Rugby World Cup 2015: Assessment after three rounds

By KiwiDave / Roar Guru

Almost every team at the 2015 Rugby World Cup have played three matches, and we are now in the homeward stretch of the pool stages.

Here is an assessment of the pools so far.

Pool A
After their great win over England the week before, Wales followed up with a narrow victory over Fiji. While they may have a few injury concerns to date, they seem to have the depth to overcome it.

With the pressure of a nation on them, England folded like a deck of cards and meekly bowed out the tournament.

Australia and – in particular their scrum – look great and they showed the sort of form needed to not just make it out the pool of death but to take the Cup home.

Along with South Africa, they are arguably the form team of the competition.

Special mention goes to Foley who was unbelievable. His brilliant individual performance was reminiscent of Carter in 2005 against the Lions. Australia and Wales will square off at Twickenham with the loser to face South Africa and the winner a date with Scotland or Japan.

Australia must be favoured to win this match but Wales have had an extra two days to prepare. Despite both of them qualifying already, the stakes are still very high with the winner avoiding the All Black and South Africa side of the draw.

Pool B
After being shocked by Japan, South Africa have gone on a rampage disposing of Samoa and Scotland with ease. Along with the Wallabies, they have the best form of the tournament so far.

Japan struggled against Scotland on a short back up but easily disposed of Samoa with the clinical skill you would find with the better sides. This team is the real deal and the South African game is beginning to look less like a fluke now.

They should dispose of the US without much trouble. Samoa has been a disappointment but if they click against Scotland and upset them this would mean Japan would make the quarters.

South Africa will top this group and although the heart would love to see Japan qualify, I think Scotland will account for Samoa.

Pool C
The All Blacks continue to win as expected in this group but their form is terrible. They went 50 minutes against Georgia B where they could only manage one try.

Their game is riddled with errors at the moment. The high standards they set themselves have been missing this tournament, with the exception of the second half against Argentina.

On current form, they will struggle to win a quarter final and are favourite on reputation only, because the form is not there. Despite the brave opening loss, Argentina have looked the better team of this group since.

Impressive wins over Georgia and Tonga have seen them lock down second spot. As predicted by everyone this group will go to the All Blacks from Argentina

Pool D
After cruising to easy wins over minnows in the open two rounds and having everyone rave about them, Ireland faced their toughest test to date against Italy. They got a real fright, scraping in by 7 points.

The bubble has burst. Despite being the most fancied northern hemisphere side, there are big questions being asked about how much of a contender they realistically are.

France have been going along nicely and look set for a big one. Putting a line through the France versus Italy game, they have the better form going into their big clash with the Irish.

Again massive stakes are on the line for these teams. The winner will play Argentina and the loser get the All Blacks. Ironically, France has a better record against the All Blacks than against Argentina so they might prefer the All Blacks. For Ireland the opposite is true, they have a dismal record against the All Blacks but a useful one versus Argentina.

Not sure how to pick this group, but I think Ireland might just edge France.

Australia versus Scotland and Ireland versus Argentina on one side of the draw. New Zealand versus France and South Africa versus Wales on the other side.

The Crowd Says:

2015-10-06T15:09:57+00:00

Derm

Roar Guru


Oh I have already as I see them beating Australia in the quarters, a tight win against France in the semis before overpowering Argentina with a barrage of penalty kicks in the final....

2015-10-06T03:01:10+00:00

Paul Kruger

Roar Pro


talk about confidence! i prefer the cautiously optimistic approach but your level of assurance is uncanny. as i've mentioned i thought we looked unconvincing against scotland. here's hoping we can kick things up a notch against the yanks and get some momentum going into the knockout rounds. however, i think that aus delivered a master class against england. nz is a black mamba waiting to strike do not be deceived.

2015-10-06T02:58:41+00:00

Paul Kruger

Roar Pro


we failed miserably on that front in 2011, brussow was supposed to be the man to mark pocock but when he went off so did our plan. however, that match is a blight on the history of the game and i shall discuss it no further. i do believe nz can shut down anything, which is why they will win. anyone that thinks otherwise is smoking peyote.

AUTHOR

2015-10-06T01:22:58+00:00

KiwiDave

Roar Guru


You should avail yourself of the $8.50 on offer for them if that's the case.

2015-10-06T01:00:02+00:00

Derm

Roar Guru


It's obvious that South Africa are now the favourites for the lifting the trophy once they got their bad match out of the way, they are the form team across all the pools. Australia got lucky against an England side that got stage fright. They were so-so against Fiji. New Zealand have flattered to deceive but will probably make the semi-finals. That's about it really. South Africa have one hand on the cup already - just 3 real matches to go.

AUTHOR

2015-10-06T00:31:17+00:00

KiwiDave

Roar Guru


NZ can shut down Pocock/Hooper. Nothing gets Richie going better than people saying Pocock is better than him and the best player in the world. Not sure about South Africa as they couldn't stop him in 2011.

AUTHOR

2015-10-06T00:27:53+00:00

KiwiDave

Roar Guru


South Africa made dumb choices against Japan. They opted to go for tries instead of taking easy penalties and building a cushion. They underestimated a team that has improved leaps and bounds in world rugby. People need to stop thinking Japan are some easy beat B side. They have a host of great super 15 players in their squad, a world class coach and enough kiwi imports in the right positions to spook sides. They don't have much depth as was evident by the B squad they put against Scotland but their best 15 are a handful

2015-10-05T20:32:06+00:00

hopalong

Guest


Hi Paul.Love it when we are damned with faint praise, No journalistic gushing when we play.. N.Z,.OZ,France,Wales (and yea,even Ireland) and up to a few days ago England are touted as being the overwhelming favourites to win the cup.Talk of stuttering wins,playing B teams and dumbplay proliferate when we are written about,.. Stay under the radar boys.

2015-10-05T20:22:58+00:00

Colm

Roar Guru


I'm not sure Ireland are the myth here Harry. Ireland play badly and still beat a fired up Italian team, South Africa play badly and loose to Japan.

2015-10-05T20:04:46+00:00

Rt

Guest


Memo to all SA fans, we are not going for the underdog "we are just making up the numbers" line. Not biting, swallowing, accepting, agreeing, approving, conceding or even acknowledging the possibility of that snow job. Sorry just not doin' it.

2015-10-05T19:22:20+00:00

Paul Kruger

Roar Pro


Cant agree with the Boks being considered one of the in form teams. We looked unconvincing against Scotland- poor discipline, crucial handling errors and not enough wide ball. Oz look like a powerhouse at the moment. Unless a team can neutralize the pocock hooper combo aus will continue to run amock. The darkness will step up when the need arises- too much mental strength and self belief

2015-10-05T19:15:06+00:00

Taylorman

Guest


Sorry Harry, it's not working, in fact I'd say the Boks are probably the number one side at the moment, the rest about thirty stories lower. NZ is in the basement, but looking for the lift. Oz are abseiling 'up' the side. Funny thing for me is no ones really been hurt by the refs, so kudos to them. Agree with Argie...seasons in the RC has directly contributed to this effort. I see them on the semis, or even final.

2015-10-05T19:03:06+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Thanks. I'd rank OZ as the form team. NZ winning without pushing themselves much. Ireland a bit of a myth in my book. ARG is my dark horse. SA is huge underdogs and is lucky bonus points were invented. (But KO rugby is a funny thing....... don't be too surprised if SA gets lucky vs Wales and NZ).

Read more at The Roar