The Big Show needs a change of state, but New South Wales isn't the answer

By Tim Miller / Editor

You can say many things about Glenn Maxwell, but one thing you can never accuse him of is being unambitious.

He’s not content with remaining a mere limited-overs superstar and bludger of state bowling attacks. He wants a spot in the Test side. And he wants it badly enough to openly criticise his Victorian captain, Matthew Wade, for batting him too low in the order to achieve this goal.

And he’s not content either with only remaining a Test option on the subcontinent, where his part-time spin bowling elevates him above other domestic batsmen of similar calibre. He thought he was a chance to play in the Adelaide Test against South Africa and was openly disappointed when Nic Maddinson was given the vacant number six spot.

In venting his frustration he upset the establishment, both in the Victorian and national hierarchy, and now finds himself relegated him to the outskirts of the one-day side, although captain Steve Smith says his non-selection against New Zealand is not related to his comments.

If anyone in Australian cricket needs a change of scenery now, it is Glenn Maxwell. A fresh start would do him the world of good.

As far as talents go, you’d be hard-pressed to find many in this country with more natural cricketing gifts than ‘The Big Show’. The vast array of weird and wonderful shots he has at his disposal, and the supreme confidence it takes to use them all at the highest level, are almost unique to him among Australian cricketers.

But at the moment, he’s out of both favour and form. He’s struggled so far in the Sheffield Shield, averaging just over 25 with the bat. For all his comments about his position in the batting order, the fact remains that in his most recent Shield game, batting at four, he managed just 6 and 29.

Also not helping his case is that fact that Cameron White, batting one position lower than Maxwell at seven, has been racking up truckloads of runs. You could even make the argument that Maxwell, even if he should be batting above Wade, should be batting below White anyway.

Earlier this year, Maxwell made a last-ditch effort to transfer from Victoria to New South Wales so as to improve his chances of returning to both the one-day and Test sides, outside the regular transfer period. The proposal was rejected. He needs to move heaven and earth to ensure he gets in before the deadline ends this off-season, or the future will just be more of the same for him.

New South Wales probably isn’t the right option, either. Yes, it will put him directly under the selectors’ noses for a potential Test call-ups. But the Blues have a very strong side, even with David Warner and Smith rarely available.

He’d be competing with the likes of Kurtis Patterson, Nic Maddinson and another captain in Moises Henriques for middle-order spots. If he’s serious in his belief that his Test ambitions have been hampered by batting at six for Victoria, moving one state north doesn’t really make a lot of sense.

Queensland seems a far more viable option. They’ve had their struggles in the batting department this season, three times being bundled out for under 200 in an innings. With Usman Khawaja and Matt Renshaw set to be there or thereabouts in the Test side, there’s also a definite opening for Maxwell to assert his own case by batting up the order, ahead of youngsters like Marnus Labuschagne and Sam Heazlett.

The Bulls’ resident spin-bowling all-rounder Jason Floros averages just 28 with the bat and 40 with the ball in his Shield career, indicating he’s probably not quite up to the level. And with regular captain Khawaja entrenched in the Test team and deputy Chris Hartley nearing the end of his career, there’s also a definite opportunity for Maxwell to stamp himself as a leader in a relatively youthful team.

There is no doubting Maxwell needs a change of scenery if his undisputed talents are ever going to earn him a regular place in the Test team. And the Sunshine State may be the ideal place for him to achieving just that.

The Crowd Says:

2016-12-09T03:42:18+00:00

dan ced

Guest


I don't really want him at the Redbacks, I'd prefer to stick with youth, although I'd take Klinger back! (despite the poor form).

2016-12-08T21:58:48+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


This makes complete sense purely from a batting point for Queensland. Other than Khawaja, Renshaw & Lynn Queensland doesn't have a batsmen averaging 35 or more in FC Cricket. Maxwell would be perfect foil for the younger guys like Heazlett & The Lasagne man! I really hope QLD Cricket get this done. But I highly doubt it, Maxi will end up playing for the Blues.

2016-12-07T14:15:34+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


We prefer Agar, Turner, Short and Hinchliffe. Victoria need him. Send Wade to...NZ.

2016-12-07T14:13:10+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Is that because you have topped up with Victorians like Nevill and Carters...or those that trained in SA?

2016-12-07T08:08:10+00:00

OJP

Guest


agreed; plus JL knows a thing or two about getting in (and staying in) the skippers good books ... and he can send Maxwell to find some form in my modified T20 team where everyone tries to bat like 'the Big Show' anyway. He may even learn a couple of new shots to incorporate into his repertoire.

2016-12-07T04:16:02+00:00

Damo

Guest


Come to WA. JL will sort him out, WA need anyone at the moment and he moves away from the East Coast media.

2016-12-07T03:50:35+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


QLD spin bowler is Sweapson so I am not he would get much spin bowling since Floros has not played that many games this year. We have many many all-rounders already in the team, no need for anymore. I am not sure I would be putting him above either of those young bats either. Maxwell belongs in NSW. It is his spiritual home. Maxwell should be playing for Vic, now, not passing out the the drinks for ODI's. The selectors have really done him over there.

2016-12-07T03:18:22+00:00

Don Piper

Guest


We dont want you in NSW Glen Maxwell We are full. Same goes for everyone else.

2016-12-07T01:25:55+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


If you can get past all the Queenslanders it's quite nice

2016-12-07T01:14:27+00:00

Lancey5times

Guest


Pretty spot on I reckon although he may see a move anywhere would be more beneficial than staying put. The NSW move was maybe as much about the spin bowling conditions and way of life than anything else (have you been to Queensland? Awful place. Full of Queenslanders). SA look very light on when you take Head out of the top six so opportunities may present there as well plus they are a reasonably competitive side with some solid youngsters. Both QLD and SA also have coaches that I think would be good for Maxi. They both know a little about forcing your way into the Australian setup through weight of runs (one more successfully than the other :))

2016-12-07T01:10:04+00:00

madmonk

Guest


Good piece and I had the same thought. Anywhere but NSW. SA or Tas would be ok but I agree Qld looks like the best fit.

Read more at The Roar