Chopping block rant: Inglis should be dropped

By Ron Swanson / Roar Guru

With Round 14 done and dusted, let’s take a partial view of the dud performances of the weekend’s action.

The highlight of Round 14 had to be big Tony ‘T-Rex’ Williams’ nod to box office smash Now You See Me 2, which stars Harry Potter.

The big rig somehow passed the ball into his left arm, regathered and split the defence in a move that even had the bunker in awe.

Ray and I missed several games this weekend after spending time bunkered down with coach Laurie Daley and Bozo playing darts up at Stockton Caravan Park – using the traditional method of selecting the Game 2 squad.

The selection process involved 19 players we had to choose from on the dart board, pretty much the 17 players selected, along with Boyd Cordner and the seriously unlucky Akuila Uate – who was placed inside the bullseye!

Daley’s controversial selections of Bryce Cartwright and Jack Bird as development players was the only sticking point over the final team make-up of the side which took three minutes to select.

Rumours that Daley was contemplating doing an Alfie Langer and recalling Todd Carney from the UK Super League was put to rest when he revealed he was chasing Chris Sandow, only to be let down when the Man of Steel favourite was listed as a Queenslander.

Ray and I are close to the release of our NRL Stats App, which combines wellbeing with NRL stats. The introduction when the app first opens is from well-known league identity and Zen master, Matt Elliott. We are still working on a name after we learnt NRL Stats had already been taken.

Now to this week’s Round 14 chopping block…

Blake Austin
This will be sure to stir up the passionate Green Machine fans. For all Austin’s running game in attack, his inconsistent movement in the defensive line makes him a passenger when the Raiders are without the Steeden.

Whether it be rushing up in his beige bike pants to make an intercept or holding his ground on the try line, Austin is showing why several other clubs overlooked him for a consistent run in first grade.

It’s true his attacking sidekick Aiden ‘Julius’ Sezer is also suspect in defence, but while the Raiders can score points right across the park, it’s the schoolboy errors in defence that continue to haunt their progress. The more solid Sam Williams might be better suited but I can’t see Ricky Stuart dropping the man with the ungainly gait.

This time last year critics stated he was unlucky to miss Origin selection – had he played Game 3 in 2015 the Blues may have lost by 78! One half-decent season doesn’t make a representative player.

Greg Inglis
It won’t happen but it should. The great man’s lack of intensity in defence was there for all to see on Friday night, and a move to Brisvegas under Uncle Wayne must be all but a done deal.

To have your leader display such a lack of urgency would have annoyed Rusty and to a lesser extent the token coach Madge Maguire. What’s worse is the boy from Kempsey (Macksville to be precise), will look like the Hulk next Wednesday night for his adopted state and all will be forgotten.

Some have said he has played with injury for the best part of 2016, while I suspect he’s carrying a heartilage injury. The Rabbitohs are at the crossroad point of their season and dumping the great man won’t happen.

But time is running out to convince South Sydney fans he has the club at heart and not a move up north to his adopted state.

Greg Eden
Coach Wayne ‘Clint’ Bennett would be having nightmares about the Broncos’ depth. Firstly, young Lachlan Maranta had a Barry Crocker the week before in Auckland and the only thing that kept the Raiders in the contest on Friday night was the performance from the Englishman.

With potential long-term injuries to Jordan Kahu and Jack Reed, the coach is not stacked for choice with readymade replacements. James Roberts has yet to hit the vintage of season 2015 with the Titans, and its obvious where opposition sides are going to run their plays in coming weeks.

Langer will be flat out over the next fortnight working out his positioning for the Broncos’ next match in a fortnight’s time, during his usual 45-minute spell in the defensive line. No doubt he will be running countless drills of his signature karate trip tackle with future incumbents.

I suspect if fit, young Tom Opacic, nephew of The Cars lead singer Ric Opacic (or is that Ocasek?) might come under consideration for a start. I can just see Benny strolling into Red Hill HQ and singing the classic Cars track to young Tom, “Don’t you worry ’bout two left feet, just shake it up!” in a dramatic announcement on his first-grade debut.

Burgess Brothers
I sound like a broken record but the Burgess brother experiment must be disbanded. Sure, George is sidelined at the moment but you’d suspect Sam had written into his contract, ‘my twin brothers will be selected every week, regardless of form’. The number of poor plays per match would drive Mother Teresa to drink if she was a member of the Burrow.

It must be hard for Rabbitohs fans not to feel a sense of fear every time either twin is charging for a hit up or tangled in a tackle with an opponent. The relief at a clean hit up or quick exit from the ruck in defence would be on par with the Australian public’s joy when it was announced Pauline Hanson had made a comeback to politics or for the elder reader, when Toby Mangle’s missing dog Bouncer was found safe and well on Neighbours!

Like headgear, the brothers could make a killing in endorsements if they donned Kareem Abdul-Jabbar-like prescription goggles for the rest of their NRL careers, if, as I suspect, they have fair to poor eyesight.

Daniel Tupou
The former Origin winger made his opponent, with all of nine games experience playing rugby league under his belt, look like a seasoned pro last Saturday night. Tupou was caught out on several occasions in the ‘Bermuda triangle’ zone in defence – within touching distant of inside centre and making a triangle with the opposition ball carrier.

Tupou is still a target for well-drilled sides that can sniff out a player’s bad habits in a flash and it was exploited more than young Bob Irwin. Sure, overall the whole side looked listless and tired, but the winger’s penchant for rushing in marking nothing but thin air did not help his side’s plight.

Quite possibly the fixture before may have made the Chooks leg weary, but then again it didn’t affect the Wests Tigers. A meeting with Rip Taylor on Tuesday is on the cards for the tall Roosters wing-three-quarter.

So fellow Roarers who made your skin crawl this weekend and why?

The Crowd Says:

2016-06-17T01:11:20+00:00

Christov

Guest


As a Souths fan I think it is true from this year's performances of GI that he has lost the desire to play for South Sydney. I agree that he will kill it on Wednesday and then return and show no urgency in defence, only to feign anger at the team letting in soft tries. Like Keary, he helped get us our 21st premiership and for that I am truly greatful and will never get up him/them for seeking better money elsewhere, but maybe it is time that he moved on. GI can get the ginormous third party deals in Brisbane whilst on a low-ish contract and would consolidate their lack of depth out wide. Alex Johnson can then be 'our' fullback and can grow into the position rather than just filling in when GI is forced to do something in centre or out for origin. It pains me to write that but perhaps it is time to part ways, and maybe it would be the best for both GI and Souths to do so. EDIT: if we let go of GI we can truly begin our next 40 year cycle to a premiership ;)

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T23:18:36+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


It won't happen turbo... it should.

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T23:17:57+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


Loz should have it on up at Coffs 24/7. I also enjoyed the Walter Matthau version of the Bad New Bears.

2016-06-16T09:32:53+00:00

turbodewd

Roar Guru


Near the start of the year Inglis kicked a FG vs the Dragons at the SCG despite Souths trailing. He didnt care. Hes won a GF and won Origin countless times. He puts in half the time this year...his urgency in defence aint there. He may be carrying injuries...fair enough. He should be dropped until he is 100% in the legs and the head.

2016-06-16T09:20:27+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It's a classic...watched it plenty of times as a lad. Classic underdog story.

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T05:58:32+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


Tyrell and Jason Clarke. Geez the cattle is threadbare at Redfern. Dane Neilsen could be added to the list of also rans. Hope they buy Jono Wright for 2017! GI lacks any resemblance of the 2014 model.

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T05:56:23+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


I need to view more games and find a fresher target but Souths games are always on FTA and factor in tipping them in the early games, and you remain filthy with them all week. Souths are still playing the same style that won them title in 2014 minus the decent cattle they had. Maguire needs to smell the roses that the power game minus any strike will fail. The backline is slow and pedestrian, the forward pack lacks any variety and they can't bloody catch! MEMO Russell, time for another truth session up Coffs!

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T05:51:29+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


Guy Pearce...what about Shortland Street, is it still running?? Jake Da Muss no longer involved I'd suspect.

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T05:50:30+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


I'd take Marika's defence every day of the week of Addo-Carr Joe.

2016-06-16T04:56:23+00:00

MAX

Guest


Delighted to read your incredibly accurate assessment of the game each week. Sadly, The Brothers Burgess could be named "Going I, Going II and Gone".

2016-06-16T04:42:34+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


100% behind you on the Burgess brothers call. Every week its the same old story...knock ons, penalties, cheap turnover and poor defence in the middle. I suspect though the Rabbits have no one else to bring on in their place as they're also playing Dave Turrell in the forward pack and he would be lucky to be playing reserve grade. The Inglis call isn't so radical as one might think....the Storm attack at the beginning of the year was pretty poor until Chambers got injured. I think before this they would take the lazy option and throw it to Chambers and hope for the best. The game against the Sharks was the worst one. Since then the attack has sharpened considerably as they play more team footy. The same might be true for Souths and Inglis.

2016-06-16T04:38:04+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


No worries bringing him to the Storm, pretty much same as Koroibete when he first came in, had a few mistakes in his game which were quickly weeded out at the Storm system. I think potentially Ado-Carr can be similar or better than Koroibete as he was brought up playing league whereas Koroibete was a Union convert. The only thing I'm worried about is his attitude, Bellamy has no tolerance for show ponies. Hopefully the famed Storm pre-season for new arrivals will bring out his best self.

2016-06-16T04:24:12+00:00

Mike L

Guest


Nah mate, I'm a kiwi, We loved Neighbours as much as the Aussies. (At its peak when Kylie and Jason were the big stars) Not so much now...

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T04:13:22+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


My bad The Barry, it was at least a decade ago I watched one of the better sporting films.

2016-06-16T03:48:41+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It was definitely the Hanson Brothers...but there was three of them, not twins!

AUTHOR

2016-06-16T02:00:29+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


I'd be surprised if it wasn't a question on the citizenship test for UK folk Mike... "what was the name of Toby Mangle's dog on Neighbours??" a) Alf (aka Alf Stewart) b) Broughy (aka Rob Brough) c) Burgo (aka Baby John Burgess) d) Bouncer

2016-06-16T01:27:26+00:00

Mike L

Guest


Sigh - I am officially old... I understood the Toby Mangel reference... and I'm not even Australian

AUTHOR

2016-06-15T23:59:32+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


Fair call, very ordinary under the high ball. Might be a blessing he is off next season to the Storm. No doubting his speed. Who would the Tigers bring in though? Not Justin Hunt I hope.

2016-06-15T23:33:36+00:00

Patrick Sills

Roar Guru


Would be surprised to see Josh Addo-Carr named next week

AUTHOR

2016-06-15T22:40:04+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


Unfortunately the carry over points system doesn't embrace common sense. It was careless in my opinion but a decade ago that tackle would of been a penalty and nothing more. Still JT has been watching Rivaldo replays throughout his career!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar