Don't write Scotland off just yet

By Alex Wood / Roar Guru

Bloodied, battered and beaten half to death, Stephen Moore and his magnificent Wallabies have emerged from Pool A – the infamous Pool of Death – victorious and undefeated.

Having had our cruel and autocratic ruler World Rugby send our gladiators into the arena to face what, at one point, looked like certain death they have conquered men from across the globe – as far afield as Fiji, Wales and the old foe England.

And while Sam Warburton and Wales too survived the bloodbath, they will now face another Herculean task, back-to-back finals against the Springboks and should they survive that, they will most likely face the All Blacks.

Australia meanwhile earned an extra day of rest, along with it the right to walk the ‘easy’ road to the final – Scotland in the quarters and then either Ireland or Argentina the week after.

Based on the way this has been broadly reported in the media, a casual observer could be forgiven for thinking that the Northern Hemisphere side of the draw is paved with satin and edged by angels holding bouquets tied in tickets to the World Cup final.

David Lord has predicted an Australia versus New Zealand final and in the process a faux-Grand Slam along the way.

Amazingly, even the power rankings in the New Zealand Herald have the Wallabies edging the All Blacks as tournament favourites, even before that marvellous victory against Wales in the final match of Pool A.

From professional to pundit and in pub banter all over the country it seems that everyone is tipping Australia to make it to the final and earn a shot at the trophy.

And they have a point.

Scotland only edged Samoa, ranked 15th in the world, by 3 points. Hooker Ross Ford and lock Jonny Gray have subsequently been suspended for dangerous play and will not take part in the upcoming match.

Ireland, the predicted semi-final opponent, have even bigger problems. An injury toll that would make even the cursed Welsh green with envy, and the suspension of breakaway Sean O’Brien for striking, means that three key players will be missing from their starting pack.

Blindside flanker Peter O’Mahoney has done his knee. Paul O’Connell, the captain and soul of the Irish team, has ruined his hamstring sufficiently to ensure that he’ll likely never play international rugby again.

As if losing O’Connell wasn’t enough, to add injury to insult and injury, star flyhalf Johnny Sexton has sustained a groin injury and though it appears that he will play whether or not he is 100 per cent remains to be seen.

That is that then. Australia’s band of merry men will skip along satin paved path to the final, collect their tickets from the angels and simply fill up the William Webb Ellis trophy with champagne on arrival. They will earn themselves a place in Rugby Heaven as they cross the speedhump of the best All Black team to have ever donned the uniform.

No.

Not at all.

Not even close.

Rugby is a game for the humble. And while the Wallabies have come through Pool A looking like potential champions, let’s not forget how close the matches were.

Any match played to within such a fine margin can go to either team on the day. It is more likely that one will win than others, but I would have loved to see someone try to explain that to South Africa after their first Pool match or the All Blacks in 2007 after they were beaten by France.

A poor decision by the referee can leave a team down a man for 10 minutes at a crucial moment in the match or, heaven forbid, the entire match as happened to Welsh captain Sam Warburton just 17 minutes into their semi with France in 2011. Even a couple of ill-considered penalties might have been enough to see Wales topple Australia just a few short days ago – so aren’t we getting a bit ahead of ourselves?

And have any of the pundits who are so assured of a Wallaby victory ever seen a rugby ball? It’s a bastard of a thing. Not even really a ball at all if you look at it closely, more like the shape of a lemon or lime. Sometimes it just doesn’t bounce your way, as the time honored post-match cliché goes, and that can be the difference between losing by three or a try in the corner.

Of course, as Christopher Roche so aptly described this week, luck – be it born from referee or roll of the ball – is in truth a product of hard work. The challenge now is that the Wallabies must not do what we all seem to have done and read too much of their own press.

Scotland and Ireland are both proud rugby nations, and on a given day are capable of beating any team in the world. In fact Australia has lost to Scotland on two of the last three occasions that the teams have competed.

It is possible too that the wounded Irish will not beat Argentina, another prematurely assumed outcome. Form is harder to judge when it comes to the Argie, off the back of a less challenging pool. However, they certainly gave the All Blacks a fright and that on its own is enough to demand that they be respected.

Fortunately, it is the neither the job of the media nor the fans to manage the mental state and humility of the players. That comes down to coach Michael Cheika.

Inexperience aside, from the outside the signs are good. Cheika is starting to look like he could be a special coach, cast in the image of Vince Lombardi, a true motivator of men.

He has given the team direction and restored pride in the jersey. It’s amazing when you watch the player interviews closely just how deeply ingrained the goals and reasons for them seem to have been ingrained.

Recently I was able to have a brief chat with Stephen Moore, Scott Fardy and Will Skelton at a corporate event and it was clear speaking to each of them that Cheika has made sure they all know why they pull on the jersey. To make their family proud and for the man next to them are the recurring themes.

However, at the point end of the tournament it only takes 80 sub-par minutes to make sure you’re out for another four years. The Scots are a proud nation and even without Ford and Gray, like the Brave Blossoms before them, they will be playing for their lives. They have nothing to lose and everything to gain and that can be enough in a game of rugby.

Australia too have injury problems. Both their most influential back and most influential forward are set to sit out this game on the sideline.

Both sides of the draw promise to provide some spectacular rugby over the next couple of weeks, and at this point nothing can be granted. It seems like every single Wallaby player has said it at one time or another, at this point we can only look at our next opponent – and right now that is Scotland.

Please, oh mighty gods of the rugby universe, please let us beat the Scots on Monday morning and I’ll never ask you for anything again – I promise.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2015-10-18T16:56:58+00:00

Alex Wood

Roar Guru


Having just watched the most stressful game of rugby I have ever seen, I feel somewhat vindicated in writing this article.

2015-10-18T14:34:24+00:00


Hell, the Springboks are letting the SH down.

2015-10-18T14:28:19+00:00

ThePope

Roar Rookie


With Scotland vs Australia to come, so far the quarters have given us this to ponder over. Arg 4 tries Ire 2 NZ 9 tries Fra 1 RSA 1 try Wal 1 try Rugby Championship 14 tries Six Nations 4 tries

2015-10-18T12:00:56+00:00

ScotandProud

Guest


Its not the balance of the back row, its the quality of the player.. Hooper Fardy and Mcalman are the better back row - fullstop

2015-10-18T11:02:04+00:00

Muzzo

Guest


There's just the one "but" from me Chook............... But the Wallabies will win, & I think fairly comfortably. I won't say good luck, due to they are good enough to win without it.. Cheers

2015-10-18T10:43:47+00:00

Riddler

Guest


Am hoping for mccalman to step up big time.. Has had some great cameos.. Now would. Like to see a dominating starting performance..

AUTHOR

2015-10-18T09:34:24+00:00

Alex Wood

Roar Guru


Interesting if Australia is not playing a true fetcher at all, though Fardy and McCalman have both been fairly strong over the ball in patches. Hopefully they can cause the Scots sufficient trouble in this area.

2015-10-18T08:06:49+00:00

Cliff (Bishkek)

Guest


Here goes the Kiwi again - too dumb and too stupid to understand the sarcasm. And the joke of "tongue in cheek"!!

2015-10-18T07:41:51+00:00

riddler

Guest


the scots have selected two fetchers at 6 and 7.. very interesting move by cotter.. the breakdown is going to be a tough battle..

2015-10-18T05:22:55+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


Yea but soft...

2015-10-18T03:43:42+00:00

wardad

Guest


You dont know much about Robbie Deans do you ? Have you heard any vindictive lashing out from him ? The same Deans who did his utmost to get the Wallabies a RWC . Bloody nonsense .

2015-10-18T02:22:22+00:00

WEST

Roar Guru


The Wallabies’ breakdown terminator Peacock can change a game in a heartbeat with a moment of muscular thieving, just as Israel Folau can alter a match’s momentum with a quicksilver slalom. So the loss of the pair to injury could not help but shine a different complexion on the quarter-final at Twickenham. Australia’s record with and without David Pocock since he made his debut against New Zealand in Hong Kong on 1 Nov, 2008. Australia’s record in all matches which Pocock has played, 2008-2015: 53 matches: 34 wins, 18 losses, 1 draw; 65.09 per cent win percentage Australia’s record in all matches which Pocock has started, 2008-2015: 42 matches: 29 wins, 12 losses, 1 draw; 69.05 per cent win percentage Australia’s record in all matches since Pocock’s debut when he has not been playing, 2008-2015: 47 matches: 23 wins, 22 losses, 2 draws; 51.06 per cent success Ross Ford and Jonny Gray (Scotland) are free to resume playing with immediate effect after successfully appealing against their three-week suspension for acts of foul play contrary to Law 10.4(j) (dangerous tackles). The appeal took place today at the London offices of the official law firm for Rugby World Cup 2015 Clifford Chance and was heard by an Appeal Committee, chaired by the Honourable Justice Lex Mpati (South Africa), sitting with Justice Graeme Mew (Canada) and Robbie Deans (New Zealand). Having conducted a detailed review of all the evidence, including new submissions from the players and their representatives, along with all available camera angles, the Appeal Committee dismissed the finding that the players had committed an act of foul play as the player had not been dropped or driven and therefore the tackle was not dangerous. The players are therefore free to play again immediately. Could make things interesting.

2015-10-18T01:59:27+00:00

ThugbyFan

Guest


Every single British player who has committed an atrocity has pretty much gotten away with it. In fact all Tier one players have been hit over the wrist with a wet lettuce leaf, except the Argentinian Lock who got done big time for eye gauging. However I do agree with Alex on the Scottish boys that 3 weeks to both players was a travesty, when you compare that cleanout gone wrong with a deliberate punch (SO'B) to a player basically just standing there only got 1 week, and a shoulder-charge cleanout (M.Hooper) also only got 1 week. Maybe the Judiciary member lost a relative at Bannockburn or something. I don't know the answer but having lawyers as the sole arbitrator, who may love rugby but have never played in the top grades, is not the answer. Perhaps a committee of three to hear the cases, one being said lawyer to explain the law, the other two being recent ex-international players (not from same country as player in the case). Suspensions must be unanimous. From my take on the video I have seen of the cleanout, a much fairer result would have been 1 week ban to the Scottish #5 for lifting the legs which caused the Samoan player to nose dive (under dangerous play) and no case to answer for the hooker who came in when the dangerous part of the deed was done. Anyway, that being said and done, it makes Australia's job a little bit harder but also I'm happy as if you have any pretensions to winning the RWC then if you can't beat a fired-up Scottish full team you don't deserve to take "Bill" home. Gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo the WallyBees. :)

2015-10-18T01:04:14+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Thanks Alex... and it would be foolish for anyone, in a knock-out tournament, to get too far ahead of themselves. The Wallaby, will face-off against the pride of Scotland in the wee hours of tomorrow, confident that they should win given both their recent form. But that's not always a given... the form bit that is. There is no doubt that the Wallaby should win... you could say the real question, for most, is by how much ? But that is so loaded with bad omens, as a Wallaby supporter, I ain't touching it. Both teams are there for a reason... they both, no doubt, deserve to be there. But as we all know... there's only gonna be one winner... and, of course, a loser. So no more buts from me on this one!

2015-10-18T00:03:04+00:00

Mike Huber

Roar Pro


Good point about holding . Seems like most retaliations center around this ! Could cost a team the RWC if a player is unable to re group .

2015-10-17T23:44:43+00:00

Shop

Guest


I can't believe they're both eligible to play. Dangerous play that has gone left unpunished. I might put a few hundred on the Scots for tomorrow.....

AUTHOR

2015-10-17T23:17:55+00:00

Alex Wood

Roar Guru


Thanks. The Scots are going to play like men possessed and I would think, if they get a bit of momentum could give Australia problems. The impact of Folau and Pocock being off cannot be underestimated either, both in direct impact and the mental/confidence impact on both sides of the ball. Australia should win, but that doesn't mean that they will.

AUTHOR

2015-10-17T23:15:28+00:00

Alex Wood

Roar Guru


Billy, I can see both sides of this one. My logic is that the clear out (it actually wan't a tackle) where, while the players head connected with the ground, the player was off his feet and leaning his weight forward in such a way that when picked up he was likely to fall forward. He started and finished very close to the ground so the actual danger, as opposed to the strict illegality, was not all that high. I wouldn't say the 3 week ban was a wrong decision, but I can see that it might been interpreted differently too. So much of this is down to interpretation.

2015-10-17T23:04:50+00:00

Raugeee

Guest


Amazing what a big final for one of the last European sides can do. That was a terribly dangerous tackle. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxeoYWaCo6E

2015-10-17T23:02:33+00:00

Raugeee

Guest


Yep - write em off. Having said that, Joubert can make miracles happen.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar