At the draft, where dreams come true

By mds1970 / Roar Guru

Draft night. It’s the AFL’s Night of Optimism, when every club leaves with a stronger list than they arrived with.

It’s a night when the hard work of talent around the country is rewarded, when the dream of becoming an AFL player becomes a reality.

And so the football world gathered at Sydney’s Hordern Pavilion on Friday night for the 2016 AFL Draft. List managers, coaches, statisticians from every club. The media in massive numbers.

Young hopefuls with a dream, accompanied by their families.

The Hordern Pavilion is just a stone’s throw from the SCG, part of the Entertainment Quarter complex. The stage at the front had been set up with flashing lights, which would change to the colours of the club with the next pick.

Immediately in front of the stage were VIP tables. Elite players who were expected to be picked early and their families had prime viewing position. The public, a few hundred of them, sat in rows behind.

To our left, 18 booths complete with tables, computers and mountains of paperwork, were where the clubs were set up. The club officials would talk among themselves, with picks being lodged electronically; the public at the venue or watching on TV would not hear them speak.

To our right was a large media contingent, each one of them furiously tapping away at their laptops. Every club had their own media people, along with the AFL and many media organisations who covered the event live online.

And behind us, on a raised platform, was the Fox Footy mini-studio; their talk projected onto the big screens beside the stage.

The early arrivers were given a briefing by AFL Talent Manager Kevin Sheehan on the big names expected to be picked early. Sheehan’s a veteran of the draft scene, and every year has a look of pride in his eyes as he enthusiastically talks up the latest crop of draftees.

Then the Fox Footy preview show was screened. And then it was draft time.

Whenever a club had a pick, the lights above the stage would light up in that team’s colours.

The club has two minutes to make their choice and press the button, which triggers a light-up message that the pick is in.

If it’s a bid for an academy or father-son player, it’s then up to the nominated club to press the button to indicate whether they would match the bid.

AFL CEO Gillon McLachlan then enters the stage and read out the player’s name. It’s a special moment for the player and their family; as a youth spent working and training hard and travelling around the country to play is vindicated. The dream has come true, and there’s hugs all round at the tables down the front.

The player then goes backstage before emerging on the stage, along with the senior coach of his new club, who presents his guernsey. The dream which motivated them through their junior years has come true; and it’s a joyous moment.

And when Gillon McLachlan reads the name out, the next club’s two minutes starts.

Essendon had the first pick. They’d played their cards close to their chest before the draft, but went with Andrew McGrath. It was no secret that GWS wanted McGrath, trading up to pick 2, but the Bombers had first pick and he’ll give the Bombers great service.

GWS used their pick 2 to pick up Tim Taranto. It wasn’t a surprise that the Giants overlooked Hugh McCluggage, they already have plenty like him. But it enabled Brisbane Lions to take McCluggage and Ben Ainsworth to find his way to Gold Coast.

The first Academy bid came with pick 5, and GWS gave up picks 15 and 37 to match a bid for Will Setterfield. That dropped Carlton to pick 6, which they used to get Sam Petrovski-Seton.

Gold Coast’s active trade period saw them land some early picks, with Jack Scrimshaw joining the Suns at pick 7 and Will Brodie at pick 9. In between, Fremantle got Griffin Logue, who with his Sideshow Bob hairdo will likely become a cult figure at the Dockers.

Completing the top 10, Gold Coast matched a Swans bid for Suns Academy player Jack Bowes.

After the top ten had been picked, those players re-appeared on stage in their guernseys for a group photo opportunity. Four Suns, two Giants, a Bomber, a Lion, a Blue and a Docker. The footy world will be watching them closely for the next several years.

From pick 11, the coaches no longer presented jumpers on stage, which saw the draft process speed up. And from the second round onwards, Gillon McLachlan was seated at a desk on stage, no longer needing to walk on and off the stage for every pick.

More names were read out, more dreams fulfilled. Academy and father-son players were bid, and not all of them matched, with Academy clubs unwilling to go into points deficit.

Stevie Johnson, taken at pick 24 in 2001, made a guest appearance to read out pick 24, his injured hand twitching uncontrollably in a heavy cast.

Luke Parker, pick 40 in 2010, also appeared to read out pick 40. Neither Johnson nor Parker were first-rounders, but both have made a big impact in the AFL.

There were familiar names read out. Willie Rioli is another from that famous family, joining West Coast.

Jake Waterman also joins the Eagles, his father being one of the original Eagles. Geelong picked up Quinton Narkle, who surely has to be related to another Eagles original.

Father-son bidding works the same way as Academy bidding. Collingwood don’t have an eligible Academy, and the Giants and Suns won’t get a father-son pick for a generation; but all clubs potentially benefit. And Collingwood landed two sons of their 1990 premiership side as Callum Brown and Josh Daicos will wear the black and white next year.

And a few appropriate names. Corey Lyons joins the Lions. And Hawthorn, after sensationally trading four-time premiership stars Mitchell and Lewis, drafted Mitchell Lewis.

GWS Giants pulled off the shock of the night, throwing former Fremantle player Matt de Boer a lifeline. Injuries killed his career at the Dockers, but if new surroundings bring him a change in fitness luck, he may have some useful experience to offer the Giants.

For GWS Giants, all but two of their picks came from their Academy, while three Academy players found themselves at other clubs. From a zone that did not produce a single player just four years ago, far from diluting the AFL’s talent pool, GWS is now a net contributor to it.

Disappointingly, the crowd was noticeably thinning out even by the end of the second round; and by the later picks even club officials who had passed on selections were filing out. It wasn’t late, barely 9pm on a Friday night and it seemed rude that so many were leaving while there were still players being selected.

But nothing could wipe the smiles off the faces of the young men up the front who by now had changed into the polo shirts of their new clubs. Cameras were flashing as players beamed with pride, being pictured with their new coaches and teammates.

After the last player was picked, the Fox Footy broadcast was shut down. Clubs had their own video cameras recording interviews, introducing their new players to their anticipant supporters; while the gathering press were gathering quotes from the footy faces of the future.

And some remaining fans took the chance to be the first to have a selfie with a recruit.

For the players, there’s a long road ahead. Many will now move out of home to relocate interstate.

For all the training, the preparation and the spotlight will be far more intense than anything they’ve ever seen. Not all of them will make it to their AFL debut, and only a select few will become genuine superstars of the game.

But for all of them, this is the beginning. The opportunities are there, and the footy world will be watching on with interest.

And for some, the superstar few, the night at the Hordern Pavilion will be fondly remembered as the place where the journey into the AFL began.

The Crowd Says:

2016-11-28T04:40:01+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


There's a nice story in one of the suburban papers about our no. 28 pick, Pat Lipinski being a lifelong bulldogs supporter.

2016-11-28T04:20:16+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


as with Giants having just selected Sproule and Swans have selected Fisher as academy rookies, that effectively means that all nine players nominated from the GWS Academy have found homes in the AFL system (with Giants getting five of the nine). That's an impressive strike rate, and makes a lie of anyone claiming all nine would have made it into the AFL without the Giants Academy.

2016-11-28T03:03:30+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


It's interesting though - the development every where needs a focus and not just non-traditional areas. Tassie this year - no draftees - sure their 2 brightest prospects were injured and missed out - however, NSW and QLD combined provided more than WA. Actually QLD/NT/NSW almost equalled SA and WA. North Melbourne are going to be running an 11-15 yrs 'next generation' academy in Tassie - which will be very important - the kids down there are playing basketball and soccer too, and the Tassie Tigers have a solid cricket program. It's important the AFL doesn't let Tasmania drop off the map!!

AUTHOR

2016-11-27T21:42:07+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


Yes but not by 674 points. And no club would consider going that far into deficit, even if they were allowed to - it would completely mess up their next year's drafting.

AUTHOR

2016-11-27T21:38:45+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


It's very possible. With only 38 on the main list, GWS need to have 6 rookies. They currently have 2 - Sam Reid & Lloyd. Joel Patfull after retiring is staying on as a rookie, and the Giants are likely to take the delisted Jake Barrett back as a rookie. That still leaves two vacancies that must be filled - and there's some Academy players who would have to be strongly considered. Zac Sproule's name has been mentioned in despatches.

2016-11-27T21:28:11+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Wrong again MDS, a team is allowed to go into points deficit.

AUTHOR

2016-11-27T10:20:03+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


It's an interesting hypothetical. But, assuming no trades, no priority picks, no future picks traded in or out last year or penalties imposed; a club that wins the premiership would get picks 18 (985 points), 36 (502), 54 (220) and 72 (19). A total of 1,726 points. To match a bid on pick 1, a club would need 2,400 points (including the discount). So in that scenario, the wooden spoon club would get the Academy player.

2016-11-27T09:23:32+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


For the record GWS has, as of today, 17 first round picks on it's list plus three 17-year-old priority selections (which would all have likely went first round). Maybe Carlton and Melbourne may have close to 70% of GWS total but I doubt it.

2016-11-27T09:11:39+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


I know they are not all at the club. The majority who have moved on or been moved on could not get game time. They may one day become good players but so far have failed to meet or exceed expectations. GWS has been able to keep the rest (or trade the few want-aways for very good returns). Other clubs weren't reluctant to make trades. Please do not assume facts not in evidence. The fact is clubs have no ability to trade players unless those players dictate a trade be made. GWS wasn't a place any players wanted to go. It was a place players who wanted to extend their careers whose original clubs turfed them, wanted to go. It was a place unproven kids wanted to go if offered contracts they'd never have gotten anywhere else. Finishing last doesn't net a team number 1 picks. It should only net them a single pick. As for having an issue, I have been against the academy rort since it first came to light, has nothing to do with GWS marginal on field success. Six years ago every one was looking forward to getting through the concession drafts then looking forward to non-compromised drafts. It's never happened and never will happen so long as a select handful of clubs, regardless of ladder finish, get first dibs before anyone else does. Here's a hypothetical for you: Let's say GWS in some future year wins the premiership. That year the stand out kid in the draft happens to be from their academy. The wooden spoon team bids on the academy kid with their deserved first pick. GWS matches it with pick 18 and some other junk picks in 2nd and 3rd rounds. GWS ends up with a flag and the #1 overall pick in the same year. 1. Is that fair? Now think of that same scenario and replace GWS with whatever team you hate the most. 2. Would your answer still be the same? Now think of that same scenario and imagine it is GWS that has been suffering a Brisbane or Melbourne like drought of respectability and you've just seen another side take away the best player even though you finished wooden spoon. 3. Would your answer still be the same?

AUTHOR

2016-11-27T08:28:02+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


Not all of those 29 are still at the club; and the number of first-round picks on the Giants' current list I doubt would be significantly different to most other clubs. Obviously in 2011, with the Giants forming a list from scratch, there needed to be concessions to enable the new club to put a team on the field. And at the time, other clubs were reluctant to trade quality, experienced players to the Giants; preferring instead to trade more top picks. The Giants came last in their first two seasons, winning just three games in total; and that netted them number 1 picks. Other clubs willingly traded top picks, and no-one seemed to mind at the time. It's only because the Giants moved very suddenly from being easybeats to premiership contenders that it became an issue.

2016-11-27T05:32:54+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


That's the thing, Carlton got the 1st round picks that GWS deemed not good enough to play for them. Give someone 29 of anything, tell them to keep them all for at least a year, pick the best dozen out of the bunch, then sell the remainder. The person who got first crack is always going to have the best collection regardless of the others 'trickling down'.

2016-11-27T05:30:23+00:00

Josh

Guest


Yes all other sports are now packing up in NSW as the AFL has completely taken over. It's a whitewash.

2016-11-27T04:30:42+00:00

alicesprings

Guest


Perspective people. It's the AFL. Its not an even competition. - GWS don't have access to any father/son players. - VIC clubs don't have to deal with the 'go home' factor. - The Grand final is played at the MCG every year regardless of whose home game it is. - Many Vic clubs are lucky is play more than 4 interstate games each year. Yes GWS have had access to several NSW/ACT players that have gone high in the draft. Home many games have they played collectively???..wouldn't be more than 25 games. Lets just calm down! Why cant we be happy that GWS list will be majority NSW talent in the very near future and that the academies have and will significantly added to the talent pool (remembering the past hysteria that surrounded GWS supposable diluting of the talent pool!).

2016-11-27T04:29:51+00:00

Slane

Guest


I was thinking that we might have 9 number 1 picks on the field at the same time when Carlton play against GWS this season.

2016-11-27T04:23:08+00:00

alicesprings

Guest


I counted 9 NSW/ACT drafted. Hopefully another couple will get picked up in the preseason/rookie draft.

2016-11-27T04:20:49+00:00

alicesprings

Guest


I recall the commentators noting during the Carlton v GWS game this year that it was Carlton who had more 1st rounders on the park. Good lot it did for them! Having the picks is one thing, making the correct selection is quite another. The simple reality is that GWS traded cleverly to ensure they had the picks and points to match any bids on the academy players. No doubt the same story will be repeated next year with GWS picking up more first road picks as compensation for home sick Victorian players wanting to go home.

AUTHOR

2016-11-27T02:49:03+00:00

mds1970

Roar Guru


Had it not been for the Giants Academy; GWS wouldn't have had Setterfield, Perryman & Cumming as first round picks. Neither would anyone else, they wouldn't have been first rounders.

2016-11-27T02:00:04+00:00

Davico

Guest


Cat, Agreed, it should be a pure draft and all clubs should contribute to pay for the development of talent in non-traditional afl areas. Father son has to go as well. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2016-11-27T01:06:03+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Stop straw-manning the argument. No one is saying not to grow the talent pool, but when that pool is being cherry picked by ONE CLUB, it is wrong and unsustainable. Twenty-nine first round picks in six years! I don't care who the recruiter/developer is, you still only have to get 25% right and be miles ahead of any other club. Other teams get a first round pick wrong and it can set them back a year or more because they don't have the luxury of multiple attempts. On top of that GWS gets to park multiple first round picks as depth players because they have more first round picks then playing positions, who can be traded for first round picks in future drafts. The system given to GWS will mean they will have 2+ first round picks (most likely top 10 or higher) every single year for the next decade at least.

2016-11-27T00:58:22+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Yeah, GWS gets the cream of the crop (@20% discount) and the rest of the league gets the leftovers (at full price) ... Fact is GWS will continue to get top end talent year after year after year, they have so many 1st round picks, who can't possibly get games, other clubs will continue to give GWS high picks for them. Even if GWS somehow doesn't trade and work its way to the top of the draft they can still get top talent with low end picks by matching bids. 2011: 11 first round picks 2012: 5 first round picks 2013: 3 first round picks 2014: 3 first round picks 2015: 3 first round picks 2016: 4 first round picks That's 29 first round picks in 6 years! Enough is enough already.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar