmer frame and still a dud coach

2015-01-07T15:44:50+00:00

EddyJ

Guest


1. A team from outside the top four makes the grand final Just because it almost happened in 2014, doesn't mean it will happen in 2015. It's hard for a reason – there are usually four very good teams in the top four. 2. One of last year’s preliminary finalists misses the eight Possible, but who? There's always a surprise (remember Hawthorn fell out of the eight in 2009 after their premiership). It's easy to focus on the teams that were soundly defeated (Sydney and North Melbourne) but can't see any of them falling from the top eight. 3. AFL home-and-away attendances will fall below 6.4 million for 2015 Neither here nor there. 4. Mick Malthouse signs a multi-year extension with Carlton I think Malthouse might be gone before the end of the year. He hasn't set the world alight at Carlton, and coaching is a younger person's game. 5. The Coleman Medal winner has no link to Hawthorn or Richmond Neither here nor there. 6. Every team wins six games, every team loses six games Strangely put, but I know what you mean. Historically, only wooden spooner has one six games (Collingwood in 1976). There are still a few weak teams in the AFL – St Kilda, Melbourne, Western Bulldogs – and possibly joined by Essendon who might be in for a disaster year. Six losses for the top team is more likely, but probably not going to happen. 7. Western Bulldogs claim the wooden spoon Possible, but don't discount Essendon having a terrible year, now that Hird is back and Thompson has departed. Hird is really not a coach, and the ASADA case may have taken its toll on the club and the team. 8. Greater Western Sydney finishes ahead of Gold Coast Possible. Gold Coast could have an incredible year, or stagnate – Eade should be a good coach for them, but he hasn't been coaching for a few seasons. 9. The Rising Star winner has already played an AFL game. Neither bold or interesting! 10. The 2015-16 free agency period will be underwhelming without a marquee player move Yes, this is possible. 11. No key position player is picked in the top five of the 2015 national draft Neither bold or interesting! 12. Harley Bennell plays less than seven games Neither bold or interesting! 13. Scoring increases to more than 92 points per team per game Average scores went up from 2011-2013, due to Gold Coast and GWS included in the competition, but as they become more competitive, they average scores will decrease. 14. Robbie Gray finishes top three at the Brownlow Possible. 15. Hawthorn three-peat Of course, this is possible. But unlikely. A three-peat is rare and even for one premiership, everything has to fall into place. I think many pundits are getting carried away with their absolutely brilliant and ruthless performance in the 2014 Grand Final. This was a rare victory because everything went right for Hawthorn, and everything went wrong for Sydney. But, remember they almost didn't make to the Grand Final – they just defeated Port Adelaide by 3 points in the Preliminary Final. Seems like Hawthorn has beefed up their team for 2015 and look even better on paper, but the three-peat is still unlikely.

2015-01-07T00:44:00+00:00

AR

Guest


Yep - a good start at home does wonders for the rest of the season. And a big win against the Pies would do quite nicely.

2015-01-07T00:18:34+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Yeah, I was looking at the average crowd tables - after 2010 things just dropped off the proverbial cliff. Spot on with your comment about fast starts Tom - I'm worried that if we go out and suck against Collingwood, this season is going to be stillborn before its even begun. We can't go out and lose the first 5,6 games like last year. Hell, our first win was in New Zealand, it was ages before we won one at home. Beating Collingwood is mandatory if we're to start building crowds again.

2015-01-07T00:11:37+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


Certainly in a slump, but they were getting ~30k per game for about 10 years until the bottom fell out in 2010. Admittedly that was before the Suns carved away a chunk of their fan base, but honestly I think 25k should be a baseline figure even when they're doing poorly. The last three years should not be the standard. Can't overstate how important a fast start is for Brisbane attendances. They'll get close to a full house for Collingwood in round one on the Easter weekend: winning that game would generate a lot of repeat business. Brisbane crowds like winners.

2015-01-06T14:58:51+00:00

Josh

Expert


Some interesting calls here. Personally, I reckon the Dogs for the spoon is actually a pretty logical prediction. The other teams down the bottom should improve but they having lost a lot of experienced players will struggle. I think you'll be right on 9 and 11 too, though what's this about Harley Bennell? I don't approve of spreading rumour.

2015-01-06T11:27:34+00:00

Alicesprings

Guest


Wow if 7 of those come off this year least to say it will be a very interesting year! A follow up article at the conclusion of the season??

2015-01-06T08:39:16+00:00

Jakarta Jeff

Guest


One factor not factored in is a prediction on Essendon. Will the players get 4-6 weeks off to start the season - or longer? Will they be found not guilty and have a full list from the start. Surely this will be one of the major shake-ups for predictions. If the players are found not guilty how will it affect AFL finances and possible lawsuits. If players found guilty, how will this affect Hird and even lawsuits against EFC and Hird. Will this rumble in the jungle (a) impact attendances and (b) final 8 composition? If Bombers outed for 4-6 weeks, how will this impact percentage that teams get for smashing a VFL type team while clubs later in the draw having to face a full team? Surely these things have to be factored in - one way or another.

AUTHOR

2015-01-06T07:33:40+00:00

Cameron Palmer

Roar Guru


Hi Tom, Thanks for taking the time to reply, just some quick follow ups from me. 6. Probably the most unlikely of the lot I will admit. 9. Crouch the big chance but O'Rourke, Broomhead, Boyd, Cripps, Sheed, Honeychurch, Acres, Templeton and Turner all great prospects over the draft class I believe. 10. Guess it depends on the definition of a marquee move. Steven would be on the cusp of a marquee player and I think that names bigger than that are unlikely. Look at free agency list, pretty uninspiring group. 13. More hope I think then anything else. Footy is crying out for more attacking games and play.

2015-01-06T07:22:45+00:00

SportsFanGC

Roar Guru


Very interesting on Bennell - hopefully pulls his head in or could possibly become a wasted talent and there is plenty of examples of that in the AFL's past

2015-01-06T07:22:04+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


Fifteeen?! Summer holidays mean nothing to Cameron! Anyway, I’m going to respond to every one of these fifteen as I kill time before the start of the Victory game. 1. I probably disagree, but Essendon would be my best bet. 2. North Melbourne the best chance for mine. I think that group might’ve been a bit fortunate to finish where they did. 3. Agreed. 4. The will might be there for Carlton, but I doubt it’s there for Malthouse. He seems to be getting more and more jaded. 5. Maybe. I don’t really see why (Jack) Riewoldt and Roughead wouldn’t be amongst the favourites. 6. This simply won’t happen. Mathematically it’s tough, even if there weren’t four teams at the bottom who will struggle to beat anyone else. 7. As good a tip as any. 8. I’m on the GWS bandwagon as well. GWS should improve a fair bit and Gold Coast have a few issues to deal with. I reckon though this year Gold Coast might finish stronger, and GWS might struggle once they pick up a few injuries, so I’m not quite bold enough to agree. 9. Good call, but are there really all that many good contenders right now? No one really stands out. Crouch from Adelaide maybe. 10. Totally disagree. I think there’ll be more and more moves, particularly as the incentives are now stacked so that in some cases clubs are actually better off letting certain players go. Expect St Kilda to only half-heartedly fight to hold onto Jack Steven. 11. Agreed. 12. Interesting. He’s certainly been very inconsistent on the field. He reminds me of Des Headland in some ways; everything needs to be exactly right for him to play well. 13. Not sure about this one at all. It really only holds for Hawthorn and Port Adelaide, and Hawthorn have such a plethora of attacking options that I doubt too many clubs will back themselves to copy that strategy. 14. Yes, if he replicates his 2014 form. Typically though players who have a big breakout year often dip a bit afterwards. 15. Not really that bold a prediction, is it? I think it’d be bolder to predict that this will be the year that gravity kicks in and the exhausted Hawks can’t quite back up in 2015 the way they did in 2014.

AUTHOR

2015-01-06T07:14:06+00:00

Cameron Palmer

Roar Guru


Thanks Mr F, Always nice to hear some kind words within the world that is The Roar. Really appreciate taking the time to read and to comment positively.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar