The Wrap: Wallabies and Boks draw a thriller as All Blacks take 15th title

By Geoff Parkes / Expert

When the Springboks arrived in Australia recently the Wallabies and Boks had met 83 times for just a solitary draw.

Three weeks later the tally now stands at 85 meetings for three draws; 160 minutes of rugby in Perth and Bloemfontein failing to separate two obviously well-matched sides.

At game end, 27-27 in what was a thrilling Test match, the Fox Sports rugby team swung into action, calling for extra-time to be played, even to the extent of feeding leading questions to interviewed players to support their cause.

Almost certainly this will be dismissed by the powers that be as nothing more than a broadcaster with vested interests clutching for a winner versus loser narrative. Others will happily reflect on this draw as a fair outcome for two sides who gave their all, but couldn’t quite establish an advantage over the other.

Right from the first whistle the game established a rhythm and flow that never let up, the Springboks maintaining possession and working the Australian defence from side to side; a tactic they would continue throughout.

While their intent was to be admired, they were poorly served by the inability of halves Ross Cronje and Elton Jantjies to align themselves squarely, with the result being that – with one notable exception in the second half – the Springbok backline attack was too lateral to take full benefit from their 60:40 possession advantage.

They were better served by quickly recycling and punching on the edge of the ruck, catching the Wallabies’ forwards too slow to re-form, leaving Israel Folau and Marika Koroibete to man the defensive post, a mismatch prop Ruan Dreyer eagerly took advantage of for his try.

Dreyer was to find less joy at scrum time however, propping against Scott Sio as if someone had told him it was compulsory to try to position his feet behind the goal-line. Or perhaps he was on a mission to bring back ‘planking’?

Earlier, it was Folau who opened the try scoring, spearing through off an inside ball from Bernard Foley – not the only pass of the game that tested the laws of physics.

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Both defences clocked off early in the second half, curiously before fatigue or the effects of altitude had kicked in, and the thrust and counter thrust contributed to a highly enjoyable, high intensity contest.

Foley was instrumental in all three Wallabies tries, his straight running and fend putting Koroibete away on the right flank, before a superb, Aaron Smith-like bullet pass found Koroibete on the left edge this time, for his double. Great stuff, mitigated only slightly by a couple of misfired kicks.

By contrast, Jantjies too often distributed the ball above and behind the inside shoulder of his outside receiver, stifling the Springbok backline attack. Jantjies also missed a 78th-minute penalty that almost certainly would have won the match, but in reality, this was justice for a blatant forward pass being missed in the lead-up by referee Ben O’Keefe, who otherwise had an excellent match.

It also felt right for this game to be determined by tries scored – three each – than by a penalty goal. Much of the pre-game chatter had fans believing that both sides would be popping over long bombs from 60-plus metres, but in the heat of battle, both captains elected mostly to keep the ball and kick for the touchline instead.

Among the many outstanding contributors on both sides, Siya Kolisi will long remember his contribution to Dillyn Leyds’ try (more fondly than Kurtley Beale one suspects), and Will Genia was again at his sharp and accurate best (note how decisively he broke from the scrum for Folau’s try).

The supreme contributor however was Michael Hooper, the heart and soul of this Wallabies team. Working harder than the undertaker currently trying to get the smile off Hugh Hefner’s face, his effort to single-handedly create a turnover in the 79th minute, to give his team one last shot at victory, when other mortal players were out on their feet, was bordering on superhuman.

Post-match, Hooper’s comments maturely and accurately reflected the progress his side is making – frustrated in their inability to take advantage of all opportunities, while recognising that a rare win on the high veldt was almost achieved through some high quality play that, at times, approached their best efforts in Dunedin.

(AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

After their win against Argentina in Canberra I was critical of the Wallabies for not playing rugby that inspired fans. Anyone failing to be stirred by this performance, or the match itself, is a very hard marker indeed.

Before the start of the Argentina versus All Blacks match in Buenos Aries, Roar Guru Diggercane and I pondered how long it would take Pumas’ lock Tomas Lavanini to do something stupid. Only two minutes 21 seconds as it turned out, although his yellow card after 22 minutes seemed to be as much about reputation than merit.

Matt Todd was also harshly treated by referee Jaco Peyper, binned in the 38th minute for bringing a maul to ground when he had his arms clasped around the ball in an onside position. It was as if Peyper realised that he should have waved the card at Keiran Read at the previous maul, and so was squaring the ledger.

This match was similar in many respects to the opening match in Sydney, with the All Blacks effectively killing the contest early with slick Damien McKenzie and Beauden Barrett inspired tries, before the Pumas eventually found a way to adjust the pace of the game to their liking, stiffening up their defence in the process.

They were aided by an accelerating All Blacks’ error count – handling lapses, wild passes, high tackles, missed lineout throws and kicking dead from penalties all stunting their attack. Even Barrett’s famed kick-pass wasn’t working, although Barrett might have reflected later that this wasn’t the right tactic for such a narrow pitch.

In the end, five tries to one, a strongly performing scrum, and Sonny-Bill Williams’ best match for some time, (why was he wearing a cummerbund?) still represented a worthwhile outcome for New Zealand, considering some of the players rested, and the fact that when the Pumas do decide to dig in, they are enormously difficult to overcome.

(AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

The All Blacks also blooded another newcomer and celebrated his debut try; David Havili shaking off the effects of teammate Rieko Ioane curiously grabbing him uncomfortably close to his nether regions during the national anthems.

Combining the Tri Nations and Rugby Championships, New Zealand now heads to Cape Town with their 15th title from 22 in the bag – yet another demonstration of their dominance in the professional era.

Meanwhile, another piece in the complex jigsaw that is professional rugby in Australia was neatly put into place on Friday with the announcement that Western Force coach Dave Wessels had accepted a new role with the Melbourne Rebels.

The announcement left those who wrote and reacted to reports a day earlier that Wessels was Ireland bound, redder than a Munster jersey. Wessels playing his cards now clears the way for prominent Force players to follow him to Melbourne, or else find places at Australia’s other three remaining franchises, potentially delivering the ‘five into four’ outcome that the ARU desires.

For those players whose phones aren’t ringing, this will be an awful few weeks. But it is also the point – if all four Australian franchises aren’t demonstrably made stronger by the demise of the Force, then what on earth was all the pain and heartache for?

There was pain of a different kind for Richmond supporters yesterday, shaking off the effects of a celebration that only 37 years of mediocrity can bring. Walking into Punt Road Oval on Saturday was a surreal experience, among thousands of Tiger faithful still not believing that our modest side could somehow be in an AFL grand final.

Three hours later the impossible dream was a reality. Two take-aways for rugby came to mind, firstly that committed defensive pressure – maintained for the whole match, not just parts of it – will take any side a long way.

The second concerned coach Damien Hardwick, under extreme pressure from media and fans at the end of last season after a lame 13th placed finish. Instead of following a populist route and sacking him, the board of management stood firm in their belief that they had the right man at the helm, and backed changes to the coaching support group, in concert with astute recruitment.

If the ARU truly believes that they have the right man in Michael Cheika, then they and Cheika will take comfort in recognising the value of stability and continuity, and the confidence that this provides to the coaching and playing group.

The Crowd Says:

2017-10-04T04:18:15+00:00

Fox

Roar Guru


No Geoff it was clear by round five he was way out of his depth at this level of the game. Japan's lower league beckons :)

2017-10-03T10:24:08+00:00

Fionn

Guest


Larkham coached the Brumbies to the finals every year (in his first 3 years as coach) and the Wallabies are attacking great. I am happy with Larkham as a coach. He isn't there yet, but he is doing a fine job, especially given his lack of experience. I believe he will one day be a great Wallaby coach.

2017-10-03T07:44:36+00:00

Jacko

Guest


He isnt trying to coach badly as yet Fionn

2017-10-03T07:33:16+00:00

Cuw

Guest


nope , he plays like Colin Slade , a former Crusader.

2017-10-03T04:47:55+00:00

Cuw

Guest


me as a neutral want to see more powerful Auzzy and Saffa teams , who can atleast give a close run to NZ, even if they lose. when u do the party thing with drinks and food and all to watch these matches , and then the result is like decided within the first 30 -40 minutes , it is really boring. ( also leads to drinking too much :P )

2017-10-03T04:40:56+00:00

Cuw

Guest


and he has signed up with USA .

2017-10-03T02:15:11+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Yep, very good player, greater potential even, I was a fan until he went of the rails .... when he didn't turn up for the photo session, that was it for me ... how many players get an opportunity to represent your country ...

2017-10-03T01:59:01+00:00

DanFan

Guest


I agree that BB stands deeper and also changes his positioning quite a bit. Also I think he tends to take the line on a bit more now than he used to which, to be honest, I rather wish he didn't.

2017-10-03T01:55:01+00:00

Fionn

Guest


Rugby Tragic, maybe DMac in terms of skills and abilities, not in terms of temperament and attitude. What happened with JOC is one of the truly sad stories over the last 10 years though. He looked like he was our best backline prospect since Larkham was coming through. He could do it all, but didn't work out.

2017-10-03T01:47:56+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Fionn, Aussie had their DMac in James O'Connor ...

2017-10-03T01:33:28+00:00

Fionn

Guest


he's not quite proven himself the new 'Bernie' Larkham yet, TMan. ;)

2017-10-03T01:28:05+00:00

Nico'larse

Guest


Well the Wally's seem to be making a habit of winning the RC in World Cup years when nobody else cares about it. We often play above ourselves when it doesn't really count. To be fair, England appear to be the only nation capable of properly troubling the AB's atm and given the inexplicable scheduling that hasn't seen these sides meet for a few years, I remain even doubtful of that. So while you bemoan lack of competition in the RC, bear in mind that the AB's have been head & shoulders above everybody else for years now. It's fair to say that the Wb's and SB's would be highly competitive against any other nation in the world including England I believe

2017-10-02T20:58:29+00:00

Good Game

Guest


Cron is the scrum guru. Player ability of course, but refined by some excellent coaching.

2017-10-02T20:55:04+00:00

Fionn

Guest


I disagree, mate, I reckon he looks like he could be the next Aaron Cruden :)

AUTHOR

2017-10-02T20:34:55+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Ah Nobes... I love it when things get lost in translation. I know exactly what you are saying about their sycophantic coverage, being attached too closely to the team and players. I was referring to the reporter...

2017-10-02T19:37:36+00:00

adastra32

Guest


Erm, Jonathan Joseph is a good player - but I'm not sure he has fulfilled THAT much potential yet..

2017-10-02T18:20:08+00:00

MIB2

Roar Rookie


IMHO Mounga is not test material. He plays in a good team that covers his inadequacies.

2017-10-02T17:20:20+00:00

Carlos the Argie

Roar Guru


In addition, the field at Velez is a regulation soccer field. I doubt it is too narrow for rugby. Velez is 70 meters wide, just like an official rugby field. It is clearly shorter.

2017-10-02T16:36:37+00:00

Carlos the Argie

Roar Guru


Was not Lavanini. See above, it was the other lock.

2017-10-02T16:33:29+00:00

Carlos the Argie

Roar Guru


Geoff I think that Digger and you, as well as the TV commentators, made a mistake with the first dumb penalty. If you are mentioning the one under the posts where Smith is pushed back, it was not Lavanini. That penalty was committed by the lock with the colored cap. Lavanini had a black cap, as you can clearly see later when he was YC. The first penalty was Petti. But it looked so dumb for everyone to see that it was safe and logical to assume it was Lavanini. Dumbness is contagious....

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar