Comedy exhibition games - on and off the field - only hurt the A-League

By Evan Morgan Grahame / Expert

The ABC, given the opportunity to televise a football match between the A-League’s best team and one of England’s most decorated, decided for some reason to construct around the event a truly dreadful ‘comedy’ framework.

Three hosts appeared on our screens, clad in ill-fitting jerseys and scarves, already primed with strained smiles. A looming dread descended; this was going to be an ordeal. Things got off to a truly bilious start, as a few abhorrent seconds of Warwick Capper’s 1985 song I Only Take What’s Mine were shown.

God… why have you forsaken us so?

Here are some of the best lines from what was a truly testing opening segment.

“We’re expecting them [Sydney] to score a few goals and get smashed in the second half” insert canned laughter.

“Ninkovic could almost play in the Premier League couldn’t he?” – it was pointed out to the presenter that Ninkovic wasn’t playing tonight, as the viewers started shuddering.

“Shows how much I know!” he said, grinning at the camera; yes, or how atrociously little.

“He’s very affectionate [Jurgen Klopp], isn’t he? roll five second, black-and-white montage set to soppy music of Klopp embracing his players.

One of the panellists, when asked about Graham Arnold, prefaced her comments with “The coaches I know about are your AFL coaches”.

Then out came the ‘Arnold-ometer’, a prop-comedy gauge used to track Arnie’s many hilarious moods – what fun, eh? Perhaps the most blaring indignity was using an elderly Liverpudlian, apparently named Billy, as some sort of cliched stereotype sidekick, sitting in an armchair with a crocheted blanket draped over the back.

A few questions were thrown at him, his answers were quite clearly unrehearsed, and then he wasn’t seen again. There were literally too many appalling gags to list without succumbing to violent heaving. We haven’t even mentioned the bizarre, off-the-cuff telephone call to Arnie, which lasted a few excruciating minutes, a sequence that was essentially just one of the presenters shouting into his un-mic’d iPhone, as the others guffawed and gurned at the camera.

Oh yes, then they all texted Harry Kewell – recently made manager of Crawley Town, and no doubt busy – a series of side-splitting comic text messages, one of which was “Hey Harry, you called. Who is dis?”

It was all fantastically awful, a utterly stomach-turning effort at pre-match coverage.

(Dean Jones / Flickr)

This match was not one to take seriously, sure, with Steven Gerrard, Jamie Carragher and Steve MacManaman set to take to field at some point. This was a post-season exhibition run-out, a light caper. But it was still a football match, involving the country’s best team, which was, Ninkovic aside, basically a full strength starting XI.

More important this was an advertisement of sorts for football in Australia, and it was being framed as a kind of pantomime to laugh at. The A-League is growing out of it’s awkward adolescence and into a fine, handsome adulthood, and this ghastly coverage fixed a clown nose to it, and ruffled its hair like you would some pudgy step-child. It was embarrassing.

The commentary team made no attempt – thankfully, if in total inconsistency to the demeanour of the earlier coverage – to carry the air yucks and sniggers into the match-call. Steven Gerrard had a fine chance to volley in what would have been a thumping opening goal, but skied it, to the audible disappointment of much of the crowd.

Daniel Sturridge slid home the opening goal after seven minutes, drifting one way, then suddenly back the other way, bamboozling Alex Wilkinson, before shooting low and hard beyond Danny Vukovic. One of the commentators spoke, in somewhat irrelevant fashion, how it was evidence of Sturridge’s readiness to force his way back into England contention, and that Gareth Southgate was no doubt keeping an eye on things. Yes, and do you think he was scouting Carragher while he was at it?

The commentator garnished that remark, as replays of Sturridge’s sharp finish rolled, with the sentence “That’s the difference between the Premier League and other countries”, by which one assumes he meant our country. How tedious and boorish it is to point out that the A-League isn’t as good as the one of the oldest and most richly funded leagues in the world.

It crept up on you, as the crowd hopefully called out for Gerrard to shoot whenever he had the ball, and cheered all of Liverpool’s promising moments, that this was a Sydney crowd who weren’t supporting Sydney. The stands were bathed in red, a sea of Optus customers, it seemed – I’m sure all of them sat up to watch Liverpool’s final league match against Boro three days ago. When Alberto Moreno – called “Arthur” Moreno by the commentator – scored Liverpool’s second goal, there was much rejoicing. A little earlier, Carragher was seen keeping pace with George Blackwood.

What is the value of these events, really? They force football into some small recess of part of the public consciousness for a night, drag some dusty Premier League shirts from cupboards for a six-hour airing, but what else? Make a mockery of the local league? Expose the woeful under-preparedness of our public broadcaster? Prompt a deep void of mirth within every unfortunate viewer, as one quip after another deflates the soul?

(AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts)

In last night’s match, even before the first kick Sydney were in a lose-lose situation. Win, and it is dismissed because Liverpool were playing literal retirees on the night. Lose, and it’s used as evidence of how poor the A-League still is, snickered at for being unable to hang with 80 per cent of Liverpool’s Champions League-worthy team.

All the people in the crowd, who had been lining up outside the Liverpool merchandise tent a few hours earlier, will not be converted into Sydney FC fans by this, an unfunny joke with our champion team as the punchline.

The referee generously waved away appeals for two Liverpool penalties as the first half wound down, and David Carney struck the woodwork. Roberto Firmino had scored a third by that time, and the atmosphere – described as “electric” by the call team – was flat.

The placidity of the half-time break was lacerated by the return of the pre-match team, and as soon as one of them described Moreno’s goal as “Harlem Globetrotter-esque” – if hackneyed ‘esque’ comparison must be made, please keep them within the sport in question, for Christ’s sake – the television was turned off.

An incredible FFA Cup 5-4 comeback win by South Melbourne against Dandenong City was being broadcast on Facebook, an absolute ripper of a game, and so I watched that instead, and I pitied all those who hadn’t switched over with me.

Arsenal will be playing Sydney FC and Western Sydney in July; if a repeat of this cavalcade of ignominy occurs, especially the torturous coverage, it will do nothing but hurt football in Australia.

The Crowd Says:

2017-05-29T01:05:58+00:00

Leonard

Guest


Thanks for the extra info - was aware of the bigger field, and of their 12-man onfield rule, but have not taxed my brain with fully nutting out the 'rouge' feature. Reckon the Canucks deserve pats on their collective backs for NOT having a cultural cringe about their specific version of the North American 'gridiron' game, an attitude of "It's our game, and that's how we like it, and if you don't like it, go and get rouged" - a lesson for us?

2017-05-28T10:39:21+00:00

northerner

Guest


Google a bit more, Leonard. BC Place is a multi purpose facility. The CFL's BC Lions are the main client, yes, but since CFL football is played on a bigger field than NFL football, the stadium is actually very suitable for "soccer." It's also great for concerts, monster trucks, and whatever else will turn a dollar. The Whitecaps get about 22,000 average attendance, which is only slightly less than the Lions get. It's not like the Caps are being embarrassed by support levels. It takes something like the Winter Olympics to fill that stadium. In Vancouver, those numbers are very respectable (bear in mind that it's a city half the size of Melbourne or Sydney and BC'ers don't have the sports mania that Australians do - much more laid back there). Yet they're still pulling numbers that a lot of NRL and A League clubs, and all the SANZAAR clubs, would envy.

2017-05-28T09:17:26+00:00

Leonard

Guest


Googled [Whitecaps] and discovered that its Home ground is the Canadian (gridiron) Football League's 54,500-seater BC Place, and discovered that it shares a feature with the AFL's Port Adelaide period at Football Park. In its last few seasons at FP, Port Adelaide covered some of the thousands of empty seats with drappage which got the nickname 'crowd shrouds' - which actually emphasised what was meant to be 'shrouded'. (But Port did get a few bob's worth of sponsor advertising on them.) In the Whitecaps Wikipedia article there's this: "The Whitecaps reduce the stadium's capacity to 22,120 for matches by using white sails (known as the "secondary roof") to close off the upper bowl" (= top tier of seating), and, presumably make the 60% of empty seats less eye-catching. Link - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vancouver_Whitecaps_FC#/media/File:BC_Place_2011.jpg ; looks less cringeworthy than Port's 'crowd shrouds'. BTW, re empty seats, last night's NRL Souths v Parramatta metro-Sydney matchup game at Homebush was played before 70,000 empty seats.

2017-05-28T06:01:57+00:00

northerner

Guest


Invite the Whitecaps over. Or send a team over there. Direct flights Sydney and Brisbane to Vancouver these days. And Canadian border people are easier to deal with than the Americans.

2017-05-28T05:39:13+00:00

Leonard

Guest


Wonder how many new Ahzzie baseball fans and players were engendered by the 2014 MLB season opener at the SCG? PS: thrilled that the Chicago Cubs won last year's World Series. Spent a short week in the Windy City in 1998 and totally chanced on the two Chicago teams playing at Wrigley Field for the first time since Columbus was playing Pop Warner in Genoa. Great experience, even though we weren't baseball fans - the atmosphere was a bit like going to VFL games before 'ground rationalisation'. Loved everyone singing "Take me out to the ball game" after the seventh. Hint: if you want to avoid terrorising Seppos by snafu-level driving on the 'wrong' side of their roads, use Amtrak to get around from one major city to the next - one of the best travel experiences of our lives..

2017-05-27T22:34:36+00:00

CrampsRowZ

Roar Rookie


Goodness I agree with this Locomotiv

2017-05-27T11:32:02+00:00

Neil

Guest


I think we should offer to play some MLS clubs from the USA to see how how we measure up against them.

2017-05-26T03:37:10+00:00

punter

Guest


Exactly Sydneysider, I'm also a Derby county & AC Milan fan, never been to either city. We have a football game in Sydney that has 70K attending & some Brisbane Roar fan calls it an embarrassment, sorry a NATIONAL EMBARRASSMENT, one thing about the AFL fanboys, we are an insecure bunch.

2017-05-26T03:23:20+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


#JamesB The BBL is interesting. Players on the field wired up - chatting to the commentary team. However - the matches are more meaningful (a national comp with finals) than the international T20s or ODIs played each summer (Ch9 is suffering as a result). Ch.10 have tuned into the 'carnival' atmosphere pretty well though - also the school holidays relaxed summer evenings feel. Perhaps the ABC thought that that was a similar pathway to take on this match? Missed the mark perhaps - - however - - some might be generous enough to give them (the ABC) credit for trying something a little different.

2017-05-26T03:18:49+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


#Laurie Don't tell me I'm harping on about something that you brought up.

2017-05-26T02:52:16+00:00

Grobbelaar

Roar Guru


Well said Stuart. It's times like this we need passionate and genuine football fans such as yourself to stand up for the game and provide the rest of us with some hope of a better future.

2017-05-26T00:31:46+00:00

Sydneysider

Guest


Punter, I am also a SFC fan and been a member since season 1. Along with other A-League club season ticket holders, I wear my merchandise around and have never felt embarrassed to wear it. I support football and in Sydney you don't get those issues of feeling embarrassed. I dare say it's the same in the other cities in Australia with an A-League club. In saying that, I also support teams from overseas leagues but mainly Juventus (my parents are Italian) in Serie A, PSV in Holland, Athletic Bilbao in Spain and Crystal Palace in England (thanks to all the Aussies who have played for that club). Football is a global game and I've got jerseys from all over the world. I've even got a Club America jersey from Mexico. As long as you wear a football jersey, I don't see the issue.

2017-05-25T23:21:37+00:00

Andrew Young

Roar Guru


Well said; had an odd feel about it all night.

2017-05-25T22:51:28+00:00

Ian

Guest


They want people to watch it.

2017-05-25T22:18:39+00:00

Sambobly

Guest


Aaron Chen is great. What a baller.

2017-05-25T12:53:10+00:00

valhalla

Guest


not sure that answers the question posed

2017-05-25T12:52:08+00:00

valhalla

Guest


let me guess .... the boozer instituted its responsible service of alcohol policy and your home twiddling ya thumbs

2017-05-25T12:44:38+00:00

Ken Spacey

Guest


Was looking for a quick reference for AFL leaning ABC journo. His lack of perspective and balance was the issue.

2017-05-25T12:28:45+00:00

Pauly

Guest


I find that there are only two real differences: - the speed of the game is faster in Europe - the finishing of the strikers is better in Europe (strikers that finish like that in the A-League are generally whisked away overseas) Other than that there are just as many skill errors, attacks breaking down in the final third and dull passages of play. Only on rare occasions do you get champagne football for 90 minutes.

2017-05-25T12:09:49+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


To all my friends, colleagues and readers on the Roar, I wish to express my utter embarrassment and sadness atf the presentation of the game last night night. I was there and oblivious to much of what happened. I am truly saddened by what I have seen online today. Our game is so great, so beautiful and so beyond the pathetic, cheap and insincere comedy attached to it by the ABC. I hope we never see it again and look forward to the June 8 qualifier where we can all rug up and start to live the magic of a world cup dream. So sad and so embarrassed but still so hopeful.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar