Australia must end their ODI slump, and quickly

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

Australia’s shambolic ODI tour of South Africa continued last night as they made 167 on a blameless pitch.

What made this capitulation even more embarrassing is that it came against a second-string Proteas attack lacking Dale Steyn, Kagiso Rabada, Morne Morkel and Imran Tahir. (Click to Tweet)

Australia were reduced to 5-49 by quicks Kyle Abbott and Dwaine Pretorius and chinaman bowler Tabraiz Shamsi. While Abbott has significant experience in international cricket, Pretorious and Shamsi both were playing in only their second ODIs.

There was no such lack of experience in the batting line-up they chopped through. Of Australia’s top seven, only Travis Head is a newcomer. The remaining six players are first-choice members of the number-one ranked Australian side.

Setting aside their badly-undermanned pace attack in this series, Australia have not performed anything like the best ODI side in the world. The reigning world champions have looked flat.

With the Champions Trophy coming up in the first half of next year, Australia need to settle on their core 13 to 14 ODI players soon and stick with them over the summer, injuries permitting.

The side’s much-maligned rotation policy may be a reason why they’ve been such a fearsome ODI side for so many years. It has helped them build depth so, when key players have been absent, other cricketers have been able to fill the breach with confidence.

But just eight months out from a major ODI tournament Australia needs to work on finding the right mix of players and allow them time to jell and build momentum as a unit.

Despite their struggles in South Africa, Australia are, arguably, still favourites for the Champions Trophy. This is due to their number one ranking and extraordinarily dominant record in 50-over tournaments, having won four of the last five World Cups and two of the past three Champions Trophies.

But they will face robust competition from the other three semi-finalists from last year’s World Cup – South Africa, India and New Zealand. That trio of teams have been elite ODI outfits for several years now. Together with Australia, they shape as the sides most likely to take home the trophy.

We know South Africa have a commanding attack and match-winning batsmen in AB de Villiers, Hashim Amla and Quentin de Kock. What they’ve also displayed in dismantling Australia is much-improved depth. They have steamrolled the Aussies in this series with either little or no input from key players de Villiers, Morkel, Steyn, Rabada and Tahir.

Admittedly, the Proteas have a record at limited overs tournaments which is as wretched as Australia’s is glorious. But they will break that hoodoo at some point and when they do, the silverware floodgates may well open.

New Zealand, meanwhile, have a wonderfully well-balanced side with a nice mix of stroke makers, proven all-rounders, quality quicks and fast-improving spinners in Mitchell Santner and Ish Sodhi.

India are the reigning Champions Trophy winners. They have a sensational batting line-up, an enviable spin battery and a world-class paceman in Mohammed Shami, who dominated at the World Cup.

The hosts England are a dark horse, thanks to their dynamic batting line-up and home advantage. Ranked fifth in ODIs, they have improved significantly since their humiliating showing at the World Cup, which capped off many years of underperforming in that format.

They are, however, heavily reliant on their batting because of the vulnerability of their attack. Not one England bowler could squeeze their way into the first-choice Australian ODI attack (Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, James Faulkner and Adam Zampa and Mitchell Marsh).

With an ODI average of 29, Steven Finn is the only regular member of England’s bowling group with a career average of under 30. Mark Wood (average of 48), Chris Woakes (34), Liam Plunkett (34), Moeen Ali (43), Ben Stokes (39), Adil Rashid (38), and David Willey (32) all have ODI bowling records which range from ordinary to awful.

Yet that lot are still better than the new bowlers Australia have fielded in this ongoing series in South Africa. Australia have enviable depth in their pace ranks, but they’ve still been exposed against the Proteas due to the unavailability of Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, James Faulkner, Pat Cummins, James Pattinson, Joel Paris and Jason Behrendorff, each of whom is either rested, injured or fresh back from injury.

Australia will need at least four of those guys to be fit and ready for the Champions Trophy if they are to be strong chances to regain that title. For now, they need to be at least competitive in the final match in South Africa and then shrug this dreadful series off and regain their winning ways on home soil.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2016-10-11T07:16:49+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I agree Brian, in hindsight that security scare probably spared Australia the ignominy of their first Test loss to Bangladesh.

2016-10-11T03:27:21+00:00

Brian

Guest


As many have said few care about an overseas ODI series. Only the rusted on few will also care about the Champions Trophy next winter when everyone is watching AFL & NRL. After the Wimbledon scores and the Socceroos Confederations Cup there might even be a mention of the Champions Trophy. Mostly if one of the Aussies gets drunk and makes a fool of himself. I love cricket but I have no idea who won the last Champions Trophy or when it was. I thought they had got rid of it. Its all about keeping the KFC buckets sold whilst the BBL is on so let CA focus on that.

2016-10-11T03:18:50+00:00

Brian

Guest


True but Australia pulled out last year (even though the Socceroos played there). Based on the Sri Lankan tour I would say that pull out probabyl cost Bangladesh a series win.

2016-10-11T00:59:24+00:00

spruce moose

Guest


Yes, I am looking forward to David Warner cashing in on the Australian roads, getting easy 1st innings centuries and then the Channel 9 commentators talking about how 'awesome' and how much of a 'world beater' he is. Then of course, they'll go to India, and he'll go AWOL.

2016-10-11T00:57:25+00:00

spruce moose

Guest


Actually, I'll change to having M Marsh at six where he is actually at his statistical best. He doesn't average 39 in ODI's...either his complete record (37) or him coming at 5 (36). His record is best at 6.

2016-10-10T22:04:42+00:00

David a Pom

Guest


Ronan, Bangladesh have never beaten a proper test side at home or away...but they may be improving I'll give you that.

AUTHOR

2016-10-10T11:05:06+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


"Depended on the decks Ronan. If they are seaming decks and overcast it would be pretty hard to leave Hazlewood out." But the ODI decks in England are so flat these days Nudge - there have been so many 300+ scores in ODIs in England the past 18 months. Of the 20 ODIs in England since the World Cup, 12 times the team batting first has made 300+ England have had good success on such home decks so I'd be surprised if the pitches suddenly changed to be seaming decks in the Champions Trophy. I rate Hazlewood very highly. My point was only that if Cummins was fit and bowling well at 150kmh+ like he did in England last year (when he was easily the best bowler from either side and tormented the England top 6) then he couldn't possibly be left out and Hazlewood would be vulnerable.

2016-10-10T10:38:53+00:00

Nudge

Guest


Yeah major problems. Imagine how bad it would be if we weren't no 1 in the world in one day cricket or 2nd or 3rd in test cricket

2016-10-10T10:28:38+00:00

Peter

Roar Rookie


Australian cricket is full of ifs at the moment.

2016-10-10T10:13:33+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I would actually prefer to see them preparing for the second round of the second full strength Shield round in the lead up to the test series. If CA could just stop scheduling overseas tours in Oct the team would be so much better for it.

2016-10-10T10:03:04+00:00

JimmyB

Guest


What patent nonsense. You never disappoint do you Ronan?!

AUTHOR

2016-10-10T09:15:14+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


"I would much rather have all the players home and in the Mat BBQ One Day Cup." The Matador Cup would be amazing to watch if every team was at full strength with all internationals available (it's great to watch now but this would make it incredible).

AUTHOR

2016-10-10T09:12:42+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


"M Marsh at 7, and push up Maxwell and Wade. Otherwise, good team." I'd much rather M. Marsh at 5 - he averages 39 with the bat in ODIs and has shown in his career that he flourishes when handed the responsibility of batting further up the order. I'd rather have Maxwell after Marsh in the order. Maxwell shouldn't be handed too much responsibility with the bat, where possible he should be coming in with a licence to tee off - play to his rare abilities in this regard.

AUTHOR

2016-10-10T09:09:26+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


"Head’s bowling is as good if not better than Maxwell." I strongly disagree. These are their career bowling records in List A cricket: Head ........ 6 wickets at 64 (economy rate 6.3rpo) Maxwell ... 71 wickets at 36 (economy rate 5.3rpo)

AUTHOR

2016-10-10T09:04:57+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


"Technically Faulkner offers that depth, but he hasn’t really produced anything of note with the bat for Australia in a couple of years." Over the past two years Faulkner has averaged 34 with the bat in ODIs. His batting is not at the same level that it was in 2013 and 2014 when he was dominating but he still adds great value with the bat at 8. As for his bowling struggling against India and SA, that is only true of India. He has average 42 with the ball against India in ODIs this year and last, but 24 against every other team combined.

AUTHOR

2016-10-10T08:29:26+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


"Do not forget England lost to Bangladesh last night." And England should really be 2-0 down to Bangladesh, who were home and hosed batting second in the first match before having a massive choke and losing 6-17. It won't surprise me if England don't win the following Test series against Bangladesh, they're a decent team at home.

2016-10-10T07:54:06+00:00

handles

Guest


I reckon most of the cricketers either genuinely don't care, or, are only vaguely aware that they are playing.

2016-10-10T07:26:29+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


The batting isn't second string, only the bowlers. SA have also an inexperienced attack. Our batting has really fired in only one match, it's not just been the bowlers' responsibility.

2016-10-10T07:23:50+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


Yes! It's rubbish, isn't it?

2016-10-10T07:19:29+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


Smith's body language is terrible. I hope the coaches and team psych are working with hm on that. You can't have your captain reacting in tough situations like that. Plus I've noticed the bowlers giving dirty looks to fielders - sure the fielding has been poor this series but none of that either. It's unnecessary in a team sport.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar