Super Rugby Expert tipping: Round 10

By Brett McKay / Expert

There’s no nice way of putting this: we were rubbish last week – or as I like to put it, the teams we picked in good faith were rubbish.

Digger’s good guess on the Blues effectively decided the round by the end of the first game, while the rest of us were looking at 0 and 4 records by the end of Saturday night in Australia. You guys only get black and white, but there was so much red on the table!

The big Round 10 questions: Can Digger handle the pressure of front-running that Paddy clearly couldn’t? Can the Chiefs beat the curse of the bye? Can the Hurricanes beat the curse of the bye? Can the Blues only confuse things even more in New Zealand?

Can the Brumbies finish with the full complement? Can the Force be the Stormers’ speedhump on the run home? Can the Shar… nope, they can’t. If no-one watches the Cheetahs-Reds, was it played at all?

Diggercane
Tips: Crusaders, Hurricanes, Highlanders, Brumbies (PP), Stormers, Bulls, Cheetahs.

“Crusaders. Why? Am I mad? Yes I am, quite mad, but they just have to win and history tells us they usually do when they have to. I am picking it will be a good weekend for the Mainlanders, however, as the Highlanders will leave the Blues with one win in a row.

“The Brumbies looked severely disappointed after losing last week and I expect them to take it out on the Rebels at home, while the Force will most likely be obliterated by the Stormers on their way back to South Africa. I cannot see the Sharks beating the Bulls, and I just have to back the Cheetahs even with some signs of life from the Reds.

“I’m missing someone…oh that’s right, the Hurricanes shall continue their general magnificent and aesthetically pleasing play with a solid win over the SuperTAHs.

“Brumbies for the Powerplay this week, they appeal as the most likely home team.”

Spiro Zavos
Tips: Chiefs, Hurricanes, Highlanders, Brumbies (PP), Stormers, Bulls, Cheetahs.

“Last week I rather foolishly said that it was a relatively easy round to pick the winners. So what happened was that four of the teams expected to win, including the Force, all lost.

“This round I am going once again for the obvious teams in the hope that I can retrieve a disastrous round of the previous week.”

Brett McKay
Tips: Crusaders, Hurricanes (PP), Highlanders, Brumbies, Stormers, Bulls, Cheetahs.

Right, so the current tactic of trying to catch the leader is not working, so I’ve inadvertently stumbled across a new plan: pick the same as the leader and let everyone in between fall over.

So while I do give the Chiefs a hope, I can’t see the Crusaders dropping two home games on the trot. The Hurricanes look well equipped to remain unbeaten, but I will still have my fun by dropping the Powerplay here and making Digger sweat.

Highlanders and Stormers shouldn’t have too many issue, and if the Brumbies can’t beat the Rebels, then they’ve got bigger issues than just costing me tips.

In South Africa, I’m now picking against the Sharks out of spite, for lulling me into tipping them to top the conference in the pre-season. And though teams often come together by the second game on tour, I’m not sure the Reds can repeat last week’s spirit with an even further depleted squad.

Elisha Pearce
Tips: Chiefs, Hurricanes, Highlanders (PP), Brumbies, Stormers, Bulls, Cheetahs.

“Last week the teams I picked upset me greatly, so this week I’m going to play some party games. Let’s have some fun, kids!

“Pin the tail on the donkey first, with the steady yet unspectacular (aka a donkey) match ups of the Bulls versus Sharks and Reds versus Cheetahs. The pin landed on the fleshy Bull and fat-free Cheetah rumps.

“Musical chairs for second place in the New Zealand conference: this week when the music stops I expect the Chiefs to grab a seat and the Highlanders (powerplay) to jump on one too. Yes, a round where two seats were sneakily pulled by the parent on the music. Sorry Blues and Crusaders, it’s a tough game that teaches children how to lose with dignity.

“Charades will take places in Canberra as the Brumbies host the Brumbies-lite Rebels. Both robust, hardworking teams with flaws that are exposed when trying to score points and spread the ball – which version of the act will win? The Brumbies.

“The zombie-Waratahs are going to be wrapped up by the Hurricanes when they play the Mummy Game in Wellington. They almost look real, they have flashed of quality rugby-humanity, but they’re not quite the real thing this year the Tahs, they’re zombie contenders. The Hurricanes are the real deal.

“The Stormers have played two truths and a lie in the last three weeks. They beat the Tahs (truth), lost narrowly to the Canes (truth) and lost to the Highlanders (lie). I’m going to say they’re a better team than those results and will beat the Force for another win on this trip.”

Paddy Effeney
Tips: Chiefs, Waratahs, Highlanders, Brumbies, Stormers (PP), Bulls, Reds.

“This week I’m taking a punt on some Aussie sides in the hope they can bounce back from a categorically awful week last time out. Plus I need to make up some ground on Digger. My Powerplay banker will be the Stormers, who I think can beat the Force.

“Both the Waratahs and the Hurricanes have played just seven games, and I think it’s going to be a great game. I’m going the Tahs, because Digger tips with his heart. Every other mug can see this is their game they have to lose.

“Top of the table again next week!”

Brett’s note: Every other mug has picked the Hurricanes…

The summary

Round 10 Diggercane Patrick Effeney Brett McKay Elisha Pearce Spiro Zavos
Overall 46 44 40 41 44
Last week 4 3 3 3 3
CRU v CHI Crusaders Chiefs Crusaders Chiefs Chiefs
HUR v WAR Hurricanes Waratahs Hurricanes Hurricanes Hurricanes
HIG v BLU Highlanders Highlanders Highlanders Highlanders Highlanders
BRU v REB Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies
FOR v STO Stormers Stormers Stormers Stormers Stormers
SHA v BUL Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls Bulls
CHE v RED Cheetahs Reds Cheetahs Cheetahs Cheetahs
POWERPLAY Brumbies Stormers Hurricanes Highlanders Brumbies
BYE Lions

 

The Crowd Says:

2015-04-19T12:07:19+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Haha! I think the Mad Genius is in the lead, now....

AUTHOR

2015-04-19T04:51:33+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


A mad, mad, constantly texting me since late-arvo Saturday, mad genius.... :mad:

AUTHOR

2015-04-19T04:49:57+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Less. ;-)

2015-04-19T03:06:55+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Miserable. It will clear up soon though ;)

2015-04-19T01:27:34+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


Righto. How's the weather?

2015-04-18T21:13:51+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


It is mad genius, the Effeney Storm has wreaked havoc! :shock:

2015-04-18T14:31:00+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Effeney all over the map. Picks up the PP in Perth, but has to rely on the Reds in Bloemfontein. What manner of mad genius is this Paddy?

2015-04-18T03:20:18+00:00

atlas

Guest


Boos? I've been nz last 10 weeks, fly home today and miss this match, apart from what I've read this forum, and links to nz herald which is the Auckland paper, never actually heard spoken mention re cheika incl at the two referee functions I attended. A non issue here, why some delicate folk got so precious about it ? He's barely known, nz does not have the obsession with cult of the coach that's so prevalent in Oz.

2015-04-18T02:56:48+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Guest


Ha!... no mate, not jealous, good luck to them and digger for today's game ... enjoy the game.

2015-04-18T02:31:25+00:00

Taylorman

Guest


If you can't beat em...join em RT. Plus it's really an undercover mission for the Blues...suss out what their secrets are for the return match...don't tell digger though! :-)

2015-04-18T02:05:40+00:00

Taylorman

Guest


Think you're just being nice Digger. Nothing says the Tahs will win this other than last years efforts. As soon as Cheikas face comes on the screen the boo's will childlessly kick in, even if for something for the crowd to do. You know how that works. And no doubt the TV folks will put him up PLENTY of times. Betcha Cheikas face is up much more than any normal amount of a coach, especially as the Tahs pile the points on. Canes score...Cheikas face...Canes score...Cheikas face...etc. An unbeaten NZ side versus a tenth position oz side coming off a hammering by a travelling side at home? How often do we lose those? Tahs for only their loyalist fans I'm afraid. But if they get up...good on them, for that will make one heck of a match. 12 minimum to the canes I'm picking, probably more.

2015-04-17T17:24:20+00:00

Taylorman

Guest


Yeah no way the Blues will finish last this year. They're better than where they are. Compare them to some sides at pleast they haven't put in any limp one off performances like some... The Sharks, Saders etc on occasion not even in some matches.

2015-04-17T12:51:45+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Jack, Im with you. Go Reds! (with both fingers crossed behind my back) Here's what I fear will happen: - Reds scores 3 tries to zero in 25' 1. Gill wins a TO penalty outfoxing Brussow Brix and Britz at the same time 2. Turner misses the LO kick. 3. WLR runs past the entire forward line, passes to Pretorius who runs past all the Reds backline for 7 points 4. repeat 1-> 3, 4x. Except - missing LO kicks. or missing high bomb, or missing 3 pointer etc, Or Big Kev 'accidentally' gouges both Coiene Oosthuizen's eye balls. Kung foo style: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2t5iblfPIl8

2015-04-17T12:45:29+00:00

Stin

Guest


Yes, but McCutcheon? Put holloway in to someone with some bulk and/or mongrel.

2015-04-17T12:44:02+00:00

Stin

Guest


Come and live in our shed in Sydney - we'll go to some Tahs games. I'll let you mow the lawn for your board and pass bits of Anzac biscuits under the shed door.

2015-04-17T12:39:51+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Hm... all I can say is DC. Brett has jinxed you mate! Better change your tips. hehe.

2015-04-17T12:17:26+00:00

Kia Kaha

Roar Guru


I told you it was an UPSET round, Brett and frankly that's very much how I feel after today's game against the Chiefs. What a (insert word that rhymes with the smallest puppy in the litter)!

2015-04-17T08:45:25+00:00

Oscar Redding

Guest


Genius? No, it's just science Justy, the laws of physical things and chemicals and stuff, mc hammer = e squared and stuff. Facts! Just looking at the facts in search of the truth…. ahhh, balls, I can't lie, it's been a tough season mate, I'd be lucky to be hitting 40% in my tips, my fantasy team is on the slide, Brumbies are busting their ankles and knees and shoulders all at the wrong time and there's still a couple of jokers posting that Pocock should be tried at 6 in gold which makes no sense to me at all, and yeah, I'm having to pick the Tahs!! Tough season mate, really tough!

2015-04-17T08:26:26+00:00

Charl

Guest


"There’s no nice way of putting this: we were rubbish last week" - dunno, Brett, I think that's a nice way to put it ;)

2015-04-17T05:39:01+00:00

Nick Turnbull

Roar Guru


Crusaders, Waratah's, Highlanders, Rebels, Force, Sharks & Reds.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar