Hayne is the Titans' X-factor - and more talking points from the NRL weekend

By Scott Pryde / Expert

You really couldn’t have asked for anything more if you were Neil Henry could you? Hayne has come in and played two very good games to start his time on the Gold Coast.

He has been close to the Titans best in both weeks, and while it had a mitigating factor on their overall game and certainly that of Ashley Taylor’s last weekend, they seemed to get the overall package like this weekend.

But the X-factor scenario is evident more than a few times a game – whether it is a big run out of his own end, great field vision for a kick or pass, an excellent play in defence or attacking a high ball he just has so many ways to hurt an opposition.

That’s before you think about how the Titans game ended on the weekend against the Wests Tigers – it was a classic game, everything it was supposed to be between two teams battling for a spot in the top eight.

It did however, descend into a field goal war during the last ten minutes. After multiple missed attempts, it was Hayne who stood up and knocked one over with mere seconds on the clock from a fair distance out.

If that, plus everything else he has done, doesn’t scream X-factor then I’m not sure what does and with a game like that which essentially becomes a four-point turnaround, the Titans should now find themselves in position to qualify for the finals.

The Broncos’ real challenge starts now
So, the Brisbane Broncos have finally reversed their form slump – but have they really?

On the scoreboard the answer is absolutely yes, but off the scoreboard the answer is still yet to be found out.

You have to remember that even though the club that once were premiership favourites have managed to win two straight it has been against sides that are at the wrong end of the table and really struggling to gain any ascendancy in the competition.

They defeated the St George Illawarra Dragons (and more on them shortly) last week by just three points in a performance that wouldn’t have filled many Broncos fans with much hope before a statement type game against the Parramatta Eels.

Honestly, the ‘statement type’ game from the Broncos has been a long time coming. You only have to remember losses against teams like the Sydney Roosters to realise where they should be and how they should be playing.

The match against the Eels on the weekend though felt like a return to form with Anthony Milford having his best performance in months, their forwards standing up, and Darius Boyd returning to form.

While there is still a lot of work to be done in Brisbane, there are no questions that it was a massively positive performance.

But does it really mean anything in the long run? The Broncos will come up against the Canterbury Bulldogs at home next week – and the Bulldogs who are playing good footy in the top four will be right up for that game as most teams are when they travel north.

The week after, they travel south to play the form team of the competition – the Melbourne Storm.

All I’m going to say in closing is why don’t we chat about the Broncos premiership credentials in a fortnight instead of now.

The New Zealand Warriors are cooked
The New Zealand Warriors look to be on their annual structure. Inconsistent at the start of the season, then massive during the Origin period in time for everyone to insert them as premiership favourites before they have a demise at the end of the season.

That demise has started in a big way on the weekend as a South Sydney Rabbitohs side who have been priming themselves for a victory over the last few weeks finally got one and in a big way over the Warriors.

They were blown off the park in the first half of the match and it was just all one-way traffic. Their attack was disappointing, defence not a whole lot better and despite all the home games they have at the back end of the season, it’s hard to see them making the eight.

Sitting on 24 points now they are still obviously a chance, but realistically the way they played on the weekend indicates they have peaked and won’t be coming back for a last run at September.

Even if they did, it would be a match on the road and you would rate their chances about as highly as me climbing Everest tomorrow.

Where has that been all season for the Dragons?
For Dragons fans like myself their victory on the weekend over the Cronulla Sharks was pleasing, but also one that made you sit there, jaw dropped and ask ‘where the hell has that been all season?’

The Dragons were switched on from the first set on both ends of the park and looked like a different team to the one we have seen for the first 22 weeks.

It’s like something finally clicked for them – hey, if we pass the football, we might score points. Well they did and yep, they scored 30 points against one of the best defensive sides in the competition.

They now need to finish the season like that and, with any realistic hope of the finals gone, build for 2017.

Is 49 becoming 50 in the Shire?
It’s been 49 long years in the Shire without a premiership – it’s an all too well-known fact that they have never won one but this year had a seriously different feel about it for the men in black, white and blue.

They had gone on a record-breaking winning streak and were crushing everyone in their path, but the real question now after a draw against the Titans and back-to-back losses against the Canberra Raiders and St George Illawarra Dragons is have they peaked too early?

The Sharks have looked like a different team over the last fortnight, and while I don’t want to write them off just yet finding some form again before the finals is absolutely key.

They haven’t been struck down with injuries, suspension or misfortune and their level of intensity and play has been gradually dropping for the last month one might argue.

That elusive premiership looks to be slowly slipping away, as does the minor and without a turnaround in form, it might be all too easy for the Melbourne Storm to run away with the trophy.

Are the Newcastle Knights the worst team ever?
Earlier in the season Roarer Taking it one week at a time had a look at whether the Knights would be the worst team in history and after another blowout it’s starting to get very difficult to argue against it.

On the weekend, they got walloped 42-6 by a Penrith Panthers team who are in a desperate struggle to make the top eight. While they looked competitive for the first half an hour of the contest they conceded 34 second half points.

Their defence is woeful and with a for and against that is now sitting on negative 451 and only one win and a draw from 21 games it has been a season to forget.

But are they the worst of all time?

Their for-and-against is now worse than the Western Suburbs Magpies of 1998 and while it won’t get to the level of 1999 they haven’t played as many matches.

The bottom line is all of the teams that are in the running for worst team ever have won multiple games – the Knights have three weeks to turn it around and with a run home against the desperate Titans, resurgent Rabbitohs and Dragons it’s hard to see them picking up two more victories.

So yes – yes they are.

Cowboys fans should probably be concerned right about now
To close out the round, the North Queensland Cowboys travelled south to Allianz Stadium and, putting it nicely, they didn’t play well.

It’s another worry for the Cowboys fans and after a couple of losses in a row the bid to go back-to-back is starting to look very shaky.

They, like the Broncos, looked like one of the best teams in the competition once again before the Origin period, but they have just never got their momentum back and after a performance that was worse than what they managed during Origin last year, plus an injury to Johnathan Thurston, they are struggling big time.

Full credit to their opponents the Sydney Roosters, but they Cowboys shouldn’t be losing to them if they want to go anywhere near the grand final.

Even with JT on the park they didn’t look good enough, and after he was rushed back from injury whereas he would normally be given a little more time on the sideline at this point in the season you have to wonder if there are a few underlying problems in Townsville.

Roarers, there you have it – our talking points from the weekend that was. What did you make of it? What did I miss?

Be sure to check back in next Sunday Night for another edition.

Follow Scott on Twitter @sk_pryde

The Crowd Says:

2016-08-15T11:17:02+00:00

ChubbzyK97

Guest


I just rewatched Hayne kicking that field goal and we need more of that in the game... Loved it. Every moment. We don't need every player to be a humble mute. The BIG THIS IS MY HOUSE after goal is classic and should definitely be on the end of season highlight reel.

2016-08-15T07:03:47+00:00

Albo

Guest


Titans - Greg Bird more important to their September than Hayne. Need his leadership and defence. Crook shoulder had to be patched up and have him sent back out there when the Tigers were coming to get them on Saturday. Now in doubt this week. Broncos - the next two matches against the Dogs & Storm will find them out again and will hope that the Roosters clock off their year early in the last round. Warriors - business as usual. Who knows ? Three wins or three losses ? Dragons - had their best side on the field this year and contracts are up for renewal. Sharks - Looking wobbly , but still have their best team available to get it right again. Knights - Yep ! The worst for some time. Need a complete cleanout from the top. Cowboys - looking very tired and some extra hurt methinks. JT two bad games in a row spells trouble.

2016-08-15T02:59:39+00:00

Jacko

Guest


Scott I hope you enjoy climbing Mt Everest

2016-08-15T02:31:37+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


I would argue Boyd is in career best form. He was instrumental in all the Qld big plays to take another series up to Friday night where he was exceptional again. I went to Suncorp on Friday so I'm not sure what they showed/commented on during the broadcast but his direction and positioning outstanding but his decision making in defense! On tackle 3 or 4, Literally sprinting 20 - 30 meters into the retreating line then rushing to tackle the next ball runner - thus taking all the steam from their attack. He done this 4x to my count. I've watched a lot of games at lang park over the years, maybe Locky's biggest fan but I left on Friday wondering if Boyd is now a better FB than Lockyer?

2016-08-15T00:58:45+00:00

Dogs Of War

Roar Guru


He is back at the Dogs next year.

2016-08-15T00:17:27+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


Obviously an egomaniac?

2016-08-15T00:15:49+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


Oh switch off.

2016-08-14T23:57:02+00:00

P. Marlowe

Guest


I largely agree with the comments about the Broncos however I do take issue with 'Darius Boyd returning to form' point. I would suggest Darius has been the only Bronco player in consistent form for us - he was absolutely excellent against the Dragons (and other teams) and pretty much kept us in that game (which we should have lost).

2016-08-14T23:52:28+00:00

P. Marlowe

Guest


Agree with that - there seems a general lethargy about the Cowboys as a whole (which is not meant to take anything away from the Roosters who were excellent). Guys like Ethan Lowe were falling off tackles which they usually make with ease. It does show the absolute importance of keeping your key players uninjured in the run to the finals. Sharks lose Ennis and immediately lose to the Raiders. Cowboys lose Granville and looked really slow out of dummy half yesterday. Ray Thompson is a trier but not really NRL finals standard. In this regard, the Roosters season has largely been undone by injuries too - agreed with Gould when he said they were the best 15th place side he has seen.

2016-08-14T22:59:30+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


I think the overachievement of the Sharks is going to be their undoing , mentally they have a lot to deal with and the expectations in the Shire must be overwhelming .

2016-08-14T22:43:33+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It's always easy on Monday morning but you have to wonder why Green rushed Thurston back. He could have taken the extra week against the Tigers and come back fresh this week. He still seems slightly underdone. The Cowboys rely on him so much that a couple of per cent below his best impacts the team. Not that it was JTs fault - the whole team was flat - but a fit JT drags the team out of that sort of funk.

2016-08-14T21:53:42+00:00

AlanKC

Guest


Number 5 was alive!

2016-08-14T21:33:44+00:00

soapit

Guest


feeding off it is probably a pretty positive thing to do seeing as it'll be written regardless (tho he probably could dampen down the medias enthusiasm if he wanted to)

2016-08-14T20:49:01+00:00

PNG Broncos fan88

Guest


Punting Cameron McInnes for Damien Cook has done wonders for the Rabbitohs.

2016-08-14T20:30:41+00:00

Mike from tari

Guest


Let's forget about Hayne & talk about the form slumps of a few teams. Broncos appear to come out of their slump, let's wait & see. Warriors got done by.a masterclass performance by Adam Reynolds, backed up by a refreshed GI & a support from the rest of the team who didn't drop the ball. Sharks are in a mental slump, it was the local derby & Saints played away from their whole of season attacking structure. Cowboys are going through a mental let down as well, should have rested a few of their players after SOO. Only 3 games to go before the play offs so interesting times are ahead.

2016-08-14T19:06:19+00:00

p.Tah

Guest


I love seeing the players celebrate a try. All do it. But there is a vast difference between how most players celebrate when they celebrate with the crowd and their team mates and how Hayne does it. I'm a Parramatta (and Blues supporter) and even when he was with us I wasn't keen on it. He spoke about the changing and humbling effect being with the Fijian rugby union 7s had on him. How for them it is all about the team not the individual. Just my perception but nothing much has changed. Maybe it's just me but I enjoyed how the Fijians celebrated their tries and how they celebrated when the siren went at the end of the Gold medal final.

2016-08-14T14:13:17+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


If he can play a significant role in the Titans going deep into the semis or further , he will have done something fairly special . He is obviously an egomaniac but I guess that's where his freakish ability gets its fuel from . I have referred to him as the the Kardashian of league , which in hindsight was probably a little unfair as he doesn't write all this tripe about himself but Im pretty confident he feeds off it though . Gee the season has taken some bizarre twists in the last few weeks .

2016-08-14T11:49:20+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


Several years ago he mentioned this as one of his disappointments about sporting culture in Australia. He lamented how people judged him negatively for celebrating a try the way he did, as if it were taboo to be exuberant and flamboyant about scoring. I understand the idea that it comes across as 'all about him' but I've no issue with his post try shenanigans. Robots only have personalities in Star Wars. Or 2001: A Space Odyssey...

2016-08-14T11:24:14+00:00

Vivalasvegan

Guest


Totally agree. Obviously a freakish player but not one I have ever warmed to. I reckon his short stint in the US has made him more egocentric and boring than ever he was previously.

2016-08-14T09:28:31+00:00

p.Tah

Guest


Ive always enjoyed watching Hayne play, but his post point celebrations put me off at times. He doesn't celebrate with the team, it appears it's all about him. Great field goal to win the match, but the 'this is my house' celebration made him look like a tool

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar