It's time for Phipps to get game smart

By David Lord / Expert

Michael Cheika is the best appointment in Australian rugby since Rod Macqueen.

They are kindred spirits – Macqueen from Green Rat territory, Cheika a Galloping Green – both from opposite sides of the harbour, with the same rugby blood flowing through their veins.

The difference is those players under Macqueen embraced his doctrine to win the max – Rugby World Cup, Bledisloe Cup, Tri-Nations, and beating the British and Irish Lions.

Those under Cheika have the same ability, but have they got the same rugby nous?

The jury is out.

The same applies to the Waratahs with Cheika wearing two hats.

And unless the Waratahs snap out of their malaise, they haven’t a hope in hell of retaining their Super Rugby crown that took 19 years of pain and disappointment to achieve.

Wasteful.

The time to start is tonight at the nib Stadium in Perth against the Force.

The scene is set with the Waratahs on 31 points from seven wins and three losses to the Force’s 11 points from one win and 10 losses, the win was against the Waratahs in the first round 23-15 when the champions were off the planet.

Time to even the books with a bonus point.

All the ingredients are there with the Waratahs boasting 492 Test caps to the Force’s 63.

It should be one-way traffic if the Waratahs get their act together and stop waiting for things to happen instead of making them happen.

Up front only second-string hooker Tolu Latu is not an international, while in the backs only winger Taqele Naiyarovoro hasn’t played for his country.

So what’s the problem, there’s enough international ammunition on board to win every game by plenty?

Let’s kick off with the pack, bristling with seven Wallabies, It should be a given they win at least 60 per cent possession, providing they give quick service to a crack backline – on paper.

But the forwards don’t take command as they should, with the problem magnified by Nick Phipps.

He’s quite capable of being a world class halfback, but he only shows that quality spasmodically.

The rest of the time he’s pedestrain servicing his backline. How many times does the referee bark “use it” as Phipps looks at the ball just sitting there pleading to be delivered.

Then the passing problem, a cocktail of too slow, too high, too much behind support, with the odd pass bouncing along the deck, placing enormous pressure on Bernard Foley who of sheer necessity tries to get rid of the ball, invariably putting pressure on Kurtley Beale.

And that scene is magnified right along the backline, until it gets to Adam Ashley-Cooper who more often than not dies with it.

Yet there are two excellent finishing wingers in Rob Horne and train-wreck Naiyarovoro, with Israel Folau out the back catching pneumonia while waiting impatiently for some action instead of just chasing or defending.

It all starts with Phipps, and that inlcudes feeding the scrum quicker to ease the pressure on his front row.

The Waratahs won the Super Rugby last year because of quick possession from their forwards, and the magic undestanding between Foley, Beale and Folau.

We could count on one hand the number of times that has been repeated this season in 10 games.

Wasteful.

The Waratahs are the best team in the tourament, but if they can’t embrace the Cheika doctrine more often and more readily, then the Wallabies won’t either. And there goes the Rugby World Cup.

While I’m calling on Nick Phipps to get game smart, it’s because all the major pluses of the Cheika doctine stem from him.

But in all fairness, the get game smart can apply to every Waratah in their own responsibility and territory.

I have no doubts the Wallabies can win a record third Rugby World Cup, but only if they follow Michael Cheika’s words of wisdom to the letter.

Seeing there are 13 Wallabies in the Waratahs starting line-up, how about starting tonight?

The Crowd Says:

2015-05-11T04:21:02+00:00

GDayMate

Roar Rookie


I'll gladly take a halfback who can't kick and knows it. That way he won't be tempted to. Smith, White, Genia all fancy themselves, all telegraph their intentions and all put up dud kicks. The 9's box kick belongs in the past.

2015-05-11T02:41:14+00:00

Mark

Guest


I was starting to think I was the only one noticing how poor Nick Phipps has been playing this season! He is error prone, with erratic passing and poor decision making putting the rest of the side under so much pressure. Cheika needs to bench him quickly, he is costing the Tahs games!

2015-05-11T01:09:57+00:00

Dwayne Johnson

Guest


Well said lol.

2015-05-11T01:09:04+00:00

Dwayne Johnson

Guest


Kirk, Straun, Bachop, Marshall, Kelleher and Smith. How lucky we are to have been blessed with such depth! Long may it continue...

2015-05-10T03:35:38+00:00

Bunyip

Guest


Who’s game to say the Rebels halves should be the Wallaby pair? I am

2015-05-10T01:27:08+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


We shall see I suppose Pete Burke and Herbert are pretty strong benchmarks

2015-05-09T23:42:11+00:00

Bfc

Guest


"Not sure everyone would agree..."....99.9% pure gold!

2015-05-09T22:20:57+00:00

Machpants

Guest


Best team in the comp ... A Tui advert right there

2015-05-09T13:41:32+00:00

Squirrel

Roar Rookie


Phipps is useless, how have halves become so pathetic

2015-05-09T13:09:20+00:00

Who?

Guest


Exactly. And talk about drawing long bows - if there was anyone truly ripe to be Macqueen's heir, wouldn't it have been Link..? His pupil at the Tahs in 91/92, his selection at the Brumbies in 96/97, moving to be an assistant under Macqueen's successor Eddie Jones? Macqueen innovated, Link tinkered, Cheika says, "We'll play our way, stuff 'em!" So what happened tonight? They played their way, and were nullified... By a team that hasn't managed to beat any other team all year. Take off the blue glasses Mr Lord.

2015-05-09T12:15:28+00:00

Farmer

Guest


Once again Phipps stuffs up and puts his team under real pressure in tonightd game against the Force. This time at the 68 minute mark with a fumble anf knock on at the base of a ruck 40 meters out and on the attack. Ended up a 22 dropout at the other end.

2015-05-09T12:14:30+00:00

Stu. B.

Guest


David please note and give us a big write up on your Tahs this coming week,yea they got your bonus point?

2015-05-09T11:30:50+00:00

riddler

Guest


Sorry breakdown. . Some of the names in that 99-01 era will be forever remembered as our best.. From this group..??

2015-05-09T10:09:39+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


I'm a big Tahs fan however Phipps and Foley are not our best halves combo. They are a handy back up combo but we won't win a RWC if these guys are our starting halves. I like Phipps motor, energy and toughness however his service is erratic whilst he has no kicking game. This puts a lot of pressure on Foleys already pop gun kicking game.

2015-05-09T08:05:20+00:00

Mike

Guest


"An actor is a guy who if you ain't talking about him, he ain['t listening" - M. Brando. Just substitute Cheika is what I hear you saying...

2015-05-09T07:36:56+00:00

Think

Guest


If you keep doing the same thing and expect a different result? Who's game to say the Rebels halves should be the Wallaby pair? They are the most effective and inform pair in Aus Rugby, and the 10 has an unruffled boot 20 m longer than anybody in Aus consistently. It helps to play the game in the oppositions end yeh?

2015-05-09T06:07:06+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


you are comparing players early in their career to players who have finished. I considered the players at about the same stage in their career. The current players are all youngish and their best is still ahead of them.

2015-05-09T06:02:33+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Thanks David, It's the pack, who needs to deliver consistently. Also, Im not sure everyone will agree the Tahs are the best team in SR.

2015-05-09T05:50:59+00:00

RobC

Roar Guru


Not sure about the last two, esp last one

2015-05-09T05:10:56+00:00

levelheaded

Guest


I'm not a fan jameswm, great re Waratahs, but I want a Coach my son will be inspired by and aspire to possibly be. I don't condone abusing cameraman, punching holes in walls and leading by fear- it may get short term results, but how long is the damage.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar