The Sheffield Shield wrap: The season so far

By Sideline Commentator / Roar Guru

With Test stars in action and international spots on the line, at least theoretically, the first three rounds of this season’s Sheffield Shield have been intriguing.

With the rounds now completed, and the international team selected, it is worth a look back at the best and worst of the Shield season so far.

Leaderboard
The most dominant team so far this season has easily been New South Wales. The Blues stand firmly on top of the leader board having won all three of their matches so far. This is not surprising, perhaps, considering the international stars available to them for these rounds.

However, it was interesting to see that perhaps their most impressive win so far, their last match against Queensland, came mostly off the back of their regular state bowling line up. This is a good sign for the rest of the season.

Following NSW is Queensland (with two wins, no draws, and one loss); South Australia (1, 1, 1); Western Australia (1, 0, 2); Victoria, (0, 2, 1); and finally Tasmania (0, 1, 2). Sitting at the bottom of the table, the Tigers will be fuming about the rumoured interjection of Cricket Australia to prolong Tim Paine’s innings in their last match, as it dramatically cut down their chance to win.

Batting
Interestingly, none of the top five run-scorers so far this Shield season are from the incumbent Test crop, and only two, the top scorer Cameron Bancroft and Test regular, Usman Khawaja, will be padding up for the first Test of the summer.

The top five run scorers are: Bancroft (WA), with 442 runs at 110.50 (with a high score of 228); Jake Weathererald (SA), with 419 at 69.83 (152); Usman Khawaja (Queensland), with 347 at 86.75 (122); Callum Ferguson (SA), 343 at 72.97 (182*); and Alex Doolan (Tas), with 318 at 63.83 (247*).

Bowling
Of the wicket-takers so far this season, by far the stand out is Test spearhead Mitch Starc. Starc has taken 17 wickets at an average of 12.70, with a terrifying strike rate of 25.7. He also picked up his career best bowling figures of 8/73 in one innings. What makes this all the more remarkable is that it was done in only two matches, one less than anyone else in the top twelve wicket takers. His form is looking formidable going into the first Test.

Following Starc is a group of players all on 15 wickets: Michael Neser, (Queensland) with 15 wickets at 17.00 (strike rate: 34.4); Scott Boland (Vic), with 15 at 19.26 (44.4); Chris Tremain (Vic) with 15 at 20.93 (42.2); and, Jhye Richardson (WA), with 15 at 24.80 (43.2).

Notable performances
Easily the most notable bowling performance so far this season is that of Mitch Starc, who far outclassed his compatriots, even only playing two matches. However, another notable is Chris Tremain. With 15 wickets at 21, Tremain is staying firmly in mix of the top wicket takers, and is only solidifying his position as one of the most underrated bowlers in Australia.

The most notable batting performance of this season so far, is, of course, Cameron Bancroft. Opening for Western Australia alongside Shaun Marsh, Bancroft has scored two half centuries, 76* and 86, and a huge double of 228*. With Test incumbent Matt Renshaw only averaging 11.67, Bancroft’s performance ensured he pushed his way into the Test team to make a dream debut in the Ashes.

Despite the dominance of NSW, the most impressive team performance so far this season is South Australia’s win against Western Australia. Batting first, the WA Warriors posted a formidable 7-514 declared, based on Bancroft’s 228*, as well as a handy 95 by Mitch Marsh. In reply SA could only manage 363, largely on the back of Jake Weatherald’s 152.

However, in a great team performance, the Redbacks managed to roll WA in the second innings for only 173 (partially thanks to an injured Marcus Stoinis) and then pull off the win by posting 5-325, again on the back of a Weatherald century (143). It was an excellent performance for SA, giving them their first win for the season.

Disappointments
On the negative side, Western Australia will be disappointed with their performance so far this seasons. Despite having the top run scorer and one of the top five wicket takers, the Warriors have managed only the one win, and more disappointingly, two losses. Losing Bancroft and Shaun Marsh to internationals will not help their chances this season, and while they are by no means out of the running, they will have to work hard to make the final.

Another notable negative is Queensland’s batting. Despite winning two matches so far this season, the Bulls have struggled with the bat. Besides Khawaja, who averaged 86.75, the Bulls’ highest batting average this season belongs to fast-bowler Mark Steketee, who averaged 27 after only participating in one innings.

The next is Marnus Labuschagne, who averages 26.67 on the back of an 88 against NSW. With Khawaja now lost to the international summer, the Bulls will have to seriously pick up their batting if they wish to compete in the rest of the season.

Queensland’s poor performances with the blade are exemplified by two players with Test experience: Matt Renshaw (averaging 11.67) and Joe Burns (20.67). Both would have been hoping to add to their Test careers this summer, but after underwhelming starts to the season, they will simply be looking to get a big score under their belt as soon as possible.

With the international season beginning, the Sheffield Shield will now roll on without the Test stars. However, with plenty of talent and impressive performances outside of the international players, there is lots to look forward to as the season progresses.

The Crowd Says:

2017-11-22T01:19:45+00:00

Andy Hill

Roar Pro


Injured. Calf. Just coming back now.

2017-11-21T23:02:44+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Where has Holland been? He was one of their stars last season and destroyed the national team in Darwin. He is probably to low on the CA depth chart to be picked.

2017-11-21T23:01:57+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Hemphrey got picked. No Heazlett yet. Hemphrey has had some good form in 1st Grade so far this season.

2017-11-21T15:23:48+00:00

Andy Hill

Roar Pro


Yeah, Harper the better keeper, Gotch the better batsman. Seems batting wins out again. When you compare the batting line up to last season, the only difference is that Stoinis has gone, and he averaged 18. So that shouldn't really make any difference. The issue is performance, not personel. Third coach in three seasons. Not sure Andrew McDonald is the right fit. I question his judgement in leaving out White and persisting with Christian for the first three matches. Still, the 12 just announced for he NSW match looks about right with Short and White coming in for Christian and Handscomb and Holland coming in for Ahmed. Young Eamon Vines as likely 12th man looks a good batting prospect in case Dean's form doesn't improve, but you'd think they would give Dean a fair go given his record so far.

2017-11-21T05:01:25+00:00

BurgyGreen

Guest


The keeping spot seems like a tricky one for Victoria. I don't know much about Harper and Gotch, as they've played very few first-class matches. I did see some ripper takes by Harper in the first two games before he was dropped for Gotch. Is Gotch considered the better batsman?

AUTHOR

2017-11-21T04:25:36+00:00

Sideline Commentator

Roar Guru


I tipped the Bushrangers to struggle a bit this year, after the hattrick of series wins. They lost a lot of players and are probably in a bit of a rebuilding stage, at least with the batting. The positive is that Maxwell will be able to play and he might help a lot.

2017-11-21T01:04:34+00:00

Andy Hill

Roar Pro


The biggest disappointment this season so far has been Victoria's batting. 2 draws and a loss to start the season and it is all due to poor batting. Our bowlers have been quite good. Especially Tremain and Boland. Handscomb didn't contribute much, Dean has been ordinary and Finch only has one 50 so far. Harris and Maxwell both get pass marks and Christian the ultimate "bits and pieces" player has failed at both bits- batting and bowling. The Bushys really beed to start to click in the batting if they want to make a go of defending that title. As mentioned above, bring in White and Short for Handscomb and Christian.

2017-11-21T00:57:05+00:00

Andy Hill

Roar Pro


Agree with that Burg. White HAS to play given our terrible batting so far this year. Christian has contributed nothing so far. Short looks a great player. Had an excellent One Day Cup and now scoring against the poms. Get him in! Hopefully Holland can come back in for Ahmed too. He has been quite loose despite taking a few handy wickets. Mostly lower order batsmen.

2017-11-20T10:54:19+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


He did look awkward getting out to a short one against Tassie, but that could just be a one off.

AUTHOR

2017-11-20T09:13:00+00:00

Sideline Commentator

Roar Guru


You might right Dave. Hayden was also someone who famously had to wait. But I think with Renshaw it was actually a technical issue that has him on the outer. Ronan actually wrote a good article about it a number of days ago. He struggles against right-arm quicks around the wicket.

AUTHOR

2017-11-20T09:10:05+00:00

Sideline Commentator

Roar Guru


WA certainly has an enviable bowling lineup. Probably deeper than any other state, with Vic a second. They are a conundrum to me: they have the players, but haven't clicked yet. I knew Langer is regarded as a great coach, but I honestly wonder if he is the best fit for WA at the moment.

AUTHOR

2017-11-20T09:07:00+00:00

Sideline Commentator

Roar Guru


That's interesting Matt. But like you say, if that's the thinking, why not tell us all. I've never thought of Maxwell as particularly week to the short ball - I always thought he was mostly his own worst enemy. Interested to here other's opinion with this.

2017-11-20T08:12:10+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Guest


You might mention Shaun Marsh's 92 against a Test strength bowling attack. CA stuffed around with the WA bowlers. Behrendorff never knows if he can play or not.If he does ,look out Coulter-Nile aggravated an old injury,but not badly. So among those who can bowl,we have a.His replacement, Holder, who is 18 and took some good wickets against SA b.Joel Paris is due a recall. c. Dave Moody,who is uncannily like Bruce Reid, but hopefully without the back problems is 22 and a good prospect. d. Jhye Richardson as already mentioned, e .Matt Kelly,another rookie, has five wickets at 13 in his only FC match f. Simon Mackin bowls fast right-arm inswingers, g. Cameron Green,another 18 y.o. is scary good, if his last season's youngest ever five for against Tassie is anything to go by. h. Andrew Tye can't get a game The fast bowler stocks are pretty high Then there's Turner,D'Arcy Short,Bosisto(watch this space) and Agar for matches at the SCG or Adelaide

2017-11-20T07:27:05+00:00

dave

Guest


I am happy to see Bancroft in the team but it got me thinking about Mike Hussey.Bancroft is in great form this season while Hussey had that kind of shield form for years and couldn't get into the Aussie 11.I understand the calibre of players in front of Hussey was pretty damn special but I also think players back then were given a lot more time to succeed once selected for Australia and the shield players had to do a lot more to be selected in the first place. I am not 100% sure did Renshaw score something like 180 in his last test on Australian soil? Curious If the old selection would have persisted with Renshaw and told Bancroft He has to maintain this shield form for at least a year and may have to wait even longer if the incumbent regains form.

2017-11-20T07:20:45+00:00

BurgyGreen

Guest


SA and QLD definitely had a go at him with it and he didn't look super comfortable but I don't think they got him out with it.

2017-11-20T06:27:42+00:00

qwetzen

Guest


The general Rule of Aus cricket is; Bowlers before Xmas, batsmen after. We may have done enough already to beat Tassie for the spoon, but I wouldn't be putting the farm on it.

2017-11-20T05:53:05+00:00

JohnB

Guest


Without in any way wanting to be seen as criticising any of these players, it isn't completely weird - it was in Townsville after all on a very easy paced pitch, on the last day of a tour match, and they mostly batted against Crane and Ali.

2017-11-20T05:48:53+00:00

matth

Guest


On the radio today I also heard Stoinis just had to score a 50 and he would have been in. Also that Maxwell is left out because he can't play the short ball. Apparently he got hurried up by some shield bowlers. If that is the case, then why not just say so. At least there is a justification there, even if it might be wrong. I never thought of Maxwell as having a problem with the short ball though. so it could be just more groping for reasons not to choose Maxwell pretty much because they just don't like him much.

2017-11-20T05:44:52+00:00

matth

Guest


It will be interesting to see how Wade reacts no that, in a funny way, the pressure's off.

2017-11-20T04:47:15+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


"Stoinis seems to have been a lock." You read it first on The Roar! Well...sort of. www.theroar.com.au/2017/10/02/stoinis-bolts-ashes-contention/

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar