Let's just cool our jets on NRC Spring Tour bolters

By Brett McKay / Expert

Irae Simone. Jake Gordon. Lukhan Tui. Izaia Perese. Taniela Tupou. They’ve all been outstanding during this season’s National Rugby Championship, and they all have one other thing in common.

They’ve all been touted as ‘bolters’ for the Wallabies’ Grand Slam Spring Tour of Europe and the UK.

And they’re not alone, either. You can add to those four names Matt Lucas, Jonno Lance, Sam Figg, Andrew Ready, Jack Dempsey, Kyle Godwin, Isa Naisarani, and I’m sure there’s others I’ve missed too.

These names have been thrown up from all kinds of angles, and from everyone from social media and rugby forum posters to Fox Sports commentators to Wallabies coach Michael Cheika himself – he spoke glowingly of Perese’s talents recently. I fully expect we’ll see new names in the ensuing discussion here today.

Just last week, Roarer Cliff opened with, “If Cheika does not take at least three NRC players on the EOYT, then that decision reinforces my opinion that Cheika is neither a selector nor an International Coach.”

At least three!

Now, in fairness, all the players named have all had really good NRC campaigns for the respective clubs. And it’s even surprising to see sides like Brisbane City and Queensland Country, who have battled throughout the season, producing some truly outstanding talent this season.

The whole point of the NRC is to develop and even unearth players ready to take the next step in their professional careers into Super Rugby, and I’ve no doubt that we’ll see a healthy number of graduates again in 2017.

Since the NRC kicked off, there were around a dozen players making their Super Rugby debut the following year, and from the 2015 NRC to Super Rugby this year, the total number is now pushing upwards of 50. Part of that is due to the Queensland Reds and Western Force enduring horror injury runs in 2016.

If by the end of the 2017 Super Rugby season that total number of graduates is averaging out around twenty per year, then what remaining doubt about the validity of the NRC will surely be blown away.

But the thing about the NRC is that it’s not supposed to be finding Wallabies. Not immediately after the completion of that NRC season anyway. (Click to Tweet)

All of these guys may well wear the Wallabies jersey in coming years, and I’m sure it’s all part of their professional end game. But in a number of cases, they haven’t even worn a Super Rugby jersey yet.

An NRC player yet to play Super Rugby pulling on a Wallabies jersey in November would be the modern day equivalent of Phil Kearns earning a Test debut from Randwick reserve grade.

I made this point in a comment late week, perhaps under the semi-finals preview, that we have to remember that a lot of these guys don’t have even an EPS contract with a Super Rugby side.

Jake Gordon has been widely touted as a November tourist – and I’ll be surprised if he isn’t crowned the NRC Player of the Year later this month – but even in the Waratahs squad, he still has two guys in front of him with 23 and 93 Super Rugby games to their name.

And I use him as an example because I just can’t see Michael Cheika painting any of the state coaches into a corner by taking a guy on a Wallabies tour who may not even play Super Rugby in 2017.

Further, I think it’s extremely unlikely an NRC player would force his way into the Test side, and though there’s a midweek game against the French Barbarians scheduled, carrying a non-Test player for five weeks is a bit of a luxury that Cheika probably can’t afford.

In all honesty, I think one NRC ‘bolter’ could go on tour – maybe – but he’ll be a player who will definitely play Super Rugby next season, and is probably well on his way to being an established Super Rugby player already. Tolu Latu seems an obvious chance, but maybe someone like Ready, or even Dempsey could fit the bill.

It makes for a great discussion point, throwing names like Gordon and Simone and Perese up as “genuine” chances, and it wouldn’t be undeserving, even. But I’m not sure the discussion has much grounding in reality.

I’d much rather see these guys do a full Super Rugby pre-season and take their opportunities next season.

The Final no-one saw coming has a really good vibe about it
With the possible exception of the 35 per cent of you who pumped for The Crowd to take Perth Spirit last week.

I’m absolutely rapped for Dwayne Nestor and his playing group, and they thoroughly deserve their place in the Final after really well-worked, well-earned Semi-Final win over the Sydney Rays on Sunday. And what’s more, they’re a huge chance in the Final in Tamworth on Saturday night, too.

But I don’t mind admitting I thought the Rays would be too strong, and I still stand by last week’s point about the competition benefiting immensely from an all-NSW Final.

That matters little now, of course, and the Final now pits the best team in the completion in the NSW Country Eagles against arguably the smartest, Perth Spirit.

Country thrive on kick return and turnover ball, yet the Spirit have a good tactical kicking game and one of the best breakdown back rows in the competition. The forwards battle will no doubt determine the result of the Final, like the more well-proportioned gents tell us is the norm.

But the centre battle will equally determine by how much. Kyle Godwin and Dave Horwitz are playing some genuinely top shelf rugby in this competition, but I tell you, as a pairing, Ben Tapuai and Billy Meakes haven’t been too far behind them.

The Crowd Says:

2016-10-19T21:56:57+00:00

NaBUru38

Guest


I agree with Bret. It's very unlikely that the top NRC players are ready to play for the Wallabies. NRC is supposed to help find new Super Rugby players.

2016-10-19T03:48:19+00:00

CUW

Guest


do they have space? i thought the squad was only 32 + 5 !!! :)

2016-10-18T20:42:48+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Because I don't agree with your negative logic?

2016-10-18T11:37:40+00:00

Redsback

Guest


He's called Tongan Thor for a reason: we'll need to wait two more years until he meets the residency requirement.

2016-10-18T11:12:37+00:00

PapanuiPirate

Roar Pro


Chook you don't have to tell me about seeing more games. Saw every rays games the last two years and the then the year I struggle to make it out to the beaches they start winning! Unfortunately it doesn't cut it with me that the club players are that close to Super Rugby Players. We are talking semi-pros vrs full timers. I can't see how a guy like Jordan Taufua can single handedly turn the tide against a side like Canterbury then Scott Fardy is anonymous when playing at the provincial level. Maybe the gap is smaller in Australia but if so that is more of an indictment than a positive.

2016-10-18T10:51:37+00:00

ClarkeG

Guest


NZ born CUW. Will be joining the Hurricanes.

2016-10-18T10:29:17+00:00

CUW

Guest


@Brett McKay there is a SAM LOUISI playing for Wellington . there was a mention he is a waratah. is he auzzy ? if auzzy , why is he playing in nz?

2016-10-18T08:50:23+00:00

Cynical Play

Guest


Bring back the Squirrel Grip.

2016-10-18T08:42:00+00:00

Cynical Play

Guest


Have you thought of applying to MENSA?

2016-10-18T08:26:13+00:00

Daveski

Guest


I'm late to the party too but agree with Brett's sentiments party-pooperish though they are. That said if we get another serious touch up Saturday, Cheika's has to look at some more fresh names on the EOYT. The Super Rugby season was a long time ago but who else was playing well that's hasn't yet had a run within the Wallabies squad? Tom English and Jono Lance are two. Jordy Reid and Jack Dempsey ( admittedly in generally cameo appearances ). All four have been good to great in the NRC also. I think all the non Super players named, it is a bit too early but I sure hope the State coaches show some balls when naming their teams early on and these guys get a go. But I'll contradict that with one name - Jake Gordon. Too good to leave behind in a position where Will Genia aside it's clear that he's at least as good as everyone else. What do the Yanks say about upside...? Gordon has a ceiling like a cathedral.

2016-10-18T07:19:57+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Good question albeit observation Papanui about the SR players not dominating over their Club cousins. I think the answer may lie somewhere in that the Club guys are pretty good, and not that far off SR Rugby. While the SR guys have everything to lose and not much to really gain. So it's a combination of the two which has given us supporters some terrific games. And there is no doubt the level of the NRC is now creditable... and least of all entertaining. You should try and see some more games... I don't think you'll be disappointed :)

2016-10-18T07:14:46+00:00

Jagman

Guest


You don't have to agree. I read a rumour before Bled 1 side was picked that the Wallabies were training AA and TR for the other side of the scrum that they played in SR and so far it has turned out correct. If Robertson is in the squad as an LHP then he is not taking Talakai's spot. I'm sure its not ideal but AA and TR are still young and Chieka is obviously looking to a future in which he doesn't see a need for pot plant props.

2016-10-18T06:46:36+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


I think it is a valid point... not many super players who aren't on national duty have really played the house down and shown themselves to be way better than the rest of the comp...

2016-10-18T06:38:20+00:00

Dave_S

Guest


Yes he was quality, can be again.

2016-10-18T06:27:05+00:00

PapanuiPirate

Roar Pro


The calm and collected approach I think is to compare to the other domestic competitions. It's been a fair few years since the NPC or Currie Cup has turned out an international bolter. It'sa bit of a shame from a historical point of view and it would really give the NRC a boost but generally the jump is just too big to expect. I think it's more likely that we will see some young SR level players in the coming years stamp down tour spots in the NRC rather than players going straight from NRC to national side. That being said, and with the caveat that I haven't seen as much NRC as I would have liked this season, I'm worried that we aren't seeing the dominance from the SR level players in the domestic competition. In the Currie Cup and NPC you really notice the quality of the SR players over some of the rest and even bench SR players can look like provincial superstars. Where are the SR regulars who are stamping their professional authority over the lower level NRC??

2016-10-18T06:23:29+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Slipper and Alexander were disasters at THP at international level. Exactly like them. Ala'alatoa has struggled at THP at times too. Kepu never came into his own as an international prop until 2013.

2016-10-18T06:21:30+00:00

Jagman

Guest


You mean like Alexander, Kepu, Slipper and Ala'alatoa. This weekend could be the last time you see Robertson at THP

2016-10-18T05:51:17+00:00

Markus

Guest


I really wish they had backed Jooste at flyhalf a lot more than they did during the NRC too, but after some of his performances I can also understand them wanting to get him out of the firing line.

2016-10-18T05:49:32+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


That has got to be the worst positional transitioning then I've ever seen then Jagman, if players are starting their switch at international level. We have an NRC and Super Rugby tournament to do that. If a player is to switch positions well, then they need to be spending their entire time playing that position. Not chopping and changing between and becoming a player that's not really good at either. What prop has ever been one of the best in the world, despite switching between LH and TH?

2016-10-18T05:49:08+00:00

Jagman

Guest


The Force have given a training contract to Con Foley.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar