Victory and Sky Blues have wrestled back control of their cities

By Evan Morgan Grahame / Expert

Things seem to be sliding back into place, at least from the perspectives of the two traditional south-east coast powers.

Last season, with Western Sydney making the grand final, and the Melbourne City project revving up into a new, threatening gear, the original Sydney and Melbourne franchises were, evidently, simply biding their time.

The Victory were bundled out of the finals in 2016, and the Sky Blues didn’t even make the post-season.

This season, though, has embarrassed those who announced a premature paradigm shift. The power balance, it seems, has not changed in the way the new neighbours might have hoped.

The way the Melbourne Victory have reasserted their quality over the last six games has been especially impressive.

Melbourne City, falling to the bottom-placed club on Thursday, have been punished for their laxity. They are now nine points behind their city rivals – having played a game more – and 13 points behind Sydney.

They are yet to appoint a new manager, and the fear for them is that the incoming gaffer, when he arrives, may have too wide a gap to make up. The Tim Cahill homecoming season is in danger of petering out, and certainly no one expects City to enjoy any finals success if they continue to meander in the way they have.

Meanwhile, Kevin Muscat and his troops are tightening their focus, with players all over the pitch growing in stature with every passing week. Their 3-2 win over the Roar was not easily ground out – Matt McKay and Brandon Borrello both had clear chances to equalise. But it did reek of the stout musk of a team – hard done by, and frustrated with themselves – refusing to submit to fate.

The match was punctuated by some sudden surges of energy, both good and bad. Shoddy refereeing and sublime set-piece execution both get the blood pumping with equal vigour.

James Troisi’s free kick was the exemplar instep strike, curling with venom into the corner, leaving Michael Theo rooted to the spot. Then, following Melbourne’s second goal, there was a puzzling decision to award the Victory a penalty, when Besart Berisha went down in the box.

No one, barely even Berisha himself, appealed with any great enthusiasm. Still, the Victory were raucous in the opening half an hour. Troisi and Rojas are probably the best creative combination in the league, and with Berisha, have made the Victory the most productive attacking team this season.

Dimi Petratos, however, was to steal the show with a thunderbolt from his own dead-ball opportunity, reviving the prone Roar fans who had all but conceded defeat. Standing alone over the free kick, from an audacious distance, Petratos trotted up and unleashed a howitzer, that began its flight down the middle of the goal, then swerved violently to the right, ending up just inside the corner.

Lawrence Thomas merely watched, and probably felt the sonic-boom as the ball rocketed into his goal, still going upwards. Two free kicks, and two stationary goalkeepers.

Brisbane forced their way back into the game, electrified by Petratos’s effort like Mia Wallace was in Pulp Fiction, after the adrenaline dart is plunged through her breastplate. John Aloisi said the word ‘character’ about a dozen times post-match.

The linesman might have summoned some of his own, in the second half, because his advice to referee Chris Beath to show Berisha a straight red card for a totally innocuous physical encounter with Luke de Vere was rash and giddy.

The new rule concerning off-the-ball contact with the head or face, that advises violent conduct be the charge, mitigates for contact deemed “negligible”. This was a perfect example of that clause being ignored, and as the red flashed into the night, it fanned the crowd into a smouldering heap. They booed throughout the remainder of the match.

Clearly, we haven’t all forgotten how potent the Victory were in their double-winning campaign two seasons ago. But the momentum – not to mention the money – behind the Melbourne City project has made it feel like a new hierarchy was being constructed. The feeling was only compounded by City’s derby win in October.

It has been reversed, however, on the back of six straight Victory wins – including one over City – and Kevin Muscat is now proving that he is not simply riding on the wake of the stellar work Ange Postecoglou did at the Victory.

Western Sydney have been prone to heavy fluctuation season to season, and this term seems to be one of their down years.

Their success since their formation has outshone their city rivals; an Asian Champions League, a Premiers Plate, and three grand final appearances, all coming in the last five years.

In belated response, Sydney FC are mow putting together perhaps the most impressive season in A-League history, certainly the best since the Brisbane Roar’s dominance. Their local superiority was underlined by a resounding derby win early in the season, with the second to come on Saturday night.

Their defensive paucity has been unprecedented; even the 2010/11 Roar team, that lost just one game all season, had conceded more goals (9) after 14 games than this season’s Sydney FC (7) have. Having finished last season so poorly, wallowing and self-flagellating, their unbeaten start – which has now extended past the halfway point of the campaign – has wiped away all those sour memories.

Right now, the Big Blue coming up at the end of January is looking like the grand final dress rehearsal.

The finals are always volatile, and are obviously far less predictable than the minor premiership, but few would disagree these two teams are currently the best in the competition. Sydney were the inaugural champions. Melbourne Victory have won more grand finals than any other club.

The hallowed colossi of the A-League are creaking, rumbling, throwing off the dust and shaking off the rust, preparing to exchange titanic blows again.

The Crowd Says:

2017-01-14T23:42:14+00:00

Chris

Guest


haha @ snobs of the west. Yes you are right in your region breakup but the real divide is east/west.

2017-01-14T23:09:02+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


Homebush is bad enough to watch any rectangular sport, I can only imagine the horrible views on offer at the MCG. I've been to the MCG once where 73k were there for an AFL game, the place is massive and even feels too big for that sport with all their players trying to cover the ground

2017-01-14T23:07:14+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


The cove have great tunes, there's no need to change them all each season the way Popo turns over a squad :) It's true, Sydney are more of a bunch of regions that sit beside each other. The obvious is east and west, but there's also north and south and then the hills brigade who are the snobs of the west.

2017-01-14T22:57:21+00:00

Chris

Guest


MCG is awful to watch football. It might be ok for afl where they have 40 odd players running around but doesnt work for football.

2017-01-14T22:32:41+00:00

Chris

Guest


I dont think (in Sydney at least) either city has any claim to being number 1. The city is split in 2 with east v west and both will claim superiority. I was at last nights game and the atmosphere was brilliant. Im Sydney FC, but have to hand it to the WSW and the RBB for their passion and noise that they make. Cove needs to come up with some new tunes!

2017-01-14T11:49:21+00:00

Josh

Guest


Strange article considering we see Sydney FC as representing East Sydney and us West. So they've never lost control of their part of the city.

2017-01-14T08:27:07+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


Thanks Mr Football for your useless post. Now off you go and collect the BBL sydney ratings and show us poor A League followers how inferior we are

2017-01-14T07:48:41+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Fox ratings for last night's game: Fri STV #ALeague #FoxSports #MVCvBRI 62k

2017-01-14T06:17:42+00:00

Jeff Milton

Guest


What did I say? My SFC membership gets me first dib on tickets anyway I think for more people to enjoy the game the mcg is best but agree it's terrible viewing Football in this country needs a national stadium I have only missed two SFC games this year but thanks for jumping to conclusions

2017-01-14T03:49:22+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


You're spot on Caltex. Additionally, the MCG is a crap sporting venue to watch football. Perhaps the worst venue I've ever been to watch football any where in the world. NPL venues provide better viewing for football. But, as usual, we've got 2 posters who together have probably have watched ZERO full matches of ALeague this season providing input on a discussion that requires deep knowledge of the ALeague - today and in the past. They're clueless, but they want to stick their ignorant little noses into the discussion to grab attention.

2017-01-14T03:44:31+00:00

Amazon

Roar Rookie


@ Caltex.........................tell him he's dreaming!

2017-01-14T02:14:13+00:00

Caltex & SBS support Australian Football

Guest


Jeff, the MCG wouldn't be big enough. Unless they put up mobile TV screens in the surrounding park spaces. The game would be screened live through-out Asia.. Something that the AFL would be jealous of. But hey, the AFL in Nauru is the country's national game that's something the FFA could not achieve in the last 11 years.

2017-01-13T23:15:28+00:00

AGO74

Guest


I think the question being posed in this article is about the now and present and to that the author is correct that Sydney is in the ascendancy. Fortunes can change quickly though especially in the A-League as wsw in particular have shown. When they are hot they are hot and when they are not, their not. As for history since wsw arrived then yes they have had more success. Interesting though that in the time even when they've had success they still have a poor record to us - I think it is more than 1000 days since they beat us?? All that matters at moment though is tonight - can't wait. If it's anything like last nights it will be a cracker.

2017-01-13T22:57:30+00:00

pete4

Guest


Looking at the ladder both these clubs look ahead of the pack for sure after 15 rounds. SFC have made some solid signings in the off-season and look a much different club. Also been really impressed with Troisi at MVFC this season he's been quality in their front third. Huge #SydneyDerby tonight. Can't wait!!

2017-01-13T22:56:25+00:00

Jeff Milton

Guest


I would love to see a SFC v victory final. Would be great to win it in Melbourne on a road trip and party the night away. Surely the MCG would sell out

2017-01-13T21:06:29+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


For Victory, control of the City in terms of ALeague has never been lost. There has been absolutely nothing about Melbourne City last season, or this season ... or any season that would make anyone think they were the main football identity in Melbourne. That may happen in the future. Right now the only thing that makes City impressive is that they are owned by a very wealthy individual and they have a strong football operation backing them from abroad. For Sydney FC, we'd need locals from the Harbour City to give their impression of whether the balance of power has shifted back to FC. But, from afar, it seems to me Sydney FC has had 2 good season since WSW entered the competition. During these 2 good sesons, they've finished * 2nd in the Premiership and * played in 2 Grand Finals: ALeague GF in 2015, FFA Cup Final in 2016. So far, they've won ZERO trophies during this period. By contrast, WSW has had 3 good seasons since they entered the competition during which time they've: * Won the ALeague Premiership * Won the Asian Champions League * Twice finished 2nd in the ALeague Premiership * Played in 3x ALeague Grand Finals Seems pretty obvious who has superiority on-the-park in Sydney.

Read more at The Roar