2015 AFL finals: A history of this week’s semi-finals

By T.W. Cougan / Roar Rookie

Delving into the past history of this week’s semi-finalists it is evident that the respective opponents have had their fair share of memorable matches and player movement.

MORE AFL FINALS:
>> WHO WILL WIN THE SEMI FINALS?
>> HAWKS V CROWS PREVIEW & PREDICTION
>> SWANS V NORTH PREVIEW & PREDICTION
>> FINALS FORECAST: HAWKS V CROWS
>> THE X-FACTOR FINALS PLAYERS
>> AN ALL WA GRAND FINAL?
>> EXPERT TIPS
>> HOW TO WATCH THE SEMI-FINALS

Hawthorn versus Adelaide

Round 1, 1991
It did not take long for Adelaide and Hawthorn to produce a memorable result between each other. A Friday night match at Football Park to open the 1991 season saw the Jarman brothers, Andrew and Darren, playing each other as Adelaide sought to take on the highly successful Hawthorn side in the Crow’s first AFL game.

The match finished in a stunning 86-point upset win to the home side but would prove to be a false dawn for both teams as the Crows ended the season in ninth place while the Hawks went all the way winning the premiership.

First elimination final, 2007
Lance Franklin, if he wasn’t already on the map as a star of the competition, was well and truly in this category after his remarkable performance in his debut final against Adelaide in 2007. The Crows had led at every change in this contest but Franklin’s seven goals, including the final goal of the day to put Hawthorn in front, broke Crow hearts as the Hawks saluted by three points.

First preliminary final, 2012
The 2012 preliminary final looked a miss-match on paper. The Hawks had been flying and motivated by the preliminary final loss of 2011 were short-priced favourites. Adelaide took a half-time lead but the Hawks fought back in a gripping contest. Kurt Tippett added extra weight to his soon-to-be-controversial Sydney contract with a huge four-goal, 11-mark display, but it was the Hawks that held off a fast finishing Crows to win by five points.

Player movement
As previously touched upon the player that stands out between these two clubs is Darren Jarman having won a flag in 1991 with the Hawks and then starring in Adelaide’s back-to-back grand final wins in 1997 and 1998.

In more modern times the move of a homesick Jack Gunston at the end of 2011 proved a controversial one. Gunston won the Crow’s best young player award at the end of 2011 but his decision to leave the club was not taken well by Adelaide hierarchy and he was stripped of this award. His departure has come to hurt the Crows as Gunston has gone on to play an important role in Hawthorn’s back-to-back flags in 2013 and 2014.

Sydney versus North Melbourne

Grand final, 1996
The Centenary grand final of 1996 pitted the Swans and Kangaroos up each other in the biggest games these clubs have faced each other in. The Swans, in their first grand final since 1945, were riding a wave of emotion having famously made the grand final on the back of Tony Lockett’s famous point in the preliminary final.

The Roos, under Dennis Pagan and Wayne Carey, had built a side that could contend year after year. Pre-game if Carey had kicked one goal while Tony Lockett kicked six you would have said Sydney would be premiers. However while the Swans were able to jump out to an early lead it was North Melbourne on the back of Glenn Archer’s Norm Smith Medal winning performance who would win the premiership receiving a Centenary inspired gold cup.

Round 19, 2004
The Round 19 clash between North Melbourne and Sydney in 2004 provided one of the more memorable games these two sides have played. Playing in Glenn Archer’s 250th match the Swans were unstoppable for three quarters jumping out to what seemed an unassailable 40-point lead by the last break.

However the Roos of this era were particularly renowned for their Shinboner Spirit. North were able to chip away at the lead until Corey Jones, the beneficiary of a deliberate out of bounds decision, kicked his third and sealed one of the club’s great comeback victories.

First preliminary final, 2014
The first preliminary final of 2014 turned out to be a one-sided Swans-dominated contest. Having won the minor premiership, Sydney stormed into the grand final as Franklin and Tippet combined for nine goals. The damage could have been far greater if the Swans had kicked straight having 41 scoring shots to the Kangaroos 20. This game will no doubt still be in minds of many Roos players as they line up for their chance at redemption at the same venue this week.

Player movement
The best example from these two sides occurred at the end of 1997 when Shannon Grant (who had played in 1996 grand final for Sydney) moved to North Melbourne and Wayne Schwass (who had played in the 1996 grand final for North Melbourne) moved to Sydney.

The trade can can be seen as a win for both sides. Grant went onto to win a premiership and Norm Smith Medal in 1999, a best and fairest award (2001) and All-Australian honours (2005) for the Kangaroos. While Schwass was able to carve a career for himself in Sydney providing invaluable leadership for the Swans as he won a best and fairest (1999) and All-Australian honours (1999).

This weekend’s match-ups will add further weight to these burgeoning rivalries and will hopefully give the players and fans of the respective teams many more memorable moments to reminisce.

The Crowd Says:

2015-09-19T01:01:41+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


The Swans seem certain to end the contract a year early and it appears the AFL is supportive - and so too the NSW Govt. Especially given the desires now for the Govt to buy out the venue and re-configure it and try to re-invent it as a top level rectangular venue.

2015-09-17T10:39:57+00:00

bart

Guest


Pretty clear fans don't like it and you can hardly blame them, i would be more content to watch the game from a pub around the SCG such as the Courthouse or from the couch at home. Would get a full house at the SCG or close to it, just crazy stuff from the AFL.

2015-09-17T10:16:55+00:00

Mark

Guest


I've heard only 27,000 tickets have been sold. A shame considering it's the last time Shaw plays in Sydney and possibly the same for probably the second greatest Swa of all time (no one gets past Bob). I know there's bad weather predicted but I guarantee it would be a near sell-out already if it was at our true home ground. Tear up the contract a year early!

2015-09-17T05:46:20+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


I recall the weather had been somewhat ordinary in the lead up to that match too. re the history - North hosted the Swannees in Round 6 2008, the Anzac day weekend. The game ended in a draw, NM 9.10.64 to Syd 8.16.64. A tick over 28,000 attended - and with about a minute to go the Swans found themselves with 19 on the field - the blame being laid on first gamer Jesse White. By virtue of the draw - these teams faced each other in the elim - having finished 6th and 7th and on 50 pts each. The Swans with a superior percentage (112.5 to 97). A win to the Swans would've seen them into 5th and host Collingwood - perhaps not ideal as the Pies from 8th travelled to Adelaide and downed 5th placed Crows by 31 pts.

AUTHOR

2015-09-17T05:04:05+00:00

T.W. Cougan

Roar Rookie


North Melbourne and Sydney also played in an Elimination Final in 2008 with the Swans running out 35 point winners in Shannon Grant's last game. The crowd at ANZ that night was just 19,127 but you can expect a much better turnout this Saturday night!

2015-09-17T00:04:14+00:00

Brian

Guest


You can add in 1993 for Hawthorn v Adelaide. Back then the AFL Finals first week was 1 v 2, 3 v 6 and 4 v 5. Now if 3 beat 6 it got to play the winner of 1 v 2 in a major semi-final with the loser of 1 v 2 playing the other winner in an elimination final. However as it was 6th placed West Coast flogged 3rd placed North Melb on Saturday, however having come 6th West Coast only qualified for the elimination final the next weekend against the loser of 1 v 2 (Essendon). That meant (4th placed) Hawthorn full of 5 time premiership stars hosted (5th placed) Adelaide at the MCG with the winner going straight to a major semi-final. It was Adelaide's first ever Final. The stakes were massive when you consider the winner would get 2 chances to make the Grand Final and the loser was out. The Crows overran an inaccurate Hawthorn who kicked 13.17 and won by 15 points. It was the end of the era of arguably the greatest ever team Hawthorn 80s early 90s and Adelaide only Finals win until the back to back premierships of 1997 and 1998

Read more at The Roar