Super Rugby is back. Try to stay calm

By Jack Quigley / Expert

As if you haven’t been marking the days on your calendars, this weekend sees the return of Super Rugby to our shores (I know, it’s exciting. Try to stay calm, everybody).

The June Tests were supposed to provide Australian rugby fans with some respite from the train wreck that has been Super Rugby this season. But after a worrisome international window, thankfully Super Rugby is back to distract us from the Wallabies.

Still no decision
More than eighty days and counting since the ARU announced they’d be cutting a Super Rugby team “within 48-72 hours”, we’re still no closer to finding out which franchise will eventually get the chop. The longer it takes, the more blood spatter there’s going to be when the axe finally falls.

Those who appear to be at most risk, the Force and the Rebels, have used the stay of execution to re-sign a bunch of players for next season.

Fly-half Jono Lance, winger Chase Peni and second-rower Richie Arnold all put pen to paper in the west this week, taking the Force’s tally of players contracted beyond 2017 to nineteen.

The Rebels returned serve, re-signing halfback Nick Stirzaker and hooker James Hanson, as chief executive Baden Stephenson proclaimed that “80 per cent” of their 2017 squad had been retained for next season.

As an outsider looking in, all this looks a bit like both teams are just re-signing anyone holding a pen. Perhaps it’s an attempt to make it harder for the ARU to cut them – by increasing the amount of work required to sort out all these contracts when/if it happens.

But isn’t filling up five franchise rosters with mediocre talent the exact practice that got us to the point we’re at now? We’ve stretched player talent too thin across the board and the overall standard has dropped as a result.

Former Wallaby Dean Mumm, head of the Rugby Union Players’ Association, suggested last week that we should be able to keep all five franchises by simply reducing costs. Alright then, Dean. But where exactly are those reductions coming from?

(AAP Image/NZPA, David Rowland)

Are the Rebels’ players willing to travel to domestic matches via bus? Are the Force players content with crashing at hostels on international trips? Unlikely. The reality is that those cuts would come from where the money is needed most – at participation and development level.

It’s always easiest to cut the small guys, because they make the least noise.

I get where Mumm is coming from. In his role he needs to (at least be seen to) protect the players’ best interests. But what Mumm and RUPA need to understand is that they’re potentially damaging the future of the game in this country in order to protect a small number of professional players.

To play devil’s advocate on behalf of the players, I understand that they have families to feed and mortgages to pay. It’s understandable that they won’t want to go quietly. But ultimately, nobody has a divine right to a professional rugby contract.

When you see how poor the standard of rugby has been from the Australian sides this season, one can’t help but feel that if you’re not good enough to crack one of the four remaining teams, perhaps you didn’t deserve a nice professional rugby contract to begin with.

Even if the RUPA and ARU found a way to make it work, and were able to save all five teams, where would it leave us?

Well, right where we are now. Isn’t that exactly the problem?

The team that sits atop the Australian conference, the Brumbies, embarrassingly have more losses than wins to their name.

Rugby in this country can’t afford another season where the showpiece product served up to the paying public (and influential younger demographic) is as painfully bland as it has been in 2017.

Finally some top quality rugby on show at Allianz Stadium
The Waratahs will be showing the third All Blacks versus British and Irish Lions Test on the stadium screens ahead of their match against the Jaguares on Saturday evening.

Fearing a poor turnout for the Jaguares game, Tahs management has come out on the front foot in an attempt to coax punters out of the bars and through the turnstiles.

Credit to them for the proactive move, and it’ll give the long-suffering Waratahs fans a chance to finally see some good quality rugby played at Allianz Stadium – albeit via a giant television.

(AP Photo/Mark Baker)

Lealiifano return postponed
Brumbies coach Stephen Larkham has opted not to include Christian Lealiifano on the bench for Friday night’s game against the Queensland Reds. Lealiifano had been considered a good chance to make his return to Super Rugby this weekend, but hamstring soreness has ruled him out of the clash at Suncorp Stadium.

Lealiifano’s comeback to rugby incredibly comes just 11 months after being diagnosed with leukaemia.

The playmaker turned out for Tuggeranong in the Canberra fourth grade competition on Saturday morning, fulfilling a goal he’d set himself after his initial cancer diagnosis – to get back on the field and play a game alongside his brother Lix.

The 19-time Wallaby is one of the senior leaders within the Brumbies’ playing group and his return will provide an enormous morale boost ahead of the Super Rugby finals.

The Crowd Says:

2017-07-10T05:51:40+00:00

Justin Mahon

Guest


They have an alternative - football. And the numbers (off an already very high base) are exploding. The AFL is the least of Rugby's concerns down here I'd say. The AFL is the king of the culture, but it's participation is flat and declining relative to football. I have not seen football numbers for WA, but it is already a high participation sport there - likely ahead of AFL, as will be the case here in VIC before too long.

2017-07-08T03:08:39+00:00

Rebellion

Guest


Typo above - "should have never" Both Cowan and Mumm were like a noose around their own team's neck for various reasons Cowan particularly was toxic - in his batting and joining Clarke's cronies. Was an irritating media tart like Drew Mitchell too.

2017-07-08T01:13:46+00:00

Crazy Horse

Roar Pro


Because Perth's massive Kiwi population will turn out in force along with a lot of other locals who just want this first ever opportunity to see the best team in the world.

2017-07-08T01:03:04+00:00

robel

Roar Pro


So it's ok to accept small crowds in Melb and the east coast because it's Fiji or italy, but in Perth there has to be a sell out for Argentina.

2017-07-07T23:11:39+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Firstly welcome back CL to Rugby, fantastic that he is playing again. I would love all 5 teams to stay however it ain't happening. Looking forward to the decider in Auckland !

2017-07-07T11:17:18+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Exactly Piru! Not only will the beatings continue, but also the culling. The grand plan is to return to 1899-1995, just NSW & Queensland! It's called, wait for it, "Forward to the Past".

2017-07-07T11:12:03+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Spoken like a true politician. All people are supposedly equal, but some are more equal than others, like politicians, bankers, public servants, CEOs, GMs...... I think it was Mark Twain who mused that the only people who thought they deserved the huge money people were getting were those people on the huge money. And presumedly those people who wanted their jobs..... Let's assume all the G20 leaders die of a mystery illness. Will the world collapse? Very unlikely. But it just depends what kind of people (good or bad) replace those who suddenly passed away. But we just keep talking ourselves around in circles.....

2017-07-07T11:05:12+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Ralph, I've twigged your salary numbers a bit. I'm happy to do the CEO job for $479k.

2017-07-07T09:08:16+00:00

Baylion

Roar Rookie


SARU owns the Kings franchise anyway. But is a deal with Pro12 is made the Kings will be able to contract players for longer terms

2017-07-07T08:35:15+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


The Kings have also agreed settlement. Not sure of the figures involved as the Kings need to recruit players on longer contracts. Some of their current squad have already signed with the Cheetahs

2017-07-07T08:25:20+00:00

Baylion

Roar Rookie


The Cheetahs and the Kings will not play Super Rugby in 2018. SA Rugby confirmed the news on Friday, with the Cheetahs having agreed to a settlement. Both the Kings and the Cheetahs agreed that they would be seeking other international opportunities, with a move to the Pro12 in Europe reportedly an option.

2017-07-07T08:24:22+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


Has been announced http://www.sarugbymag.co.za/blog/details/cheetahs-kings-out-super-rugby

2017-07-07T08:21:05+00:00

Boonzie

Guest


They screwed the pooch on that one... Surely it would have made more sense to play Italy in Melbourne and Fiji in Brisbane based on expats / heritage...

2017-07-07T08:07:06+00:00

Kane

Guest


Bad news for the ARU with SA soon to confirm that the Cheetahs and Kings will be dropped from Super Rugby. Looks to be harder now for the ARU to back down from axing a team now.

2017-07-07T07:47:30+00:00

Kashmir Pete

Roar Guru


GtW This is getting better - down to Super 5 (1 team from Oz). Cheers KP

2017-07-07T06:53:37+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Well, the nurse did demonstrate something she called the 'football hold' for holding a baby one handed. Had to correct her as there's no way you'd hold something as precious as a ball in such a precarious grip

2017-07-07T06:52:04+00:00

world in union

Guest


@ Rebellion - you had your 2 mins worth of paying out now get back in your cave

2017-07-07T06:50:43+00:00

MitchO

Guest


I don't know how broadly applicable this is but the link is to the Eligibilty Policy of the ASRU (Australian Schools Rugby Union). That is I have not taken things a step further and tracked down the eligibiligy criteria for the WA schoolboys. No time today so I hope I am not giving anyone a bumsteer. http://www.schoolsrugby.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/ASRU-Player-Eligibility-Policy.pdf

2017-07-07T06:44:43+00:00

world in union

Guest


@ Rebellion - WTF are you on about ? your petty little attacks on cricketers who are rightfully trying to keep the board honest in their dealings with players has NOTHING to do with Super Rugby. Who are you anyway? Some kind of goose by the remarks you've made ... not funny either

2017-07-07T06:44:03+00:00

Ralph

Roar Guru


"The bloke was on $1.2m a year, and running the ARU at a ~$9m loss per year!" Back up the truck! I clearly wasn't given all the facts when I made my generous employment offer. I didn't realise the job spec was to lose money. Not to appear too selfish but before I take on the role can I enquire how much is in the bank right now and what the current "burn" rate is?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar