Are Melbourne Storming to the 2015 NRL premiership?

By Ryan O'Connell / Expert

If it feels like every NRL season I proclaim that we shouldn’t rule out the Melbourne Storm for the premiership, there is a very good reason: I do pump up the Storm every year.

This year is no different, as the Storm are a serious contender to be playing at ANZ Stadium on Sunday, October 4, and every chance of winning as well.

In fact, I find it amusing and bemusing that some people don’t think the Storm can win the competition this year.

Melbourne are not far removed from their last premiership – a 14-4 win over the Bulldogs in 2012 – and in coach Craig Bellamy and stars Cameron Smith, Cooper Cronk and Billy Slater, they retain the brains trust and spine from that winning team.

Yet, for some strange reason, many people overlooked them as a serious threat this season, with pre-season premiership predictions mainly focussed on the Rabbitohs, Roosters, Bulldogs and Cowboys.

The primary concern with the Storm is that they’re too old, yet this argument doesn’t carry much weight. Smith, Cronk and Slater are all just 31 years of age, which is the prime of their careers, rather than over the hill.

Slater has had some injury concerns over the last season or two, and there is no question that the physicality of the game will eventually take its toll on his relatively small frame. However it’s a bit early to declare his play is in decline – it certainly didn’t appear so earlier in the year.

Meanwhile, Smith and Cronk have been at their precise, detailed and executional best, leading the Storm around the park in the clinical fashion we’ve all grown accustomed to when watching the men in purple play.

All in all, the Storm are still fortunate enough to roll out three of the best players in rugby league, despite any apprehensions about their somewhat advanced age.

In America they’re fond of the saying ‘Father Time is undefeated’, but I don’t think the Storm’s Big Three are too old just yet, even allowing for the extra games they’ve played, courtesy of representative football honours.

Bellamy is also one of the best coaches in the competition, as evidenced by how well prepared the Storm are each and every week, along with their penchant for playing to their strengths – and their opponents’ weaknesses – in almost every single game.

The Storm have three superstars and are extremely well coached; which will always be an extremely dangerous combination.

Yet don’t make the mistake of believing that’s all the Storm are, for it’s the players outside the names I’ve already mentioned that should give Melbourne fans confidence that their boys are ready to add another premiership trophy to their impressive cabinet.

(Enter your salary cap gibes here.)

Melbourne’s depth of quality players has always been questioned, but Bellamy has traditionally been able to take players that other teams didn’t want, and make them valuable contributors to the Storm.

Jason Ryles, anyone?

Having watched the Storm play this season though, it’s not a case of them running out a number of players rescued off the scrap heap. The supporting cast includes representative players like Jesse Bromwich, Ryan Hinchcliffe, Will Chambers, Kevin Proctor and Tohu Harris.

Meanwhile, there are a number of talented youngsters who have really found their feet this season. Jordan McLean (23), Cameron Munster (20), Dale Finucane (23) and Felise Kaufusi (22) have all had very good games for the Storm. Though Melbourne’s star core will be almost impossible to replace, it’s always heartening to have young players performing.

Even rampaging, in-form winger Marika Koroibete – he of the 95-metre try against the Cowboys, and 80-metre try against the Warriors – is still just 22 years of age.

Perhaps I’m stuck in a time warp, but I even think ex-Kangaroos prop Tom Learoyd-Lahrs still has serious NRL impact left in him. After all, if anyone can help write another chapter in the big forward’s career, it’s Bellamy.

Talent, depth, experience and youth. Exactly what every club desires, and exactly what Melbourne has.

State of Origin has often put pressure on the club, as they lose a number of their stars during the representative period. Even when said players return, they’re sometimes a little emotionally and physically drained – or even injured – and can therefore take some time to re-adjust to NRL football again.

How the Storm respond to this period will be crucial.

Though with some solid depth this year, combined with the talent of the Big Three and the mastery of their coach, I’d feel pretty comfortable wagering on the Storm to be smiling come the end of the season.

The Crowd Says:

2015-04-25T03:12:36+00:00

Breathalyser

Guest


Niall have you ever watched a game of league? You have no idea.

2015-04-22T20:41:08+00:00

Walter Penninger

Roar Guru


Storm have been very impressive but for mine the Cowboys although so far erratic have the team which can run over all other contenders.

2015-04-22T10:29:03+00:00

Muzz

Guest


I guess we'll have to wait and see.

AUTHOR

2015-04-22T10:10:18+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


I certainly think Smith can recapture the same form, and I think Cronk's best form could still be in front of him. Slater would be my only concern, yet ironically, he looked the best out of the three to start the season! Plus, I'm not ruling out a switch to 6 in the later stages of his career, which may change the way we look at Slater anyway. Having said all that, The Big Three are the point I was making anyway. My point is the Storm are loaded with talent elsewhere, and it would shock me little to see them with the title this year (and next), despite whether there Big Three are considered in their prime, past their prime, or three prime numbers carrying a bucket load of fish to bring home to their pregnant bandicoot wizards. Or something!

2015-04-22T09:57:24+00:00

Muzz

Guest


Unless you think they can recapture that same or better form, you'd have to concede that their best years are behind them and therefore past their prime. Andrew Johns stated that a RL players prime is between the age of 25 - 29. I tend to agree!

2015-04-22T09:26:03+00:00

Alex L

Roar Rookie


Muzz, you realise that Smith played the majority of last year with an injured ankle that ended up requiring surgery? He's playing vastly better this year.

AUTHOR

2015-04-22T09:18:58+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


Without looking at any stats, I'd say Smith has performed slightly lower, Cronk significantly lower, and Slater - before he got injured - almost on par.

2015-04-22T09:09:00+00:00

Muzz

Guest


Ryan, "so i'm not sure what your arguing about" Smith, Slater and Cronk have had illustrious careers. Have they (in the first 7 rounds) performed at the same level or better than back in 2012 when the Storm won the premiership?

2015-04-22T08:03:55+00:00

Muzz

Guest


Systemic!

AUTHOR

2015-04-22T07:12:16+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


Finally! A salary cap joke!

2015-04-22T06:51:24+00:00

Muzz

Guest


The team that's leading the comp were "clearly robbed" lol Thank's for the laugh, Angus. We all know what the Storms DNA is made of hence * in the record books : ) Let's see how well the Storm are placed around September when the old 3 start to feel the pinch.

2015-04-22T05:45:19+00:00

Crosscoder

Roar Guru


Consistency has to be applied to the Storm.When they have lost games,it has been by a point or two,nothing more this year. Bellamy can grab a hard working back from elsewhere ,such as Green and turn him in to a vital part of the team's backline.He does it with just about every player you can think of. That puts the team,well in contention for the walk around the field at full time of the G/F holding the trophy.At the same time the Melbourne press would have to be a little more forthcoming for the team making the G/F ,once more. You can throw a blanket over at least a dozen of the remaining sides to have the capacity to make the top 4. Looking at the points table,one suggests confidently,this year is one of the most competitive on record,and the standard in many cases up on 2014 for many of the game.Getting rid of the wrestle to a degree plays its part . If the Sharks don't make the G/F would love to see a Cows v Storm G/F.Cows for the last two years ,were stymied by reffing errors.To see Thurston gutted twice was just too much.

2015-04-22T05:20:52+00:00

Jeannine wallace

Guest


Hey thanks Kirk... Wasn't watching in 2005 but I have to do some footy research...Oh actually that was the last time the west Tigers won a grand final!

2015-04-22T05:10:16+00:00

eagleJack

Roar Guru


Storm are playing very well, and will again be there or thereabouts when the whips are cracking. They are a quality football side. But saying they were "clearly robbed" against Manly and the Cowboys is a little subjective. Sure they had crucial calls go against them. But so do most teams throughout a match. They certainly weren't the biggest howlers of 2015. If the Storm score against Manly in the first half, do they go onto win? Who knows, I don't have a crystal ball. The complexion of a game changes so much with every call and non-call. To label a side as being clearly robbed from an incorrect call in the first half is not accurate.

2015-04-22T04:57:28+00:00

Angus

Guest


Muzz...have you watched any of the Storm's games this year....methinks not. I'm with Scott and Ryan...and the majority Roarers. Totally agree with Scotts comment..."Very harsh mate….the Storm are leading the comp, were clearly “robbed” against Manly and the Cowboys so could be an extra 4 points clear, and they just defeated the Roosters without Billy Slater while Cooper Cronk played injured"...well said Scott!!! about sums it up don't you think Muzz?

2015-04-22T04:50:09+00:00

Carlos

Guest


why?

2015-04-22T04:12:38+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Muzz, How do they agree with you Muzz? They are single digit figures and would be shorter if the Roosters and Souths were not so heavily committed before round 1. I suggest you go and look at their run home this year.

AUTHOR

2015-04-22T02:52:34+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


At 31, I would suggest you're still in the prime of your career. Form, however, can fluctuate throughout your career, regardless of whether you're just starting, just finishing, or in your 'prime'. All three have probably had better form in their careers, but that doesn't mean they're not in their prime. As for Smith, I hope you're not basing his 'decline' on just one game from last year? A game in round 25 of a season in which he played a World Cup, Origin and a full season of NRL? I've watched Smith this year, and it's not the best he's ever played, but he'd still be one of the top 2 or 3 at his position. At least. I don't think any of them have declined that much, and if you're saying they're worthy of rep honours, then you must think they are still 3 of the best players in the comp. So I'm not really sure what we're arguing about?!

2015-04-22T02:17:36+00:00

Muzz

Guest


If your aged 31 and in your "prime" surely you should be in or around career best form. Right? Watch the Storms 2014 round 25 game and you'll see 2 very "uncharacteristic" tired like errors form Smith which swung the games momentum and ultimately cost them the game. Speed may not be their weapon, however as a players speed, agility and reaction time naturally declines so does their form. I'm not suggesting that there still not worthy of rep honours.They just simply aren't the players they use to be.

AUTHOR

2015-04-22T01:56:06+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


When did I say they're in career best form? Nope, I don't recall all the 'uncharacteristic errors' from Smith late last year. Slater may have lost a step, but I don't think the other two have. And speed has never been either of those two player's major weapons anyway.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar