The Roar's AFL expert tips and predictions: Round 10

By Josh / Expert

Hello Roarers and welcome to another week of AFL Expert tips. We are neck and neck in the tipping race at the moment with myself and BJ Conkey on 57, leading Michael di Fabrizio and The Crowd on 56.

Ten rounds into the season and this is still truly anyone’s game.

This week, however, perhaps everyone will have a chance to get one up on me – or vice versa – as I make a pick that I suspect will be against the pack, selecting my beloved North Melbourne to upset the Sydney Swans on Friday night at the SCG.

Can you really call it an upset when North is 9-0 and two games clear on top of the ladder? Apparently you can because the team is out to nearly $3 odds with betting companies.

Both teams have a squadron of hard nuts in the middle, quality ruck divisions, firepower-filled forward lines, and underrated defensive units, making this one very hard to pick. The Swans have the home ground advantage but North have the Farren Ray factor. North it is for me.

EVERY AFL GAME THIS YEAR LIVE ON FOXTEL

The other corker this week will be the match been Adelaide and GWS, wherein my tipping process involved a lot of umming and ahhing. It’s a tough game to call with the Giants arguably in better form, but the Crows boasting a huge home ground advantage.

The Giants took a great win over the Bulldogs last week but they will have their maturity tested this week when asked to beat a fellow top eight side away from home, something they are yet to do so far in 2016.

The Crows are an excellent side and possess the best forward line in the league. That said, the Giants have a significantly deeper midfield and that will prove to be the difference here. Though there is a chance that some of the more experienced heads among the Crows could upset that plan.

Two other matches of interest are between Melbourne and Port Adelaide, and Collingwood and the Western Bulldogs. The Dees and Dogs look like the favourites here but there’s definitely some potential for an upset with Melbourne’s performance still a bit up and down from week to week and Collingwood building in confidence after two consecutive big wins.

Hawthorn and Geelong will get the chance to bounce back from disappointing losses, coming up against Brisbane and Carlton respectively. The Hawks will be travelling to the Gabba for the first time since 2008 if you can believe it, but they should find their feet there well enough.

St Kilda should get their fourth win of the year when they come up against Fremantle and it will be much the same for Richmond when they play Essendon in the annual Dreamtime at the ‘G match.

Last and certainly least in terms of watchability will be West Coast and Gold Coast at Domain Stadium. The team who likes winning by a lot at home, playing the team who likes losing by a lot (well, they probably don’t like it, but they do it a lot). An Eagles victory is my lock of the week and it could easily be a 100-plus thumping.

Michael DiFabrizio
Winning ten games in a row is hard, but North Melbourne are in a position to pull it off heading into Friday night’s game against the Swans.

The problem is, I like Sydney. Especially at the SCG. The closest anyone has gotten to the Swans on their home deck this season is 25 points and that was the high-flying GWS Giants.

Aside from that match, they’ve knocked over West Coast by 39 and registered two wins by 80-plus (against Collingwood and Essendon) at the ground. Like North’s win streak, this trend is hard to ignore.

The Roos have continued to show strong signs as the season has progressed and they always seem to have an answer. But for this one, I’m going with the red and white.

Melbourne versus Port Adelaide at Alice Springs was the other game I was left to grapple with this week.

Despite two losses in a row for the Power, it’s worth noting that both defeats were by less than ten points. It’s also probably fair to make the call that another defeat this week would spell season over. The stakes are high.

Melbourne aren’t always the best side to go with coming off a win, either. That said, the Dees are playing better footy right now. I’ll stick with them.

BJ Conkey
The Kangaroos have to lose eventually, right? The Swans back on their home turf after conquering Hawthorn at the MCG are too much of a force to tip against despite North Melbourne’s consistency.

The Giants just keep chugging along and deserve their third place on the ladder. Considering they’ve won four out of five games away from Sydney this season the Adelaide Oval shouldn’t be too intimidating and neither should the opposition. Eddie Betts has struggled to kick goals in recent weeks and if the Giants can shut him down, they’ll be hard to beat.

The Magpies have surprised many, including me, with the way they’ve bounced back to form. But even with an impressive win over Geelong their consistency still bothers me. Jack Redpath will be a key inclusion for their opponents the Western Bulldogs. Collingwood will be out to recreate the fast start from their win over Geelong and therefore the first quarter could be the key.

Round 10 BJ Conkey Michael Josh The Crowd
SYD v NTM SYD SYD NTM SYD
BL v HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW
MEL v PA MEL MEL MEL MEL
STK v FRE STK STK STK STK
ESS v RIC RIC RIC RIC RIC
ADL v GWS GWS GWS GWS GWS
CAR v GEE GEE GEE GEE GEE
WB v COL WB WB WB WB
WCE v GCS WCE WCE WCE wCE
Last round 6 6 8 7
Total 57 56 57 56

The Crowd Says:

2016-05-27T00:54:22+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


We'll take Benny "Meh" Brown at Freo. Very mobile...great on the ground...holds a mark and kicks straight.

2016-05-27T00:52:00+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Freo has to finish 12th. Apparently 7th draft pick has been the most successful over the years.

2016-05-27T00:49:28+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


I'm scared about Essendon. I won't be able to read The Roar if Essendon beat us. We'd better do it this week. Josh...just your comment on Adelaide having the best forward line... Surely they have to sit behind WCE.

2016-05-26T23:49:49+00:00

Norticus

Roar Rookie


Looking forward to the next few weeks as "vs top 8" starts to even out

2016-05-26T21:07:05+00:00

Penster

Guest


I reckon you're in with a chance, big danger game for the Hawks. Brissy looked the goods against Swans and almost knocked them off a few weeks ago, Hawks well off their game (hopefully not too distracted with the hysteria around Roughy) and not managing the match ups. Based on the Hawks loss last week, I'd say they'd get the job done this weekend but it ain't a lock.

2016-05-26T14:51:39+00:00

Kiama Chris

Guest


Swans - desperation will win it Hawks - lose this and pack for Vegas Port - they know this territory and will provide sterner resistance than Dees have faced recently Saints Tigers Adelaide - home ground factor. Can equal GWS in ball movement Cats Dogs - back in the kennel, Pie pretenders Eagles - at home Avagoodweegend

2016-05-26T09:00:54+00:00

Michael Huston

Guest


I think they're 'meh'. Waite's had a good start to the year, but when you've had a whole career of mediocrity, it can be easy to fall back into it. Petrie's entire career has been the epitomy of good, but not great (drops absolute sitters, kicks shockers etc). Thomas goes missing too often. And Brown has got good hands but, like Thomas, goes missing too often (he's still relatively young so he's forgiven.) They are just very tall players. I don't think there's anything special about them.

AUTHOR

2016-05-26T08:53:17+00:00

Josh

Expert


Today's team announcements, hitting me right in the Farren Ray factor...

2016-05-26T08:17:55+00:00

big four sticks

Guest


Richmond will smash Essendoom We are not on a mini roll. We are on the express route to the finals. K.B said Richmond are back and his word is gospel. After all they have made a statue of the great man. It's Tiger time and all other teams can get stuffed.

2016-05-26T07:53:01+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


I reckon GWS are certainties.

2016-05-26T07:50:20+00:00

hal

Guest


I hope so. Fingers crossed but I think their confidence is up and they are on a mini roll. I think North will touch them up next week.

2016-05-26T06:54:02+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


I remember watching that one on the Telly Bri. Could be wrong but that is the record last quarter comeback I think.

2016-05-26T06:19:22+00:00

Brian

Guest


The greatest ever era in modern times came to an end at the GABBA in 1995 when they beat us from 45 points down at 3 quarter time. I hope another glorious era doesn't end at the GABBA on the weekend. If we lose to this Brisbane side we can throw the towel in for season 2016.

2016-05-26T05:27:59+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


The Geelong win was full of merit although it was surprising how off their game Geelong appeared early that day.
Not really, I don't think Geelong has won a game the following week after playing Hawthorn in about 10 years.

2016-05-26T05:13:04+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Richmond could still find a way to lose the Dreamtime game

2016-05-26T05:09:06+00:00

hal

Guest


I think North can beat Sydney. If they do, surely people will have to rate them after this. Other teams that I feel will win are Geelong, GWS, Melbourne, Richmond, Footscray, St Kilda, West Coast, and Hawthorn.

2016-05-26T04:41:01+00:00

Tricky

Guest


"And their forwards, while all pretty ‘meh’, are still very tall" Meh? Waite, Petrie, Thomas and Brown?! Hardly "Meh"

2016-05-26T04:16:20+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


do they really though?, all part of the cunning plan

2016-05-26T03:56:18+00:00

Michael Huston

Guest


I don't understand why Sydney are such favourites to beat North. You only need to look at the match-ups around the field, and they have our measure. And their forwards, while all pretty 'meh', are still very tall. Too tall for Grundy or Rampe or Laidler. Our only hope is that our midfield can really smash theirs and limit their forward 50 supplies. But they're a very experienced, mature side that's priming for a flag. Sydney are a pretty young side (our av. games played goes down even more when you replace Richards with Aliir), and yeah they've done brilliantly thus far, it's hard to see them being the team that's able to do what nine other teams couldn't. This is just the kind of game I expect Sydney to lose. If Swans win, I'll need a week to get over my state of shock.

2016-05-26T03:19:09+00:00

johno

Guest


At home v Essendon ... they can't throw that one without raising eyebrows

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar